HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | listless's commentslogin

Unfortunately activists have done a fantastic job turning gay into a broad political issue encompassing a lot of ideologies that many people find off-putting. So when you see a plot like this, your first thought is that 1) the author has a self righteous agenda and 2) the award is not deserved but rather given to signal sides in a culture war.

Neither of those things may be true. And that’s tragic because a lot of great work is going to be written off under these pretenses.


> your first thought is that

> 1) the author has a self righteous agenda and

> 2) the award is not deserved but rather given to signal sides in a culture war.

This is psychological projection from a debased information environment.

She has been studying classics, writing, and winning awards since at least 1975!

Quote: Carson is known to be reticent about her private life, and discourages autobiographical readings of her writings.Information about her in publications is often limited to the phrase: "Anne Carson was born in Canada and teaches ancient Greek for a living." While not a confessional poet, her work is considered personal. Carson has said that in her work, she uses her life democratically as just one set of facts among others in the world.

You should be less online so you don't lose your whole self to bottomless cynicism.


I should clarify that I personally would not write this off. But I understand the thinking a lot of people are using when they do.


The Nobel Prize in literature is given for a body of work, not for a specific publication. The book OP quotes does have gay characters but Anne Carson's body of work is hardly about LGBT issues specifically. Writing it off because of one sentence in an antagonistic comment is a bit strange. The Guardian article lists many other quotes of people describing what's compelling about her work.


> turning gay into a broad political issue encompassing a lot of ideologies that many people find off-putting

When was it otherwise?


When YOU see a plot like this. And that YOU see this says a lot more about YOU and your preoccupations with another person's sexuality. If you would just be honest and say "i don't like LGBT people", we'd save a lot of time.


I think you need to read what you’re replying to again, especially the last part.


> Unfortunately activists have done a fantastic job turning gay into a broad political issue encompassing a lot of ideologies that many people find off-putting

This is true of almost everything nowadays. I recoil at almost anything religious for similar reasons, even though I know not everybody that goes to church is a militant anti-abortionist christian nationalist. Nonetheless I will watch `The 10 Commandments` as it's still a very good example of the golden age of Hollywood epics.


I'm beyond thankful that Chinese AI models are so good. I desperately want us to cure the myriad of maladies that humans suffer needlessly with on a daily basis. We're going to need more powerful models than we have now if we're gonna do that and the Chinese are providing the competition needed to push this thing as fast as we can.

I realize "going as fast as we can" is not the most popular position atm. But I'm far more interested in what good we can do than 10% apocalypse scenarios. I volunteer with a charity for childhood brain cancer and I do not want to see another 4 year old die. I'm willing to risk anything to stop this.


Do you mean that you don't believe in the 10% apocalypse scenarios or that you think they're an acceptable risk? Only the latter is really "risk anything".


I would say I’m willing to accept the risk. But I do believe the risk is overblown. It’s always overblown.


I’m pretty sure they meant they believe in the 10% risk of everybody dying but are ok for all of us to take that risk without our consent because they saw a 4year old tragically die. Which sounds completely unhinged, to say the least


i don't know much about medicine so i'm curious about how you're using AI, and how medicine in general is using AI


I don’t actually know. But it’s logical to me that a system designed to find answers in context is well suited for these healthcare problems. We know the answer is somewhere in all the data we have. It’s just too difficult and complex for us to get through quickly.


But you’re ok with AI being used to kill school children in Iran?


This really is a place where the guns-don't-kill-people argument applies, even moreso than guns themselves. The U.S. government massacred school children in Iran. Why does it matter how they targetted them?


It matters because the US military utilised Palantir’s Maven Smart System, a battlefield-management AI designed to compress the "kill chain". It matters because these kind of incidents are more likely to happen in the future.


If your argument is you can’t trust democratically elected governments to make decisions about technology, say that. This banal “oh the children” and “but they’ll use it to kill people” is baby think.


We can't trust democratically elected governments to make decisions about novel technology.


I’m glad you find the killing of children banal. You’d fit right in at the Pentagon. Just make sure to top up on testosterone before you join.


Most people aren’t okay with that, but the blame lies in the people who deployed the AI tool in that situation, not the makers of said tool.


The AI providers offer their services to institutions doing those killing. They make money from it. Of course they share part of the guilt


The knife company offers their products to people doing the stabbing. They make money from it. Of course they share part of the guilt.


If the knife was deliberately marketed and sold specifically to someone who the company knew would use it to stab someone, then, yes, the knife company shares part of the guilt.


I can’t understand any of this. It’s saying everything and nothing at the same time. Whatever TLA+ is this article makes it sound like the most tedious and academic thing ever.


Here's my regular engineer explanation:

TLA+ is a specific kind of formal verification framework for software. The overall idea is that you can "prove" that some software works, rather than the typical "seems like it works" we aim for.

But under the covers, all formal verification schemes are (imho) best viewed as "very fancy testing". There are a few kinds of this fancy testing. TLA+ is the kind that can auto-generate all the relevant test cases for your code (there's more to it than that, but this definition works for now). So now instead of "I wrote a bunch of test cases, all that I could think of, and they pass" you have "I used TLA+ so I know I'm exercising all the possible test cases and they pass".

Here's the problem though: to achieve that trick, you have to write your code in a special language (TLA+). It isn't a tool that can be just pointed at regular production code.

So what you get to "prove" is a translation of your actual code into TLA+ code. It may be possible to auto-translate one to the other (I asked the original author if they did that, but no reply yet). Usually it's a manual process. Therefore you have "proof" but not quite as you know it, because you proved something different than what runs. But still more useful than a wet finger raised into the wind.

For this reason it's typically only used on narrow risky pieces of code (quorum voting is the canonical use case).


This makes sense to me but if I continue with the "fancy testing" analogy it seems like there is no accounting for interactions beyond the system itself: it has perfect unit and integration testing but only for a myopic amount of global state.

I am curious about the limits of what one can expect this language to solve and therefore the types of programs/domains to which it is more/less suited. Why is determining quorum the canonical use case?


> But under the covers, all formal verification schemes are (imho) best viewed as "very fancy testing".

This is misleading. Testing and formal verification are vastly different.


* You define initial states and all possible state transitions.

* It will brute force all states.

* You can add a variety of assertions.


Four-letter acronyms or longer.


This makes sense from a business perspective. If your primary customers are men, you wanna branch out of that real quick. I think something like ~80% of all consumer spending in the US is done by women. You gotta go after that. That's an ENORMOUS market to just leave on the table.

That said, I fail to see how trying to attract more women alienated men. I just don't buy that culture war as a reason. I remember Nike doing some things that were a bit annoying that I wished they would just stay out of, but I still bought their shoes. The only thing more insufferable than the culture war is taking part in said culture war.


>I fail to see how trying to attract more women alienated men

It's less about Nike making decisions that men don't like and more about Nike spreading themselves too thin.

Just think about Nike as a company: the products they actually sell are generic, barely mid-tier clothes and athletic gear. Their actual product is their brand. That's why all of their products prominently display their iconic logo and everyone and their grandma knows their slogan is "Just do it."

A brand is only as valuable as the awareness of the brand. So every dollar that Nike spends on marketing is incredibly important for driving their bottom line. If you split those marketing dollars in an attempt to reach a new audience, you're necessarily spending less of those marketing dollars on the existing audience that found your brand valuable. So, in trying to attract more women, Nike ended up attracting less men.

The question, really, is how important is this dynamic. Apparently, it's pretty important. I don't think Nike made a blunder in attempting to expand their audience. I'm willing to bet that they started seeing some writing on the walls which suggested not doing anything was going to be bad enough that taking the risk to spread themselves thin was appropriate. But at the end of the day, I think modern consumerism moves too fast and is so much less concentrated than it was in the past (when Nike dominated) that they just couldn't keep everything together as effectively as they needed to.


I don’t agree. Building a date picker used to be next to impossible. Overnight it was trivial. That’s some serious disruption.


That was certainly not overnight. The biggest disruption they personally did was offering a better alternative to Bootstrap. More customization, JIT compilation that allowed for custom class interpretation without any added CSS, proper flex consideration, removing unused library classes in the production compilation step, etc.

Beyond this, you should really be thanking things like Shadcn for the “date picker disruption”. It is a component library which arguably could’ve existed without Tailwind ever existing.


why shadcn and not bootstrap? shadcn is like a cool weird approach to a ui kit but bootstrap got us a date picker iirc.


Nonsense. There have been perfectly good free date picker widgets available for every era of web development, going back to clunky server-rendered html templates.


Seriously. I always wonder who makes these comments, then I remember I'm old and there are people who don't remember every era of the web. Although, it's still incredibly weird to essentially claim that Tailwind solved date pickers.


You have to remember the biggest appeal of tailwind is that it throws away the entire cascade of css. The people that reach for it are choosing it because it offers less functionality, and is therefore simpler to reason about. I hesitate to say they don't understand css, I'm sure some of them do, but in my experience the devs that reach for it are the same who deride css and make statements such as "I have better things to do than learn css"


I think there's plenty of developers that are perfectly competent with CSS who still reach for Tailwind.

You're right that Tailwind throws away the cascade, or at least enables developers not to have to think about it (under the hood, Tailwind 4 uses pretty modern cascading features like layers), but people aren't reaching it because of a lack of understanding, they're reaching for it because as front-ends get increasingly componentized, the cascade becomes less and less of a benefit and more of an obstacle to be worked around, and something that gets that obstacle out of the way becomes more attractive.


I'm perfectly competent at CSS and... at this point I don't even look at CSS. I just feed descriptions of what I want to the LLM and it nails it every time. The result either looks the way I want or it doesn't.

I'm not universally pro-AI. I meticulously review every line of backend code, and still do hand edits. I review FE commits less carefully but still keep an eye on it to make sure AI doesn't go off the rails. But there's only so much trouble you can get into with CSS and the problems are the kind of bite-sized problems that LLMs excel at.

I don't think it matters at this point what you use for styling. If you like tailwind, the AIs use it just fine. If you like SASS, or raw CSS, the AIs are also just fine.

I'm not sure there's really a human job here anymore.


Do you store your CSS in separate common files independent of markup? Out of curiosity, do you run into issues with excessive token usage when you want to work with CSS?

That would be my gut instinct - you ask your agent to change a CSS rule, and your agent would feel the need to find all usage of that rule to avoid introducing unexpected changes. Does that happen? (I'm operating purely on assumptions here because I regularly use tailwind where changes are kinda definitionally local).


I'm quite versed in CSS but tailwind has convenient abstractions on top. It's like "why you need C if you have assembler". I don't remember when I wrote raw CSS last time. Even global styles I tend to express via @apply.


Don't forget that, in my opinion very positive way, it also normalized the concept of "uniform measurements". Every instance of `rounded-md` is the same on a site.


True. I'm grateful for that but typically reach for them via openprops or home built variables for most of my projects these days


IE, it has a built-in design system!


A bunch of people have already said this but I also have known CSS very well (being using it since its release) and even enjoyed it. Butt the moment I saw someone using Tailwind I thought, "I want that!" The idea that Tailwind is for, or rather only for, people who don't know CSS is very misguided. That said, I'm back to using vanilla CSS.


Indeed, I don't know what to make of such a bizarrely nonsensical assertion. Age and lack of experience doesn't really explain it, because all the poster needed to have done was make the simplest sort of web search. It's so wrong, it's... not even wrong.


> Thieves, grifters, rapists, pedos, just the absolute worst human garbage imaginable.

I would urge you strongly not to let yourself be this consumed by this kind of thinking. This is a distorted view of your fellow man - however accurate _some_ of it may be about _some_ people - regardless of their political affiliation. This kind of thinking is exactly how we got to where we are now and persisting in it will almost certainly get us more extreme reactions.

that said, the Republican establishment has proven itself unworthy of the office and should be shown the door in the next election cycle - in decimating fashion. So much so that it should cause a complete recalibration of that party.


>This kind of thinking is exactly how we got to where we are now and persisting in it will almost certainly get us more extreme reactions.

It was seeing a black guy, and then possibly a woman, and then possibly a black woman get to the top that got us where we are now. The message is clear, don’t disrupt up our image of the hierarchy, or else we will support the worst of the worst, as long as they maintain the order.


I take 1.25 every night. I titrated down off of three and ima keep going. I cannot tell the difference between those doses. Both make me very drowsy.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: