Valid claims for services performed by a licensed doctor on an insured patient, yes.
If this is too much there is a simple way to avoid it, the way most everybody else does - don't write insurance policies that purport to cover people's medical issues.
A licensed medical professional has determined that 10,000 people require a treatment course that costs 1m per dose and requires 3 doses per day for 10 months. Now what? Is the insurance company obliged to go bankrupt and liquidate to support 10k patients?
Scarcity exists and rationing must occur to resolve that scarcity.
If said insurance company has agreed to cover 100% of costs? Sure, why not? Make bad bets, go bankrupt. But in the situation you describe, there should be an investigation into fraudulent conveyances. It would seem the insurance company rapidly took on a load of unsustainable business - presumably so they could book the revenue as profit and put it into their personal pockets before the bill came due.
Does your logic apply to houses as well? Pay into home insurance for decades, have a structure fire, then insurance company denies claim "sorry, scarcity exists! not everyone can have a house" ? I'd say that's preposterous - the whole point of insurance is to keep the insured party whole.
You are representing insurance companies as if they signed up to pay any and all medical expenses, which they absolutely havent!
If I carry wildfire insurance and then have a I kitchen fire, I wouldn't expect them to cover it.
Insurance isnt to make/keep you whole, in almost any cases. It might offset very specific issues, or mitigate a fraction of the cost of others. I have $10k life insurance on my infant. Will that make me whole?
As a hypothetical alternative, unconditional approval can be discussed, but has tons of problems around cost control.
We might as well all put money in a bank account and race to spend it.
They signed up to offer health insurance, a product that most everyone is forced to buy, while having very few choices about who they can buy it from. So no, I am not receptive to the idea that when it comes time to provide healthcare, that companies should be able to use fine print to weasel out of actually doing that! As a matter of public policy, the entire point of insurance is to provide coverage for small probability high cost events - expecting a purchaser to weigh which particular small probability events might end important to them runs directly contrary to that.
In general, the overarching dynamic of our system is the worst of both worlds - central planning for the provision of healthcare capacity, but then free market for extracting wealth based on the resulting shortages. I'm not saying pushing the way I'm pushing is a solution, rather merely pointing out the hypocrisy of the extractors to wax poetic about free markets when they're taking money, but then appeal to collective limits to avoid having to spend it.
If you want to talk about actual reform, sure. The easy response to what I'm saying is for health insurance companies to require 10% copays (or whatever purely-dollar-based schedule provides sufficient financial incentive for a patient to keep costs down). But of course that would require transparent pricing in a functioning market, rather than the state of shameless collusion and fraud the industry has entrenched itself in.
Also note getting back to the original topic, the reason people are so universally against AI writing justifications to deny healthcare is precisely because it is not a positive sum open market, but rather a negative sum closed market. Any "innovation" here is necessarily based on making things worse for actual patients the system is meant to serve. If you want AI in healthcare to be positively received, then you need to address this dynamic first!
Seems like you are starting from a distorted view of reality that is hard to build any productive change on. We aren't living in the same world.
The companies dont think they are selling a golden ticket to unrestricted care. Buyers dont think they are getting an unrestricted ticket.
You may want it to be the case, but asserting that is the contract everyone signed is delusional.
I dont think denials are negative sum. Every ai or human denial is money saved out of my pocket instead of waste on unnecessary care. I want more of them!
I think we agree markets and insurance benefits should be more transparent.
Get rid of policy specific pricing and make it all up front.
Insurance policies should be clear, Eg Generics only or unlimited access. Maybe insurance should dollar denominated like your car or home, eg insured up 100k/yr or 1 million lifetime.
I dont know if care would be better, but it would be more certain.
I agree that the government should stop restricting supply. Either lower accreditation standards or make lower tiers of doctors and HCPs. Let the market sort it out. A doctor with no bs and a 2 year MD should be paid less accordingly.
> Buyers dont think they are getting an unrestricted ticket.
They definitely do, to the extent that the plan says they will pay for X, if you need it, and your doctor thinks you need X, leads to a reasonable expectation that they should pay for X. But wait, the insurer decided you don't need X! Hooray, more profit for the insurer, and you don't get the care you need (and that you reasonably thought you had an "unrestricted ticket" for, based on need).
nit: This is fallacious. It would be great if the world were so simple. Outright profits are capped as a percentage of revenue (ACA). The real dynamic here is the ever growing bureaucratic complexity that creates and illusion of savings/sanity/control but actually does the completely opposite.
The other play that has/had been happening is the same people owning/controlling insurance companies also owning providers, as a way of getting money out (booked as expenses for the insurance entity) without running afoul of that cap.
You're the one invoking an idea of "golden tickets", as if access to healthcare should be some rare privilege rather than a reasonable expectation in a functioning society. And I am well aware I'm talking about how things should be rather than how they are.
> Every ai or human denial is money saved out of my pocket instead of waste on unnecessary care. I want more of them!
If you believe this universally, you can simply just cancel your health insurance and you will have solved the entire problem as you see it! But presumably you will only hold this position until you yourself end up needing substantial care.
Also from my experience it's not even outright denial is the problem, but rather the soft denial that a patient/family (already having to deal with the actual medical issues!) then needs to spend an extreme amount of time and effort to reverse. Never mind the overhead of the staff at providers whose whole job is to navigate this system and write justifications for the insurance companies - a core of rot the system is drowning in.
> Get rid of policy specific pricing and make it all up front.
Yes, I elaborated on some other things to show you we actually probably agree on a lot. I'd say our disagreement here is based on you having internalized a negative sum justification of the medical industry - one that absolves the insurance companies of responsibility for the position they've chiefly created and now sit.
On the whole I'd say providers have done as much, if not more, to corrupt the system. I can rant for hours about their routine-fraud-based billing practices, which tbh I have suffered more harm from than from insurance shenanigans. But here we're talking about insurance companies, and I don't think it's right to let them escape blame for their part - specifically the ever-growing-complexity paperwork bureaucracy they've eagerly created.
Sorry, my sentence structure was a bit ambiguous. By "valid" I mean conforming to the two conditions I followed with.
The licensed doctor is the one exercising judgement of whether a given treatment is medically prudent. An insurance company asserting that it is entitled to create its own medical opinion on which to deny care is sophistry. If the insurance company has a reason to believe that the doctor is violating their professional responsibilities, then the insurance company should take it up with the medical board.
(I think our healthcare system needs much more wider sweeping reform than this, although I'm not predisposed towards single payer. My angle here is pointing out the corruption of the current system)
> If I were in that room, I'd be throwing chairs. I'd be so vehemently opposed to this kind of garbage that the meeting would come to a screeching halt.
Sure. Then they'd call security, and reschedule the meeting to the next day. The next day, everyone would say "Great idea, let's do it!"
The problem is the incentives created by the pervasive digital backdoors products now ship with (for decades now). Consumers just aren't that forward thinking or self actualizing (or they would have never adopted these products in the first place!). Once one company does it and gets away with it, then all the rest follow.
The only thing that is really going to fix it is laws, and good luck with that with our corpo-pwned government. If you sold someone a device that you had added retained remoted access to, and then used it to harm them and benefit yourself, you'd be facing CFAA charges - even if you slipped some legalese nastygram in the box along with it. But when a corpo does the same thing, it's just a "profitable business practice".
I'd say contributory negligence on the part of the US military should bring the damages down to $60. You're prosecuting an extremist's holy war and shamelessly killing children, and you're running logistics through a country known for their tempers? Not the best idea.
> if you already have a negative view, it might further drive your opinion
Exactly. The goal isn't really to effect (create) what is uniformly considered to be true, but rather what some (likely small) subculture believes. This helps further entrench that subculture (providing one more example of how "Ukraine is the aggressor"), as well as uses up most of the air in the room for discussion in the larger context - as the nonsense point is repeatedly brought up and re-litigated in place of anything constructive/substantive. In other words, the ultimate goal of disinformation isn't to alter the truth, but rather to destroy confidence in there even being a truth.
I’m honestly very frustrated that this pattern has been on display for decades already (most prominently in Russias bot farms, and the American political quagmire) but no countries really are thinking in terms of actually combating this.
Yes we should be afraid of authoritarian regimes that could use this new power, but we get these regimes if we do nothing as well. And we should be wary of “ministry of truth”, but we will get it eventually anyway, and we could at least try to make it a real one that works, than just blatant fear lies and propaganda.
Countries should be experimenting in taking this whole thing head on - some institution that has no executive powers but has information clearance powers? Creating _some_ space that is accepted and respected enough so that serious discussion can happen.
It saddens me that we are just sleepwalking into a much more sinister world and it seems things will get worse before people feel the need to make it better?
Maybe the 20th century _was_ the anomaly because of the world wars disrupting all the previous powers, and now we are going back to the mean of an unequal world, with AI effectively creating economical problems for _everybody_.
facebook could shut it down tomorrow. so could twitter. they know. google knows.
VPNs and proxies are only so effective, and after twitter opened up where the posters are located we now know they're not hiding behind them very often.
but their leadership is ideologically inclined to the hard right, and perhaps more importantly, propaganda pays -- and that stock price gotta go up
The "man" is 80 years old and looks like he's already got radiation sickness. And Qatar Force One would be wheels up faster than you can say Bone Spurs. A "dirty bomb" isn't much of a threat.
I suspect Iran also knows that directly attacking the US would actually unify and bolster support for the deeply unpopular Trump-Epstein war, as Trump already helped their regime this way.
That condemnation would be better lobbed at all these parasitic businesses that showed up and put toll gates on what had been an environment of open information publishing.
Probably much worse with Firefox, at least with its security settings enabled. Google doesn't need to hassle you to login when they have another way to create a persistent identifier for you. Chrome is chock full of security vulnerabilities that let Google (and the rest of the surveillance industry) fingerprint you. They don't consider your privacy as part of their security model, so WONTFIX.
> a majority of the online stuff is set up similar to amazon, along with various third party vendors
I feel like all of these threads just get derailed by people not really staying focused on the value proposition offered by each store [0].
When I'm thinking about Walmart, I'm thinking about items that Walmart themselves are selling/fulfilling. I have never found a third party listing on Walmart.com to be compelling. In my estimation they must exist because listing is essentially free for Walmart and the seller [1], people get confused (especially browsing on a tiny screen on mobile), have no idea where they should actually buy a certain type of item, have no idea what things should cost, etc. [2]
So having said that, to me Walmart is actually an outlier in being different among [online] shopping. Most of the type of sundries you'd actually buy at Walmart get delivered quickly from the store (gig work courier?). Or if they won't do that for a certain item, or you don't feel like meeting the "shipping minimum", then you can do a store pickup.
Contrast with say Target where everything gets shipped Fedex (or Ontrac now I think), and basically takes at least two days if not several because it's coming from a further warehouse. I'd say this is in the same logistics bucket as Zoro, Newegg, etc - large shippers that still wholly rely on delivery companies for fulfillment.
[0] the thesis of the original article doesn't match my experience at all, but I also keep an eye on prices for what things should cost, and the idea that you'd just hit buy on some boots because Amazon itself told you they were a good deal is utterly foreign to me. Like yes, fuck their dark patterns. But the real check here is shopping around, or more pertinently, being able to have automated software that shops around.
[1] there is very little exclusiveness to third party listings. the same exact 3P-fulfilled listings are generally on Amazon, eBay, even Zoro / Home Depot / Lowes depending on the type of product.
[2] I'm more than willing to accept someone chiming in and pointing out something compelling they have found from 3P Walmart sellers [3]. Just do it within the framework please! Or point out where my estimated framework is wrong, that's great too! Just don't analyze things as if "Walmart" consists of everything returned from a naive query on walmart.com!
[3] eg I think the return policy might be better (90 days, and you can bring to the store for free?), but prices are also generally a little higher.
Good point. I think instead of comparing Walmart to Amazon, the correct comparison would be to Whole Foods if we are restricting ourselves to items that would be in-store locally and can be picked up and delivered quickly.
It's odd to me to frame things as "comparing Walmart to Amazon" as if you'd only ever be considering those two options. But it's even more odd to compare to Whole Foods instead. (or at least Whole Foods as I remember it. I haven't been in years as I'd have to go out of my way these days, and Trader Joe's uses that bandwidth)
Each store (or really each fulfillment method of each store) has types of items of items they're good at. That is my primary key for where I start looking.
Most items that I've found Walmart is good at, are going to be nowhere near a Whole Foods. And for food items specifically where they do manage to overlap, I would expect Whole Foods to be much more expensive for little gain. But YMMV, as food is like the one single thing where I still go to physical stores - I haven't found any online+delivery that provide enough value to justify the various fees they want.
In my experience, for most items that Walmart is going to be good at, Target is likely also going to be good at. Some of them will also be on Amazon at reasonable prices.
reply