HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | mannanj's commentslogin

There's also a case of accusation by a murdered ex-open ai employee who was set to testify against copyright in a openai case. That poor soul's mom has been hateful against Sam since.

I have an example. Greater than 90% of knowledge workers in tech now are required and expected to use AI. If they aren't, their job prospects are at high risk.

That's an exposure in the Party A-Party D frame is it not?


I don't think so. If AI gets really expensive and/or proves to be useless, those requirements will go away. And it's not the knowledge workers paying for those tokens either.

The parent was talking specifically about debt instruments, not about knowledge in general. He didn't mention it by name, but he was describing CDO-squared. There's nothing like that happening now, at least not yet.

It doesn’t seem like it to me. Explain?

they are covering all losses, so why would anyone sue? companies have done significantly worse and then just left you with a $6 class action lawsuit damage claim. What a sham to say to so disproportionately target the crypto company when you have public American companies that harbor criminals as employees still operating today.


actually, your comment is naive. clearly you don't understand game theory and economic incentives. if a company doesn't reward good behavior, you'll see bad behavior.

but then again since you're not naive, you already know these AI companies like openai already act evil and like bad entities.

I conclude therefore, per your words "you are the last one anyone should consult with, basically about anything"


Which game theory model specifically applies here?


What about AI? Do you think that had no impact here? Certainly I've noticed all knowledge professions gain a sense of urgency, survival like psychosis-style thinking, and deterioration of quality and human thinking.


This is how jailbreaks work though, in reverse. The AI providers put a lot of work into stopping jailbreaks, so, something tells me they won't be able to have it both ways. They either block jailbreaks, or allow the LLM from programming in all languages.


How many humans are worth restoring the coral reef?

Because it’s nice to say these things in Sentiment, until you see past the naïveté to see human lives are what cause the wear and extraction on the environment. Humans live, eat, shit in, consume their environment for their lives.

How many humans are worth restoring the reef for you? And would you sacrifice your own friends and family?


This is an absurd remark.

You don’t need to sacrifice humans, you need humans to behave different. Do you know the energy requirements that go into war? The chemical, carbon and physical changes to the ocean from all we do?

We don’t need to kill more humans, we just need to stop being fucking idiots for a few hundred years.


I think you are still naive and IMO ignorant, as I was getting to in my comment.

So don't straw man please into changing the focus into war because you're uncomfortable. I can see I struck a chord - would you agree you're shifting onto a straw man? And sounds a defensive retort to then reduce my argument to absurdity to dismiss it and invalidate it.

Why should I engage your straw man? Are you uncomfortable? I'm not - but why would I engage you if you failed to demonstrate you heard me. edit: if you're going into an emotionally hostile state, I refuse to take on the emotional labor of being your emotional processing for you - we can agree to mutually disengage.


We need the matriarchy instead of the patriarchy.


I can only assume this is satire.


Sorry, but the ignorance and intellectual dishonesty of that comment is too thick to even warrant rebutting.


Sounds like instead you're just uncomfortable and with your hypocritical Ad hominem you justify your own intellectual dishonesty.

You responded with Ad Hominem, which is fundamentally intellectually dishonest - and then accused me the exact thing you're doing.


That wasn't software engineers eliminating that work. And neither is it today AI eliminating software jobs. Let's name the straw man in the room: it's humans displacing humans, and extracting the value for themselves.

Just like in past history.

Yes, it sucks, for software engineers, those in the past, and those in the future. As long as you and others fall for the straw man perhaps you and others will get more and more tricked and hurt, misplacing your aggression and hatred on each other rather than those receiving most of the extracted value.


> extracting the value for themselves

Yes in some cases, but the reduced costs also allow lower prices which benefits all consumers of whatever product is being produced. At least for those products where there is a competitive market.


Hasn't thinking already become a hobby for most people, and most delegate their thinking to others?

Think: those in authority figures, for church or politics. Or science or chemistry. And especially in their own health, which should always remain part art. A few nerds on the internet, like us in hacker news, are still remaining open to question and apply our hard thinking to tough problems. But most people: they've resigned and bought the belief they are not qualified to think about hard problems.


This sounded really like elitist thinking. I don't know what most of the people do but I know my wife is a caveman of we are speaking about technology but if we start taking about law then suddenly I'm half brained chimpanzee with banana in the nose trying figure out why I can't drink it

Even my uncle who work as a carperter proved to me to know more about math and physics than I would ever thought physical labourer would know.


Probably. If the remaining who think go too, we're done for.


been a while since ive see the real talk on hacker news. its refreshing. usually I feel like I'm the only one among nerds asking to hold people accountable.

so, how do you think we can do this?


> so, how do you think we can do this?

For a lack of deep knowledge in this area, I don't think I have answers for this, but if one is interested in working on this problem, my approach would be to start with diving deeply into scientific literature about psychology and sociology to find out

- what convinces people to change their opinions,

- what causes people to take action

etc.


yeah, sure. Do you think all scientific literature is the same though? I am skeptical of thinking to just look at them all equally. Clearly, if theres a class of people being held unaccountable who have been practicing imposing their will and power on the people, that has certainly been done in the scientific community and would show in the literature, too.

So when I think of going through any media like scientific publications, I wonder how to discern and point out the captured and biased media vs the more objective ones (or at least the ones that don't have a hidden financial motive behind them). I wish our scientific community had better disclaimers and traceability for financial influence in every paper we could read.


> So when I think of going through any media like scientific publications, I wonder how to discern and point out the captured and biased media vs the more objective ones (or at least the ones that don't have a hidden financial motive behind them).

This is exactly the hard part: a topic which many people in more applied scientific disciplines worry about. Welcome to the real word, Neo. :-)

Again, I don't have definite answer, but rough guidelines are:

- is a result too good to be true?

- is some result coherent to results that are much more established?

- why would you assume that the author is unbiased or biased? (biases not only have financial reasons)

- which agenda does the author have (yes, deep pursuit for scientific truth is also an agenda? Nobody is free of an agenda)

- does the author make an effort to explain how the findings could be explained in an alternative way that makes the result look much less impressive?

- could the results be reproduced in other labs?

- which is the minimum amount of facts that you must believe in (like axioms) such that the result holds?

- ...


I like that, I can see that being true and working.

The hard part is indeed that we have to exert all this effort to get past the noise that I (and maybe you) feel a responsible author should have already done for us.

And with AI: I was hoping it would help us filter through this noise. So far, I feel lost in how to use AI to help me filter through prejudice and bias, and hidden motives and intentions, when the very filters given to us in the mainstream AIs we are sold are doing that same very bias and incoherency and hidden agendas. I retain my hope, however! Thank you for some solace and inspiration here, friend!


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: