HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | kubb's commentslogin

I wish I was better at talking, coaxing and getting rapport. That’s the limitation preventing me from getting something more out of life.

Money is lying around these days, and you can just legally take it by duping people, but you have to know how to dupe. I never learned this elementary skill for life success.


Forget about all the possible problems that problem solvers work on, ignore all that, sell the dream and forget your morals.

No thanks.


We have to ignore our morals anyway to survive. Might as well get paid for it.

And who or what is forcing you to? Do you claim all other people do the same to survive?

Not all, but so many do. We eat meat, work on brain rotting tech, pollute the environment, use way too much fossil energy, manufacture need for useless crap.

In comparison, cheating a VC out of a couple million is mild.


GPUs aren’t liquid like stocks or commodities. There’s no guarantee you’ll be able to get them in 10 months.


Same with ag output, but we have a futures market for that.

I guess corn is more fungible than gpus? Not sure what to tell you.

It's fun to note that nobody mentions AGI in these threads anymore.


It's like people saying Bitcoin will become a universal currency adopted by all.


You just wait, we're still early®.


It's because all the arguments have already been said, and now neither side believes they can convince the other.


If you have to convince someone it's AGI, it's not AGI.

This demagogy works both ways.

It really doesn't. The default state of being is not-AGI, in much the same way that the default state of the sky is not-green. If the sky were green, nobody would need convincing of it; they need merely look at it. As long as they cannot see it with their own eyes, however, no amount of telling them it is green will convince them that it is. So too with AGI. AGI would be overwhelmingly self-evident; its mere existence would speak for itself so loudly that it could not possibly be denied. It would not need humans to convince other humans that it exists, nor can humans convince other humans that it exists.

Just more demagogy. But I agree, once a person is blind no amount of arguments can convince them the sky today is green, any smart person knows that. Only if they are stupid _and_ blind can they possibly believe sky is green!

I think most people who care or are tracking it would say we've hit it, and those who disagree just have their goalposts a lot more clearly defined and are quietly waiting.


The very first goal post for AGI must be that it can act, learn, and grow independently. They must be self healing, self correcting, and anti fragile. That's definitely what the G in AGI is about. But all models fall into decoherence if you let them work on their own too long.

If you left an AI alone for a long time and when you came back they had built up a working society and learned new useful things, then that's the proof it's AGI. From this definition you only know it's AGI after you let it loose.


You are describing ASI, AGI is just the stage where it doesn't need to be trained on a specific, narrow task to succeed (like with ANI). You are asking for Agency and motivation, something particularly lacking even in most humans. All the top labs are working to ensure AI doesn't gain that motivation, but I think it exists in living beings only as a evolutionary necessity, not as an artifact of reasoning ability. The entire religion of Buddhism is about abandoning the base human desire to do things and then more things in the endless cycle we possess.

These AI companies changed the definition of AGI, to mean can do all white collar work.

I don't understand how anyone can call these AGI. I've always had the view that AGI == Independent human-level intelligence.

At some point someone moved the goalposts for this to include LLMs that emphatically are not that. I think it was Altman when they came out with Astra?


Please do a youtube series where you ask random people on the street some questions and have them go against Opus 5.5. The model is definitely smarter than me in many ways- it would obliterate me in trivia, could write a poem in iambic pentameter before I could remember or look up what exactly the rules for it are, would probably dominate me at chess or football strategy, would do a better job at taxes, and for sure writes better code outside my small little slice of specialty. It definitely parses and diagnoses logs better than me unless I wrote all the loggging statements myself.

I have to ask, what humans do you know that have more general intelligence? This isn't a dream team where you can say "Magnus Carlson can beat it at chess, and Linus can write better C code", this is a comparison across all domains and levels of intelligence. Even its IQ is estimated at 141, which is seriously higher than the average human. The average human's reading level is atrocious. The average human cannot write a standard 5 paragraph essay about a random topic.

https://www.aiiq.org/labs/anthropic/


If I choose an arbitrary video game, board game or whatever can Opus play it?

My understanding is that models will often still forget games rules etc unless you design a harness specifically to assist them and prevent them going off the rails. I was going to use chess as an example but it sounds like they are good enough to do that now, albeit I'm not sure if they have a special harness for it.

It's not about how "smart" they are, or how good they are at recall. It's about whether I can teach a model to understand and execute an arbitrary, general task regardless of whether they have been trained on that task before.

Disregarding the above, the fact models still require a human prompter/decision-maker is defacto proof they aren't AGI in my view. If they were humans would be obsolete in decision-making.


Emphatically, yes. That's easily searchable. They do need a way to play it, just as a human needs a controller.

I don't get what you're saying here- AGI doesn't need intelligence? You just want autonomy?


I guess im doing a terrible job of explaining my view.

If these were AGI we wouldn't be talking about them helping engineers, engineer jobs would just not exist. The AI would be superior in every way that mattered. That's not the case yet, so IMO we don't have AGI.


i don't think it will ever be comparable

they aren't as intelligent as a human, but they can throw shit at the wall faster, and get something that sticks faster. they are superhuman in areas that require trial and error, like hacking.

everyone stopped talking about the Turing test once ChatGPT came out and broke right through it while still being very very dumb. AGI is just too blurry to define.


I think it will probably happen someday, but not anytime soon (and probably not in my lifetime)


Because we already achieved it, haven't you saw the post by Nvidia's CEO Jensen Huang?

Nvidia's Jensen Huang says "We've achieved AGI."


The system was introduced around 170 years ago and it was done very suddenly after a civil-religious war won by protestant liberals.


On the federal level yes but that only reduced the autonomy that the cantons had, it didn't introduce a fundamentally different system of government, most decisions were still taken on the local level.


Do you have an agent scanning the front page waiting to post the pelicans?


I should do but no, it's just a bad HN habit.


Can you ask your favorite „AI” to comment on what you’ve just said?


Thanks for the ragebait. Reminding myself that the flaw here is obvious, there’s no need to respond, arbitrary „tests” aren’t binding to anyone, protecting the future is perfectly defensible as a moral stance even at cost of present convenience.


Is it possible to change the language of Wikipedia? For many places, the local language Wikipedia has more articles.


Yes!! And with today's translation programs, the user does not even need to understand the local language. Better — for me — would even be a mix of languages. Give me the most and longest articles of all languages for the places around.


This unfortunately doesn’t help if it isn’t paired with withholding judgement in the face of insufficient evidence, but rationalists don’t do that. They just pick a model they like and continue, and the burden of scrutinizing that model is on others.


Making rational decisions means picking the most responsible option given imperfect information. It doesn't mean delaying decisions until you have perfect information because that point never comes.


Sufficient information, not perfect information.


What's sufficient information is also a huge part of the debate. See: should we start worrying about AI safety or not yet?

Opinions based on insufficient information help immensely in determining whether we have sufficient information, and also raise awareness of important topics that we need more information on. These blog posts serve a very important role in the information exchange ecosystem and the whole world would be worse off if all these people held off until they're 99% certain. Nobody would be talking about climate change, about economy, about quantum gravity, about ancient civilizations, about prehistoric animal species, etc. etc. and so on.


Sure I agree.


Using the easy to defend claim (acting without perfect information is necessary) to defend a much broader one (my judgement is rational and justified based on the information I have) is a classical motte and bailey fallacy.

People in the rationalist community don’t see it, because ironically they’re not rational enough. But they use the language and essay format to make it seem like they are.


Yeah I think it is some form of missplaced reductionism. No information versus perfect information then argue for perfect information.

I wrote in a sibling post that they like fascism because any dispute can be reduced to and solved by beating the counterpart to death with sticks.


If your pick of the option is based on emotion or aesthetics, the decision isn’t rational. Presenting is as such is misleading and dishonest.


Censorship to prevent thought crimes on HN? Can’t be!


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: