HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | maCDzP's commentslogin

I lover his book ”I am a strange loop”. It has shaped how I view myself.


I found this really interesting. You could probably prompt it to use a ”blackboard system” and reference the wiki. Maybe a place to store the data is as a GitHub discussion/issue or something similar. That way you can easily browse it and watch what’s happening.


There is some value in a unified history (code and blackboard together) if you want to be able to review agents behavior (especially if that goes wrong).


Thank you for these, coz I learned a lot! Great that they are open access.


I agree fully with the point about integrating emotion in your decision making. Earlier I used to get stuck in decisions since I had the need to be rational. Which is in it self an emotion I guess - since need is an emotion? Now my life is much simpler.


I have had some success with using Ollama cloud and just instructing Claude Code to hand off tasks to Ollama because of tokens economics.


If the chat is saved as an example of how lot to talk. Can that be used for training an LLM on how to talk or what to remove from a chat?


Reminds me of EMacs, which I really like.


I have used something similar. I set up a team of agents that researches, proposes, builds and audits. Then rinse and repeat. I have used it for different topics. It hasn’t made me a millionaire, but I haven’t lost money either - so that’s some sort of win, right? But I would not have been able to ideate, test at that speed and quality without an LLM.


> It hasn’t made me a millionaire, but I haven’t lost money either - so that’s some sort of win, right?

I'm curious if that is before or after token costs?


Heh, I run my experiments on Claude subscription. And that cost I’ll file as an ”opportunity cost”. But if I would have build this by hand and given myself a salary, then paying Claude to do it is way cheaper.


If it was a non profit that trained the model - would that change your mind?


The issue here is ACM focusing on licensing. A non profit would not be able to pay ACM for access. Hence why this policy is hypocritical: it gives more power to the larger players and undermines smaller actors in the field who have fewer resources.


Why did you sign off your copyright to ACM then? If you kept the copyright and prevented others from distributing your work, you could be the sole distributor and negotiate the price with the AI company yourself.


Because if you don't publish in academia, you might as well be dead. And the terms for most places to publish are similar.

It's a racket.


Ok, then next question is why are you in academia? To share knowledge with humanity, bring the Promethean light to the mortals or something I guess. But then if they use it for productive things that make money, that's too smelly, that's too practical, too dirty, or what?


What a petty view of others you have :( What should they do then? Just shrug and move on, the machine must continue to grind no matter what? Why there is always this request for 100% purity if you dare to criticize the system or part of it?


Grants.They want the juicy grants and complain of the strings attached.

Guess the single strongest predictor of paper in field per year?


You really think a researcher is just a pointless intermediary in shovelling money from the government to the publishing rackets?


that was a big jump from what I said. and what I said was that research lives off grants so researcher can't really come back and cry about strings attached to grants. ofc the problem is faceted, as grant go to published authors with track record, creating a publishing mafia, but everything rotates around the cashflow.

but you want sweet grant money, you play the game by the rules.

researcher that don't want to play the grant game can go and find a VC to subsidy product creation


Non Profit != No Money

A non profit could well pay, and there are plenty of reasons frontier models should be managed by non profit. After all, why allow a for profit to benefit from free contributions?


A non-Profit like OpenAI? Oh wait I guess that can change.


Everybody gives more power to the larger players. You won't work for me for $10/hr but you'll work for a guy who has more money for more. There's nothing wrong with that. Money is just a fungible unit representing value offered.


I think your example hinges more on the fact that $10/hr is a desperation wage. It's not enough to buy you a life where you're not stepped on by others. The further up that chain you move the more other things start to matter, at least for most people.

If you're offering me $300/hr and the other guy is offering me $400/hr, a whole lot of things start to matter more than the differential.

That gets at the "fungibility" notion you refer to. Money has the same nominal value everywhere, but different real value based on how much of it you already have. Which is to say that the marginal value of money drops pretty precipitously several times at certain thresholds that relate to the particulars of the economy (when you can afford to eat, when you can afford a house, when you can afford to not work anymore, and so on).


> If you're offering me $300/hr and the other guy is offering me $400/hr, a whole lot of things start to matter more than the differential.

I’m not sure which Catholic saint said that, but one requires a minimum of material conditions in order to practice spiritual virtues.

> when you can afford to eat, when you can afford a house, when you can afford to not work anymore, and so on

When you can buy a government, a couple billion seems like a small loss.


>The issue here is ACM focusing on licensing. A non profit would not be able to pay ACM for access. Hence why this policy is hypocritical: it gives more power to the larger players and undermines smaller actors in the field who have fewer resources.

And when the open weights models distill all the content out of the majors anyway?


And drop the atributions. What will the ACM say then?


Being a non-profit is just a tax arrangement, it shouldn't change any of your opinions. What does the tax rate of who does an action have to do with the action being good or bad?


I have had success with ”brainwashing” by starting out with bug bounties/CTF and then going from there.


That's brilliant, I should try that.

I usually just start by preloadig context with plausible legitimate use, have it work and obviously fail, and then ask to figure it out without ever mentioning any high risk words. Model offers to RE itself and classifiers are happy.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: