I agree. I looked at DSL, TinyCore, Puppy, and then decided to try a “regular modern distribution”. I have an 11-year-old, early 2015 MacBook Air with an i5, 4gb of ram, and a weak battery, and have turned it into a nicely usable “couch terminal” with Fedora Sway Atomic. It was a good excuse to jump into a tiling wm, and I chose Fedora Atomic out of curiosity and a desire to have a stable base OS even if my battery died in the middle of an update.
But I could have gone with XFCE or Cinnamon or any of the other lighter-weight desktop environments and had a great experience, because it runs great. I have the cpu power pinned low while on battery, but on AC it’s quite fast. I could replace the battery for around $30, but it’s a different kind of project to try to make it work as well as possible for as long as possible.
Maybe Fedora Atomic (or another atomic) would be a good solution for you. I have an old MacBook Air that needs out-of-tree and closed-source WiFi and webcam drivers, and with Fedora Atomic it won’t update the system if it can’t get them compiled in first. Then, if it did and there was still some issue, I could roll the whole system back to the previous working state all at once.
But I could have gone with XFCE or Cinnamon or any of the other lighter-weight desktop environments and had a great experience, because it runs great. I have the cpu power pinned low while on battery, but on AC it’s quite fast. I could replace the battery for around $30, but it’s a different kind of project to try to make it work as well as possible for as long as possible.