HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | max_sendfeld's commentslogin

There have been so many attempts at this. From "Alexa, buy a blue jacket" to embedded shopping for items in movie scenes to smart fridges ordering food...

It turns out that people like to do some research, look at a lot of images, read user reviews and more before making a purchasing decision. The subset of people that treat most everyday shopping as a completely automatable commodity is much lower than the tech world thinks.


Anecdotal, I've used ChatGPT to do most of my research on buying things lately. For instance, I am learning how to sew outdoor gear -- backpacks, duffel bags, pouches, etc. I basically take ChatGPT's recommendations at face value when I'm asking about what kind of thread, zippers, webbing, etc. I should by based on what I'm trying to create. While I'm doing the research, I have at times wished I could just say, "Okay, buy that for me from one of these handful of retailers."

"I take chatGPTs recommendations at face value" just means "I beleive whoever is paying the most to get their products into chatGPT, at face value". If you dont think this is what's happening, you're a fool.

This is going exactly the same route as Apple or Android's "forced" 15/30% cuts... they will start free, and then, start to take commissions, or else, they will not "recommend" your product.

This is yet another attempt at squeezing the money out of sellers.. and it will mostly be smaller ones that will be impacted.

One silver-lining is this might give some negotiating power to sellers on Amazon.. who have been ripped-off by Amazon more and more every passing year.. until of course, they both don't end up colluding.


We are going to enter an economy in which the quality of anything sold is irrelevant, and the only thing that matters is outbidding everyone at sponsored content. Even brand recognition will be meaningless when everybody just buys whatever their AI agents recommend them.

I think about this sometimes in relation to Adam Smith. He talks a lot about division of labour, making pins and so forth, but not at all about the cost of marketing products. Yet in the economy today the cost of finding and convincing your customers is often the dominating cost - especially in software. Are we really efficiently solving the economic problem any more, or just playing pretend like we are?

Adam Smith couldn't have predicted marketing to be a dominating cost back in the 18th century. Goods were cumbersome to transport, only commodities or luxury items would be worth sailing around, and those don't really need marketing.

Just like how everyone just buys what their TV tells them to?

At worst, at best maybe it's an honest user's review on reddit. Or a content marketing company's bot's review. Maybe it's a hobbyist's personal site that was scraped. Or an industry shill's site.

Some care is in order with this approach, especially when ChatGPT uses web searches. Some companies are known to market their products disguised as user feedback in forums etc. so when ChatGPT just goes ahead and reads these posts (or even reads marketing material directly) it will definitely steer the output. There are also cases in which websites cater to these agents directly.

Not saying a user couldn't also be tricked by this, but of course it is more nuanced than the models sometimes make it out to be.


Why can't you right now?

I agree, but I see a use case if this is integrated directly into standard chats. Many people use ChatGPT to research products and would probably check out within ChatGPT if they had the chance.

i dont think its being treated as an automatable commodity. one of the most popular uses of chatgpt is to aggregate and compare item information. in fact it improves the researching and reviewing experience

This just makes it so you can actually buy the thing from chatgpt vs. going to a specific site and filling out your info


ChatGPT is not the only large language model available, anyone can make or download their own.

very odd misunderstanding of the original point

automatable commodity is referring to buying stuff


How often do you need something you really need to research?

I think you've got it backwards. The vast majority of people who don't have enough time to begin with will gladly just keep typing their shopping cart into their AI of choice.

I wouldn't be surprised if this ends up being the majority of usage for suburban housewives, along with webmd type things and relationship questions.


You can do all that within a ChatGPT conversation. It can provide links or you can ask for them.

How is this going to compare to one-click purchases? which is banned in enough places.

What about "ChatGPT, buy regular groceries for this week" ? There are a whole class of items I don't do much research for. I can have a thread where I keep updating this list based on the season and week on week is just done and maybe it gives me useful suggestions based on behaviour too.

I think many people do "research" their groceries somewhat, and it can be highly personal.

Does ChatGPT know that my kid wants grapes but my wife wants him to eat only organic grapes, but doesn't like grapes herself, so we should only buy a small quantity of organic grapes?

Or that as a household we try to avoid Nestle products altogether?

Or that we want tortillas, but only made of flour and the burrito size from one specific manufacturer?

Maybe after enough time and enough coaching it could get it right, but I also have never ordered groceries online. I don't even trust a random person to do a good job picking produce, so I suppose I'm far from the imagined target market here.


"Sure! I just set a monthly HelloFresh plan for you!"

Any information you could find is SEO-sponsored slop, all the accompanying images are AI generated, all the reviews LLM-written by bot farms. Go on with the times and just talk to your AI agent to get the latest sponsored answers.

People are already doing all their shopping benchmarks on ChatGPT and Claude. A wallet for agents like Stripe Link or ChatGPT will remove friction, and humans love being lazy.

Just saying something has not worked in the past doesn't make it true for the next iteration too. Many touch-enabled phones failed before the iphone.


AI is a great shopping research companion. There are critiques to be made, but I don't understand yours.

I think the critique is focused on this part of the announcement:

> Over time, we expect users to be able to delegate purchases entirely to their agent by setting clear parameters—such as spending limits, purchase categories, or time periods—and pre-approve those purchases with enhanced safeguards

Researching with AI is one thing, but the announcement is suggesting that eventually they want to be able to take the human out of that loop too.


ive been testing this for a while, because I am a serial over-researcher when I buy stuff.

It is a great research companion, but it is perhaps the most important use case I've run across to feed multiple models from different providers the same/similar prompts. You'll get wildly different suggestions sometimes.


Researching is not the same as “Alexa, buy me a black cylindrical jelly shaped object”

You may have a point - there is a kitchen tool that helps you drain curd to make thicker yoghurts (greek yoghurt or something). And I saw it once in an online shop and though I would buy it later. But I just couldn't find the same thing again, despite trying different keywords. Searching by describing it would indeed have been useful.

You are holding it wrong. Did you know that Alexa for shopping can do AI search on its inventory? It is quite useful. https://www.aboutamazon.com/news/retail/alexa-for-shopping-a...

Walmart has one too: https://corporate.walmart.com/news/2026/10/sparky-shopping-a...


Good thing openai doesn't make Alexa or currently any home speaker assistant.

I believe it is the same with travel. Some tech bros will plan their honeymoon with AI, yes, but choosing your favorite airbnb is sometimes part of the fun of a trip.

Not to be insensitive, but stock is at 164.53 right now (down from almost 240). Good time to buy or is there worse to come?

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: