I was replying to a post that said people aren’t being forced to use “AI”. They are, I’m one of them. Part of the force is the difficulty of switching careers. Part of it is market forces. What do you think “forcing” means in this context? It’s not someone standing behind you with a whip.
"What do you think “forcing” means in this context? It’s not someone standing behind you with a whip."
That was my point. It is unnecessary hyperbole, reinforcing doomerism. Because indeed, no one is forcing anyone to use AI. If you really don't want to, there are options. Probably with other downsides, but the word "forcing" implies there are no options. And this is largely not true.
I don’t know how you get to “forcing” implying there are no other options. A force, as a physical phenomenon or general metaphor, is something with a finite magnitude. We talk of forces being overcome. Of course I have other options, that doesn’t mean I’m not being forced. And in fact, you appeared to assume I’m super-anti LLM code generation – I’m not, I’m more uncomfortably ambivalent. I use it by choice on a couple of personal things. Still doesn’t mean I’m not being forced to use it at work. Anyone who cares about freedom should be clear on what’s happening here.
Yes, technically "your money or your life" is a free choice, but I think we can all recognize that this is a pedantic and dismissive way to address a valid concern.
"but I think we can all recognize that this is a pedantic and dismissive way to address a valid concern."
I am just fed up with the doomerism.
Literal slaves working the fields or mines had no choice and were forced. A academic educated person in the west usually does have choices, even if they involve a paycut or other work that is not as convenient as IT work used to be. But if you want to ship things in IT and not do the craft for the sake of it, then there was never a better time than now.
You're right that as an educated software developer in america, I could quit my job and find a new career. But that's daunting- risking your health insurance, or paying exorbitant fees to maintain coverage. I actually did quit a job about a decade ago, and had to take my daughter out of daycare and sell a spare car while I job hunted. It was scary, and there was some risk, and yeah, it worked out okay.
I think it's a false dichotomy to say we're either "Literal slaves" or "totally free". There's a spectrum. Fear and risk are not things you can just handwave away as "all in your head". Yes, I'm glad I'm not working a mine and being whipped by an overseer- but I have duties and obligations to a partially-invalid spouse, two active children, and a problematic asshole of a mutt. I'll quit rambling, you see where I'm going with this.
"I think it's a false dichotomy to say we're either "Literal slaves" or "totally free"."
I did not meant to imply that at all. And I am very aware of what this means, especially if you have family. It is just that the impression I get in these debates, that people behave like entitled slaves sometimes. "There is no alternative! I cannot leave my golden cage". So also hyperbole from my side a bit, but my main point is, AI makes building software very easy. If one knows how to build software, now is the time to do your own projects (on the side) and get the full revenue. This is what I am trying now, after I did not found my dream job. There are risks, but for survival there are options. So far there is no shortage of shit jobs, also ones where you don't have to touch AI, but of course you cannot expect the same pay.
"1. It is better to see the world as it is, than any other version"
Well, evolution made us filters, we just see a small spectrum (and could not process suddenly seeing all). But it is good that we now know that there is more. And should take that into account. That there are things literally too small to be seen, because light has a wavelength.
My point, which admittedly could have been clearer, was that the ratio between the two companies makes no sense. Think about what we know Anthropic has, in relation to what we know Google has.
Both have data, both have AI. Google is more established and likely has way more data broadly, but the perceived number 1 in AI is now Antrophic. I never payed google 200$ a month (and always used adblockers), but now I do pay so much for Antrophic and for me it is very worth it. And governments and companies seem to think likewise.
So basically also when it is about the ratio, it does not seem so irrational to me. In the big picture with all data in the open it might, but from my limited point of view it is definitely not obvious wrong.
Yes but anthropic advantage is built on frontier models and the industry is at most 6-12 months behind on that - which means the sliver of jobs where you need frontier-class AI gets smaller and smaller every month.
More than that, it's easily replaceable good, when better models comes (or just "good enough and cheaper) there is very little friction in replacing Anthropic with competition - and that is much harder for most parts of the Google's business
I think Anthropic's advantage is in everything combined that made them the frontier in an industry where many companies are trying to be on top, staff, processes, good will
> I never payed google 200$ a month (and always used adblockers), but now I do pay so much for Antrophic and for me it is very worth it.
Agreed. And it's much more likely for me to pay OpenAI $100 / month instead of Anthropic than it is for me to pay Google. Even if they have the models, they seem really good at making it difficult for users to actually use them.
And an addition, Google's revenue is still vastly from ad placement in search. I just don't see how that high revenue is going to survive the arrival of AI.
Google as in Alphabet has much wider holdings, which include Google Cloud (which has been growing rapidly and is a double digit billions business), Waymo, etc.
Google as in search ads has been having trouble, yes.
Connect with other matrix servers? As far as I understand, this is the hard part and makes scaling difficult. (One of a servers user joining a group on a different server will make its original server load all that group data as well and that sums up)
For your use case I also considered setting up a instance. Connecting a cluster of friends. But it would be nice if it could grow a little bit, without problems and the server choking.
"We tend to romanticize super intelligence like it would be some new life form"
How do you know it won't be?
Right now it does not really meet the biological criteries, as it cannot reproduce on its own. But once it can mine minerals, build its chips and engines and maintain itself, what word we have to call that, if not artificial life?
Doesn't mean it will have a soul, but that ain't a scientific concept either. Feelings and emotions? Is that for life required? But we don't know how that works either.
(Apart from that, I would define intelligence as the ability to understand the world.)
But a cat consists of many small parts, cells and smaller, that would not survive and replicate on their own, just when they form a bigger collective. The same pattern of complex matter organisation would be artificial life. But if you insist, I can also think of machines, that have the replication parts integrated in them (miniaturized metal sinterers etc.) and just need to feed themself with certain raw matter and energy. Would that be artificial life to you?
"And we actually do know how feelings and emotions work. Biochemistry."
We know that what we perceive is the result of biochemistry, but we don't know if it cannot also be based on other (quantum) process and we absolutely do not understand how feelings work, as it requires accurately moddeling the mind state of a person and as far as I know we are pretty far from that. Otherwise psychologists would be working with brain simulators to help cure their patients.
"I can build a theoretical brainless self-replicating zombie that does those things."
I hope the comment made you feel good, because it's utterly useless at anything else. The research is freely available, go forth and read it! I can't be arsed to spend my time predigesting neurology as a discipline for you.
I never did either, then my time became much more limited and now to get at least a glimpse into a game, I do not find the time fully diving into, I sometimes enjoy it nowdays.
Depending on the group, because you know some personally who know others personally ... a chain of trust. In other cases because you at least know some online long enough to be quite sure they are human. Also most bots are still spottable, just not always on first glance.
No so much for the scenario studied. More so that it’s probable (and undisclosed) that there now exist nuclear weapons 30x smaller than known, with more controllable effects (EMP, neutron, blast radius, fusion ratio, etc)
I don't think this makes the result any better. While the destruction can be a little more tailored to a specific target, it still results in a massive infrastructure collapse.
I thought the holy grail of nuclear weapons during the Cold War was the neutron bomb, because they thought it would erase life while preserving most of the infrastructure. I don’t know if such weapon was achieved, or even if it’s possible, but declassified tech is usually decades behind.
I think it’s an interesting assumption that ‘infrastructure’ is going to be a fungible asset that an aggressor could productively take over. Even in the 70s the actual operation of a power plant or manufacturing facility would have depended on huge amounts of institutional knowledge. These days, think about the effort that goes into onboarding a single employee and the time taken for them to become truly a net positive. Now consider replacing the entire staff with zero handover, I’d expect the effort required to be on the same order as just building from scratch.
"I’d expect the effort required to be on the same order as just building from scratch"
Not really. If you already have machines and manuals, it just takes some smart people with dedication to figure out most of the rest.
Harder then being introduced, but way way cheaper and easy then building new. Most production is not classified experimental research, but operating standard equipment.
Not really. There aren't so many industrial equipment manufacturers. You just need people that worked with the same equipment elsewhere.
I work in a medical lab. We have the exact same analyzers as a lot of other labs over the world: Sysmex XN for hematology, Cobas for biochemistry, Siemens Microscan or Vitek for microbiology, etc. Even using a completely new one is not an issue. They all work the same. Passwords could be a problem, but 99% of the time they're either not used or written on a sticker on the monitor.
The problem is there is a minimum amount of material to make a bomb. To some extent you can substitute higher pressure for less material but mostly you make a very small bomb by a lower multiplication factor causing less of the material to fission. But that is inherently a random thing, the closer you get to not working the bigger the effect of a very minor difference early in the detonation. Thus, while you can make a very small bomb you can't predict it's yield.
But could you imagine farm workers refusing tractors and doing just manual labour, because it feels better, would have had a chance?
reply