HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | lxgr's commentslogin

"Made with by" at the end killed me.

I don't get it. Can someone explain?

Typically there is a heart emoji in that text string. The blinking indicator is a meme/trope presented throughout the article in an overbearing fashion, reflecting its prevalence in contemporary LLM output.

I would read it as:

> Made with "lol fuck you" by Mike Lacher


I think the blinking red dot is supposed to represent a red heart. Some pages have "made with love" but love is instead a red heart. It's an older trend. On this page, it's obviously satirical.

Looks like HAL 9000 to me but the page does give reference for the blinking lights, in this case it’s “0 Real Incidents”

In terms of risk, that’s no different from just writing down the card number and expiry these days, which is why no merchant has embossing devices anymore.

It's not really the same. The imprint exists to evidence the physical presence of the card at point of sale. If you dig through issuers' documentation about fraud and chargebacks, or PCI rules, you'll find the analysis. Of course someone could fabricate a forged embossed card, but it's a big step from just rattling off the numbers, so they give it some weight.

Huh, TIL that Visa apparently still gives the imprint some weight in all regions (Mastercard doesn't, as far as I can tell).

Yeah, oceanic flights largely use satellite-based CPDLC today, or HF voice as a fallback, but not VHF in any case (which I suspect is the implicated system here).

VHF Omnirange (VOR)[1] is unlikely to be involved. VOR stations are not dependent on a network. All they need is power. It's 1950s technology. The big ring of antennas next to US 101 just north of SJC is a VOR.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/VHF_omnidirectional_range


Sorry, typo, I meant VHF (i.e. voiceband), of course. VORs are indeed for navigation, not communication. Updated.

Seeing some takeoffs again at 22:44 UTC.

Hm, only international ones though, and only at coastal airports. I guess oceanic airspace is less affected by whatever this is?

From the very first line of that article:

> The FAA has reassured the public and airlines that SMART only suggests routes and doesn't affect air safety.


Sure, but the tool needs to get information from the communication systems, and if it's badly written maybe it could overload some system components.

That's just a scenario off the top of my head, it could be a lot of stuff. Plugging something new into an old, complicated system isn't risk free.


From the NYT article linked:

“Mr. Mullin said that new technology upgrades overloaded the existing, antiquated system, “overwhelming” the existing equipment.

“It’s going to continue to fail,” Mr. Duffy added. He also outlined many of the additional investments he believes the air travel system needs, like new air traffic control towers, infrastructure and communication networks.”

Of course they are all going to insist it has nothing to do with SMART, that would be incredibly damming, and threatening to ASI. But it’s pretty unfortunate timing no? What other “technology upgrades” have been recently applied to air traffic control/ communications?


That would make me feel better if we could trust a damn word from this administration and I wasn’t on a plane waiting to land.

It's also the corporations that are not exactly telling the truth & funding the administrations, just FTR...

The destructive & arrogant behaviors won't be reigned in properly if we all fail to recognize that, just FTR.


The good news is this outage is not impacting approach or ground control so you’re safe.

John Wayne, a class C (the approach mentioned above) isn't even letting VFRs go. If it's actually limited to ARTCC I don't know why that would be.

Except some airports haven't enough free gates for disembarking as planes that wanted to take off were denied. So they tried to go back to their gates. As a result some planes in the air are being diverted to less-busy airports.

Sounds safe, just extremely inconvenient.

Thanks, bud - very reassuring that some minimum bid contract shop built something on a “secure” network they can’t even keep up.

If only routes didn't affect air safety.

Until it got out of its sandbox…

If it's working correctly, anyway

Or Panasonic or Viasat/Inmarsat :)

What network does the Panasonic run on ?

I believe they lease Ku band transponders from various commercial GEO satellites, think Eutelsat, Telesat, SES etc.

That’s obviously not what’s happening. But if this upgrade is really implicated, the real question would be where the line of accepted residual risk for an outage like this was drawn.

Doesn't seem like it; I've seen several international flights land in JFK alone since this started. (On the other hand, these might simply not have enough fuel left to divert to any non-US airport.)

Not in the industry, but I think ground stops might actually not be a regular/automated procedural thing for inbound international flights in the way that they are for domestic flights.

As for asking already airborne flights to turn around, those coming in over the ocean might simply not have a non-US alternate airport available with their fuel remaining, so that's often not an option.


Every flight over an ocean has a set of pre-planned diversion airports.

Yes, but most of them are not viable in the late stages of a flight. Planes aren't carrying enough fuel to cross an ocean for a second time; most don't even have the capacity.

The diversion airports are chosen specifically for each stage of the flight, so a flight doesn't ever need to return to where it came from.

Oceanic flights are planned so that at every point along the route, the aircraft can lose an engine or cabin pressure and still reach a pre-approved diversion airport with enough fuel, with the flight plan marking the points where turning back versus continuing becomes the faster option. If a diversion is needed mid-ocean, the crew offsets from their assigned track and altitude to stay clear of other traffic, then heads to the nearest suitable airport, such as Gander, Keflavik or Shannon over the Atlantic, or Anchorage, Cold Bay or Midway over the Pacific.


Please suggest an appropriate international alternate for a plane just about to land in Denver with an hour of fuel remaining.

Alternate airports are picked based with regards to all kinds of contingencies (many of them meteorological), but "the US closes literally every airport" is not one of them.


That likely falls within the case-by-case basis the FAA mentioned, and would likely be allowed to land at a U.S. airport that has capacity.

And that's exactly why you got the reply that international flights MIGHT not have enough fuel left to divert (and thus obviously have to be allowed to land within the continental US), but for some reason you insisted that every flight would be able to.

I'm not aware of a requirement that you need to always be able to divert to a different country.

> This is a system that's supposed to have it's own built in redundancy and must not go down.

There are contingencies for radio outages, but yeah, everything going down at once (if that's what's happening here, which I doubt) is bad.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: