HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | labrador's commentslogin

Chlorine gas is no joke. In high school I was making it by running electricity through salt water and then diffusing the gas through pool water to chlorinate my parents pool. My cousin took a whiff when I was distracted and had to go the emergency room for breathing problems. Fortunately he recovered fully.

Why?

Like, what leads a teenager to do such things?


Curiosity. I picked apart that component that made my shoes blink. It was very difficult to get it open, but the silver liquid in it was fun. Today I think that was mercury and that I probably shouldn't have done that.

Are humans born with innate knowledge that some things are deadly to smell? Or are we born with an instinct to smell things to figure out if it’s good or bad?


This is a funny question on a forum, that's called "hacker news"...

What, you’ve never been a teenager?

I did plenty of experiments as a teenager, but I never attempted to chlorinate a freakin swimming pool.

It was an above ground pool so I'm not all snooty about it

> ... but I never attempted to chlorinate a freakin swimming pool.

Me neither, but that is probably attributable to the fact that I didnt have a swiming pool.


Perhaps for the same reason a kid [0] built a nuclear reactor in their backyard.

> With one experiment, he created chloroform and as the book encouraged him to sniff the chemical, he did so and was unconscious for more than an hour, according to his recollection.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/David_Hahn


Teenager is stupid.

Back in the day, i tried to sniff NH3 because i've heard it smell like piss.

It's a lot of worse.


Volunteer in an hospital sometime. You will see some shit.

I lost all respect for Jensen when he started gushing about data centers in space which is a stupid idea and obviously self-serving for Elon (sells launches) and Jensen (sells chips). Anyone who says data centers in space should explain why Microsoft determined data centers under the ocean are too expensive (for now). A submerged data center is orders of magnitude easier and cheaper than a space data center.

Microsoft finds underwater datacenters are reliable, practical and use energy sustainably

https://news.microsoft.com/source/features/sustainability/pr...


Space has an efficient way to get power (peak solar 24/7) and is less regulated. Can easily launch a shitton of satellites exactly the same way over and over again once starship works, need to keep finding sites for underwater, each one needs different structural engineering, etc.

> A submerged data center is orders of magnitude easier and cheaper than a space data center.

Source?


Is a source necessary? Just applying some basic common knowledge, such as it takes less energy to move something up than down, or the fact that everything in space has to get there on a rocket, which is only possible by buying space on rockets from whatever three companies or two countries or whatever are sending up rockets. The ocean is accessible from every salt water harbor on earth.

Then there's the fact that you can run hardlines to ocean datacenters, the fact that the ocean provides abundant coolant (cooling things in space is hard but this might surpass common knowledge), the fact that repairs and upgrades don't require a rocket, astronaut, and spacewalk, the fact that you only need to harden against salt water instead of radiation and micrometeoroids, etc.


Thank you. I couldn't have said it better myself. I was on a nuclear powered submarine. A data center on a barge with a nuclear submarine parked next to it for power (out sub did 80 MW) is easy to envision and doable today. Sea water cooling systems are a solved problem obviously.

On the other hand, a data center in space? A data center is heavy. Solar panels are heavy. That's not a problem on land and sea. It is a problem when you have to lift it into space. Then what about maintenance Do you send a regular crew into space to work on it? Or do you keep a crew in space like a giant space station? It's all doable but at what cost?


> is easy to envision and doable today.

It’s not doable today. The private sector would never be given access to naval nuclear generation for a project like this.

It’s only doable today in the sense that we could just build nuclear plants everywhere today and end the climate crisis. On paper the energy works out but society doesn’t want nuclear because of hysteria.


Cost and long time horizons is why nuclear is not competitive, not hysteria

The cost and long time horizons are a direct result of hysteria. Plants are bespoke with huge lead times because we never gave it the time to standardize on a plant design before panic set in after some incidents.

Yes a source is absolutely necessary. Investors are dumb but there's a reason multiple startups and established firms are pursuing space datacenters seriously; they did have to show investors some compelling numbers. Why are there no major underwater datacenter efforts today?

you know you can just make up numbers? I say this as someone who has raised money from investors in the past, a huge number of the startups I have networked with are knowingly doing fraud. Many of them very successful at raising money from investors. If anything, I see a negative correlation between honesty and funding round size

> Just applying some basic common knowledge, such as it takes less energy to move something up than down, or the fact that everything in space has to get there on a rocket, which is only possible by buying space on rockets from whatever three companies or two countries or whatever are sending up rockets. The ocean is accessible from every salt water harbor on earth.

Your whole premise assumes that energy to run these things is free/cheap and that energy to install them is the dominating factor. 24/7 solar power in space is literally the entire argument for these orbital datacenters. So unless you have some proposal for why electricity is easier to get underwater, you’re just ignoring the most significant factor.

Data centers on land are even easier than data centers in water. But they are getting blocked because of FUD about power prices.

So yes, a source is necessary because you ignored the biggest ongoing cost to running a datacenter when applying “basic common knowledge”.


> 24/7 solar power in space is literally the entire argument for these orbital datacenters.

That's good to know because that makes the case for data centers in space even worse.


If you weren’t informed enough to know that was the motivation I don’t think your analysis on the merits of it is going to be accurate.

>once starship works

More like IF Starship works. This thing is spearheaded by the same guy who spearheaded the Hyperloop high-speed rail, which became a single-car tunnel under Las Vegas, Humanoid robots that are actually just people in bodysuits, the Cybertruck, which was a complete flop, and now "flying cars" that are just proofs of concept that won't ever actually get sold (or will kill people if they are).


If datacenters in space work out. It will be good for Musk & Google.

Sucks for everyone else though.

24/7 solar power with 9 times the power of surface solar without grud waiting times and regs

With 0 land, water or zoning bottlenecks. Free global real estate.


By the time data centers in space are a thing, everyone alive today will long be gone, including Google.

Why?

Because it's a comically difficult problem. The largest, most power hungry thing we have ever built in space is the ISS and it's peak power production is 0.215 megawatts. That's barely enough for a single current generation server rack.

Heat is also a huge barrier, radiators have to be huge because they have to rely in black body radiation and to be more efficient requires power hungry heat pumps to increase their temperature so they can radiate more efficiently


Ok well a single Starship is the size of the ISS. Heat rejection is not a problem contrary to what armchain redditors would have you think.

Heat control is one of the main issues in space and a space datacenter will be creating orders of magnitude more than any other thing we've ever put out there. We have a lot of techniques for it but the space datacenter is asking them to scale to levels we've never tried before.

It’s fine

You are out of touch. A single gen3 starlink sat is 250kw.

Ok so approximately 3 starlinks worth of power for a single rack not accounting for any draw for the cooling equipment. It's still a huge step up in the power density of the things we put in space and the datacenter would have to be many times larger than the ISS just for the power and cooling scaffolding around the racks units.

What’s the source on that?

It doesn’t look like the actual power figures are public, and V2 satellites look to be around 10kw of solar capacity.

250kw is an incredible amount of solar capacity, practically unbelievable that a single satellite would need or produce that much power.


Isn't Google also doing the same? Are DCs in space a point of argument any more?

Project Suncatcher is a research project not expected to replace earth based data centers

"progress depends on the unreasonable man"

it feels like data centers in space only make sense if you're trying to protected them from the general population (mobs with pitchforks when we all lose our jobs)

There'll still be an army of civilian cubesats with solar arrays potentially capable of targeted collision.

I'd never bet against Musk. Microsoft can't make data centers in space viable in the same way ULA cannot make reusable rockets economical.

What happens if Anthropic becomes a specialized high intelligence company because they can't afford the build out. Claude would be like an expensive Bloomberg Terminal or an investment letter that offers valuable and expensive intelligence.

I think about this because I pay $100/mo for Fable. How much more would I be willing to pay? I'm not sure yet. It depends on how smart the AI in the future becomes.


> would be like an expensive Bloomberg Terminal or an investment letter that offers valuable and expensive intelligence.

Whether it's Anthropic or not, I think it's inevitable some highly specialized offerings will emerge. I suspect there are already some incredibly sophisticated, hyper-narrow, astronomically expensive models being created for private in-house use.

As an imaginary example, I wouldn't be shocked if some company like Jane Street is secretly investing a billion dollars to create the highly specialized synthetic RLVR data needed to train an AI that gives them an average .08% edge on a certain kind of commodity, equity or asset trade. If so, it's not a leap to imagine another company spending $100M on a model that gives a .008% edge and selling access to 100 high-volume institutional traders for $2M each.

Expanding general purpose LLMs to incorporate increasingly specific use cases has, so far, seemed to be economically viable but I don't see a fundamental reason that must remain true for incredibly narrow yet ultra high-value domains requiring monumental bespoke development, data, etc to profitably exploit.


> As an imaginary example, I wouldn't be shocked if some company like Jane Street is secretly investing a billion dollars to create the highly specialized synthetic RLVR data needed to train an AI that gives them an average .08% edge on a certain kind of commodity, equity or asset trade.

The crazy thing is ... it's not imaginary, nor is secret, it's literally a video on YouTube from five months ago - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8J-GUnfSqeE (though that facility is only showing of ~$200 million worth of compute).


Being a specialized firm might work if they didn’t have $700 bn in commitments.

Already they have exclusive deals with trading firms who pay $$$ for faster models and more features. But there are only so many firms who will pay that much (and a lot of companies are pulling back on spend, not increasing it)


and that would still be valued at a fraction of $1T.

As a software engineer I’d be paying thousands if there were no alternatives. As a household - just about everyone pays $100 a month for internet access alone and something like cloude can be easily worth that.

Thing is - regular people have no clue what to do with it since they are locked in ecosystems of apple and google.


I'm having flashbacks to when I was in high school in the 1970's while Nixon was at the height of his powers.

The difference is Nixon had real domestic enemies to worry about: The Weather Underground were bombing buildings, heiress Patty Hearst was kidnapped by the "Symbionese Liberation Army", the Black Panthers were making demands which conservative America found frightening, mass protests were going on about the war in Vietnam on college campuses which resulted in the deaths at Kent State. Nixon believed these protests were driven by Chinese and Soviet influence to support North Vietnam in the war. The CIA’s Operation CHAOS spent years looking for foreign control of the antiwar movement and reported back that there wasn’t any.

What domestic enemies does Trump have? Antifa is a philosophy, not an organization. Black Lives Matter protests were his last administration. There have been a few lone wolf attacks like the Dallas ICE sniper, but the domestic threat is no here near what Nixon faced.

Under the Trump's White House directive NSPM-7, which defines a potential domestic terrorist as anyone expressing “anti-Christian, anti-capitalist, or anti-American” views, DHS launched an operation to find a “network of conspirators” against ICE.

The surveillance op in the Wired article targeted labor unions, a climate change group and socialist collectives — the SEIU had three years of wire transfers investigated, and the AFL-CIO, DSA and Showing Up for Racial Justice were also investigated. That’s the mismatch: a 1970s-scale dragnet for a threat that isn’t 1970s-scale.

Trump appears to be grabbing power for the sake of grabbing power.


According to my MAGA friends/family, Antifa is the biggest threat to the US.


he's a wannabe dictator.

yeah - he's shaken u.s institutional protections to their core. but lucky they keep standing. maybe he or someone else will finally make a break through - but most likely it won't be trump due to his incompetency and him surrounding himself with 'yes' incompetent people.


They're standing, but he's weakened them. He's also laid down a pattern of how to attack them.

Either the institutional protections are strengthened after 2028 (presuming the Democrats win the presidency) and before 2030 (presuming the Democrats lose a bunch of seats in Congress in the midterms), or the next try (whenever it comes) is likely to break the institutional protections and result in authoritarian rule over the US.


Big deal. I could put bombs in things to kill people but I'm not a murderous person.


Dolly Parton was a beautiful spirit and my life was measurably improved by reading as a child so I donated $50 on her death. It's not much but I'm retired on a fixed income. I had to do something.


It's fascinating to me that the upper classes find Holmes interesting. In the working class world I grew up in, chicks like her are a dime a dozen and can usually be found at Grateful Dead tribute concerts espousing the benefits of crystals and channeling her alien guide who she discovered while chanting an invented baby talk language high on molly and nitrous oxide.


Your comparison missed the actual interesting part about the billion dollar fraud.

People who commit fraud at that scale are not a dime a dozen.


People who commit fraud on this scale are simply those who start at this scale. Not always the super wealthy but often the super wealthy and sometimes those with social ties to the super wealthy.


They usually steal the weed and shrooms out of your backpack because you weren't using them at the moment.


They were taken with her blue-blood "high WASP" background. Elites put a premium on pedigree (because they benefit from theirs!) and so they just loved the fact that her ancestors started Fleischmann Yeast even though her fam squandered their inheritance within 2 generations. Part of the reason her parents put so much pressure on her to become wealthy was to try and claw back that generational wealth they felt they were owed. Her dad in particular was very bitter over how dad had lost a load of money on bad investments in Hawaii. He then flopped at his oil career (Enron) and never got over his family's loss of wealth and status.

If you read Bad Blood there are quotes from her wealthy investors saying things like "well, her great-grandfather was a famous surgeon so medicine runs in her family!" as part of their decision to invest in her.


Generational wealth is often squandered within a couple generations. The first generation can often times keep it together, but the generation after that and beyond have no connection to the origins. If Elizabeth Holmes’s parents were upset at their loss of wealth, it’s because they had no special abilities that would make them good capital allocators.


It’s quite interesting and can be both. Many well-of friends have a period of rejecting their heritage and end up abusing all kinds of things, only to later fall back into the lane so to speak. Some lose it completely tho.


I learned of an interesting case of this in the film "The Sunshine Makers" about LSD production in California in the 1960's. Billy Hitchcock was a wealthy heir to the Gulf Oil fortune who financed the labs but eventually went back to being a protected rich guy by betraying his chemists.


I think what I was trying to say is that, while rejecting their heritage, my ‘friends’ also could always fall back on their families wealth and power. Pretty toxic cocktail. Thinking of it, 50% became super rich entrepreneurs, the other 50% ended up in the psych ward.


Why? As a way ‘out’ ?


Those don't seem like particularly lower class attributes, I know many trust fund babies that are jam band wooks/roadies that could be described this way.


Many rich people are really gullible to direct bold face lies because they are used to things working out for them and so are often less skeptical / guarded(generally speaking) if the lie sounds good.

I grew up with the mindset being told if things were too good to be true they probably were and to expect failure and be pleasantly surprised if things worked out. This is practical advice for many lower to middle class individuals, but it can also hold you back because you stop looking for genuine opportunities. Better advice would be to do your due diligence.

With Holmes, and hindsight is always 20/20, it should have been obvious that she was full of shit. As you say, I have met dozens of people, men and women, like her, that just lie reflexively and I have learned to spot them from a mile away and avoid them at all costs. If you catch someone lying or exaggerating something inconsequential, and by that, I mean it really does not in any way help them or get them out of trouble, it is easy to brush it off as a white lie, but it is the people who will lie for no reason at all who are the most dangerous because you can be assured that they will lie when they do have a reason.


Most people (including rich ones) who had any scientific knowledge passed on investment/partnership. Humanity has developed ways to evaluate ideas without all of the contextual noise people are referencing in this thread. They’re just effortful and sometimes awkward, so too many people of all types just don’t.


Always good to pass on any opportunity you don’t fully understand. You may miss some opportunities, but you will also miss being taken as a fool.


I think particularly in the case of investors it's that they're pretty comfortable with founders that straddle the fine line between bullish and bullshit, because the ones who back up their claims that seem too good to be true make them money, and the ones who don't are priced in. And some who make them lots of money tell a lot of "white lies" on the way. FOMO is a way of missing red flags too.

Holmes' mistake was to massively overdo the "fake it til you make it" in a regulated industry where the implications of the lies appal people, as well as to have a product that was never going to work so the lies were more "this car definitely isn't just rolling down the hill" than "the person at the wheel is only for regulatory reasons". If she'd settled for fantasy metrics and self dealing in a real estate play rather than faking medical tests she'd have investors lining up to fund her second venture...

I'm more intrigued by how she managed to keep customers and at least some of her employees believing and how often that mask slipped.


From what I know, extreme compartmentalization of information, to the extent it seriously harmed whatever chances there might have been to pivot to some kind of realistic product.

And then an extremely tight circle of people she knew she could manipulate. Liars hate people that see through their lies and get rid of them as soon as possible or otherwise try to ruin them.


Oh yeah, I have no doubt there was a lot of knowledge compartmentalization and to many/most employees that seemed like normal practice in an IP sensitive industry. Just wondering how she dealt with the people that started to be mildly pessimistic or suspicious


I know she fired and/or discredited a few people including an intern who's father was on the board of directors. Otherwise the compartmentalization did not allow everyone to see the full extent of the lie. Others were just too incentivized to go along with it.


I think there was an internet meme somewhere, that suggested something along the lines of: if you consider pain to be an essential learning signal, and that beyond a certain level of wealth, you can more or less eliminate pain, then the cognitive effects of such wealth is like being kicked in the head by a horse on a daily basis.



> Many rich people are really gullible to direct bold face lies.

I agree with this point. I think that in the investment world, many VCs investing in deep tech are not deeply familiar with the underlying technology. They often say they are betting on the founders, which can inadvertently encourage this behavior, since founders know that their investors are unlikely to scrutinize the technical details too closely.


VCs are typically kinda gullible because they are primed to believe and sometimes do not have the technical background to really do proper due diligences.


Woah woah woah, lets not bring molly into this. The greatest drug on the planet has nothing to do with new-age nonsense. Nitrous on the other hand...


I agree. I should have said shrooms!


You should have mentioned cocaine, meth, anything that strips away your ability to empathize. If she took shrooms she’d have had some connection to her fellow humans.


Well, in the upper class, they aren't dime a dozen.

(Btw, your comment filled me with warmth, thanks. I also recommend Scott Aaronson's "On Self-Delusion and Bounded Rationality" [1].)

[1] https://www.scottaaronson.com/writings/selfdelusion.html


Those who make fun of crystals fail to realize that technology is literally a race to who can etch the finest/smallest inscriptions into the most perfect crystals. Followed by who can best feed the knowledge of the world into those very crystals via optimal mechanations such that those crystals produce intelligence.


What does that have to do with what parent is referring to?


Both use the word "crystal." That's it.


A lot of women want it along with the ability to order Uber/Lyft from women drivers only.


What about race or religious preference too?


Yeah, if its OK to discriminate on the basis of the immutable characteristics of the Gender class, it should be OK to discriminate based on other characteristics as well.

Its very bigoted and regressive that you can be charged a 'cover' just because you have the wrong genitalia and belong to the wrong gender. I don't see how that's any better then charging a cover because someone has the 'wrong' skin color.

Of course, we have very bigoted courts here in the US that consistently rule to discriminate against men. I promise you if people respond to this comment it will be to argue how discrimination against men is justified and should continue.


Cathering to racism now? /s ?


But sexism is OK?


I don't understand why you think anyone is supporting sexism...

Saying "Think of the women" as you say "think of the children" as a blanket statement can be malicious. Reasoning requires hard data, not evoking feelings.


Fair point, Uber has a female driver mode now.

Doesn’t change my desire for better public transport though.


Maybe fix underlying social problem instead of forcing more crap that tries to patch the absolute terrible state?


That's a very different problem that probably has a generational timetable.

Letting women get home safely with a robot driver is a thing that can happen today.


Not today. Not next year, either. And calling taxi service that dangerous is an exageration. Preference enhanced by that type of comments would be more accurate


I guess? I was on a date with someone and we took an uber back to her place after a concert, and she mentioned off-hand afterward that had I not been there she would have just walked... even though it would have been over an hour on foot, it just wasn't worth the risk after multiple bad/creepy experiences taking carshares home late at night.

Maybe it's a bit like cops: they're not all bad, but the system is kind of set up so that bad ones thrive and good ones burn out. It's going to be a particularly kind of person who is willing to spend their late Friday night driving drunk people home from the club, and honestly if you're a vulnerable person, maybe the guy most willing to do that job is the one you least want as your particular driver.


Fair. There is no reason to not believe you. Women are more vulnerable than men. Still, calling the service dangerous without any backing, by some report in addition to annecdata, is offensive, and only does a service to the provider, however well meaning the deduction may be.


It's definitely not nothing, and the numbers bear that out: https://www.bbc.com/news/business-59008000

Whether this is one of those "we accept some number of school shootings cause gun freedoms are just so great" issues or not is I guess its own matter for debate. But the fact that this happens, and then as dudes we get to discuss it at arms length on the internet and opine about whether "99% of trips completed without incident" is reason to dismiss it all out of hand may help explain why an individual woman getting home from the bar might choose to walk or take waymo vs getting in a cab and risk joining the unlucky 1%.


The link you posted leads to the lyft report. The incidents we are talking about, vulnerable groups, is at worst 1/800,000 which corresponds to Touching

https://assets.ctfassets.net/q8mvene1wzq4/4jxkFTH5YCQK8T96ST...

1% Is a gross exageration if you go by this article / document.

Since you mentioned weapons: Robotaxis will have a social cost, and in Canada that is important in a way not seen in the US. Unlike weapons, there will be not much discussion about robo-everything.


Surveilling on women without their knowledge and then using that footage as you like is dangerous too. Tech companies are famous for their ethics. Letting women get into a cab controlled by an overseas driver seems dangerous too.

Lets not hide profits behind women's safety.


I'm not sure if I buy this, it seems like it's a bit of a turtles-all-the-way-down discussion. Like a vulnerable person ordering a taxi also has a phone, which is the ultimate surveillance endpoint, and opens them up to potential abusive behaviour from employees of their phone maker, their telco, and every app they have on there, including the rideshare ones which by necessity have precise location and other permissions.

At the end of the day, a man driving them home and knowing their home address while right there is a much more immediate and specific point of threat than "I'm being surveilled while I travel in a Google-controlled robotaxi".

Also, like it or hate it, but Google actually has a pretty decent track record with protecting their customers from their own employees. Gmail and gsuite content stays private, and there are enough protections in place to satisfy insurance companies, medical institutions, banks, and even governments. If a Waymo kidnapped or killed someone under the control of an overseas remote operator, it would be national news and congressional hearings; a person getting assaulted by a cab driver is nowhere near that level.

I just don't think "but Google/Waymo bad too" is a reason to poo poo someone feeling more comfortable sitting alone in a robotaxi than sitting alone in a cab or an uber.


> ' a man driving them home and knowing their home address while right there is a much more immediate and specific point of threat than '

Its not anymore of a threat than the taxi itself in case of Waymo. If you have already designated the driver as the threat actor then the Waymo is just as much a threat. In case of the driver the threat is visible. In a robotaxi the threat actor is invisible and multiple. You can be remotely locked in, driven away, suffocated, driven into water , driven in middle of a shooting.

You are just trading a visible threat with an invisible one.


Where's the profit in that?


We're about to revive the Apple vs Microsoft lawsuits of the 90's over "look and feel"


Lispers never give up. I admire that.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: