And I am sure they are acting in the interests of the paying entity. But the interests of the paying entity may not align with the interests of entities like XFCE.
Easy, three examples of where the US system has failed in the last two years:
1. Congressional authority for federal spending. The current administration has withheld or redirected spending that lawmakers had already approved.
2. Independence of the Department of Justice. A number of examples where the current administration has pressured DoJ representatives to pursue obviously ridiculous and un-pursuable charges against political 'enemies'.
3. Almost anything that DOGE did. Choose your example from the grab bag.
And the bonus round of breaching constitutional norms such as birthright citizenship and outright defiance of court orders.
The system hasn't failed because someone I dislike got elected, the system failed because the system is not constraining the current administration from their overt system-contravening actions.
I'm very sorry, and I'd rather it wasn't the case, but the system has failed.
1. The President has ultimate authority over the executive and how money is spent. And the President is not forced to spend money on “fraud, waste and abuse”. That’s in the Constitution and legal code.
2. The President has authority over placing judges, as per the Constitution. Every President puts judges they want in, that’s how it’s supposed to work.
3. See point #1
You seem to think the system failed because you don’t understand the powers the Executive has
The executive has been kept in check. How many of Trump EOs have been overturned?
If the Constitution is violated, then sue in court (as has been done). If the court agrees with the EO, then they don’t think the Constitution is violated.
It’s not unconstitutional because you don’t like the outcome
It’s a bit silly to expect ordinary citizens to have a near infinitely more mature attitude towards democracy than their elected representatives though? It’s not like anybody could have ever expected until relatively recently that one of the (objectively) most immature public figures in the country would somehow end up its president
Without taking sides, the US system was broken was when Congress started self-reinforcing the 2 party system institutionally ~1880s. Regardless, it's likely that the decades of lack of enforcement was due largely to perverse incentives, which still exist. Granted, no governmental system runs perfectly.
Failure of enforcement, is not a signal that US politics are broken, as much as a niche inconsistency. There's plenty of enforcement that is not occurring today, due to pure corruption. The US electorate has failed to hold politicians accountable for over 150 years. Again, this is largely because of a 2 party system that only selects for oligarch-directed interests. Most of it (like how immigration law is enforced) is performative. This administration has laid it bare.
After reviewing both posts, I can conclude that the post you're responding to did not contain hyperbole, and yours instead attempted to minimize reality for political reasons. That your entire post chose to focus on an only tangentially-related political subject, seems to reinforce this.
It's also worth considering, if masked secret police weren't kidnapping* and killing people in the streets, including citizens, then state governments wouldn't be trying to identify them as suspects in a crime and hold them accountable for their crimes (or "dox" them as you so hyperbolously put it).
Rodrigo Duterte is currently being held for trial in international court for doing with his security forces what donald is currently doing with his, both perpetrators claiming it's all in the name of law and order, fighting crime, etc. Food for thought.
* Yes, kidnapping: countless court rulings have found that ICE did not have any legal basis to arrest, detain, or attack the bystanders who were arrested, detained, and/or attacked. ICE's criminal court cases have mostly fallen apart or been dropped due to this.
And the citizens do not have enough spine to bring their politicians to justice. If they weren't causing so much death and destruction around the globe the sidestepping-of-responsibility-shuffle of the american people would be really funny to watch.
> And the citizens do not have enough spine to bring their politicians to justice.
This really betrays a lack of understanding of the structure of the government in the US. The Constitution, for better and worse, heavily insulates the government from tempestuous public opinion. The framers were readers of greek history who understood that democracy was a condition that a republic could devolve into. They built the system to give the voters the vibes that they had a say in the workings of their government while ensuring that in reality they had no such thing.
What are you trying to say? That the poor poor citizens' hands are tied? That they simply have to watch from the sidelines while their dear leader does its best zo sow ruin and carnage? This problem will never be solved while americans duck away from responsibility like they are about to win a limbo competition.
It's very easy to get on a tech forum and say "let's you and them fight," but violent revolution is generally pretty awful and typically ends up with worse conditions than they started with. I don't begrudge anyone for not wanting to go outside the regular electoral process.
What exactly are you imagining could be done? I'm all ears. Seriously, please, offer suggestions!
From my perspective the situation is that my fellow citizens who would be the most predisposed towards extrajudicial violence that might "bring their politicians to justice" are also the most steeped in propaganda and so end up getting their own itches scratched by that very state organized death and destruction.
Nationwide protests, general strike. Organizing groups that bring down whatever is left of US-justicias rotten arms on anyone trying to undermine democracy. Organizing groups that offer support and counceling for any victim of the regime. Boycotts etc. But most importantly: start 40 years ago and don't let the country become this way.
There are. Check out No Kings. My smallish "city" has a protest every week, and organizes a larger one every few months. I go when I can. Most people driving by are even supportive.
> general strike
There was talk of this a while back, and I analyzed it at the time - I don't see how it would help. In fact it seemed like it would make our position worse. The regime wants economic destruction, so its cronies can swoop in to pick up the pieces. That's basically the main thing they want, and it seems like a general strike would be handing them even more chaos and destruction on a platter.
> Organizing groups that bring down whatever is left of US-justicias rotten arms on anyone trying to undermine democracy
From what I see, this is indeed happening at the state-by-state level. But it's happening slowly, and the distributedness makes it hard to see. And much of it gets stymied due to a lot of rotten interference by the federal government - they tend to get things moved things to federal court, where many of the judges are regime apparatchiks. And if they aren't, then the rioter in chief goes to work threatening them with stochastic violence.
> Organizing groups that offer support and counceling for any victim of the regime
There is definitely some of this at the grassroots level, but on the other hand it's pretty hard to help someone who has been dragged away to a concentration camp far away.
> Boycotts etc
Boycott who? The problem is all the corpos are basically in on it. I've stopped buying stuff at Home Depot, and now buy that stuff at Lowe's instead. Big whoop! I expect to find out down the line that Lowe's's corpo management is also full of fascists.
> start 40 years ago and don't let the country become this way.
While the issues have been apparent all along, the problem is that the corpo propaganda has been successful at stopping any sort of reform that would have alloed us to address this ahead of time. Glaring meta issues like campaign finance and non-plurality voting are basically opposed by both professional parties, who had been offering us the shit sandwich vs turd torta dynamic for decades.
Yeah, but I have not seen anyone really do anything opposed to the war (or all the other shit), so its fair to say that the US made the choice to approve of the war.