HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | mcherm's commentslogin

Hosting on your own website is a GREAT solution for avoiding platform censorship, and the tools to do so easily and cost effectively exist.

That leaves two key issues: getting paid, and discovery.

Getting paid (at a minimum, enough to cover hosting bandwidth and art supplies, but I like to dream some artists earn at least a tiny bit from their work) works now but is VERY fragile. Just a couple of vendors offer mostly-not-censored payment services (eg: Patreon) and if they stopped due to pressure from credit card networks, governments, or billionaires it would be difficult to replace them.

As for discovery, we need to build platforms that aren't the major social networks that can help audiences find new comics. This is a fairly easy problem to solve.


Yes, but "DELETE" is the basic, built-in tool for deleting some rows from a database. Maintaining partitions, and migrating long-lived data from old partitions is a workaround.

There is nothing wrong with using the partition solution -- it might be a good solution to your problem. But it certainly isn't a case of "rejecting technological simplicity" if someone chooses to use DELETE instead.


IME as a DBRE, it usually is rejecting simplicity. Most devs know precious little about RDBMS, and so reach for what they do know. When an experienced DBA / DBRE shows them the idiomatic way to do what they’re attempting, they often reject it and claim “flexibility,” or “keeping logic out of the database.” It’s just not wanting to do things they’re unfamiliar with, but for some reason it’s accepted for RDBMS, because it lives in the liminal space of infra and code.


If you wanted to argue that the Democratic party suffers from many of the same problems, then there might be a productive conversation to have.

But if you genuinely cannot see a difference between the current Trump administration in the Democratic party -- if you argue that they are completely identical, with all differences "just for show" -- then I cannot believe you are making your statements in good faith.


The futures market (or at least the ones I was watching) predicted that Donald Trump would lose both of the presidential elections he ran in (especially the first).

That should serve as a simple existence proof that the futures market CAN and does sometimes "lie".


Since you didn't state which futures, I will assume it was the Canadian and Russians futures. And your spot on those markets do lie.

At least in the U.S. they we're spot on predicting Trump's victory 2022 & 2016, and congressional control. 2020 predicted the loss.

If your willing to share how you read futures markets for predicting elections I'd love to hear it.


Prior to recent Supreme Court decisions many regulatory agencies and things like the Justice Department were independent agencies that could provide some check on executive branch abuses. But that is gone now.

Congress can perform investigations, but without the President's signature they cannot take actions that have the force of law. Impeachment cannot remove any official from office without 2/3 support in the Senate. Congress CAN refuse to fund some activities, but the administration has been ignoring existing legal restrictions on spending.

So no, Congress won't take any meaningful action to reign things in for at least two years, regardless of who wins the election unless we also overthrow the government in some way.


Yes. In fact, I have met quite a few humans who make a point NOT to go bashing the work of others. (Of course, I have also met quite a few who do spend their time bashing others.)


It is true that Rust does not have a complete formal specification for its type system which has been analyzed and proven to be sound.

You seem to be implying that because of this, Rust has no definition of its type system (other than whatever happens to be implemented in the current compiler). I would disagree.

As evidence, I would like to point out that not a single person argued that this flaw was not a bug, but was in fact the officially defined behavior. Clearly, the community has a shared understanding of what Rust's type system "ought" to do.


The true specification was inside our hearts all along!


I mean yes, part of our understanding of systems is a social one!


Sure, but in Rust's case the social understanding is "there exists some type system that guarantees perfect memory safety, and has the general aesthetic features associated with rustc's type system, and 'Rust' is defined to be whatever that type system ends up being".

This is a nice ideal, but it doesn't actually exist in concrete terms as a design. It can never have flaws because the definition of it is just "rustc without all the flaws".


Haskell is in a similar boat with regards to a missing formal spec.



> It's not as if visibility into whether someone voted or not has driven voter turnout

Actually, it does. If the party you are registered with thinks are a voter who might not make it to the polls, and this is a close/important election, then there is a good chance you will receive numerous calls and/or visits reminding you to go out and vote. However, if you show up on the list of people who have voted by mail OR if you appear on the registry of people who have already voted in person, then they will stop reaching out to offer rides and reminders.


What if the opposing party knows you haven’t voted yet?


The practice of making public whether someone has voted dates back a very long time. There were practical reasons for it when it originated, and many of those remain valid today.

Originally, everyone in town knew most everyone else and could see them physically walking into the polling place. So long before electronic records were kept, the question of who voted was public information.

Even today, I run my local polling station and I know and recognize a significant portion of the voters in my precinct.

The fact that the list of who votes is made public protects against several kinds of abuses. It goes a long way to protect against "dead people voting" and other kinds of ballot box stuffing if the list of voters is public so anyone can review it and potentially catch such abuses.


The value of transparency goes above and beyond protecting against abuses (for which there are other methods) - it also provides assurance to the public that there is protection against those abuses, and that those abuses are not taking place.

i.e. 'Justice must not only be done, but must also be seen to be done'


I once read an account by a poll watcher of her experience in 2012. She said that at her polling place, there had been a number of people showing up to vote on Election Day, being told they had already voted during the early-voting process, and swearing up and down that that wasn't true, that they always voted on Election Day and never voted early, and that whoever had voted in their name had done so fraudulently.

Now, in that particular case, the state (I believe it was Colorado though I'd have to find the article I read, and I don't remember where to find it any more) didn't require photo ID, so there was no way to prove that the people showing up on Election Day were the actual voters, as opposed to the cheaters. But this poll watcher's opinion was that they were the actual voters, and the cheating had been done by whoever had submitted ballots in their name days (or weeks) earlier. Given how many people she said this had happened to, I'm inclined to agree with her: it wasn't three or four people, it was (she said) something like one-third of the people who showed up on Election Day at that polling place.

That's a case where the fraud couldn't be repaired by knowing that it had occurred — the fraudulent ballots (if they were indeed fraudulent) had already been accepted, and it was impossible to go pull the ballot allegedly belonging to Joe Smith back out of the ballot box. But the publicly-available list of "who voted" did at least make it possible for the fraud to be detected in that particular case.


I think all you can do is sue at that point.

I personally do support voter ID, and for the same reason. Members of the public must be able to verify the process is happening fairly. It might be fair without it (fraud truly negligible), but it must also be seen to be fair. This would resolve so many controversies.

Likewise mandatory voting and private ballots (can cast a donkey vote) helps ensure the public people are not being paid to vote and that other biases are not coming into play.


I'm not entirely sure mandatory voting is wise in a country the size of the United States, but I'm with you on the voter ID and the rationale. I was shocked to learn that with everything else that requires photo ID, it's not required to vote in American elections. (At least, in some locations; laws vary from place to place). That just looks bad.

My personal opinion is that if people think they can benefit from cheating, a certain number will do so. It's just human nature. We're seeing more and more of this with LLM cheating on the rise in universities. So there's always going to be a certain number of people who want to vote fraudulently — after all, if the right person gets into office, it'll probably benefit you. Your taxes might be lowered, or your government handouts might be increased, or whatever other reason you have for preferring one politician over another. Preference alone does not mean that people will vote fraudulently: after all, most legitimate voters also prefer one politician over another. But the easier you make it to cheat, the more people will cheat successfully: among those who wanted to cheat but didn't, usually the only reason they didn't is because they couldn't see how to get away with it.

So photo ID to vote just seemed like common sense to me, along with other measures like ballot boxes kept in a publicly-visible place until they're opened, to help prove that nobody has tampered with them. (Read up on the 1946 elections in Athens, TN sometime — there, the fraud was being done by the sheriff and his cronies who would take the ballot boxes away, "count" them in private with no outside observers present, and announce that surprise surprise, the sheriff's crony had won the election again).


We only recently started requiring ID here in the UK, it was a move that was seen by many as a form of Gerrymandering because the actual recorded rate of voter fraud in a general election is very low, around 200-300 cases per election usually.

In the last general election 16,000 people were prevented from voting because they didn't have the correct ID - despite there being mechanisms for them to get suitable ID for free ahead of an election.

Sometimes the fix is worse than the actual problem you're trying to solve.


Interestingly UK has another system to prevent fraud - you can only vote at a single polling station. So it is historically more restrictive than most of US (and here in AU). Explains the low fraud rates. And likely inhibits a lot more voters than a simple ID check.

Also, without a photo ID the fraud rate is near impossible to measure - people can just sell their votes to imposters, fabricate voters, etc. It would be undetectable in your stats. A similar concern applies to postal votes, and there have been high profile cases of this in the UK.

As a concrete example The Tower Hamlets Scandal saw Luftur Raham's election declared null 'on the grounds of corrupt and illegal practices by him and his agents, and general corruption so extensively prevailing so to reasonably supposed to have affected the election' despite a similar number of low hundreds of allegations of fraud. That's a proven-in-court example showing you are wrong to dismiss the concern based on the data. The methods used are clearly not detectable by the system you endorse, and that system has demonstrably lead to the unjust disenfranchisement of your fellow countrymen.


An added benefit of voter id is that by making it easy or cheap for one groups and difficult or expensive for an other (or choosing acceptable IDs that already have these characteristics) you can create some friction to make it more difficult for the wrong people to vote.

That is why I like voter ID if it relies on documents provided for free with minimal fuss.


The situation you describe, where the laws would be selected to make obtaining a photo ID (and thus voting) difficult for one group over another, would amount to a poll tax — which has already been found unconstitutional in the United States.

However, every US state I'm aware of (if you know of exceptions, please let me know) has some form of photo ID you can obtain for free. Usually it's in the same format as a driver's license, and obtained from the same place (the Department of Motor Vehicles, Department of Land Transportation, the name varies). There's a fee to obtain a driver's license, but a photo ID card (in the same format as a driver's license but marked "NOT LEGAL FOR DRIVING" or similar wording) can be obtained for free, by going through the same process as getting a driver's license (bring something to prove your identity, get your photo taken, wait for the card to be printed) but without taking a driving-skills test.

And before someone asks "what about the people who can't prove their identity"? Well, I can actually give an anecdote. I know someone who ended up in that situation: away from home for college, couldn't get her birth certificate or anything else, and needing to replace her passport that was lost. (She is American but had grown up overseas because of her parents' job, hence why she had a passport but no driver's license when she went off to college). She had quite a time of it at first, since every "prove your identity" requirement circled back around to another form of ID. But she was eventually able to get a fishing license just by swearing under penalty of perjury that she was indeed (name). With that in hand, she got another form of ID (I think a library card, though there my memory is iffy), then with two forms of ID she could get something else, and then eventually she was able to get that non-driver's ID card... and then was able to prove who she was to get her lost passport reissued.

That all happened nearly 30 years ago so I can't swear to the details. But the point is, photo ID cards are widely available, and it's normal to be asked for one. So as long as the law specifies that acceptable forms of photo ID include X, Y, and Z (where X, Y and Z are forms that most people would already have, and that are normal and in common use), and as long as at least one of those forms can be obtained without a fee (which as I said, is true in all U.S. states that I'm aware of, please mention any exceptions you know about because I'd like to know) then it will pass Constitutional muster.


This sounds like some third-hand anecdata. Trump et al (Chris Kobach, for one) have spent millions of dollars trying to find voter fraud and they have all come up with zilch.

And you have some memory of some account from someone 12 years ago in a state you can't remember saying that a third of voters had someone pretend to be them?

If this were close to true, it wouldn't be some blog post that you can't remember; it would have been a national scandal and it would have been something that we would never forget because the election stealer conspiracy theorists would never let it go.

Really, you should just delete this post as it's irresponsible and lacks any data.


The point I'm trying to make is that I agree with the parent comment to mine, which pointed out that transparency is essential to protect people's confidence in the voting process, especially when people are loudly claiming that someone committed fraud. The more open the process, the easier it is to prove that it's legitimate.


> The point I'm trying to make is that I agree with the parent comment to mine

But you did that by making a big, surprising claim for which you haven't provided any evidence. You might not intend for that to be the main thing people focus on, but they are right to be both interested and skeptical! If true, it's a big deal.

The closest thing I could find is this (https://www.thenation.com/article/archive/voters-predominant...), which was attributed to 'human error' rather than fraud, and was resolved by allowing the affected voters to cast provisional ballots. 'Human error' is a vague explanation, and for all I know it was a coverup -- but the onus is on you to provide some positive reason to believe that. Surely there were plenty of people motivated to investigate this, so it would be surprising if a bullshit explanation was just quietly accepted and no further public attention paid.


And my point is you, like Trump and Kobach, can't prove there is a voting fraud problem so instead share, at best, anecdotes.

Not sure why your OG post is still up.

Voter ID solves a non-existent fraud problem and does so by making voting harder.


No system is immune to bad faith actors undermining trust by just making shit up.

The idea that if we had paper ballots with walk-in only, ID-verified votes, that Trump and Fox News et al wouldn't have launched a coup attempt, or wouldn't have gotten nearly as far, is pretty laughable. In fact we have Trump on the record saying as much: "It doesn't matter whether you win or lose, you have to fight like hell."

Let's take your scenario. In fact there is a way to verify which vote was correct (and it's used already) which is to match the signatures between the voter registration and the ballot.

This is sufficient except in cases where the registration itself was fraudulent, which would have required 1) having someone's ID at time of registration and 2) intercepting the mail sent to their ID- or utility-bill-confirmed mailing address.

An attacker who could achieve that could also have achieved just walking into the polling place to achieve the same false vote.

Any attack is extremely expensive to do at any meaningful scale, and all scaled attacks are detectable by simple statistical sampling.

If meaningful amounts of tampering were detected by statistical sampling then you can obviously re-run elections with tighter controls, more burden, lower turnout, and a generally-less-representative result, which is why we start with a more inclusive system. This can and does actually happen. Whether it's necessary is literally 100% statistically knowable through basic sampling.


I’d rather have buffoons looking for fraud under every rock and not finding it than people like yourself insisting, without evidence, that it never happens while showing no interest in doing even the simplest things to reassure people that no fraud is occurring.


Yet so few people go the next step and say, “Let’s do away with the secret ballot itself.” It really is a recent invention, American democracy survived nearly 100 years before the Australian ballot was adopted. There are obviously concerns (vote buying, organized crime, etc) but they can be dealt with. And public voting would almost completely eliminate concerns about the voting process itself being subverted by a malign actor.


> There are obviously concerns (vote buying, organized crime, etc) but they can be dealt with.

I don't think they can be dealt with. But I'm willing to listen to your ideas. How would you deal with vote buying? How would you stop the scenario where a guy says "I'll give you $1,000 if you vote for candidate X" (or "I know where you live, I'll break your kneecaps if you vote for candidate Y")?


I mean, the same way we deal with corruption, bribery, and threats generally; have a strong, independent law enforcement and prosecutors office. The FBI regularly and successfully investigates (and the DoJ indicts and secures convictions for) legislators, whose voting record is already public, who sell their votes on city councils or in state legislatures. It takes a lot of votes to swing most elections, so a concerted bribery campaign would be much easier to investigate than these examples.


Are you confident that Trump's FBI and DOJ (and Trump-aligned state police/prosecutors; if you are a Trump supporter, please substitute in the names of your most distrusted democrats) would vigorously pursue all credible allegations of vote-buying and coercion in his favour? And even if you are, and they did, do you think more than ~half the country would believe it?


As elections are run by the states, you can have state and local governments legislate anti-corruption law and enforce it too. So, no, no real concerns with who specifically is in charge at the federal level at any given time


Vote buying/intimidation is just too big a vector, IMO. I would never accept that risk. It's transitive too - you can pay/intimidate the people who enforce the no paying/intimidating rule.


You can structure the law such that, if you report a bribe that results in a conviction, the criminal is still forced to pay the person they attempted to bribe, similar to how Qui Tam works. This would do a lot to discourage attempts at bribing law enforcement and prosecutors, who would be best positioned to secure such a conviction.


I would never vote again if it wasn’t anonymous. Retaliation is real.


I would suggest that if you don’t have the courage of your convictions to stand by your vote in public, maybe you shouldn’t be voting in the first place


It's easy to minimize someone else's situation down to "courage".

Quite a few husbands believe they should have control over their wives' votes. I guess you'd say they should have the courage to leave them and wreck their children's lives and be ostracized by their family and community?

And it's not hard to imagine certain employers having a strong opinion on how you vote on specific measures. Of course they couldn't compel anyone to reveal their votes, but it could be made customary enough that refusing to would be enough of a signal. I guess you'd need the courage to quit and take a lower paying job?


An employer creating a hostile workplace should obviously create a tort and liability under any kind of reasonable anti-corruption law in the same way it does under anti-discrimination law.

As for what happens in marriages or other social settings, yes, wives can coerce their husbands, fathers can coerce their adult daughters, friends can coerce one another. If your counterpart is the kind of person who would threaten to blow up your relationship over how you vote, yes, I would suggest maybe that tells you something about who they are and whether or not you want them in your life. But if the relationship means that much to you, you can always go along to get along and let them tell you how to vote. I think that says something about how much you value your vote though. And at the societal level, I don’t think this would have a meaningful impact on governance


I genuinely believe that once the current administration is out of office the new President should strongly campaign in favor of the strongest possible changes to prevent dictatorship: constitutional amendments to reverse some of the most egregious harm done by the Supreme Court and the general inaction in response to fascism. Then if the opposition party isn't supportive, the new President should set a date after which they threaten to abuse their powers in exactly the same ways Trump has abused his. Surely that would motivate the opposition party, right?


> he new President should strongly campaign in favor of the strongest possible changes to prevent dictatorship:

And why would they do that? Willingly give up power?

Of course they should, but it's not something I would bet much money on.


IMO just start with SEAL Team 6's "official actions" and then you can start proposing changes. That way you just need to motivate the people who didn't already attempt a coup.


Very little of what has happened is novel.


Frog reports water is still comfortable, though no longer lukewarm.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: