HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | krapp's commentslogin

Google was born out of CIA and NSA research grants - US intelligence services saw the potential of the internet as a platform for mass surveillance, data collection and psychological warfare back in the early 1990s.

As with the CIA funding the modern art movement and various counterculture groups, and the LSD that drove hippie culture being a product of MKULTRA, the money would have appeared from somewhere.


Internet Nazis want the Nazi wizard to be fuckable, but not in a gay way because that's gross, so they did what fandoms have been doing since time immemorial - fanart. The only novel thing about it (pun intended) is that it's all AI generated, and thus all mediocre. I'm surprised it's still going. How much traction can you get out of "what if Malfoy, but a yandere?"

>It’s not like those who are not part of it will just lay down and die.

History suggests otherwise, but they'll need some "encouragement" first.


>All code should be open source, because apparently everyone learned how to program from publicly available open-source code.

I mean, open source is leftist, it's practically socialist. Everyone can, and many people did learn to program from publicly available open-source code. Just think of how many people learned programming by copying and editing javascript on the web, or BASIC programs from a book. I'm not aware of any CS courses that use exclusively proprietary code.

All code should be open source because open source code provides an opportunity for education, and all of the freedoms of OSS presuppose a level of education that allows exercising them. You can't edit, rewrite and redistribute code you don't understand, and using an LLM doesn't give you that freedom because it doesn't give you that understanding. The freedom being exercised in that case is by the company that runs the service, or arguably by the model itself.

The problem with considering AI generated code open source is that first, LLMs don't track or respect the license of the sources they are trained on (they can't) and open source as a legal argument depends on copyright and attribution. One issue with TFA's proposal is that LLM generated code could just as easily include non-free code as well, which would be forbidden under OSS licenses.

Second, and to me more importantly, the culture around LLMs is vehemently opposed to human intellectual curiosity, to any human work beyond prompt engineering, and certainly to using LLMs to educate people to write their own code. The "freedom" of open source isn't simply about using whatever code you want for whatever purpose without consequence, it's about respecting and maintaining the human provenance of intelligence and skill that went into that code, and extending that provenance into the future for other humans.

If the goal of LLM culture is to have software only ever be created by, edited by and distributed by machines then calling it open source doesn't make sense, and using OSS licenses for AI generated software is little more than a dark joke.


>I can't believe people actually think outlook being down would take down all departures across the US

Because American infrastructure is modern, well designed, maintained and funded? Because government is competent and rational? I could absolutely believe that would happen.


Today's paranoid times?

The current status quo for software architecture is giving a swarm of LLM agents root and full access to user data and letting them run amok, unsupervised, connected to a proprietary remote black box service either being monitored by Palantir or the CCP. What is this "paranoia" you speak of?


It would be wrong even if AI were good at prose, for the reasons outlined in TFA.

>A solo dev can create (from scratch) an FPS engine, assets, music, levels from scratch over a weekend now.

What does "from scratch" even mean when using an LLM trained on existing assets, music, art and code? Why even bother with that parenthetical? No one believes an LLM creates ex nihilo like God.

Show me the AI generated game that's superior to Balatro, or Hades, Or Undertale/Deltarune? Cult of the Lamb? Expedition 33? Factorio? Kerbal Space Program? Ultrakill?

It not being easy means it requires actual effort and skill, and effort and skill are where the quality comes from. No one is ever going to care about whatever vibe-coded slopfest you had Claude shit out over a weekend. Being able to make low quality low effort shit quickly is not better.


Free markets don't exist in the real world, and neither does capitalism according to your logic.

The governments of all rich and developed countries regulate their markets, alter prices and make subsidies. No modern economy is free from the government.


No. That argument doesn't work because there are degrees of free market and capitalism. For example, there are two indexes of economic freedom: one by the Heritage Foundation and the other by the Fraser Institute.

Both indexes show that standards of living and wages rise statistically with economic freedom, and fall with lack of economic freedom.

So you are proven wrong again by the facts.


It created a novel form of psychosis.

We already had that. Did everyone forget about QAnon?

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: