HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | justsid's commentslogin

With the big exception being radio waves. Once electronics are invented and especially anything like radio, the planet should light up. There is nothing particularly human about it, except for how we encode the data and what data we find worthwhile to encode (maybe), but it would still stand out over the background noise.

Assuming tech == electronics is a very human assumption to make. Biology is a way more "advanced" kind of nanotech and it has significantly different characteristics to electronic based tech. We simply don't know and even taking that into account there are blind spots in our blind spots.

How far would the radio emissions of Earth be detectable? Could even Martians watch our soap operas?

even on earth those high-power radio transmitters were relatively short-lived phenomenon; modern 5G cells are dramatically quieter that the kilowatt AM radio (and TV) towers of the past.

Okay but even with a 85% margin the true cost for 30 minutes of usage would be $2.25. At that cost $34 should last only 7.5 hours. I would imagine the average user uses more than that?

I think you would guess wrong.

The median user is using AI as a search engine, meme creator, and/or chatbot… at best.

The additional cost created by the subset of programmers using subscriptions rather than tokens/api can easily be categorized as a marketing expense.


At best? Do you have any data you're basing that claim on, or are you just speculating based off of you projecting? AI maximalists would have you believe that people are using these things as therapists and having conversations with it that are more intimate than any lovers'. AI minimalists would have you believe that no one is using these thing except at gunpoint, and even then. Unless you have some reason for us to believe you that isn't just "trust me bro", your portrayl of the median user is as suspect as any other.

> At best?

Remember that I referred to median user here.

> Do you have any data you're basing that claim on, or are you just speculating based off of you projecting?

Anecdata? I guess it depends on what you count as “data”.

I am currently training a lot of people directly or indirectly (train the trainer type of stuff) on how to use AI professionally. I always start with “what do you currently use AI for?”. The answers I listed above are largely the categories that people have told me and the folks I train, with the exceptions being a handful of non-technical folks who have leaned into AI and have used agents and/or created apps of some sort.

To add some categories that I didn’t initially mention, some folks also use AI for drafting/writing documents and for creating meeting transcripts.

> AI maximalists would have you believe that people are using these things as therapists and having conversations with it that are more intimate than any lovers'.

Chatbot… this is something I hear, but I’m guessing I don’t hear all of the examples since it’s personal rather than professional. But some folks certainly say something like “I treat AI like a non-judgmental friend that I can ask personal questions to”.

> AI minimalists would have you believe that no one is using these thing except at gunpoint, and even then.

In my experience, this is almost exclusively the domain of old/older people who are happy to let tech pass them by and young people who are virtue signaling to their peers (or at least trying to).

> Unless you have some reason for us to believe you that isn't just "trust me bro", your portrayl of the median user is as suspect as any other.

It seems like you’re new to HN. I understand your skepticism. There is a relatively high density of actual professionals here. Trust me on that, bro.

My data set numbers are in the 100s, and it is not a statistically representative cross-section of the US or world market. That said, I’m guessing that I have a fairly good range of data points for the US market.


Thank you for thoughtful reply! I don't hold any Anthropic stock so this isn't material for me. I don't want to mislead you, this isn't my first account here, my favorite HN moment is when cpercival was called out on the Putnam and he fkn delivered. My old identity was too easily tied back to my real world persona, which felt dangerous in this day and age. Plus I wrote a book and needed a pen name.

> some folks certainly say something like “I treat AI like a non-judgmental friend that I can ask personal questions to”.

is why I believe that these things are stickier than I think you believe. I'm obviously biased by my own personal usage of AI and where I live and my own bubble which isn't the same as your bubble. Thank you for the context of your dataset. It's larger and more professional than mine. Mine is not professional at all and definitely a bubble of whom I happen to run into at a non-random selection of events.

We'll have to see what the stock market decides.


> cpercival was called out on the Putnam and he fkn delivered

Classic


I'm surprised by your skepticism, but anyway, it is your burden to bring data to the table that counters the overwhelming majority understanding here.

> or are you just speculating based off of you projecting?

This is also a strange thing to say. Why would you assume speculation or jump to projection as the basis for it? Nothing in the comment that you are replying to hints at projection.


So that’s the takeaway? “There is no money for this, so it just is what it is”? That’s insanity. So what now? Hope they don’t get hacked again, because by that logic there is still no money for upgrades and fixes, especially after losing a ton of money on spoiled inventory? But I guess that’s okay, only the “laptop class” actually cares. The supermarket lives in the real world with real challenges, none of that pesky security needed. I feel like I’m taking crazy pills here.


I would say the takeaway is that it cannot be expected that the majority of businesses hire an IT security expert (let alone multiple, + technicians) whose job it is to keep on top of CVEs and apply updates to a variety of embedded devices. IMO it must be a legal requirement, which is now coming (e.g. NIS2), but it will take time.


Shouldn't the seller of the embedded devices or the maker of the product with those devices inside take care of that?


Yeah, no, it is crazy. I'm reading these comments too like, what?

People advocating to do nothing? Saying it's not practical to do anything.

Smells botty to me.


You are less likely to double dip as a PC player if it’s available in a timely manner. However right now there is a lot of PC players that will buy the console version just because it’s available and there is no announcement for the PC version. And then buy again in a year or so when the PC version comes out with the ability to crank the graphics settings up.


Now I understand, thank you, I know little about the gaming industry.


As a graphics programmer, the most charitable interpretation I have here is that in 2D all the animations are baked into texture atlases. A 3D model would re-use its textures during animation, in 2D it’s a new one.

But I don’t see Factorio as being a VRAM pig, even with all their animations, which you could certainly improve on from the simplistic “every animation frame is a whole new texture” model.


Now if that isn’t a great Zachlike game mechanic. Playing as the patch pipeline builder.


But that’s also a data point and could/will be flagged as suspicious behaviour. Opting out of the norm makes you identifiable just as much.


Not everything has to happen in your or my lifetime. Not everything will happen in our lifetimes. If time is so important, Haiku was never going to work for you anyways on account of it being niche, which adds friction, which adds time. Velocity isn’t going to fix this either


As I mentioned, projects that take a long time make for interesting artistic statements. But if the goal isn't performance art but is utility, then alacrity matters.

Many other niche projects have enjoyed enough velocity to have meaningful utility, in my lifetime. Linux was still niche when I started using it in '94.


I think that's a false dichotomy.

Some people enjoy building things. It's not performance art, it's a hobby. Can Haiku not be a hobby for people who enjoy hacking away at BeOS? (You might think I'm splitting hairs here, but performance art is precisely the wrong analogy to use, since performance art is for the benefit of others. Performance art is inherently public and assessable in terms of how it reaches others, unlike hobbies. Performance art is env=PROD.)

Was the purpose of Haiku ever utility? What do you define as utility? If I spend a day building a shelf, does that have more or less utility than buying a shelf from IKEA? What if I like making shelves? What if I like making OSes? Does the shelf (/OS) that I build have less utility than the one from IKEA (/MS)?

In economics, utility is a measure of individual satisfaction. The person who likes tinkering with Haiku is deriving cold hard economic utility from Haiku right now. What should it matter to this person whether you find Haiku web scale and production ready? John Q Public is never going to run Haiku, no matter how much polish you throw at it. Why rush to some goal line that doesn't exist in the first place?


If its purpose is to be the output of a hobby then it is art; if it is shared with the world, then it is performance art.

Art has utility, of course; but we're discussing primary goals.


Yeah the title reads quite weird, but I would think “turned up” instead of “turned into”. The domain didn’t cause geopolitical war after all.


I definitely assumed it was a Bloomberg terminal for doom scrollers.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: