HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | kps's commentslogin

> Gecko is at 5%

Apple doesn't let you use it on iOS, so that cuts out a slice.


Gecko would get just 5% of those 15% at most, but Chrome would get up to 95%. So basically Safari is just protecting us from further Chrome monopoly.

Apple could choose to selectively allow Gecko as an alternative while rejecting Chrome's rendering engine.

For what it's worth, concerns of Google "beating" WebKit may be overstated: Only 19% of iOS users choose Google Chrome's app right now, while 79% choose Safari[0]

[0]: Per CloudFlare Radar, https://sqmagazine.co.uk/mobile-browser-usage-statistics/#:~...


They did. US 2780765 Solar energy converting apparatus (1954).

> constitutional mechanism that protects citizens' rights against the government.

The UK mechanism is elections.

The US mechanism is elections followed by waiting 50 years for the stacked Supreme Court to turn over.


Elections are a fiction. UK is governed by uniparty answering to the rich oligarchs, not the people.

Who voted for the uniparty?

The people who see there is nothing else to vote for.

Reform, Greens

> "If a user chooses to turn on Advanced Data Protection, their trusted devices retain sole access to the encryption keys"

The implication is that if a user does not “choose to turn on” Advanced Data Protection, then something else also has access to their encryption keys.

Users in the UK cannot “choose to turn on” Advanced Data Protection.


> if a user does not “choose to turn on” Advanced Data Protection, then something else also has access to their encryption keys

That's exactly the case. Without it, Apple Support, anyone with a valid warrant/subpoena, insider threats, successful phishers, etc. could access iCloud data.

Previously, Apple did not support E2EE for user data in iCloud, but later added it - that's what "Advanced Data Protection" is, after all.

But I believe when it was introduced, it was a news item (not from Apple, but from industry watchers) that it wasn't available in the UK, likely because of UK laws that harm privacy. It is the foremost surveillance state after China and North Korea, after all.


> It is the foremost surveillance state after China and North Korea, after all.

It's merely one of the five eyes, and it's by far not the biggest offender in the group. Obviously I wish the UK wasn't a surveillance state, but let's not pretend the US isn't an even worse one.


As I recall, own of the "benefits" to Five Eyes was that if state X wants to spy on its own citizen, but cannot due to its own laws, state X can ask around and see if any of the other Eyes have spied on that person already, and get their data that way (or perhaps, ask another Eye to begin spying on the subject and report back).

Ironically then, I have less to fear from a supposedly "hostile" state spying on me, than I do from my own state or my state's partners. Russia can spy on me but has no power or interest to do act on it against me. Particularly if what I'm doing is, say, against my own state's interest. An odd and uncomfortable situation.


Exactly this - and this has been going on for decades.

Here is an early example from almost 50 years ago:

https://api.parliament.uk/historic-hansard/commons/1994/mar/...


US citizens still have certain legal and constitutional protections, though?

Not so much in the UK. Also the British parliament can legally pass pretty much any they want. British courts can only stop laws from being implemented on procedural grounds they can't challenge the actual intent the parlament had.

In a certain way British political system is highly authoritarian since the government has no oversight if they have a majority.


As we speak, US citizens are routinely being abducted in streets by immigration enforcement for whom it suffice to pretend they think you are foreigners to deprive you from your constitutional protection, some of which having been deported in foreign countries.

Not so much in the UK.

Constitutional protection are only as protective as they are enforced, which is not a lot under the current regime unfortunately.


Any specific examples? I have never heard of this and I live in the US. That sounds like a psy-op from the far left or perhaps your own country's press

Yes, but the ECHR is incorporated into UK law which provides the equivalent of constitutional protections, as would ECHR/council of Europe members hip without that, although it would require an appeal to ECtHR if it was not directly incorporated.

Five eyes has grown to fourteen since the phrase was coined FWIW

This is not true. Most signals intelligence is automatically shared and accessible among the members of FVEY. Though there are close relationships between the US and various European countries, none of them have close to the amount of access of those in the "five eyes" agreement.

Let's pretend I don't know why the US is worse (I legit don't) and maybe you can explain it to me.

Snowden leaks

Why are five eyes worse than China or North Korea? Let’s not include others such as Saudi Arabia, Vietnam, or Russia.

The collectively spy on each others citizens (and foreign citizens) and share that data. (Remember, there's also Nine Eyes and Fourteen Eyes - collective intelligence spying agreements with other foreign nations).

While understandable to have this view due to implied wording in articles about the Snowden leaks, this is not accurate. Intelligence sharing agreements are not synonymous with on-demand access. These agreements dictate how voluntary, limited intelligence sharing occurs.

The "five eyes" nations share a large amount of signals intelligence. The other nations receive a small subset of the information shared between FVEY.


The point I was trying to emphasise is that this collaboration allows them to collect more data than individually possible. It also allows them evade each others individual data privacy laws and still spy on their citizens via a "friendly" third-party.

> Why are five eyes worse than China or North Korea?

I never said they are. I'm just responding to the claim that the UK are third to NK and China, when the US are up there fighting for the top spot with China.


I think the UK is third in the threat to freedom represented by their surveillance, not necessarily the scale of the surveillance itself (though it's large).

The practical, everyday impact of that surveillance on law abiding citizens is rather large, especially the chilling effect on free speech and expression of personal opinion.


>UK is third in the threat to freedom represented by their surveillance

USA have concentration camps and forced deportation of citizens because they're the wrong ethnicity. The whole thing supported by Flock, apparently.

What's the 'practical everyday impact' in the UK that you believe exceeds that?


> concentration camps and forced deportation of citizens

?? I am so confused. That is not something I have ever heard of, unless you're talking about behavior toward Japanese people during WW2.

Meanwhile Australia had actual concentration camps during COVID


https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_immigrant_detention_si...

> Meanwhile Australia had actual concentration camps during COVID

I am so confused. That's not something I've ever heard of happening.


Australia has exactly the same thing: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Australian_immigration...

An immigrant detention facility is not the same thing as a concentration camp. To compare the two is incoherent.

As for COVID camps in Australia, I should have used the term "internment camps". Here you go: https://unherd.com/newsroom/inside-australias-covid-internme...


> An immigrant detention facility is not the same thing as a concentration camp.

It is when due process is ignored and you start jailing US citizens in there.


> US citizens

You keep saying that in this thread.

Examples please?? I live in the US, have been here all my life, and have never been afraid of or even heard of an actual citizen who was afraid of that. If you have a US passport, no chance!


https://projects.propublica.org/american-citizens-detained-d...

> I live in the US, have been here all my life, and have never been afraid

How is that an argument? British people aren't afraid of what you're seeing in your alt-right twitter bubble either…


I read the first ~25 and they all are "so and so was detained". Is there any evidence of citizens being indefinitely detained, not arrested and released shortly after?

If not, then calling this "concentration camps" or "internment camps" is a complete mischaracterization.


Yes both Australia and USA have concentration camps, but I don't see what COVID has to do with it.

Link (ad-filled slop) appears to be saying quarantine == concentration camp, which is obvious nonsense.


The use if the “houghtcrime arrests“ and “lack of free speech” phrases in another comment below suggest that they may be unhappy that some white supremacist organizing violent riots could be prosecuted for that.

Not at all. A couple of examples of what I mean. These kinds of things have happened again and again in the last ~8 years:

- someone posted an online comment that was critical of Palestinian flags being flown in their English city. "Why not UK flags?" Arrested the next morning.

- someone spoke critically of Islamist rape gangs in the UK. Arrested.

- people quietly loitering outside in the vicinity of an abortion clinic, not on the actual property, not talking to anyone or holding any sign or anything, just standing there. Arrested for allegedly "praying in their heads"

If I didn't tell you where this was happening, you might surmise it was in Afghanistan or something


Bingo.

> white supremacist organizing violent riots

> Bingo.

I see zero connection between the incidents I mentioned and anything "white supremacist", let alone one who is "organizing violent riots".

Unless you think preferring your own country's flag or criticizing rape gangs is "white supremacist", or alleged silent prayer is violence -- in that case there's no point continuing here.


> I see zero connection between the incidents I mentioned and anything "white supremacist

Come on.

There's not a single sane person in the UK that refutes that the rapes circles aren't bad. The people saying “but grooming gangs are bad” are never talking about “grooming gangs”, they are always talking about the Pakistani immigrants, and foreigners as a whole. And yes these people are white supremacists and they do organize violent actions across the UK.


Citations please. For every single one - any one that you don't cite was made up.

these videos are from count dankulas second channel which covers the news.

flag hangers jailed or fined. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r2rUHDmjN8U

don't mention the grooming gangs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nfmOQ5zNBx8

grandmother arrested for peacefully protesting abortion https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wg_Wzh_Fa3I


Cause they can arrest me and Vietnam can't

UK arrests more people for tweets than Russia of all places.

As stated above, most of these are for harrassment and breaches of injunctions etc which are enforced most places.

Comparing UK to Russia on this is absurd, because most people in Russia do not freely criticise their govt online for fear of repercussions. When enforcement of censorship is extrajudicial it doesn’t appear in your stats but is no less important


Really, people in Russia criticize their government all the time in Telegram. Lots of cuss/racist/micro-aggression words used. UK, however, has become a model-Stasi state now. Lots of arrests due to chat messages under a bunch of different acts. 65,000 arrests specifically for "online communications offences" since 2017.

Right, but it you are a prominent person or stand for political office in any successful way you find your way to an open window somehow. This is a category error to confuse enforcement of speech restrictions that have bipartisan support (eg posting revenge porn, threats, harassment and hate speech in public spaces beyond societally accepted norms) with the political violence in Russia and China for that matter. If you want to campaign to change these laws then do so, but we are not freedom of speech absolutists here. I doubt your campaign would get much traction outside of eternally online MAGA funded right wing circles.

so what, 0.1% of the population has been affected by this?

Umm... 0.1% of the population being arrested just for "online communication offences" is a ridiculously high number.

> most of these are for harrassment and breaches of injunctions etc

This is a crazy level of cope. I don't know of anyone in the US ever getting arrested for an online post of any sort, except perhaps if it's a direct threat to murder a public official (and even then, almost never).

Online posts are used all the time to build cases against people who are otherwise criminals -- like selfies with a stolen car, etc, but people aren't ever arrested for merely expressing an opinion online.

(Yes, people in the US were debanked, fired, and otherwise persecuted by the political left for expressing some opinions between about 2017 and 2024, like being anti-abortion. But that wasn't the government, and it wasn't arrests.)


Just so we have some concrete examples of the things we’re talking about some examples below.

I don’t claim these are wholly representative — they are a sample picked by Claude because they were controversial (my request). However it doesn’t seem unreasonable for the police to investigate them given the relevant laws in the UK.

Also worth considering that In the UK, arrest is often just how police get someone into an interview room. It's an investigative step, rather than a sign they have enough to charge. Most people are released without charge or "under investigation", and suspects normally aren't named unless charged. So it’s not like a public booking with mugshots. So the ~12,000 arrests a year for online messages compare with only about 1,100 people actually sentenced.

Some example:

Luke Yarwood, 2025. His posts on X included "I think it's time for Britain to gang together, hit the streets and start the slaughter", and others called for asylum hotels to be burnt down. They were viewed only 33 times. Prosecuted for stirring up racial hatred, Public Order Act 1986. Sentence: 18 months.

Joseph Haythorne, 2025. Posted "burn any hotels with those scruffy bastards in it" just as rioters attacked the Rotherham hotel in August 2024. Prosecuted for stirring up racial hatred, Public Order Act 1986. Sentence: 15 months.

Thomas Webster, 2024–25. About a year of posts on X and Substack. One said: "I would prepare for murder and prison time, I am serious. These invaders must face our repressed Anglo-Saxon savagery." Prosecuted for 10 counts of stirring up racial hatred and 2 of stirring up hatred on grounds of religion or sexual orientation. Sentence: 2 years.

Bernadette Spofforth, 2024. Reposted a false name for the Southport attacker commenting that if it were true there would be "hell to pay". She deleted it and apologised once she realised it was wrong. Arrested on suspicion of publishing written material to stir up racial hatred and false communications, and held for about 36 hours. Outcome: no further action.

Svenska, July 2026 (animal-rights activist). Posted a video claiming that MBR Acres, which breeds beagles for research, sent "hundreds of kilograms of animal remains" to incinerators. Offered a community resolution that included taking an "online thinking skills" course and an online "impact exercise," or face arrest.

Allison Pearson (Telegraph columnist), November 2023. Reposted a photo of police officers posing with two men holding a flag, captioned: "How dare they @metpoliceuk… Look at this lot smiling with the Jew haters." The men were actually supporters of a Pakistani political party, and the protest had nothing to do with Palestine. She deleted the post after a Community Note corrected it, by which time it had over 400,000 views. Investigated for stirring up racial hatred, Public Order Act 1986, after two officers visited her home a year later on a Sunday. Outcome: no further action, on CPS advice.

Lucy Connolly (2024): on the day of the Southport attacks she posted: "Mass deportation now, set fire to all the f*** hotels full of the b**** for all I care… if that makes me racist so be it." She got 31 months for incitement to racial hatred and served about 12-and-a-half months. Her appeal failed.

Tyler Kay: reposted the same wording, "Set fire to all the [expletive] hotels full of the bastards". He got 38 months.

Joseph Kelly (2021) – "grossly offensive", s127 (Scotland) The day after Captain Sir Tom Moore died, he posted: "the only good Brit soldier is a deed one, burn auld fella, buuuuurn" The tweet was only live for 20 minutes. He was convicted and given 150 hours of community service.

Southport riots, 2024 – Jordan Parlour: posted that "every man and his dog should smash [the] f--- out of Britannia hotel", where 210 asylum seekers were living. In another post he wrote that immigrants "rape our kids and get priority", and he had 15,000 Facebook friends. He got 20 months.

Dimitrie Stoica (2024) – false communication, Online Safety Act s179. On a TikTok livestream to 700 followers he claimed far-right rioters in Derby were chasing him: "I am running bro because they are running after me. They're coming. Everyone get back" He wasn't in any danger and later called it a "joke". He got 3 months.

Ricky Jones (Labour councillor), 2024. At a counter-protest after Southport he called far-right activists "disgusting Nazi fascists. We need to cut all their throats and get rid of them all" and drew his finger across his throat. It was a rally speech that went viral online, not a post. Prosecuted for encouraging violent disorder. Sentence: none, because jurors acquitted Ricky Jones after about 30 minutes.

Azhar Ahmed, 2012. After six British soldiers were killed in Afghanistan he posted on Facebook that "all soldiers should die and go to hell". Prosecuted for a "grossly offensive" message under Communications Act s127. Sentence: £300 fine and 240 hours of community service.

Zakir Hussain, 2024. Ran an X account posting statements in support of Hamas and Hizballah, and also wrote numerous anti-Semitic comments, including praise for the actions of Adolf Hitler. Prosecuted for supporting a proscribed organisation under Terrorism Act s12(1A). Sentence: 5 years 8 months.

Ozain Yousef, 2023–24. In one post he aligned himself as a "brother" of the proscribed organisation, and he reposted an image of a Hamas sniper. Prosecuted for posting images that suggest support for a banned group, under Terrorism Act s13.


[flagged]

Do you have an example to cite of someone being arrested for saying "I prefer UK flags to Palestinian flags in my home country" or is this made up

There are vast tracts of the US in which you can be reasonably assured of no physical surveillance whatsoever, unless you attract nation state level attention, simply due to population density being too low to support surveillance state infrastructure.

ever heard of flock?

Yes. There is not a single one in my whole county.

Your phone and any Internet connection and connected devices provide vast amounts of information.

I'm not sure what you mean by "physical surveillance" - other humans actually watching you?


Or spy satellites

OP out there thinking that using a Starlink connection shields them from data collection.

Siberia is even more remote, you could live in a yurt herding Yacks there completely out of control of the Soviet regime. Does that somehow mean the USSR wasn't a surveillance state to you ?

No, but it does mean that yak herder was subject to less surveillance than someone in a dense urban area covered in security cameras, who h is the subject we are discussing.

This has nothing to do about the topic, which is about whether or not the US are a surveillance state. The existence of remote places where this surveillance is looser doesn't invalidate the original claim.

I mean for thoughtcrime arrests and lack of free speech, in addition to domestic surveillance. And have you seen how many cameras there are in London?

Australia is arguably in 4th place, but no five-eyes country is ahead of the UK on thoughtcrime arrests.


There aren't that many hate speech arrests in the UK. The statistics which purport to show that include stalking, harassment, violent threats, posts which are also illegal (and routinely enforced) in the US and elsewhere. In fact I wouldn't say there's significantly more restriction of speech overall. And polling suggests people across the political spectrum want limits on e.g. racial hatred and wouldn't prefer US-style absolutism. (This has become less 'bipartisan' as Reform voters do prefer protecting speech.)

The right to protest though has been restricted more recently. Probably less policing escalation/violence than say France, but more situations where they can legally ban protests and arrest or fine people.


> This has become less 'bipartisan' as Reform voters do prefer protecting speech

They don't. They want to promote racial hate specifically, but they do not want to protect speech in general.


The UK participates in FVEY. They share their intercepted traffic with America, and America shares their domestic backdoor access with the UK.

Efforts like MUSCULAR allegedly dwarf PRISM collection and is only possible with American cooperation: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MUSCULAR


> it was a news item (not from Apple, but from industry watchers) that it wasn't available in the UK

It was available in the UK and it is still available for anyone who had it switched on before this fight with gov.uk began. Once the fight started, they stopped offering it to new users, but they never actually took it away from those who had it already.


I mean how could they.

They could just issue a software update that would make that data inaccessible. Or they could scan iCloud and delete everything they can't decrypt. Or they could delete all data from users who have ADP=true in their account.

They can push an update which uploads your device key to the cloud in the UK

Realistically, the way it would work is that they give notice to UK users that they must disable ADP by such and such date or else their data will be deleted from Apple servers and become local-only.

This is like Telegram, where the average user thinks it's encrypted because they mention encryption in their marketing, but it only really applies to secret chats which have to be explicitly enabled and come with their own limitations.

Except secret chats still work in the UK, for now (I think)


So exactly like local disk encryption on Windows devices?

By default, Microsoft has a copy of your laptop's encryption key and will hand it over in response to a warrant.

> Microsoft Shared BitLocker Keys With FBI, Raising Privacy Fears

https://www.techrepublic.com/article/news-microsoft-bitlocke...


>By default, Microsoft has a copy of your laptop's encryption key

Calling that option "the default" is bit misleading when all the other options are presented with equal weight:

https://static0.howtogeekimages.com/wordpress/wp-content/upl...


Current versions of Windows 11 (including Home versions) encrypt your C: volume by default during setup. By default the encryption key is stored in cleartext in volume metadata until you sign in with a Microsoft account, when the key is automatically backed up to your Microsoft account, and then stored inside TPM secured by "boot attestation" and the cleartext variant is removed. (This means that the drive is automatically decrypted when Windows starts without you entering any PIN/Password, but protects the drive from being accessible when booting another OS from USB stick or taking the drive out and putting it into another computer).

Microsoft explicitly calls this feature "Device Encryption", not "BitLocker", but it uses BitLocker under the hood. This happens automatically, by default. Then, if you're on Windows 11 Pro(/Enterprise/Education/... anything but Home), you have two options to secure it more:

The first and more obvious one is to add PIN/Password, but that's only adding PIN/Password protection to the existing decryption key that's already backed up to Microsoft account if you have already logged into one.

The second is to decrypt the drive and then re-encrypt it, which prompts the screen you've shown a screenshot from, where you can choose to not back the key up to your Microsoft account.


>Current versions of Windows 11 (including Home versions) encrypt your C: volume by default during setup. By default the encryption key is stored in cleartext in volume metadata until you sign in with a Microsoft account, when the key is automatically backed up to your Microsoft account

That seems... fine? You didn't enable encryption yourself, so you don't really have any expectation your data is protected. Indeed, if you didn't sign into a microsoft, your keys would be even less safe.

>The first and more obvious one is to add PIN/Password, but that's only adding PIN/Password protection to the existing decryption key that's already backed up to Microsoft account if you have already logged into one.

No, the bitlocker design avoids this by not backing up the key used for encrypting your data. Instead it encrypts that key with another key, backs up that key, and stores the ciphertext on your hard drive. This allows you to revoke such keys without reencrypting your hard drive. The same mechanism is used for passwords as well as numeric recovery keys.


okay... seems that I've misunderstood how the recovery keys work... nevertheless, the point still stands: By default, if you set up Windows like a regular user (not an IT professional) would, Microsoft has something that can be used to decrypt your drive.

If you log in to your Microsoft Account during Windows 11 setup, it will automatically create a numeric BitLocker recovery key and back it up to your Microsoft Account. This recovery key will not be revoked if you switch unlock method from TPM only to TPM+PIN. There is no GUI option to revoke this recovery key. You can only revoke it via command line.

The "Back up your recovery key" screen on the screenshot you provided only backs up the same recovery key or adds another, as evidenced by Microsoft's help article[0] claiming "You can make as many backups as you want. It's not a bad idea to have more than one, just to be safe!"

[0]: https://support.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/security/encrypt...


You only see this dialogue if you don't have a microsoft account set up. Having a microsoft account is the default, you have to go out of your way to not have one. I'm sure there's a way to prevent your keys from being uploaded even with an account, but it is very much the default.

Source? I don't have a microsoft account and the "save to your account" option isn't available , suggesting that the person taking the screenshot does have an account added.

The source is me trying to install windows 11 without signing up for a Microsoft account then eventually giving up because the oobe setup is too much of a fuckaround.

>trying to install windows 11 without signing up for a Microsoft account then eventually giving up

Installing windows without an account being difficult is orthogonal to bitlocker saving your keys to microsoft "by default"


I don't have an ms account set up and the option is shown for me. If I press it it complains that I don't have an account of course. That MS enables encryption by default if you sign in to an MS account, and saves the key to said account, is reflective of my experience and verified with a brief search.

> By default, Microsoft has a copy of your laptop's encryption key and will hand it over in response to a warrant.

Note that this is meanwhile proven with both of the Bitlocker exploits that Nightmare Eclipse released this year.


If you're comparing your security model to Windows, then it's already beyond hope of salvation.

> Users in the UK cannot “choose to turn on” Advanced Data Protection.

And this is Apple's fault?


> the United Kingdom ... has fewer African Americans per capita

Quite a surprise.


They maybe pulled above their weight in other descendants of the Atlantic slave trade - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hpypYcMe16I

I think GP is poking fun at the fact that the UK would indeed have fewer African Americans per capita than America.

Absolutely, that was intended when I phrased it that way originally, also to highlight the fact that the subject is two different terminologies from two different countries with two different (albeit intertwined to a degree) histories.

Call it it an example of Australian absurd understatement.


I've seen people refer to African people living in Africa who grew up in Africa as African Americans.

Is that better or worse than referring to his Muskiness the same?

BTW, FYI- https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50529748 (I'm still pressed for time, but it's a partial answer)

and, FWiW, the UK had a small influx of African Americans post WWII who were there for the war and stayed (apparently) for the general acceptance ("better than Mississippi") .. which led to the Rolling Stones and other acceptably white Brits introducing Black American music to the white Americans of the USofA (or so the story goes).


values of ß will give rise to dom

Yeah, he's a spammer.

> end of the Old Internet when the Eternal September began

Usenet over UUCP predates its connection to the Internet and predates Arpanet's adoption of TCP/IP.

Damn kids get off my lawn.


All true.

Colin Huang will do the job cheaper than Jeff Bezos.

Note that Google doesn't get special treatment from Project Zero. There are (as of this comment) four Google issues disclosed after missing the deadline.

https://project-zero.issues.chromium.org/issues?q=status:ope...


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: