HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | michaelbuckbee's commentslogin

Beyond all the issues with third party JavaScript inclusion on sites blowing up their security perimeter, there are also significant issues with the link tracking for these as they nest and re-encode their values so much in the URLs any reasonable firewall concludes that they're some kind of obfuscation attack.

Usually they don't, they just need to fire an event with the analytics properties from the link and whatever persistent identities are available on the client side (device ID, fingerprint etc.), and then keep firing new events with at least one of those identities. The link URL or query string will have the user's canonical identities in it already.

When IDs don't persist across domains or subdomains there are also plenty of methods that don't involve passing via URL or tripping reasonable network security, and that work for >99% of user clients.


There have been a few published rumors of Apple getting ready to release a new set of local models.

Where did you see these rumors?


+1 for Blacksmith. You need to have a Github org to use it as it won't work on personal accounts, but it feels like a magic want that just makes runners 2x as fast.

I have it for all my stuff (dozens of repos and hundreds of PRs/builds per week) and it's only once in the last year that I've exceeded the free resource levels. I don't know if it's just extra capacity or they're burning VC dollars in the hopes of inspiring posts like this, but either way I feel like I'm taking advantage of them at this point.


But doesn't Blacksmith piggy back off of the Github Actions control plane? Outages will just spread to Blacksmith


I saw video of a costume contest this year where one participant was wearing an Amazon delivery driver vest, flung a cardboard box across the stage and then took a picture of it (all to wild applause).


Well it's negotiated, right?

So say you run a SaaS that allows for something like letting people set their Avatar from an image URL which gets downloaded.

As an attacker I setup a new server that serves only brotli and then submit that URL to the SaaS.


Just send a POST with Content-Encoding:br to any URL and hope it gets decided before the URL route is checked.


> So say you run a SaaS that allows for something like letting people set their Avatar from an image URL which gets downloaded.

That's a clever example, but why would you do that? The avatar should be a static resource. As such, I'd only provide an upload file dialog.


Gravitar was super popular for a year or two.

Quit being overly pedantic about how contrived the example is and struggle with the underlying fact that the compression type is negotiated between the client and server. If the compression happens on the HTTP request (as some of the comments here suggest), then the server must use that compression method or it fails to read the body of the request.


> how contrived the example is

That's basically one of the core ingredients of security. Build a threat model.


Lots of apps will, for example, bring in your Google avatar (i.e. they fetch its URL for ingestion) as a default avatar if you use them for SSO. Slack included, IIRC.


I can almost certainly make my browser submit its file upload POST with the compression of my choice and your server will accept it.


apache does not accept brotli by default. so while the first part is true, the second part is only true for some X% of websites.


There’s both request compression (no negotiation) and response compression (negotiated).


So if I read the post here and told someone, would I be breaking the embargo?


No, you didn't. I misread.


I don't think you're supposed to actually host a real site on ngrok like that (idk, guy works for them).


Yea, it's advertising their 1-shot hosting like everyone else is doing lately:

https://ngrok.com/ship


Stay tuned ;)


Even air conditioners have improved as we've moved away from having multiple leaky window air conditioners to mini-splits and central (though I would still think that's an increase in overall energy use).


we never had window AC in the UK, if we did it was only a handful of installations.


Was this rooftop or ground mount? Asking because I keep getting rooftop quotes closer to $20k than $12k


"The utility of a robot is inversely proportional to how much it looks like a robot." -- Buckbee's law.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: