HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | mlazos's commentslogin

This would be an unmitigated disaster - most programmers have trouble with Haskell, I can’t imagine saying hey finance guys here’s an LLM and Haskell figure it out when they’re used to using a full on application with UX. It’s actually so crazy I feel like you’re joking.

What also makes the monad more interesting than just composition or flattening is that when executing the ordered computation, you can decide next computations based on previous results. This was what really made it click for me.


I find it easier to think of them as transforms which turn "a function which accepts/returns plain values" into a "function which accepts and returns a type which embeds plain values".

    map     :: (a -> b)     -> (t a -> t b) -- Functor
    bind    :: (a -> t b)   -> (t a -> t b) -- Monad
    cobind  :: (t a -> b)   -> (t a -> t b) -- Comonad
    ap      :: t (a -> b)   -> (t a -> t b) -- Applicative
The resulting function type is the same in all these cases - the difference is the type of the input function. There are other similar functions which return a `(t a -> t b)` too.

The "ordered computation" isn't unique to monads, it applies to all of these when you chain them. For monads particularly though, you can't begin the continuation until the previous result has been generated - whereas with a comonad, you can begin the continuation right away and extract the value afterwards (inside the continuation).

Can also think of it like a producer/consumer or push/pull thing. Monads push values into some type `t`, and comonads pull values out of `t`.

The naming of `return` is perhaps unfortunate as it gives the impression you're returning a value (done to make do-notation look like imperative code) - but monads don't return values. `return` produces a computation.

`coreturn` is usually called `extract`, which is better naming - it extracts a value from a computation.

The order of arguments is also unfortunate because it makes the above pattern less obvious - they're usually written as:

    fmap :: f a -> (a -> b) -> f b
    bind :: m a -> (a -> m b) -> m b
So it's not obvious that `fmap` is transforming a function `(a -> b)` into one `(f a -> f b)`, etc.


When I worked at Microsoft, I learned that the average user will fail to do ANY process that is longer than 2 steps. Let that sink in and then reread your comment. Nobody cares about SOTA outside of tech. They want the basic floor of “it does what I need at a reasonable price” that’s it.


He’s saying put regular money in the bank vault, why complicate with crypto.


Yeah I use the Xbox edge browser sometimes, even popups break because they’re like wtf is this.


Ive been thinking about this a a lot, like now if LLMs can just try a bunch of things, you can just try them all now. Are there some applications where we can just brute force and test at scale and no longer need to understand? Where understanding is now in essence that it “works” and passes our acceptance tests.


There's been a decent amount of drugs that have been made via a brute force method, but it's a pretty physical process, usually pipetting a few hundred thousand compounds and samples. There's also a lot of drugs where we don't fully understand how they work.


I give a shit about knowledge! I think it's good entirely for its own sake.


I agree! I'm also not going to turn down an Alzheimer's vaccine that's been demonstrated to be safe and effective even if we don't know exactly how it works. (And if you think that's a contrived fantasy, check out the shingles vaccine).


I don’t think appeals to morality or ethics are required for this. You paid for the LLM’s output, you should be allowed to use it how you wish. The only reason distillation is a dirty word is the AI labs trying to spread FUD to protect their non-existent moat.


It’s to the point I don’t even read Anthropic’s marketing blog anymore lol. The ai psychosis is just so real when people take these fluff blog posts which never have evidence or reproducibility and treat them like gospel


It’s crazy to me that companies/researchers share important data with these AI labs, you’re basically giving them your secret sauce which they then share with all of your competitors via training on conversations. At the same time I don’t really know alternatives other than a slightly less than frontier local LLM. Not sure how good they are at math.


Academic work is based on worldwide sharing, the sharing is not the problem, it's the lack of attribution. Unsurprisingly, these companies neglect standards of academic honor and attribution. Some human researchers also used to do that but in a discipline like mathematics this used to be a small problem because people tend to be so specialized that very few people could just grab someone's research and quickly piggyback on it, and if they do, colleagues will generally understand what happened. Unfortunately, AI is changing this.


You are both using a different definition of sharing I believe. When people have an expectation of privacy, use by others should be forbidden. Tech has gone completely off the rails with the use of private data.


The ultimate drive for some researches is the pursuit of knowledge. If I'm stuck at some block which prevents me from continuing in some direction that I want, of course I would like some help. I believe we already have nonzero collaborative proofs on math.SE, I can't recall good examples, but I have definitely seen citations to mathSE before.

So for me it sounds quite natural to also share this with AI especially under the privacy assumption. Also there's the assumption of scale -- maybe your problem is not large enough for anyone to care to scoop; and just for blind retraining, how do they know that the proof is even correct to include it into training? I have definitely received a ton of incorrect proofs before. So the SNR of such private chats is also not clear. I'm imagining millions of masters/phd students also trying to solve various random things with various capabilities, but how much real signal is there?


Or start competing with you.


LMFTFY:

"Its crazy to me that some people are not egotistical, self-centered, and don't solely care about fame and wealth accumulation".


I don’t think you realize how often depressed people say they will but don’t commit suicide, and also being able to know when is quite remarkable - I think this study is pretty interesting, and not as obvious as you think it is.


yeah but look how much overhead this is

> They were sent brief (20-item) smartphone-based surveys 6 times/day for 3 months

Is that in any way realistic? 120 answers/day??


Assessing my mental state that often could lead to a crisis, if I’m already a bit unstable.

A dark take: “We can predict suicides by driving people to commit them”.


Yeah, I can't see what the questions were, but if they were about suicidal thoughts and plans, having to read, consider and respond to those questions six times a day would certainly reinforce any tendency to think about it, just through sheer exposure.


Makes me consider it just by thinking about enduring that


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: