HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | lvl256's commentslogin

I highly recommend you check out their database Youtube channel as well. It’s an awesome resource.

Anyone who’s been around Wall Street long enough could have told you Lutnick has had questionable morals and ethics even against subpar standards among finance professionals.

Here's a refresher on who Howard Lutnick is. His company, Cantor Fitzgerald, famously lost a huge portion of their staff on 9/11. Because of this, Cantor sued American Airlines, ultimately leading to a payout of $135 million in 2013 [1]. Fair enough.

But what happened to the money? Did it go the families of those victims? Not really [2] (emphasis added):

> But Lutnick and his fellow Cantor partners reportedly kept some of the money for the firm and distributed the rest to themselves, in proportion to their ownership stake. Lutnick, the firm’s biggest partner, may have received as much as $25 million.

[1]: https://www.courthousenews.com/american-airlines-to-pay-cant...

[2]: https://archive.ph/th3UD


If someone blew up my factory I wouldn’t expect the factory repair money to go to the people inside the factory. That’s a separate matter of compensation, either between the company insurance and the families or between the families and the person who blew up the factory.

He also rather infamously lied about never having been to Epstein's island.

The next administration should seek to put him behind bars. I don't understand this dichotomy between oversight and governance the mainstream media narrative has been pushing. The administration of the next president should be able to walk and chew gum at the same time.

Seeing Bolsonaro flee to Miami right after losing an election, I really will not be surprised to see the same sort of private flights to Moscow, Tel Aviv, etc. out of Washington DC if 2028 swings in any way like 2026 did. The scale of the avarice and duplicity is truly staggering.


He actually said he was disgusted by Epstein so would never be in the same room after 2005.

He subsequently took his wife and kids to see Epstein after Epstein's conviction.

He also invited Epstein to a Hilary Clinton fundraiser

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Howard_Lutnick#Relationship_wi...


Read the Wikipedia article.

Lutnick visited Epstein by his own yacht. His own yacht has lots of staff and his family was with him so there was no opportunity for bad behavior. It sounds like Lutnick had to meet Epstein about something, so he set it up to be sure no misunderstanding could occur.

I have no other opinion on Lutnick, but having lunch with a powerful figure (Epstein) who is also a neighbor, and doing so in the presence of many, many witnesses isn’t evidence that Lutnick wanted to do anything untoward with Epstein.

There are many, many people who went to Epstein’s island solo or with a group of folks looking to “party”, and there is documented evidence of this. It doesn’t look like Lutnick was one of them.

This whole “oh my gosh, he talked to Epstein a couple of times” is such a distraction. One created by the very people who are actually guilty.


The point is not that he "he talked to Epstein a couple of times", its that he lied about it.

Regardless of having his staff and family there, taking his kids to meet a convicted sex offender is very peculiar behaviour. He could have Epstein alone if he really had to.

Did he also have to invite Epstein to a fundraiser? Did he have to contribute to Epstein's "philanthropic dinner".


Bill Clinton was also vacationing with family when he visited the island as president. This is the common cover tactic.

[flagged]

Blatant corruption? US probably hasn't had a more corrupt administration since the 1920s (arguably the 1800s or even ever in history).

[flagged]

That's a weird, almost pedantic.

The 'vibe' is multiple reporting of nepotism, suspicions of market manipulation, and the list goes on. Source: multiple newspapers, easily googable.

And of course there would be a due process - the hypothesis is that politicians would flee because they would be found guilty, and therefore jailed.


[flagged]

Did GC Michelle Lee own a family business which profited from her decisions ?

Lee came from a web tech company (Google) to the PTO, adopted web tech company friendly policies at the PTO, then left for a web tech company (Amazon).

Cantor Fitzgerald is a diversified financial services company with 12,000 employees, which is exposed to a wide swath of the economy (meaning that government action in any one area doesn't move the needle much).


Michelle Lee joined Amazon 2 years after leaving the Trump administration USPTO. Neither Google nor Amazon are her family business. She clearly followed the federal ethics law. In no way, Lee was operating in a manner that clearly indicated nepotism.

Lutnick's adult children: Brandon Lutnick is chairman and Kyle Lutnick is executive vice chairman. This family owns Cantor Fitzgerald.

As to the scale and magnitude, we already know that Cantor Fitzgerald was designated sales agent in a ~$1 billion offering for a single data center of Bitdeer. And they involved in many such business deals with Bitdeer that involved hundreds of millions of dollars. A full scope of how much "the needle moved" will need a formal investigation. Remember again - this is his family-owned business.

Michelle Lee is rich, but not even a billionaire. Her personal wealth is ~$100 million.

While do note that Lutnick nearly doubled his net worth to greater than $7 BILLION since becoming a member of Trump’s Cabinet. Please read forbes article https://www.forbes.com/sites/saradorn/2026/09/11/how-commerc...

You are comparing two extremely different people. One is clearly corrupt to even a layman. If you cannot see it, then I am afraid you are operating with an extreme bias. I suggest talking it over with someone you trust.


Why do you keep emphasizing it’s a “family business”? What difference does that make? The facts you’re pointing to aren’t relevant to corruption. The problem with corruption is where an official does something he or she wouldn’t otherwise do because it serves their personal interest. So what’s relevant is how direct and specific the connection is between the official acts and the personal interests.

With Michelle Lee, there was a very specific link between her policies and her employer’s interests. Michelle Lee went to the USPTO and implemented patent policies that directly effectuated what Google and Amazon had been lobbying for. The patent policies Lee worked on were specific hobby horses of tech companies.

Lutnick by contrast is a pro-AI guy in a pro-AI administration who happens to have a generalized investment in AI. That’s not a direct and specific connection. AI is 25% of economic growth right now. It cuts across a huge swath of the economy.

Again, what Lee did is not “corrupt” by typical standards. But the specificity of the conflict of interest is much more acute. But I’d say your average high level bureaucrat is worse than both! There are many, many lawyers who implement some major regulatory framework in government, then spend their whole careers helping companies navigate the regulations they implemented. If anything is “corrupt,” that seems much more corrupt than what we’re talking about here.


> Why do you keep emphasizing it’s a “family business”? What difference does that make?

What ? It makes ALL the difference in the world. He is directly enriching himself. I fail to understand how you cannot understand this.

> The facts you’re pointing to aren’t relevant to corruption....

I just don't get you at all. This is an utterly clear-cut case of corruption - as stupendously blatant as it gets. As clear as the Sun rising in the east. Worse, this is just the tip of the iceberg. Why bury your head so hard in cement for Trump cronies ?

His net worth has more than doubled to around $7.3 billion - a big portion of which is thanks to Lutnick’s indirect stake in Tether, via his stake in Cantor Fitzgerald.

Remember this -> Lutnick publicly vouched for Tether. Lutnick promised to divest his business interests when he joined the Trump administration. This promise was UTTERLY broken. Lutnick also continued to market and directly support his family business during his tenure as Secretary of Commerce.

Case-2: USA Rare Earth hired Cantor Fitzgerald as the lead placement agent for a $1.5 billion private share offering needed alongside the government deal. This after the CEO had a meeting with Lutnick. So, the Commerce Secretary effectively said - kindly use my family business for the govt deal.

>Lutnick by contrast is a pro-AI guy in a pro-AI administration... AI is 25% of economic growth right now. It cuts across a huge swath of the economy....Again, what Lee did is not “corrupt” by typical standards.

Ahh.. I finally get it. You don't really care about him being massively corrupt and want to hand-wave his actions away. You really don't want to rock the "AI Boat". Trump cronies can continue to be corrupt to their heart's content and keep favoring up their family businesses earning them billions in any/all manner. Just don't "Rock AI" plz.

I think we have reached the limit of our discussion since we apparently fundamentally disagree on simple tenets regarding public accountability and basic corruption. I really look forward to the future change of the US administration and the investigations which will come into play.


So not exactly equivalent? If she worked at Google and the patent office simultaneously and received bonuses from Google based on the decisions she made in her other job then it would be a fair comparison to what Lutnick is doing...

Lutnick divested himself of his interest in the business.

Right.. to his sons. I guess that's fine then. Its perfectly legal to abuse your office and make decisions that financially benefit your close family members. How could both the president and the secretary of treasury do it otherwise.

Others were corrupt so this one ought to be allowed to be corrupt too?

[flagged]

> It's a big club and they're all in this together.

Collapsing all politicians into one giant corrupt elite only benefits the truly corrupt elite. This kind of cynicism and false equivalence justifies fatalism and lack of political engagement, which is a large part of how we got into this mess. The solution is not to give up and say they're all crooks. It's to push hard for accountability.


The parent has a point. There is so much no-partisan corruption I don't think calling it like it is cynicism. We need to accept there is a system-wide problem before we can do anything about it. I don't see this as giving up, it just needs a systemic change.

At this point I think cynicism is well justified.

[flagged]

| left ran a grift where one party funneled tax dollars to public employees

Isn't this just paying them? Can't the union's membership simply vote in a different set of leaders that don't donate to the Dems if they don't like it?


Sure. It's like an intern at big corp asking C-levels "oh please follow the rules".

They set the rules. So they will never lose.


Well a fair court probably wouldn't have convicted Clinton because she didn't really do much that was illegal (even if she did it's not even remotely on the same level).

Trump and Lutnick (and other in his admin) are exceptionally corrupt and have profited massively while they were in office. There is a difference between running an unauthorized email server in your basement and using yours powers to make billions of dollars from insider trading and various corrupt schemes.


>Well a fair court probably wouldn't have convicted Clinton because she didn't really do much that was illegal

Apart from you know, all the pics with her and her husband, the former president, partying at Epstein's island dressed like in the classic pdf 'Eyes wide shut' outfits.

A fair court would have a lot of questions on that topic.


Sure, but that's entirely unrelated to Trump's promises to prosecute her if he won the the election.

Unpopular opinion: there are upsides in this corrupt arrangement between opposing political parties enforced by some form of mutually-assured destruction. Obviously it is not fair to have this dual-class structure with certain people "above the law" to some degree, but the alternative of extreme accountability may be even worse. Net result is a system where each political transition is effectively a full regime change and maximal interest is there. It is just too easy to find or accuse someone prominent of something and destroy their livelihood after they lose political power. This incentivizes many negative behaviors one of which is to undermine the peaceful transition by the incumbent.

So Hillary didn’t really do anything clearly criminal, I think… or they absolutely would have strung her up. And with Trump, there is nobody in position to hold him accountable.

That isn’t to say you are necessarily wrong just that you are letting your cynicism override the fact that there are major differences now. Next few years will tell.

Personally I doubt Trump is held accountable but I would bet at least 3 of his inner circle / family go to prison, and maybe 25% of the grift is clawed back.


If we look at the bank bailouts, when was that? I dont see anyone of any value going to prison until the system changes. I still support accountability. I just think there are too many people in powerful positions that have a lot to lose that will do all the can to keep everything normalized.

The bank bailouts were legal and a good idea! Generally the underlying banking activity was also entirely above board. Creating a systemic risk is not a criminal offence, otherwise the climate crisis would be being handled differently.

Certain details of the crisis were not legitimate. Irish banker Seán Quinn was personally bankrupted and spent a few weeks in prison (for contempt of court).

The major US abuse of process detail that should not have been legal was "robo-signing".

Wells Fargo was actually after the GFC: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wells_Fargo_cross-selling_scan...


> I would bet at least 3 of his inner circle / family go to prison

It's probably going to have to be at the state level, because there's gonna be a bonanza of federal pardons, including the untested self-pardon.


America at some point will have to say "You can pardon yourself all you want, but that can't protect you from a mob with a noose"

Should be: “But that can’t protect you from An Official Act™"

And where are these mobs capable of stringing up a corrupt former president? Don't you think former presidents and multi-billionaires have their private islands for a reason?

Historically(I mean recent history), mobs are more likely to clash with each other, rather than go after politicians, because that's what the media does, pits people against each other so they don't unite and go after the elites. Divide and conquer it's called and it's always worked to this day.

You'll never be able to convince millions of people to march together in unison to go hang the fictional orange man (in minecraft).


A suitable approach would be to put him on a boat on international waters and then blow it up. The Trump administration has itself determined that this is completely legal and requires no trial.

Maybe the next President can have their own paramilitary goons kidnap those pardoned as an official act. Can’t have traitors from the Trump admin circulating in public, and this administration has opened the door for expanding who can be disappeared.

"Personally I doubt Trump is held accountable but I would bet at least 3 of his inner circle / family go to prison, and maybe 25% of the grift is clawed back."

Convicted maybe, but going to prison? I doubt it. I can imagine there will be "deals" in the background. No prison for the inner circle and only some clawing back, but also no capital storming and acceptance of the outcome.


My personal opinion of Trump is sufficiently low that I'd rank diarrhea higher...

... but if anyone thinks this country is going to put an octogenarian ex-president in prison for any reason whatsoever, they're deluded.

The absolute, utter worst case scenario for Trump is house arrest, and I'm pretty skeptical even of that.


Little could be less impressive in these increasingly unsettling times than rote cynicism parading as insight.

> "Now, there's this about cynicism, Sergeant. It's the universe's most supine moral position. Real comfortable. If nothing can be done, then you're not some kind of shit for not doing it, and you can lie there and stink to yourself in perfect peace."

-- Borders of Infinity by Lois McMaster Bujold


[flagged]

I remembered a statement from a favorite book-series, from paper pages read by a human (me) for intrinsic pleasure, sharing it at a moment when the quote was relevant.

That's normal. You're the one being weird.


Fiction is not reality. Argument by fiction as if it was an authority is false by default.

> Fiction is not reality.

No shit?


Ironically people on this website would probably have a better handle on reality if they read more fiction.

[flagged]

Reality doesn't work like fiction, in reality the bad guy wins. Luckily I'm all out of giving a damn and am willing to play the bad guy.

> in reality the bad guy wins.

More correctly, the most unscrupulous guy wins. And bad guys tend to be more unscrupulous more of the time, vs good guys who shackle themselves with societal values that their opponents don't abide by, leading them to come last.


> Reality doesn't work like fiction, in reality the bad guy wins. Luckily I'm all out of giving a damn and am willing to play the bad guy.

How strange.. this is the same sentiment expressed by a subsegment of the emo/goth teen crowd in my high school in the 90s.


And by the current leadership of the US, so you tell me.

Fiction is how people have communicated about the human condition for centuries.

Try reading a few books.


>Fiction is how people have communicated about the human condition for centuries.

History communciates facts on the human condition way better than fiction. Finance and insurance quants use historical data to predict the future events, not books of fiction.

>Try reading a few books.

Try touching grass and interact with real people in the real world.


Ah yes, quants, the most well-adjusted people I know. Certainly not a group of overpaid, self absorbed and immature people who are high functioning Ketamine addicts and gamblers.

Outsourcing a component of your thinking (and many other aspects of your life) is called civilization. Not everyone is an expert at everything, and expertise does actually matter. Other people, shockingly, can have intelligent and valuable thoughts! They can make statements that resonate, or that more effectively capture what you might say yourself!

This is not the sign of failure that you seem to think it is; in fact, it is often the exact opposite.


Lynndie England[0] et al. suffered little if any consequences for their heinous actions. Dick Cheney died a free man. George Bush walks around as a free man.

There will be no substantial consequences for the people involved in these crimes from decades ago just as there were no substantial consequences for these criminals in power now.

No legal system is going to stop these people, no mob of millions marching and demanding justice, no clandestine group of antifa doing targeted drone assassinations, no avenging lone private citizen with nothing to lose because of an inoperable brain cancer and a few months left to live will either. People are by and large fine with the status quo.

They talk and they talk about it but nothing ever changes.

That's just how it's been for at least my entire life and it's just not going to change.[1]

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lynndie_England#Gallery

[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=phC4JevVr2k


I'm not the person you are responding to, but I am as cynical as they are that these people will face any justice... but for different reasons (outlined in my reply to your original post).

I'd love to believe these people will face justice, and I do think there are plenty of people on "the other side" that will fight for justice... But the odds are unfortunately stacked against them because the US founders lacked the imagination to foresee a situation in which a president would be as openly corrupt as Trump while the other branches of government simultaneously abdicated their own power to said president. The founders also didn't realize how dangerous the pardon power was when people had no shame in using it.

(well, tbf, some of the founders like Sam Adams and George Mason did realize the pardon power was likely to be abused, but they lost the fight on it).


[flagged]

I don't discern an argument in your reply. Simply "nothing ever happens".

I didn't mean to personally upset you, I just frankly found your reply to be very boring, to the point of being trite. Perhaps especially in this LLM age I take a particular aversion to humans that simply parrot each other. Cynicism has never been easier. If it's "just basic stuff" why remark on it with so many words as you did? Is it really so basic? You think I am unfamiliar with the nature of your take? It's a sentiment echoed so often it begins to read as pablum.

I just urge you to stretch your imagination. Even a survey of America's own relatively short history may give you some wider insight into the poverty of the "nothing ever happens" creed you espouse.

But I wish you the best personally. Again, I mean no offense and I apologize if my tone was overzealous. Have a good day.


>I don't discern an argument in your reply

Read it again, I explained with examples.

>Simply "nothing ever happens".

You're over-writing my argument with a conclusion you made up based on your feelings on the matter, because I never said that "nothing ever happens". A better more accurate summary of what I said would have been for you to say I said "history shows people aren't held accountable", which is true.

>You think I am unfamiliar with the nature of your take?

You have yet to prove that so far. You claim a high hand in wisdom above what I said, with nothing to show as proof.

>Perhaps especially in this LLM age I take a particular aversion to humans that simply parrot each other.

Who here did I parrot?

And even so, do you have any argument to disprove your "nothing ever happens" vibe? Because your comment is full of accusations but no arguments, no substance, no alternate PoV, no curiosity, nothing, just personal feelings.


> I really will not be surprised to see the same sort of private flights to Moscow, Tel Aviv, etc. out of Washington DC if 2028 swings in any way like 2026 did.

I wish I believed this.

Unfortunately, Trump is going to mass pardon everyone who remained loyal to him, including Lutnick, of all federal crimes.

So they are either going to have to find things these people can be charged with at a state level, or we get lucky and all those McDonalds cheeseburgers catch up with Trump before he leaves office before he issues the broad pardons.

Trump has already stated multiple times and in no uncertain terms that he intends to pardon everyone around him.

It is theoretically possible he already mass pardoned everyone since pardons don't have to be announced (until they are needed as a legal defense), though this seems unlikely because once he pardons someone he loses the leverage he has over them, so I'd expect transactional Trump to wait until the very last moment to issue the mass pardons.

And even in the case where he croaks before issuing them, I wouldn't be surprised if the group of people who need pardons magically find some autopenned pardons in a drawer of the Resolute Desk. If you already expect to do serious prison time anyway, forging some pardons hardly matters on top of that and at the very least would gum up the legal process for years, giving you plenty of time to flee then.


The law is ultimately about power. Of course he will try to pardon everyone and everything, including a blanket pardon for himself.

Everything can be legislated. No legal instrument - including a pardon - is absolute. Finding a way within the Constitution to dismiss such pardons is not inconceivable. The more outrageous he becomes, the more he creates the space for a backlash with a very wide mandate and a deep interest in pushing back against his conduct with a vigor more reminiscent of America's first 100 years than the last.

If you simply think nothing ever happens I simply suggest you have not read enough history. Let's see. He can still course correct to an extent that you may be right and they simply decide to let him dawdle off into the sunset. But if he goes even more rouge over the next two years, it would really not be surprising to see a new mandate emerge which would in some meaningful part be predicated on a kind of commitment to a prosecutorial reaction against the prior regime.

If a figure on the left can emerge who can do this while reaching across the aisle - I mean, if Trump is going to be put on the stand for Epstein, why are the geriatric boomer Democrats still defending Clinton? - then I think you could see the sort of electoral wipeout, that building on 2026, could lead to some real sea change.

A big part of this is generational. A huge part of why the freshman class of 2026 seems so impressive is because they aren't geriatrics. They are breaking the mold. We should not discount the reaction we have already seen (blue in Texas, in South Carolina) nor underestimate the capacity for more if the President continues to disgrace himself, which we have every reason to believe he will.


The pardon is legally absolute. The only way around this is amending the Constitution, an extremely tall order and unlikely to occur within the next 2 years. Nor do I see any coordinated push for a Convention of States to make sweping alterations.

These aren't actionable suggestions that you're posting, just prayers that somebody does something. You are correct about the incoming Congress showing a lot of energy, but they're either going to have top erate withint he existing framework or overturn it.


It's not as absolute as you're suggesting. In particular there are two big limitations:

1. A person can only help someone avoid federal criminal cases

2. Accepting a pardon waives your 5A rights against self-incrimination for the crime in question

If Democrats are sufficiently committed to charging these folks, the pardon mechanism opens gaps that future state criminal cases and civil cases can build on. It is definitely possible to claw back these ill-gotten gains and maybe even send some folks to jail for tax evasion or other ancillary crimes.


The next president can just annul the pardons. Pack the SC for when it reaches them.

It depends on how outrageously he uses them.

Things that can never happen in social/economic contexts tend to always happen once people start betting too hard on the impossibility.


I don't believe there's a mechanism for pardon annulment once granted.

Sure there is. It’s called “guy with guns shows up and puts you behind bars.”

SCOTUS is happy to invent new mechanisms when necessary.

Not this SCOTUS with a different admin

It's not exactly clear cut whether preemptive pardons are legitimate (of course the supreme court would have to say they are not and good luck with that)?

Also it's not entirely clear if someone can be pardoned for crimes he was impeached over? I guess realistically it would only result in someone being barred from holding federal office rather than criminal prosecution.


The one thing I’ve seen consistent about Trump is that he only acts in his own self-interest. As soon as others are no longer useful to him, they are cut from his inner circle and he won’t lift a finger for them.

With his political power fading and these lackeys hopefully soon to be out of office along with him, I find it surprisingly likely that he will see them all increasingly as dead weight who failed him through their incompetence rather than as friends and compatriots who helped him with his grift.

If they want preemptive pardons, every day he doesn’t sign one is a day of increasing likelihood he doesn’t bother to grant them one. If he were to pass away, I have no doubt that Vance would be furiously signing them as his first official acts in office.


I agree. He is using his pardons to give boldness to his people because pardons are free.

But for the pardoned - it’s not free. They cannot claim the 5th, they are still open to state charges, and can also be sued/held financially liable.


> to his people because pardons are free.

Finding an evidentiary link is a different thing altogether, but if people don't think that payments to lobbyists, "advisors", donations to his campaign, projects or ego from many of those pardoned is anything more than a coincidence...


I think GP meant that it costs him nothing to hand out pardons, or at least the promise of pardons.

It absolutely costs those who wish to get a pardon from him. And I’m not sure the members of his administration have much to offer him in the waning days of his administration.


> If he were to pass away, I have no doubt that Vance would be furiously signing them as his first official acts in office.

We are both wildly speculating, of course, but I don't think it is likely that is what would happen if Trump died and Vance took office.

Vance is already trying to distance himself from the whole mess of the Trump administration because he (incorrectly, IMO) believes he has a political future post-Trump. Vance issuing mass pardons across the entire administration would make that entirely impossible, he'd be inexorably linking himself to the Trump trainwreck.

I don't think Vance really has strong ties to most of the people we're talking about here (like Lutnick). In some ways it is one big corrupt administration, but there are certainly little factions of it (Rubio faction, Hegseth Faction, Tech/Thiel Faction [JD Vance is here], etc). I'd expect any pardoning Vance did would be localized to a subset of the Tech/Thiel faction and he'd let everyone else hang out to dry to limit the fallout on his future political ambitions.

All that said, I do think it is possible Trump's dementia paranoia and sense of aggrievement reaches a level where he also just decides not to pardon a bunch of people out of spite, so thanks for pointing out that hopeful possibility.


Honestly, you’re probably right on that point. It’s far smarter for Vance to use that as a way to distance himself from the administration and set up his political future, although I agree that it’s likely dead in the water regardless of what he does.

> Unfortunately, Trump is going to mass pardon everyone who remained loyal to him, including Lutnick, of all federal crimes.

Naturally! This precedent of preemptive-pardons was idiotically set by President Biden and will now be the defacto last action of every U.S. President going forward into the future.


Most of Trump admin has questionable morals.

Most of America has questionable morals nowadays.

Everyone wants to be rich!


Wanting to be rich is fine, but too many people are trying to get rich in zero-sum ways. We need to get better at differentiating extractive types from people who create valuable products and services.

Being a builder is positive-sum and we should be happy when people who build new and helpful things profit from it.


We should want to get rich by providing good services and products. It seems to me that more and more people are trying to skip that and go straight to rich without doing anything useful.

This is why I've chosen to build without VC funding and the enshittification its structure tends to create. Fellow builders that want to get rich building good services and products please consider joining the alliance! [0]

[0] https://NOVC.fyi


The US Government has become so sprawling and is intentionally layered with so many laws and regulations that the forward path in the US is extreme corruption through the state. It's the absolute easiest path to outsized thefting. Trump is merely a health indicator for the system of what's possible and what's to come. And Trump is a lightweight, a performative clown that doesn't understand the levers of power, he doesn't really know how the US Government functions. There are far more dangerous, far smarter people that do and will use those levers of power more effectively for horrific things. We're lucky the Trump Admin/s have been so chaotic, so undisciplined, filled with so many political weaklings.

The partisan idiot show in the US would have you believe Trump is somewhere between a dictator and the devil. He's nothing compared to real authoritarianism. Trump is gone in two years, the system that made his behavior possible will only get far, far worse. The culture that made him possible will get worse.

The far left and far right will rock the US apart, back and forth. Each side will get more aggressive and more authoritarian as it happens. Their positions will get more extreme. That will continue until one side de facto 'wins' and then proceeds to wipe out the other side politically (acquire enough power to cripple the other side).

The left looks at the levers of power and says: oh but I'll use them for good.

And the next NixonTrumpBush? You only have one choice: leave the levers of power in place and understand what's inevitable to come from it. Or strip the power that shouldn't exist in the first place (eg executive orders as they exist today). If you don't do that, you will get something worse than Trump, far worse, it's only a matter of a short time.

The left is like Gandalf talking about how he would seek to use the ring of power for good. The ring has something else in mind.


> The partisan idiot show in the US would have you believe Trump is somewhere between a dictator and the devil. He's nothing compared to real authoritarianism.

Trump is absolutely this bad and my non-partisan take is so are most other presidents. We kill people around the world en mass and at-will. We killed over a million people in Iraq, two million in Vietnam. It’s easy to claim our leaders “aren’t that bad” when we’re not the people they’re killing. Of course we also have the largest prison population in the world, so in that sense this is directed domestically as well.


You're confusing that I said they're nowhere close to real authoritarianism, and that I said they weren't bad. I never said any of them weren't bad.

They're nowhere close to real authoritarianism. And you're seemingly confusing what authoritarianism is and somehow relating that to having anything to do with launching wars.

A non-authoritarian, democratically elected President can launch a war.


> A non-authoritarian, democratically elected President can launch a war

No, only Congress can declare war. A president bypassing Congress would by definition be authoritarian.


No, we live in a global world. Where the killing happens doesn’t matter. We literally are complicit in genocide. We need updated terms, because our pre-industrial, pre-information age, pre-globalism vocabulary is allowing atrocities to go mislabeled.

Ram makers are more understandable since they went through this already in the past. The Koreans learned it the hard way.

What a twist of fate. He would be worth north of $100B if he simply chilled out like Coinbase.

For all his faults, I do feel for Jensen. He built this thing from an absolute scratch. He had a lot of luck on the way, from crypto to CUDA. And who can forget his spat with Jobs all those years ago.

> "And who can forget his spat with Jobs all those years ago."

Apparently I am able to, what was that?


Apple used nVidia GPUs in most of its computers. Around 2008-2009, nVidia produced a line of faulty GPUs that were used in the Macbook Pro. This led to widespread hardware failures, and was known as "Bumpgate" because the problem was caused by faulty solder bumps inside the GPU chip. nVidia refused to fully reimburse Apple for repairs because it wasn't contractually obligated to do so. In response, Apple switched away entirely from nVidia GPUs.

I think it was well into 2013 because both the 2011 and 2013 MBPs I had suffered from it. but I thought that was an apple issue (ie not soldering the dicrete gpu well enough to save money on it)

after the 2 faulty products in a row, I haven't bought an apple product since.


You are missing out, the M series laptops are insanely good. Now wondering how the field of ML would have developed if Apple had had Nvidia chips all the way...

This is not 2020 and nobody is missing out not having to deal with macOS in 2026.

This is truly the year of the Linux pcs and you’re missing out running anything else.


> the year of the Linux pcs

How so?


No, it was Nvidia because of the way the BGA solder was done. The problem was across manufacturers.

The infamous early 2011 MBPs had AMD GPUs that basically crapped out the entire logic board. That was what got me to switch back to Windows.

And that's kidna funny because now Apple Sillicon has pretty great graphics on their own.

Maybe that's the lesson he learned and why he _supposedly_ was making sure his GPUs were still getting to China. Because he knows that the alternative would lead to good Nvidia Chinese competitor later on


I don't remember either, but I do remember Linus Torwalds not being entirely satisfied with NVIDIA. That is actually something very hard to forget.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iYWzMvlj2RQ


Every time I have to reinstall CUDA, I fondly remember this video.

Nvidia eventually had a spat with just about any corporation it has ever worked with. Their only partnership that stood the test of time is probably Nintendo.

TSMC?

from what i remember, morris chang is a close friend to hueng.

i wonder what will happen to nvidia's relationship with TMSC now.


Morris is almost 100 years old. His role at TSMC was instrumental, but now is more of an ornamental figurehead.

> Their only partnership that stood the test of time is probably Nintendo.

But even then, the original Switch 1 homebrew relied on an oversight in NVIDIA's Tegra chip that blew open the whole platform due to the ability to execute unsigned code. The Switch 1 was actually pretty locked down. Nintendo worked hard on securing it properly, only for it to all be for naught due to their SoC vendor making a massive blunder.

I wish I could have seen what was said in the meetings between the two companies when the first Switch exploit was released, considering it was fully on NVIDIA.


Yeah but that was only 1st gen and Nintendo can be just as much to blame for exposing it so easily. They fixed the second rev.

Megaspeed? :-P

He worked at Dennys in Portland for a while, so... He can always lean on that experience if needed.

I think he will be ok with $50B+

In this economy, that might just cover his rent until next month.

This is undoubtedly the most painful professional moment in his career which has been almost entirely Nvidia.

and entirely preventable. FAFO

> I do feel for Jensen

Why? He caused this. He chose to have affairs with a spy and a subordinate. Now he has to deal with the consequences.


It remains possible to feel sympathy for people who have done wrong. He's one of the richest men on the planet, he's acted with hubris and ignominy, he's betrayed his loved ones, and he's also probably feeling pretty terrible right now.

Why would I have sympathy for him? Sounds like he got what he deserved

Because its the human thing to do.

The human thing to also do is not pushing AI everywhere for the benefit of themselves and their stakeholders, to the detriment of literally the rest of humanity

Have you never been in a situation where you made mistakes, felt guilty, and appreciated the empathy and sympathy from fellow humans in light of all the shame and vitriol you received counter-wise?

Yeah but I'm not also a multi-billionaire who ran a company that is going to crash our economy

And do you only judge whether people deserve your humanity by how rich or poor they are?


probably feeling pretty terrible that he finally got caught?

based on the reporting about the second affair, it's possible his security has had to shut down similar witnesses in the past.


> It remains possible to feel sympathy for people who have done wrong.

It does remain possible; he's a parasite and someone who's just had an affair. He wouldn't value the sympathy given, Neither himself or Nvidia would return the gesture.

They give null shit about you.

> He's one of the richest men on the planet, he's acted with hubris and ignominy, he's betrayed his loved ones, and he's also probably feeling pretty terrible right now.

He chose to have the affair and as having my father do the same to my mother; you get no sympathy for cheating. Let them feel pretty terrible, maybe they will find what it's like to be human for a change.

Nothing more than a parasite in the corporate playground. His actions caught up with him; woe is me. What will I ever do with so much money.


Sympathy isn't absolution. Do you not have mistakes you live with? I hope he's okay in the same way I hope everyone is okay.

No, I don't. I've been working on my mistakes from the bottom of the barrel for the past twelve years of my life.

Changing everything to get out from rock bottom.

Some billionaire cheats on their wife and I am suppose to mourn for them?

You want me to be empathetic for a sociopath? Blow me.


Congrats on the work. I wasn't trying to accuse.

I think you have misunderstood me. I'm not telling you to feel anything and I'm not going to sleep tonight feeling sad for Jensen Huang either.


It’s possible to have empathy for sinners. We’re all human.

I agree. I think the biggest issue is to not have empathy for sinners and you think you are a saint…

> I think the biggest issue is to not have empathy for sinners and you think you are a saint…

At least that's only hypocrisy (assuming you are not, in fact, actually a saint--you might have developed habits and values that mean you are not likely to sin in that way.) At some level it's not even a problem: you want to aspire to be a better person than you are right now, which means you will hold values that you do not currently measure up to.

But thinking you are a saint because you have empathy is perniciously self-righteous. You can see something similar to this in the progressive movement right now, for instance.


I'm not religious. I do agree though.

But you shouldn't have empathy because you like him or anything.

You should have empathy when he proves he's changed. You can make mistakes, we all do. You don't deserve empathy.

He sells GPUs, he's not a rockstar.


It's like if, after a shooting, you were worried about the shooter having to go to jail instead of wondering about the people shot.

Indeed, except, not at all like that

spending your empathy on billionaires rather than people being screwed over by billionaires is a choice.

I don’t have finite zero sum empathy.

Something you might be excited to learn is that empathy is not a finite resource! You can spend as much of it as you want and never actually run out - try it!

Choosing who deserves empathy based on their bank account is also a choice.

Genghis Khan probably had bunions and I could have some empathy for the pain endured, but I don't because spending a second feeling anything for him is a second I'm not invested in empathizing with, and better yet, helping people that actually need it.

DO you feel for how depressed that WW2 dictator was before he took his own life? How sad and lonely the big "H" was? That stirs empathy in you? Not me. I make choices about who I spend my mental and emotional efforts on.


I think a lot of people might also disagree with the consequences. Something along the lines of - if it’s all consensual then why does it matter. Disclosing trade secrets (wittingly or otherwise) or skirting export ban is a separate matter that does have real legal consequences if proven true.

This is his identity. Sure, he’s made some poor choices. Imagine Jobs resigning at the height of iPhone phenomenon or Gates at the very peak of Windows. Not sure if Jensen can bounce back from this psychologically. He’ll be broken for awhile.

"with a spy" where is the proof that she is a spy? It seems to be perfectly ok for CEOs to profess blind allegiance to a terrorist state, like Larry Ellison does, seems like a double standard.

Let's not forget him most likely knowingly breaking US export laws. Some might even call that treason.

Most likely based on?

You mean he knew she was a spy?

Exactly. I don't feel bad for a billionaire who operates in an extremely unethical fashion.

[flagged]

It will be the end of this species

I feel for his wife, personally

> For all his faults, I do feel for Jensen.

Me too. If he needs somebody to take his place he can reach me at my HN profile page. I'll take the bullet and try to struggle through with just billions of dollars.


> He built this thing from an absolute scratch.

Pretty sure all those nVidia employees over the years had a bigger hand in building it.


I mean they obviously didn't because they never would have been working together without the founders.

Ahhh, yes, Jensen Huang, the legendary 10000x engineer.

They say he only hired other engineers because he wanted to spend time with his mistresses.


Right. I'm sure if you got all of those employees in a room together with no vision and no Jensen, Nvidia as we know it today just pops out, right?

“The graveyards are full of people the world could not do without.” -Elbert Hubbard

https://quoteinvestigator.com/2011/11/21/graveyards-full/


Aha. So now we know why the world is in such a sorry state.

There are dozens, if not hundreds, of AI chip startups right now. So yes is a very reasonable stance to your question

It's CUDA, indeed, only Jensen can do it

Allegedly Ai does it better now, and there is more than CUDA these days

The idea that only one person matters is a plague on society


Every boss tells themself they're indispensable.

This is why socialism/communism won the Cold War. They got rid of entrepreneurship, yet new and innovative companies just spontaneously self-assembled for the greater good!

Wonder if he'll enjoy his retirement or end up like Marlo Stanfield at the end of The Wire.

Not to hate but he didn't build any GPU tech really.. He just came up with the name "GPU" (like CPU but with a G").

I, too, feel for the billionaire adulterer.

[flagged]

Success in some areas of your life does not insulate you from tragedy. The guy still puts his jeans on one leg at a time. Probably very expensive jeans he throws away after one use...but still. The human condition cannot be escaped.

This includes his family and the family of those involved in the affair. Many lives were turned upside down.


The guy has enough money to buy an island in French Polynesia and never leave it for the rest of his life. You are correct he is still human, but he can do pretty well at making a new life for himself where he doesnt have to ever think the word Nvidia again.

In 10 years he will have a new family and new friends and this will be a distant memory for him.


Yeah, it's just potentially a little light treason, what could go wrong

Treason has a legal definition, you don’t just get to call behavior you don’t like treason.

They had export restrictions placed on them for national security reasons. Deliberately circumventing those can be construed as providing material aid to enemies of the state, which is a legal definition of treason.

It really doesn't seem like that big of a stretch to me. I do think it's extremely unlikely to go that direction, but it's close enough that it's conceivable.


Yeah, pretty small potatoes compared to the current US president.

But the President is an untouchable. Huang isn't.

Trump will get away with everything he's done. Rubio, Vance, Kennedy and Hegseth won't.


Trump will pardon every one of those people on the way out.

They'll get indicted after he's left office. He can't pardon retroactively.

I don't think it's been tested yet, technically?

https://www.criminallawlibraryblog.com/preemptive-pardons-co...


> Trump will get away with everything he's done. Rubio, Vance, Kennedy and Hegseth won't.

Well, there's a first time for everything I guess. Trump can just pardon them in return for a bribe after all.


The current chair of the House Foreign Affairs committee proudly wears a foreign military's uniform on Capitol Hill, so probably nothing.

It isn't the tragic human condition to have affairs. It's a choice he made with his free will. There is no need for apologia; he could simply have not done it.

Humans being fallible and not being able to resist our urges is indeed part of the human condition.

Not my clearest comment. What I mean to say is: "it's the human condition" is being used as a defense/absolution of his affairs, as though it's somehow a matter of course that he's going to commit infidelity. It isn't inevitable, because he could have simply chosen to do otherwise. It may be the human condition to experience temptation, but in the end it's irrelevant. He made a choice. That's what matters.

[flagged]

That’s a strange argument. His wife owns half of these dollars, so no one should feel for her as well?

(I personally don’t care about Jensen. I just don’t think that “people don’t deserve sympathy because they are billionaires” makes any sense.)


Being a billionaire is a choice to continue to hoard resources that could be put to useful purposes instead. Yeah, I don't have much sympathy for people who choose to squander our society's resources like that.

Does a billionaire who became billionair by marrying a person who became a billionaire also bears the responsibility of hoarding because they choose to marry that person and not divorce early?

No, not morally. If she divorces, she should also be subject to that proposed the wealth tax, which she won't mind because according to your frame she didn't choose to hoard.

He's not hoarding crap. Man's probably got maybe a couple hundred thousand dollars in free cash, the rest is all loans, stocks, investments and properties.

The only people that should be wealth taxed is leeches like you that see how utterly corrupt the state is with how it handles tax dollars and wants to give it more money.


Nah. He could sell most of that stock and it could be put to useful purposes while making no difference whatsoever to his life. It could be used to build housing, or pay teachers more, or build libraries, or found new companies, or pay off medical debt, there's thousands of things it could be used for. Instead he's just sitting on it. This is hoarding.

Wrong tree?

> Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang Backs California Billionaire Tax Despite Potential $8B Bill

> "I don't mind paying taxes. The more you make, the more taxes you pay. I'm okay with that," Huang said


Jensen has been one of the few outspoken billionaires for promoting higher taxes on himself. In fact, only he and Buffett come to mind as the members of that category.

Then again, below is a 2024 article from the NY Times claiming Jensen was taking advantage of loopholes to save $8 billion on taxes. Actions speak louder than words so perhaps his more recent messaging about being in favor of higher taxes on himself was the result of a PR effort, given his rapidly increasing visibility.

However, I imagine that any good accountant would strongly recommend saving $8 billion on taxes like Jensen did before 2024. The article:

https://www.nytimes.com/2024/12/05/business/nvidia-jensen-hu...


It's not necessarily inconsistent. You can support improvements to the tax code while also optimizing for the current version.

Saying you support then actually making it possible, something that every billionaire can easily do with how super PACs work is an actual choice.

Talking is the cheapest thing you can do and his actions say more. Rather than helping make a free and safer society for Americans, he chose to ignore export bans and work with an adversarial government.


Things Jensen has said are now all suspect. Does he really believe this or is it just his day time positioning, in contrast to his nighttime positioning that cost him his job

Owning part of the company he built isn't hoarding, kiddo.

Tens of thousands, maybe even hundreds of thousands of people built that company, kiddo.

They did the jobs they were given and were well compensated for it. This fact has no bearing on whatsoever on the claim that Jensen is "hoarding" his shares in the company that he created.

He could give away >95% of his wealth and it would make no difference at all to his life. He would still have the exact same life he has now. That wealth could be put to useful purposes, but isn't, because he is sitting on it. That is hoarding.

You could drive a 20 year old car, live in a small apartment, wear Walmart clothes, and rely on Social Security for retirement while donating everything else to charity, and the difference on your life would be negligible. You'd likely go from a 99.9th percentile lifestyle (globally) to a 95th percentile lifestyle. Why are you hoarding your wealth when people are hungry and dying of preventable diseases around the world? Of course, you'll insist that "it's different" (you can't possibly be expected to take a 5 percentile hit to your lifestyle!) but that's just an excuse to exempt yourself from your own moral code. Why would anyone take progressives' supposedly "moral" beliefs seriously--or even to view them as being sincerely held--when even affluent progressives consider themselves to be immune from their own moral calculus? Is there a single religion on earth that is so blatantly hypocritical as to make demands of others without requiring them of the faithful?

> You could drive a 20 year old car, live in a small apartment, wear Walmart clothes, and rely on Social Security for retirement while donating everything else to charity, and the difference on your life would be negligible.

No, this is obviously false.

If you're bringing up buying clothes at Walmart, then I don't think you understand how much money a billion dollars is. A billion dollars in a HYSA giving 3.5% yields 35 million dollars a year, with zero work and zero risk. It takes a married couple ballpark 5 million dollars to basically never need to work again. So a billion dollars earning guaranteed interest gives you enough money to never need to work again, seven times over, every single year. After just one year, you already have more money just in interest than you could ever reasonably spend, and you haven't even tapped in to your principle. A billion dollars is an absolutely insane amount of wealth.

Jensen Huang has eighty times that much money. There is no difference between eighty billion dollars and one billion dollars. It's the same amount of money. It's effectively infinite. He can give away 79 of those 80 billions and he would not notice, it would have zero impact on his life. He wouldn't have to drive a Walmart car or live in a small apartment, he can still have every lifestyle choice he could possibly want after giving away 95% of his money. The difference would not even be negligible to him. There would literally be no difference.


You could also fall in a well and would probably make no difference to the world.

> well compensated for it

If they were, how could he hoard so much of their output?


He didn’t, that’s just a reflection of how much nVidia has made.

I get what you're trying to say, but the whole point is of course that well compensated is not in relation to other companies but purely within the company.

Even if they were paid 1 million per hour, if their economic output was worth 10 million per hour, they would still be effectively exploited. The easiest way to tell if this imbalance is going on, is simply: how much money does leadership make?

The amount of money leadership (or stock-owners) make is (for many companies, and heavily simplified) essentially revenue - costs - wages. For this equation to return positive yield, it is essential that workers produce more revenue than they cost in wages. If you flip that framing, then it is essential that workers earn less than they contribute to revenue. This is to some extent normal, as some percentage should be accepted as the risk-imbalance between employment and owning stock, but in many modern companies this balance is completely off, e.g under my-employees-piss-in-a-bottle-for-break-bezos.

This is a surprisingly radical view, and I don't expect you to agree with me, but this is the view that considers Jensen to be hoarding.


Apple lost its magic long time ago.


I recently tested a bunch including a lab-grade transmitter setup as control. My focus was on temperature in a lab refrigerator for home use and RuuviTag Pro was the best. You can also modify the firmware yourself which is a huge bonus. Pair with Shelly as a gateway and it’s quite useful.


So you’re OK with Grok but not Muse. What an odd conclusion to make.


What were his metrics?


I am so glad AI was not around to get in the hands of fascist and authoritarian regimes. No, wait…


A legend through early 2000s. The game changed starting 2013-14 and he never adjusted. Bailed or undervalued a bunch of tech names that could have yield 2-3x his actual return. Recent example is them bailing on TSM because of Chinese invasion fears.


TSMC? They did well investing in BYD though.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: