HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | marcus_holmes's commentslogin

None of that is part of commercial web dev culture. Leftpad-level dependencies are.

"you either die a or live long enough to become a "

“You either die a LISP, or live long enough to become JavaScript”

Which is funny, considering the size of CL spec.

I'm fascinated that MS are making the exact same stupid decisions with Copilot that they did with Internet Explorer: bundle it into everything, don't bother making it good, just trust that the moat around Windows and Office will suffice for adoption. Report adoption numbers based on people forced to use it by their IT department rather than people who actually want to use it. Focus on corporate and enterprise customers because they're easier to get and can mandate adoption by their staff.

I can easily see a point in a couple of years where Copilot is cursed in the same way that IE was, and becomes the same kind of sick tech joke of a system that really hurts the MS brand.


I think we also come from a bias view as people in tech. MS have captured the entire non tech world, where a lot of people barely understand what product they're using/doing so they don't notice these things. The average person's tech literacy is a lot lower than we would expect and I think it peaked at millennial/gen z

People seem to forget that IE was a good browser until MS basically stopped working on it after releasing IE 6.

Also that CSS Grid as it exists today, was the result of the team being disbanded, going to work on WPF, and eventually some of the team folks were the ones that submitted the original CSS Grid proposal, largely based on WPF Grid capabilities.

Versions of IE before 3 were hardly used so let's not mention those.

IE3 was worse than Netscape and not many used it. Only massive MS fans. Sort of like how Safari on Windows was very niche.

IE4 was the first version truly bundled with the OS in ways you couldn't remove. It was a trash fire of bugs, crashes and rendering errors but was otherwise matched with Netscape Communicator from the user's perspective and had the advantage of starting faster. Communicator was the last version before Netscape went down in flames and they made the disastrous decision to rewrite the product from scratch. IE5 was basically IE4 with the bugs fixed and the first version that was clearly better than Netscape. It also some new APIs that we now take for granted like XMLHTTPRequest. It also ramped down the damaging integrations like Active Desktop. By the time of IE6 it was a lot more stable than Communicator and had a few other new features but otherwise not much and Mozilla was in the weeds shipping tech demos but no usable browser.

So I'd say IE was "good" only for quite a brief period of time, and only in the small window where Netscape had given up. Once Mozilla hit its stride and pivoted to Firefox IE was no longer considered good.


IE4 on the Mac was really good -- probably the best browser around at the time.

Yes but a totally different codebase, it didn't even share the rendering engine.

"In addition to supporting GPT and Claude, we need to also support all the way back to Copilot 6..."

In particular the decision to move away from Intel feels like something Jobs would not have done, and has been critical to Apple's recent success.

It's absolutely what Jobs would have done; he might've done it sooner than it actually happened given what relative shitboxes the latest few revs of Intel MBP were. That was a blemish that would've gotten Jobs scream-at-you-then-fire-you mad.

Remember that the transition to Intel happened in the first place because the PowerPC chips were too power-hungry and the Pentium M design presented a much more attractive power-consumption profile.


Why wouldn't have he done it? He did move away from PowerPC, which was as ballsy of a move.

There's a huge difference between Open Source (even FOSS) and public domain.

Open Source depends on copyright, and makes the source available. The restrictions that (e.g.) the GPL makes are enforced by copyright law, and derive from the author's copyright protection of their work. Effectively the author is granting the recipient permission to use their copyrighted work under certain conditions.

AI-derived works cannot be copyrighted and so cannot be made Open Source in the sense that FOSS means. There can be no restrictions on what the recipient does with the code, because the code is public domain already. Effectively the recipient has as much ownership of the code as the author.

However, the author has no obligation to publish their code, even if it is public domain. And no-one has any right to request a copy of the code, even if it is public domain.

Essentially the current situation is the reverse of FOSS. In FOSS you get a copy of the code along with restrictions on your use of it. With AI code, you don't get the code even though there can be no restrictions on your use of it.

If we did as the author suggests, and all AI-generated code was Open Source by default, we'd be in a worse position - we'd still have no obligation on them to publish, and we'd have to give the author ownership again.

Instead, we probably want some obligation to publish any AI-generated code because it's in the public domain. Though how you'd protect the human-generated bit would be interestingly tricky.


I have felt this for a few years now, that the old distinctions of copyright do not fit the generative AI world. They are laws that come from a different time and no longer work as intended.

> I don't envy the situation Jensen is in but I won't be sorry for him.

Connected. Complete lack of integrity.

If he cheats on his wife, and on his customers, he'll probably cheat on his shareholders. Hence having to quit before he's pushed.


The board told him to quit or else he would be fired. Make no mistake about it.

Yeah. Literally any time a CEO "resigns" amid some negative news, it's a very safe bet that he was actually fired.

Well - the situation with his wife or being unable to control his Jenwong or whatever one would call it, is still a private matter (the allegation of the spy situation is a bit more complex, but the other affair he had going, or at the least one, losing track here of his personal love life), is at the end of the day not really something that is or should be in the spotline for others, even though it has already generated tons of meme videos. People are very happily putting memes about the ex CEO right now - he is probably one of the top #3 meme people right now. The other day I saw where he approached two female podcasters; it suddenly had such a creepy vibe, given his weakness for females ... (though that was not a meme as such, just some seemingly accidental Jensen sneakily creeping in situation ... can't stop him zooming in on the ladies, apparently)

But customers having to pay more due to NVIDIA milking them - now that's something that really would require mandatory jail time for all NVIDIA folks involved here, IF true and verified in court (right now we can only speculate, even if we have extremely convincing proof; the courts would have to come to such a conclusion at the end of the day; and for this, the court systems have to work. I have severe doubts the courts work in the USA right now. It seems a billionaires-controlled court. Why is the whole Epstein network not investigated? Why is only Ghislaine in jail? A single person master-minded +5000 sex slaves over some 20 years or so? How is that even logistically possible?).


> But customers having to pay more due to NVIDIA milking them - now that's something that really would require mandatory jail time for all NVIDIA

It’s the task of every capitalist business in existence to “milk” their customers for the maximum amount of money they can for any given product. Everyone in business would be in jail by your metric.


This isn’t true. The somewhat infamous court case that established this is a USA only thing.

Business are absolutely free to set as their task things like “long term sustainability”, or “quality” if they so choose


Sure, not all businesses, but just like the consumer social classes their is the same sort of heirarchy in business, the top n percentile including big tech, oil, large chains, etc, are absolutely operating in the milking game.

Yeah but that’s a choice. Not a universal law.

The society can easily change this simply by actually enforcing the anti-trust laws that are already on the books.


I'm not arguing the on-paper, I am saying in reality, it's not exactly looking all fair and even as intended; en contraire + it looks much the oposite.. in my opinion.

When capitalism is working as intended everything is covered in a layer of soot and 10 year olds are logging 60 hour work weeks

Not everyone, we just need to jail a few executives and the rest of them will get the message

Well that sounds hyperbolic considering “capitalist business” runs the gamut between “trillion dollar company” and “guy down the street doing this in his spare time”

I think the complaint is that the test has nothing to do with the job.

It's like "to get into Marine boot camp, there's a minimum crochet requirement".

Solving leetcode problems has nothing to do with commercial coding. It's an unrelated hoop that we make folks jump through, because it's easy to measure. It's like measuring developer productivity by LoC written.

Yes, it'll measure how much time the candidate spent preparing for the interview, and how well they can jump through hoops. But it'll also deter the actual people you want in the team, the folks who know that leetcode has nothing to do with commercial coding, and see the leetcode test as a sign that your organisation has no clue and a bad management culture.


I heard similar arguments about the SAT as a college entrance requirement. Lots of universities dropped it, including MIT. They found out that SAT scores really did correlate strongly with success at the university, and reinstituted the requirement.

It also reminds me of the "EE"s who carry around a card in their wallet with:

    V = IR
    I = V/R
    R = V/I
written on it.

> But it'll also deter the actual people you want in the team

All the FAANG companies do leetcode testing, so you can write off the high paying jobs.


I wouldn't want to work in that kind of environment anyway. All that politics and bullshit .

I guess that's staying as a valid measure then - if a company uses leetcode for its interviews, it's probably somewhere I don't want to work.


Or zero old

A time of 100 plus 0 is 100. A time of 100 plus infinity is infinity. Only one value changes the outcome, so that it represents something as existing.

That assumes infinity exists, which we haven't observed yet.

And 100 times 0 is zero, so it really depends on which operator you choose


Easiest way our of that loop is to remember that we're in a simulation :)

How does that do anything? It would just move the question one layer up

Not really a way out.

not really, since who created the simulation?

Maybe Diane, in "I Don't Know, Timmy, Being God Is a Big Responsibility", or a feedback loop.

https://qntm.org/responsibilit


People living in another simulation? See Neal Stephenson...

Whereas I really like the idea that infinities cannot exist, so for any definition of the universe, it must have had a start somewhere/when.

Why can't they exist? That's an arbitrary and unnecessary constraint.

How could it start from absolutely nothing?


It's an interesting concept that I read a few years ago on HN. Basically, if you add 1 to a number, you get a bigger number. You never get to infinity. You can keep doing this until the heat death of the universe, and you still won't get to infinity. So why do we think infinities exist? We know the universe started, it's reasonable to conclude it will also end, and is therefore not infinite. And if the universe is not infinite, it cannot contain infinities, by definition. Which matches our observations; we don't see any infinities in the universe.

Time is part of spacetime, and spacetime is a property of this universe. So there's no "when" or "where" outside the universe. So it doesn't make any sense to talk about "before" the universe. Time started when the universe started. Causality is a property of time; one thing follows from another because of time. If there's no time, there can't be any causality.

> How could it start from absolutely nothing?

So this question doesn't really make any sense. There's no other way it could have started, because the very concept of "nothing" and "started" didn't apply outside of the thing we're saying started (sorry, it gets very difficult to talk about this using a language so firmly grounded in time). It doesn't make any sense to ask what caused the universe because causality itself is a property of the universe.

Like I said, interesting concept and thought. I have no idea if it actually describes reality.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: