Does ULA launch test flights or just swing for the fences every time? It seems like managing expectations and payload value allowed SpaceX to iterate faster and do things you wouldn't do on a contracted mission.
This is a great step but it needs to go even farther. The ALPR tools should only be able to store hits on license plates that are under an active warrant.
I feel like it’d be an uphill battle to say you can’t use it to find e.g a car in an Amber Alert, or actively escaping. But I don’t know, do they already get warrants for that kind of thing?
It's a shame cops can't be trusted to not abuse it if given access not through the courts. Every single time a tool like this is given to them without massive fetters it's abused so they don't get to have the toy.
There's a ton of things that would make policing easier but we don't do them because they destroy other valuable parts of society. It'd be much easier to solve crimes if everyone had to wear networked body cameras and GPS trackers at all times but we don't do that because it destroys far more important things.
I like it. But it's going to rule out some very useful searches. (Where was that car in the 48 hours before the crime was committed, and in the 24 hours from the crime to the warrant?) So there is going to be great pressure against this idea.
That kind of thinking is exactly where the "slippery slope" concept comes from. It's all Very Useful, so just keep it all forever!
Before this technology existed, we didn't have this level of information retention. How did enforcement happen? Slowly (as it should), methodically (as it should.)
I don't think AnimalMuppet is suggesting that there will be pressure from outlawing searches that are Very Useful for enforcement. I think the suggestion is that the pressure will come from outlawing searches that are Very Useful for rescue.
Well, he responded that I did understand. But my point is that it doesn’t matter. Regardless of who’s pushing to keep data for Very Useful (say legitimate?) purposes, everyone with their own “Very Useful” (say nefarious?) purposes will use the data.
Yeah, I was disappointed too. I think there's an increasingly large part of HN that mostly just wants to get (or confirm) a simple 'black hat' / 'white hat' morality tale and then move on. Really understanding nuance is hard and when all the hats are varying shades of gray, it's a lot more work for an unsatisfying outcome.
And this mess around export controls on GPUs is an especially confusing and conflicted situation with layers on layers. Since posting that I've been reading and cross-reference papers written over the past year by foreign policy and trade analysts and gained a lot more detail and insight on the dynamics. The one thing in my post above I now know was incomplete is the part about NV banning Megaspeed (MS). It's true they did but there was an exception (the "Affiliates Rule") enacted by a one-year waiver on 9/30/25 which expired on 11/1/26. But the U.S. extended it for two more months three days ago. That waiver permitted NV to keep selling to Megaspeed affiliates. That exception was not a mistake. So NV blocked MS but the rules allowed them to legally keep selling to MS affiliates - and they did (and probably still are). With the full knowledge and approval of the US Govt.
That seemed crazy to me but it got clearer once I understood how the US government is split on this issue. The Commerce Dept, White House trade policy desks and external advisors are aligned on one side and State, Treasury and Defense Depts on the other. The forcing function for why the leaks of ~6 month-old intel about Jensen happened now, is the H200 waiver extension and the Trump–Xi summit in Shenzhen on November 18 where the U.S. and China will negotiate whether to extend that waiver after January.
The Commerce Dept side wants to include extending the waiver as possibly 'negotiable', if China is willing to give enough value for it (like rare earth metals and major trade concessions, limiting oil purchases from Iran, etc). The State/Defense side wants it 'non-negotiable' for any price. NVidia's interests are obviously aligned with the Commerce Dept/trade policy desk faction and Jensen's personal relationship with, and ability to potentially sway, Trump was a wildcard variable. The leaks have taken Jensen off the board before the negotiation. I actually hate how much this sounds like a 'crazy uncle' conspiracy theory but serious policy and trade analysts all agree this is the basic dynamic that's been unfolding over the last year. Just ask your favorite LLM to give you a list of links on this and look for yourself. It's really complicated but my takeaway is no one related to this mess looks remotely good. The perverse thing is I'm still pretty sure NVidia fully complied with every rule and reg. Yet thousands of GPUs were diverted because the regs were designed to be swiss cheese-like and then got waivered on top of that. NVidia made billions but that was intended to happen and explicitly made legal.
[Edit to add: ... and WSJ just posted 3 mins ago that Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick is "Fighting for His Job Due to Blame for NVidia Fallout", so looks like the leaks not only took Jensen off the board but now the leakers are trying take down Lutnick too. No way the B200 waiver extension happens now. Marco Rubio's gotta be dancing on his desk. God, this really should be a movie someday. ]
The smuggling and romance details that have been exposed so far are either well known or immaterial to the business. So why the crazy urgency now?
Perhaps some influential folks want to support Anthropic's IPO by showing that the open source models will soon be blunted/outlawed, but IPO-ing into a crash seems like a high price for that moat.
Or do similarly influential folks want to tank AI as a whole but couldn't politically afford a crash before mid-terms?
I am in the same boat. Sun servers were still the best that money could buy when they lost to the Linux revolution. Linux was _good enough_ and destroyed their margins.
Looking at a sample of 40,139 death records from the Veterinary Medical Database from 1984-2004, scientists from the University of Georgia determined the average age at death for dogs that had not been spayed or neutered was 7.9 years versus 9.4 years for sterilized dogs.
Most enterprises capable of running that much gear won't take that risk even if it is unenforceable. Oracle has made a great living threatening audits of companies who download its updates.
Yeah, but only Western companies who might have to defend themselves in court. I have no doubt that pirated copies of Oracle DB and the JDK are frequently used in China.
I love this article and I love that LLMs enabled it to exist. The labor cost of software has been setting such tight bounds on creativity and exploration that we will soon wonder why we ever loved to write code.
reply