Stallman's reply to this all is really good, especially as this who discussion appears to be a contest of Who Is The Most Principled And Consistent and Stallman is the OG there and still very hard to beat. Some excerpts:
"The example that you're responding to is about where to draw the line
-- it was designed to be a borderline case."
"We don't reject contributions from companies such as Google and Amazon
which are intentionally subjugating users. These practices are not as
evil as outright enslavement, but they are plenty nasty nonetheless."
"Rejecting their useful contributions would not help us fight to stop
their unjust practices. We may as well accept the former, as long as
we don't mute our condemnation of the latter."
The benefit of the analogy is that I can trust someone to come and go but not trust them enough to not want to give them my house key for fear that they will copy it and give it to someone else.
Because I'm not just worried about the person I'm lending to but all of the other people in their mind. An LLM provider is not just the LLM model but the company hosting the model and the company that hosts that company and the company that routes that company and I need to trust that none of them are scraping my data for keys.
Well the post explain that it is a way to give them ssh access to your server without giving them your key. But if they have access to the server and can add any key there, it's quite useless...
If money is all you care about, and all your customers and shareholders care about, them yeah, I guess I can see your logic. Pretty big ifs, and pretty awful if true.
Even if she is not a spy, even if he's not married, having sexual relations with customers is a bad look for a CEO. Having sexual relations with employees is also a very bad look for a CEO.
The thing is, Jenson (and any other founder) has to be replaced at some point, for old age/death if not for any other reason. Companies and shareholders have to be prepared and ready for that eventuality. I know it's hurting everyone's stock portfolio right now and it hurts, but these things happen.
If someone was going full Chicken Little, I suppose "these things happen" could be reassuring, but that doesn't seem to be what Blank or the top commenters here are saying.
I tend to think indeed the effects will be bad in terms of Nvidia's ability to execute and in turn bad for the world. I don't understand exactly why Nvidia has stayed so unique a leader for so long when the prize is so juicy, but as far as I can tell it's because they are super able to get shit done; as far as I can tell, it isn't just because they could book more TSMC time than AMD or Broadcom or even because Intel hasn't quite mastered the fabrication.
Not saying firing him wasn't the right move after the level of unethical and illegal behavior and amount of indiscretion he's shown.
What will actually "hurt retirements" (delay them) is if this bubble bursts like the dotcom one did. Which seems strictly less likely without the most valuable company in the world relentlessly increasing leverage on its single investment thesis.
"Furthermore, what does society gain from my code being made open source if anybody else could just themselves go to Claude Code and ask for the same thing?"
Claude Code is not free (in any sense of the word). Not anyone can just go ask for the same code.
True, just writing some SystemVerilog that can be simulated does not guarantee working hardware. The OP does point out that he took it all the way to a netlist targeting a real hardware library. Place and route and actual fabrication, or building it for an FPGA and testing there are still needed to fully prove the design, but if the synthesis tools he used are reliable then there's not a lot of room for it to fail at this point. The clock speed is based on the netlist only, so it'll probably not be that fast after actual place and route, so it'll probably have to be clocked a little slower than 500 MHz, but it should work
Chips can and do degrade over time, but it's really more about how much chips improve with each new generation. You can't stay competitive by continuing to use old technology
"The example that you're responding to is about where to draw the line -- it was designed to be a borderline case."
"We don't reject contributions from companies such as Google and Amazon which are intentionally subjugating users. These practices are not as evil as outright enslavement, but they are plenty nasty nonetheless."
"Rejecting their useful contributions would not help us fight to stop their unjust practices. We may as well accept the former, as long as we don't mute our condemnation of the latter."
https://lists.gnu.org/archive/html/emacs-devel/2026-11/msg00...
reply