This opinion (not yours, it's shared with the majority) always strikes me as odd. This isn't directed at you, just commenting here as a relevant spot in the threads.
It's clear they built something unlike anything that has ever existed. And it's _wild_ to me they can do it with existing console hardware. 30 FPS is perfectly servicable. Sort of like the Louis C.K. bit about people forgetting how magical flying really is.
> It's clear they built something unlike anything that has ever existed. And it's _wild_ to me they can do it with existing console hardware.
Likewise, I find this take baffling. Yes it is impressive what they managed to do, but this is first and foremost a video game, not a tech demo. Frame rate is hugely important to how it feels as a video game.
It feels to me like they optimised the game for marketing, not for gameplay. Pretty screenshots sell games, and you don't experience how the game feels to play until they already have your money.
An even more cynical take is that they knew this and it was part of the reason to not sell the game on disc: you can't resell a digital copy. This prevents the 2nd hand market from being flooded with copies from people who are disappointed with the frame rates after the honeymoon period over the pretty graphics passes.
For anyone who bought the original No Man’s Sky, would know how unplayable and buggy it was at first (but it was indie studio). Same with Cyberpunk which was from a well-funded studio. Both were eventually able to patch things up and went on to become major hits.
I believe a similar situation might be in order for GTA VI. Already plagued by so many delays, someone probably foot their foot down and said we’re going to ship the best we can on so and so date and follow it up with patches.
I bought No Man's Sky on day one, and it was perfectly playable for me. But I disliked it because of the lies they told about it being multi-player, the extreme repetitiveness, and especially the nightmare scenario in which KarenBots are everywhere on every planet in every galaxy like a law of nature.
It could be, if it was consistent, but the parent comment was just saying how any interaction drops the rate to 20 (and likely below even that). The human eye only recognizes smooth motion at 17 frames a second, so the idea that the "greatest game ever" is an interactive slideshow whenever game play gets intense is laughable.
>they can do it with existing console hardware
I don't think they can, and they should have lowered fidelity so people could actually play the game.
> The human eye only recognizes smooth motion at 17 frames a second
What is noticeable depends on size of screen and how fast things are moving across the screen. Anything up to about 10,000 FPS can be noticeable for very fast movement.
Wow that video makes me insanely jealous. I wish more places had that attitude about how these onew tools can affect positive change in our life and in our workday.
In my corner of the world we were hit with the expectation that we are pushing up to 10 things forward at the same time since agents can operate in parallel.
I also realize the juxtaposition of that video coming out of a Chinese company and the slave labor used across the country. Still a guy can dream.
I hate ROS so much. Such a misguided effort given what we have with both common / existing and modern dev tooling. Sorry I don't use it now only because I can't test your replacement.
Good luck! Excited to see more stuff like this coming.
Thanks! Tell me about it… btw you don’t need to have a ROS stack to try Cerulion! Try giving the quickstart prompt to your agent and lmk if something breaks :)
At a certain scale (probably bimodal distribution) it makes sense to have a provider you can shrug it off to and point the finger to when things are missing features or the system goes down, etc etc. On the big-co end of that spectrum I think you are right and AI makes this stuff easy to launch internally.
The owner at my current gig has multiple times said "software is over" as it being a sort of gravy train of rent seeking. Products are gonna have to offer real / significant value to attract new customers. Maybe even to keep them, too...
>> and point the finger to when things are missing features or the system goes down
This sounds good in theory but - and I speak from experience with a FF system causing a system-wide outage - clients don't care why YOU had an outage, or that it's not immediately your fault, and they really shouldn't have to. The reality is more like you're paying for a dependecy that you can't mitigate.
Being able to point fingers is also a moot point from a theoretical perspective.
Given that every FF system comes with a bunch of different mechanisms that prevent your system from being catastrophically impacted in case the provider goes down, its still the fault of the integrating party if you experience an outage due to a FF provider.
It's clear they built something unlike anything that has ever existed. And it's _wild_ to me they can do it with existing console hardware. 30 FPS is perfectly servicable. Sort of like the Louis C.K. bit about people forgetting how magical flying really is.
reply