That is not an automatic fact. Humans are very emotionally complex creatures. And Jensen didn't call his secretary and say "can you pencil in 'humiliating my wife and kids around 4PM'? You can? Great, thanks".
He has full agency over his actions, so yes, it's an automatic fact. He knew what he was doing and he knew what the effects would be on his wife. He knew what would happen when this came out. If you're saying he DIDN'T know what would happen, then you're saying he's extremely stupid. I haven't seen any evidence that he is even a little bit stupid.
Are you saying this was an accident and he didn't have control over himself?
If he doesn't have control over himself and he isn't accountable for his actions, then how does that factor into him being the CEO of the most important globally strategic company in the world? Are you saying that he is capable of making actions that he isn't in full control over? Does Nvidia need to have a CEO that doesn't accidentally make mistakes like potentially giving secret information to Chinese spies?
This seems like an emotionally compromised perspective (which is very, very normal, and I am not insulting you).
It is, of course, not an automatic fact. The context here is emotions, so it makes no sense to point only to agency as proof of an emotional "fact". Such a thing doesn't even exist.
... only if she hates the word 'girl', I guess. Which we don't know. Personally, I know many grown women (30's, 40's+) who are perfectly alright with the word "girl". It is contextual, and often times cultural (i.e. your background).
No offense, but this is why it can often be pernicious to do drive-by virtue-signaling online.
> Unlike some other Americans Huang seems to at least have a preference for people who are no longer minors
What does this even mean?... do you think what you're implying is exclusive to Americans? Honestly that's what it sounds like.
Most women who are okay with being called a girl are okay with it only in certain contexts. For example I don’t know any woman who is in her 30s or 40s who would be okay with being referred to as a girl in a professional context.
Your reply is a non sequitur. This is Hacker News. It is unprofessional to write in a misogynist or infantilizing style and it is unprofessional to defend such writing.
> Your reply is a non sequitur. This is Hacker News.
The irony is astounding.
I don't think you understood what I wrote, but I could be wrong. It's impossible to tell currently since you didn't address anything specific (your comment reads like gaslighting to be honest).
> you did seem to imply that unless one is unequivocally correct, one should not be issuing corrections
I'm still confused. What does that have to do with anything? Can you be specific?
If you're confused about why I can call out the above poster's "'girl' robs every woman of agency", it's pretty straightforward (I said this upfront): I know women that do not feel that way about "girl", and do not feel that they were robbed of their agency because it was used.
Both of these assertions cannot be true at the same time.
I’m not confused about why you chose to call out the above poster but you yourself have nothing to be called out on, no.
Go ask these women if they think that it’s appropriate to refer a woman who is married, in her 40s, and an executive at a multibillion dollar company as a “girl.” Let me know what they say. I have the feeling you’ll be surprised.
Instead of trying to defend your right to refer to women as girls, why don’t you just… not?
> Instead of trying to defend your right to refer to women as girls, why don’t you just… not?
You're on the wrong website for this kind of gaslighting. It just doesn't work here. More appropriate for Reddit, or similar.
It appears we're going in a circle now (the tail has connected to the head). On the one hand, you don't want to let this go, but on the other hand you haven't been saying anything new, and every attempt I've made at an explanation has gone from one ear out to the other ear.
Sometimes, it's the humiliation that comes from the public finding out and putting a spotlight on it that is the kicker; not the random side piece(s) (ex: Bill & Melinda Gates).
I agree, though.
___
edit: Funny enough, there's a House of Cards scene that goes over this exact scenario. Francis is sleeping with Zoe the reporter (they're both using each other for the perks/their own agendas). When Claire finds out, her response is something like "you know you must not embarrass me (publicly) with this", which Francis already knew because he would never do that to Claire... she doesn't say those exact words, but that was the vibe.
Not exactly subtext but yes, it would be inappropriate. I'm noting that "inappropriate" != "impossible." Many of his peers have done exactly such a thing.
She is a CEO in Singapore, she avoids going to jail by obeying Singaporean law. I don’t know how American law would even apply to her, they definitely apply to Jensen though.
Certainly no government would ever encourage its own agents to engage in things like smuggling especially the smuggling of drugs to certain Global South nation states where the capital acquired from those operations end up funding pro-American paramilitaries who topple their local government. That would be totally bananas for any kind of republic.
Contra-ry to common conspiracy theories, I'm certain any government-led self-investigation into culpability in this vein was all very aboveboard and well-substantiated, and such incidents never ever happened.
USA, which is famous for engaging in several smuggling operations, like the Iran-Contra affair or the many cases when CIA was allegedly involved in drug trafficking.
> "Non-determinism" (i.e. the "N" in NP-Complete) does not mean "random", it means "following all paths at once" (there's a really elegant way to understand the List monad as representing non-deterministic computing). It's such a fundamental (and delightful) concept in computer science that refusing to understand what it means is a tragedy related to the loss of technical language itself.
You opened by expressing disdain for articles that misuse the term "non-determinism", then proceeded to give a definition that also misuses the term "non-determinism" in the given context, or at best is a bit too vague for anyone to gain insight from.
Here's a better definition:
An algorithm that can produce different outcomes, for the same input, on different executions.
> If you give an "intelligent agent" offered by one of these model providers a task of updating the content of your website, and it updates it with inappropriate adult content, who incurs the cost of the machine's error? The model provider generally does not.
Something in your prompt led it to do that, is alex0015's point. The statistical odds of these frontier models screwing up to that extent are so impossibly low that it would almost have to be intentional or accidental negligence on the part of the prompt writer to accidentally have their agent write pornography to their website.
The burden of the mistake would have to fall on the person that gave the tool instructions, because it can't know that what it did was wrong. Wrong is subjective in this case. It only did what it did because you, figuratively speaking, encouraged it to.
Yes but I'd actually go even further than that. We've all had experiences where the model straight-up produces gibberish sometimes, right? It's happened to me with a badly configured harness on a local model, and even also on frontier models like when you used to ask them something innocuous about the seahorse emoji.
What I'm arguing is that yes, it's your fault if you misprompt the model and it does something catastrophic. It's also your fault if you prompt it correctly and it does something catastrophic anyway due to some other glitch beyond your control.
The whole discussion started with the point that OpenAI could be financially responsible for damages if their models cause problems for users. If my job is to design a system that works, and instead my system doesn't work, it's my fault regardless of whether I used no LLM, a local LLM, or OpenAI's LLM. Depending on whoever's in charge of doling out consequences, I might get away from it with zero, light, or heavy consequences. But at all levels, I can't reasonably expect to deflect blame onto the model itself.
reply