Probably a mix of both. There's a gigantic amount of costs (and debt) piling up for many companies without anything to show for it when it comes to generating revenue.
But for sure a lot of businesses are getting disrupted - Adobe and now Google are good examples. Just that Google has quite a lot of areas where it shouldn't be so bad - Android, Youtube, mail & storage, cloud. And AI lets them reduce headcounts which is a very big cost.
Yeah Youtube has no real competitor and AI shouldn't disrupt it that much, aside from the inflow of AI generated content which might be a problem on the storage cost side.
But most of Google's income is from search and AI/LLMs are killing it off pretty fast. Maybe they'll try to more forcibly inject ads into the summary output.
I think when AIs start summarising YouTube videos it will take a hit too.
I do this a lot already, I run the audio through a transcriber and get an LLM to summarise that. I deeply hate watching videos because I have a short attention span (ADHD). I'm really glad I now have the tools to not have to do that anymore. Because some content is only available in video or podcast format.
i think thats a very specific subset of ppl consuming technical cotent where ai summary makes sense.
most of youtube is pop content that doesnt make sense to summarize. Because ppl are trying to get entertained not gain knowledge. take a look at top trending videos.
The problem is you're focused on 1st order effects. I presume you work at some company that sells a product or provides a service - what happens if the demand for that evaporates because the clients can do it themselves or the market has been flooded by much cheaper alternatives created using AI? Or people who bought the product can't do it as they lost their jobs to automation?
Second, if "all software vendors in all spaces get wiped out" was going to happen I think we'd be seeing more of it already. Yes, there is support for some software vendors possibly getting wiped out... but, then again, you can't look at a bad vibe coded implementation of "the entire Adobe suite" that was rather overblown in the press coverage and forget that Adobe also has AIs. Instead what I'm seeing at my own workplace as we ponder the question of "should we replace this service we buy with some local vibe coding" is still remaining but we don't want to support that. Can we replace Confluence with vibe coding? Yes, but that was true five years ago too and we didn't want to do it then, either. We still don't want to do it. HN commenters have always overestimated the desire everyone in the world has to become programmers and take responsibility for everything.
One wonders what percentage of those who are certain that vibe coding is going to nuke all software vendors can't even be arsed to self-host a Jellyfin or VaultWarden install... which is way easier than vibe coding the whole of those things from scratch, and we're talking about people who are already programmers. Physician, heal thyself.
This is the same naivete that I saw in coding some time ago before most people finally accepted there is no going back and the times of writing code by hand are gone.
And the guy is not a mathematician primarily - he's a Youtube creator and entrepreneur. I liked a lot of his videos but now I usually just ask the LLM for detailed explanation and I can probe it as much as I want if something is not clear enough.
Education will also take a huge hit, you can't really beat an almost free supergenius that has all the time in the world to explain something to you in as much detail as you wish.
It is not, and for the same reason it's not over for mathematics. For anyone doing anything truly novel, and yes there are still software engineers out there doing that, it's still inept.
It's de jour to leverage formal verification as LLMs are quite good at looping it, but that's still a tool we had to invent to solve problems. It'll be truly over when we're being outpaced in the realm of invention but I have seen absolutely nothing to suggest that has meaningfully occurred at all. Coding by hand is not gone, there's just less of a reason to do so now.
I’m a cheerleader for the Khanmigo AI tutor effort. But, apparently so far they are discovering that the hard part is getting the kids motivated to actually ask the AI any questions.
3Blue1Brown does an amazing job of making math interesting to learn in itself. As opposed to the hundreds of millions of kids told “You just have to learn it or you’ll be dumb. Keep up or you’ll fall behind forever. Go!”
The vid calls out explicitly that math education is a primarily a motivation problem and I agree. One way or another, we need a lot more focus on that.
Lack of motivation can be a problem and I love 3b1b videos. However, if you want to truly learn, you still have to sit 30-60 hours on a subject to be able to solve problems. No motivation will replace that.
When you have limited time to learn as a student, you either have the smarts to learn in the limited time or you cheat.
I can beat this “supergenius” - I hire a professor that knows exactly how to teach and what to teach. This professor isn’t rolling the dice every time I ask them a question. Boom.
It mostly is. Just that "spiritual" doesn't automatically mean something mythical like God. It can be politics, astrology, social justice, philosophy, etc.
Something that we think is very important to us and the World and bigger than us.
Have you not noticed the fervor with which acolytes of each 'side' preach the gospel according to their respective messiah? One can easily see similarities between sports and politics and you can't see those between religion and politics?
Reads in a lot of places a bit like a mix of anger and bargaining. There is no putting the genie back into the bottle.
But I understand that for people whose whole life was math and solving math problems this will lead to an identity crisis. Seen the same in my area of work (software engineering)
IMO, this is better. Luna is super cheap, but it's not that capable. At higher levels of reasoning, it's not that fast.
This is more expensive, but it also looks like it's better enough that it's far more useful.
I also won't be surprised if you look at cost per completed task + wall clock time that it comes out ahead for the majority of what you'd want to actually use it for.
Luna will still be a great option for doing non-engineering tasks super cheaply.
You assume that a bug that can take down production is more likely to be produced by the LLM than by a human. That very well might not be so with current models and especially in the future once they get even better.
It's coping, the truth is writing code by hand is dead.
3 years ago, these things became useful. Every year, they're drastically better. Most juniors are already dead weight. Most of the rest of us are next.
IDK how it could be otherwise. It's moving too fast and gone too far already.
I'd love to know if you still felt that way after seeing what I do in a day. Company IP won't allow it. Maybe I'll stream some personal dev work or something.
I'm not saying you're wrong, but, I'd be shocked if you were still so adamant (assuming you're rational and not in your own psychosis).
Here's something I'm about to drop on AI. Like 90% of things like this, when I ask for a fix (with a few skills), get fixed with fewer edge cases left dangling than I'd have left if I'd spent all week on this stuff. And, it'll be done before tomorrow, with no further input from me. This is a list I put together in about 1 hour.
Things to fix with OCR text labeling
- vertical line in center breaks box-drag
- nope, not line in middle... IDK why, but the drag pretty frequently snaps back to original position in middle of drag... lets me keep dragging, but have to start back from there
- happens with "draw stamp box" too
- forces me to re-click the button to start over
- add zoomed view of text in bottom right corner of video
- add ability to restrict OCR
- current job is 0 1 2 3 4 X 6 7 8 9
- 5 is an X, for some reason
- is detecting full alphanumeric
- add ctrl+z undo for modifications to drawn box
- deleting character in middle of "your label" text box jumps cursor to end
I could do even better than you in 30 minutes and let it write code for a satellite if I wouldn't care about quality. But at this point I have the feeling I'm talking to a bot
Yeah, I'm not saying this is an example of great work. It's sufficient for the job - more time spent refining my instructions isn't necessary.
What I'm saying is, with just the effort it takes to notice and somewhat-sloppily mention things, they get fixed, and usually fixed well. Further testing will tell us whether it needs more work or not.
They may have never had these troubles at all, if I'd coded by hand originally, but then, this particular app would've never been written, because it wouldn't justify that amount of work.
But for sure a lot of businesses are getting disrupted - Adobe and now Google are good examples. Just that Google has quite a lot of areas where it shouldn't be so bad - Android, Youtube, mail & storage, cloud. And AI lets them reduce headcounts which is a very big cost.