HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | kerblang's commentslogin

> “What should I study in college?”

> Computer Science

Ha ha sometimes the AI is just plain wrong


> how hard is it to right 10 pages yourself?

Wellllll


I don't think the author was describing it as an interesting philosophical problem; rather as the difference between the real world and philosophy class. Indeed the real-world problem is not one of moral calculus. It's reacting in a decisive & timely manner with partial information. Most of us are not well-prepared for emergencies, and philosophy class is kinda laughable as an idea of adequate preparation.

The article describes a grant system where recipients used the money to train up & start small business operations. The US also has small business loans in its own right.

For the record, psychology research has demonstrated that humans do not think in language. This was a popular myth started by someone in the 1930's or so, I think, leading to authoritarian ideas about thought control via language control. People still won't give up on it...

I have found that databases are the exception where documentation is critical, in that knowledge of what we do to the data (described in program logic) is completely different from knowledge of what the data means. Reverse-engineering that meaning often takes me longer than anything else.

Beyond that, however, English is a horribly ambiguous, contradictory and complicated programming language. It's a literal anarchy. Had it not been for primitive 1950's hardware, I suspect people would have refused to invent programming languages and insisted on AI-processed English anyhow. For now I guess we'll work as computational attorneys...


> For the record, psychology research has demonstrated that humans do not think in language. This was a popular myth started by someone in the 1930's or so, I think, leading to authoritarian ideas about thought control via language control

Are you describing strong linguistic relativity here? I was under the impression the weak form still held under study (e.g. names of colors being the popular example).

I haven't encountered the notion that "humans do not think in language." Is there a paper or keyword I can look up?


Here's one example:

https://www.google.com/goto?url=CAESbAHrOzAVyZ7APar4z2OEdFu0...

"Taken together, these two complementary lines of evidence provide a clear answer to the classic question: many aspects of thought engage distinct brain regions from, and do not depend on, language."


As I understand it, the chirality problem is one of the big ones in abiogenesis - the beginning of life. How does some initial series of inorganic "accidents" lead to life? The necessary chemistry has to give the right chirality.

But maybe someone better informed can explain... I've only heard James Tour ranting about it


What, no mention of our old friend, ASCII-armored Base64? For shame! Everything can be text with Base64, including things that have absolutely no business being text! Best of all, in light of popular widespread abuse of every available resource, Base64 is comparatively efficient! Bring on the petabytes! Yay and I'm not being completely sarcastic


And then you add RFC2045 headers so you know what the encoding is...


Text headers, mind you! Ah, text text text

Don't ask me what my point is


Clearly none


I think it's been pretty well demonstrated by neuroscientists that the brain is not a binary computer. That doesn't mean that those scientists erred on behalf of supernatural religion or anything like that.


As long as you believe a brain is just a physical system - then it can be simulated to any degree of accuracy with plain ol' binary computers.


Nobody is actually trying to do that, because it's too hard, they don't know enough about how the brain works, and/or they can't compete on efficiency; pick whichever reasons you like, or add more, but don't pretend that AI researchers have figured out how to simulate a brain.


You're arguing about whether it's possible or not. You're saying it's not possible.

It is possible.


Not really. He said no one who knows anything about the brain thinks it's a binary system.

AFAIK, that is true.

Whether it's possible to replicate what happens in the brain on a binary system or not is a separate thing entirely. It's also not what LLMs are attempting to do.


You're reading him too narrowly. He's answering the question of whether the brain can be modeled (math or magic), and arguing against it. Or maybe he's arguing for a middle ground. Hard to say exactly, he's not very clear.

Except the brain can be modeled with arbitrary precision - so he's got an uphill battle in either case.

TLDR: Yes, he literally said "binary computer" but from the context it's clear he means more than that.


No need to straw man, they aren't pretending anything. It's just a fact about computational theory.

Just because I can't count every grain of sand on Earth, doesn't mean sand grains are uncountable. Those are two distinct facts.

The practicality of a binary brain is distinct from the possibility of it.


Why would someone believe that the brain is just a physical system?

Genuinely I don't understand this.


Because the metaphysical is definitionally outside the realm of science and rationality, and every bit of scientific and technological progress humankind has made has come from discarding superstition and approaching the world as a physical system.

If the brain isn't just a physical system, then we may as well give up. There's certainly no point discussing it, as any assertions will be untestable and one persons elaborate and well thought out theory will be just as valid and predictive as the next persons "consciousness is created by invisible purple unicorns" theory.

So if we are going to discuss it, we should start from the assumption that there is no magic or witchcraft or religion involved.


> Why would someone believe that the brain is just a physical system?

Because we've never in the history of science discovered a non-physical (supernatural) system. So it would be quite a surprise.


Music isn't binary either, and yet here we are with totally digitized lossless music ecosystem.


What does the ability to encode or decode data in binary have to do with the brain being or not being a binary computer?


It shows that it doesn't matter. There is nothing a brain can compute that a base 2 system cannot.

People can drill really really hard on the fact that the brain doesn't function with purely 2 states, but it gets you nowhere. It's the same illusion as "pure analog music sources are "better" than digital sources". They're not, and it's a totally immaterial topic when discussing how the music sounds (audiophiles, come at me). Either system can produce the same sound, indiscernibly, even to the fanciest test equipment.

The brain also cannot escape that it's digital clone mirrors it's inputs and outputs to an arbitrary point of perfection.


Mathematical modelling in binary, is not the same thing as the thing being modelled.


you can represent floating point numbers in binary


> Application programs were really considered software until at least the 1970s

Did you mean "were not"?


Yes - fixed that. Thanks.


Has the engineering enhancement been beneficial in your work?


Immensely. Especially early in my career I felt very different to the comp sci grads around me. I was trained to think at a systems level, about consequences, about people and processes. In the first few months it was obvious to everyone I was a leader and quickly had a team.

Somehow I felt like I was thinking about the big Picture and the ramifications for the future, those around me were just looking at a tiny problem.

It also helped immensely for talking with the Engineers at various companies.

My education was like an electrical engineer is to an electrician.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: