HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | jstanley's commentslogin

Some of us refuse to use proprietary software, so the universe of viable CAD software consists only of open source software.

From that perspective, the commercial offerings are the ones that are light-years behind, due to not even trying to compete.

I've been using FreeCAD for 9 years, it is amazing software and has changed my life. Don't fear FreeCAD.

I've also tried out Solidcraft recently, it is impressive software but very slow and I keep running into bugs, so FreeCAD still wins for now.

> FreeCAD, last I checked, didn't even have PMI.

I can count on no hands the number of times I have wanted this. It's not part of my workflow at all. It's hardly a dealbreaker.


Good for you… All he is saying is there are many features open source CAD is missing that non-hobbyists take seriously.

I’m a mechanical engineer and live in CAD. I can promise you, PMI is very much something that is taken seriously in industry.


If you so much as read the output of a sufficient intelligence then it can accomplish anything it can persuade you to do.

You don't know how effective persuasion can get because you've only ever encountered ordinary human levels of persuasion.


But the apparent orbital period doesn't vary by 22 minutes, the cumulative error in the orbital period reaches as much as 22 minutes.

100 laps that are all a second too long makes a cumulative error of 100 seconds but there was no lap that was 100 seconds too long.

(I actually have no idea about Io, but that's the distinction I think Coeur is trying to make).


I think you're right, the orbit is much faster than 6 months so the 22 minutes would be spread across many orbits. Excellent point, thank you.

A Leatherman is a convenient folding pen knife but is unfortunately illegal due to the locking blade.

A Leatherman would be considered a multi-tool rather than a pen knife. But being a tool, it's the kind of thing one presumably has a 'good reason' to carry for their activities, right? If you're working a trade, doing DIY, or out camping, no-one's going to question you having it on you. I wouldn't carry one around at the shops.

You could easily put it in your pocket during the course of your trade or DIY or camping and end up visiting a shop without remembering the Leatherman is in your pocket, at which point you're committing an offence.

I would say it's reasonable to just carry one around with you in general, in case you need it. It's not that far off from your average pocket knife, which comes in handy in tons of situations.

I would too but we don't get to decide.

It's different from your average pocket knife because it has a locking blade.


I'm completely blown away by the discussion about non-locking blades in everyday knives. I categorically reject any knife that has a non-locking blade because it can snap closed on your fingers. It's a safety issue. And here we are with people acting like all normal knives have non-locking blades.

I say this is a guy that has a collection of several dozen knives I've collected over 40 years. Practically every single one of them has a locking blade.


> It's different from your average pocket knife because it has a locking blade.

I just meant as in it's utility and why you'd carry it around. It's just handy in general to have a tool that can do a lot of small, common things to help.


Sounds like a good reason - you were at your trade or DIY or camping

Unfortunately precedent disagrees.

You didn't have a use for it at the shop, and forgetting it was there is not a "good reason" to have it.


If you catch the eye of a bobby, and if that bobby decides to make something of it, and if a prosecutor decides to press charges, and if a judge decides you had no good cause ...

There's leeway and human judgement all the way through the chain.


Yup, only as soon as the police officer decides they don't like you, they can arrest you. And then they can hold you for 24 hours. And then you've likely missed a day of work (very impactful for some people), or been unable to feed your pet, or pick your kid up from school, and any number of very impactful things.

Every law needs to be balanced against it's possible impact if someone decides to abuse it. And giving officers of the law the ability to do things "because they probably won't" pretty much ALWAYS turns into "oh look, they did".


This is why every system of law and order, of civil service, of political policy debate, etc. need strong mechanisms of oversight and self correction.

This has happened to people, example: https://www.lccsa.org.uk/george-bayliss-v-director-of-public...

He used a knife to cut vinyl floor tiles at work or something, put in his pocket, went to Tesco the next day having forgotten it was still in his pocket, and got prosecuted and convicted.

Unclear what sentence he received, but the process alone is enough of a nuisance already.


Yes, I'm unsurprised it's happened. (I'm in Australia, closer to UK law than US law).

I'd rank that as a failure of judgement rather than a failure of policing; edge cases and grey areas are unavoidable when applying law to humans.

The strength or weakness of the UK system wrt knife carrying law depends almost entirely on what has happened in the 23 years since 2003- has that case caused any revision, etc.


Those were examples of good reasons, not an exhaustive list.

For example if you buy a cooking knife and are carrying it home from the shop, I would think that's a perfectly good reason.


Why?

One simple reason could be to have an online forum with almost no bots.

If every account has to be tied to a real person, the cost of obtaining bots accounts will rise exponentially


> If every account has to be tied to a real person, the cost of obtaining bots accounts will rise exponentially

Nope. Dedicated states love building fakes and passing these identity challenges. That doesn't stop the bots. Also, scammers perform these identity validations with vulenerable populations. (They even sign up their victims for KYCed bitcoin accounts)


Well, the examples you provide just show how much the cost is higher to get an account. And over time, id.me could perform additional security measures which increase the cost even further.

To be clear, I don't like that future, but I suspect that some variation of it will be in demand given the amount of bots exponentially rising.


It doesn't stop the original problem, it just makes the scams worse.

Foreign states mint fake documents all the time, scammers force their victims in to lengthy KYC processes and it gives them more leverage to do even more damage. The companies who invest in this crap end up getting a "get out of jail card for" well we implemented something how can we be responsible.


Why what?

Why do you want a guaranteed US-centric social network?

They said US citizen, not US centric. Plenty of sites are already US centric.

> Plenty of sites are already US centric

But not always authentically so. Pretty much every election cycle someone turns up a network of foreign bots engaging in political debate on the various social networks (and not just in the US either - UK and Australia both have had the same issue)


And now you just answered yourself why OP [probably] wants it. For me at least it seemed obvious.

There are less-charitable explanations: the OP could want to explicitly exclude undocumented immigrants (and anyone else without an up-to-date government ID), from their social networks.

Typically open source projects will not thank you for your contribution and will instead be annoyed with you for bothering them.

Yes fix bugs and add features etc. for your own personal use, but don't get your hopes up about contributing back, it's usually a waste of time.


Isn't the fact that spreading work across many congressional districts is necessary rather evidence of government incompetence?

That's not a mitigating factor!

"Before you walk away thinking the government is incompetent, please remember that the government makes bad decisions on purpose" ??


It’s evidence that they are solving different problems. Does the fact that Musk spends hundreds of millions on election cycles mean he’s incompetent, or he’s trying to mitigate a political risk you and I don’t have to deal with?

Sure every system has its unique problems but when you cut to the results, one is clearly way more efficient.

One system is way better at doing the thing that it was designed for.

The other system is way better at doing the thing that it was designed for.

And since both of the design goals are important, having both systems is a good thing.


It really depends to what degree you're willing to ignore the externalities.

As said elsewhere, that simplistic take falls apart when you realize there would not be a SpaceX if there wasn’t a NASA.

I'm not super convinced that the commercial aerospace industry really needed NASA once super high value satellite services came about in the 90s.

The ideal of a good government industry program, is to create a domestic industry, and A: maintain it at a minimum level for whatever goal is in focus (defence, technology familiarity, investment certainty). And B to help it grow to be independent of the government, so the profits and funding can go elsewhere.

To me, most of what NASA did after Skylab are a bit questionable. With most of the high profile stuff being of limited value compare to the RF and solid state electronics projects.


I mean, Musk himself stated SpaceX needed NASA. New entrants especially benefit from a self insured customer because private industry won’t accept that level of risk.

I agree with a lot of your point, but would probably caveat a lot of the JPL work.


NASA did not invest in SpaceX. What they did was buy launches from SpaceX. Musk risked everything he had on SpaceX.

You are shoehorning in an entirely different argument. The question is not about whether NASA invested, or loaned, or contracted or whatever other funding mechanism. It is whether their existence is predicated on the existence of the other, and whether they are both dealing with the same problems.

When people fail to acknowledge that, it becomes a vehicle for a digression and creates tired discussions that follow the same well-worn paths.


The point is, SpaceX was not given tax money. It delivered on contract.

lol, what do you think NASA money is if not tax dollars?

You have an oddly dogmatic take when it comes to nearly all things Musk. Whether it’s tax dollars is a tangent from the point being discussed about whether they would exist without early govt contracts


The money was not "given" to Musk, nor was it a "subsidy". It was a contract of money in exchange for deliverables.

Nah, SpaceX did get subsidy in COTS for developing F9/Dragon. Not to mention various small amounts DoD gave them just for being US launch vehicle developer/provider.

That amount is very small compared to private funding SpaceX got but esp.the COTS contract literally saved SpaceX from bankruptcy (see Liftoff or various statements from Musk/Shotwell). So "no subsidy" is wrong argument, I would use "very little subsidy, esp.compared to their competitors".


That’s why I used the word “contract” above and elsewhere in this thread. It’s still tax payer funds, though. You seem hellbent on having a different discussion which I find tiresome.

I mean, considering nothing like it had been done before (or since) kinda proves the inefficient approach worked. I'm not defending gov inefficiency but often it still leads to good results somehow (and also major disasters, sigh)

What does worked mean in this context? A barely reusable craft that risked human lives to launch mundane satellites and was so unreliable DOD stopped using and was so expensive NASA couldn’t afford to keep it running?

With the technology available and the requirements of the missions it was intended to fulfill, that is what was built. You are being stubborn and annoying.

The technology was available for something much better than the STS. What wasn’t available was the political will to build it better.

“Solving different problems” means intentionally creating inefficiencies in an engineering project so that voters can get a little cut of the government funding. It’s a roundabout way of buying votes.

It shows that the government’s incentives are not aligned with the project’s goals and why privatization works better for this type of project.


Said elsewhere, but if NASA didn’t spread their resources around, there likely would not be a NASA. As Musk said, if there was no NASA, there would not be SpaceX. People act like they SpaceX exists in a govt vacuum. They do not.

I don’t take umbrage with the govt/private model when done right. I take issue when people act like one deserves all the credit while ignoring the larger system that is required to bring that success about.


One could almost say that "You exist in the context of all in which you live and what came before you."

And the fact that SpaceX would not exist without NASA would still be true.

He only has to do that to prevent the government from doing to his projects what they routinely do to their own.

He’s paying extortion money to keep them from making SpaceX as awful as NASA, or preventing him from doing anything at all.


So not incompetent if its mitigating political risk then. Which is why NASA was designed the way it was.

Solving different problems is a good way to put it, but to even be in that position implies they’re trying to meet false objectives and artificial constraints that are beyond the scope of the original endeavor even if there’s some intersection remaining. These extra constraints I imagine have a high likelihood of compromising the original objective by forcing tradeoffs that don’t move the needle and carry costs with ill spent efforts.

Can see your point, that spreading the constructions sites across different states was necessary in order to get it built, but in terms of pure engineering, this is probably a negative.

Guess the point is that generally speaking, large scale engineering is typically not done at efficient and creative-levels when directed by the government. Governments have too many stakeholders that have needs that have little do with with engineering that need to be satisfied

...And of course, there are exceptions -guessing the Gemini and Apollo programs would be a good examples.

... oh, and am not trying to call you out, just trying to think through this for myself as well.


What makes you think Gemini and Apollo are counterexamples? They were successful, but were also heavily dependent on contractors and occurred when NASA funding was many multiples of today’s budget when measured by percentage of GDP.

Well, they seemed like highly effective government programs as they were able to get people to the moon under a very tight deadline (and also knew they were extremely expensive programs. Kind of crazy the amounts relatively to gdp they were spending).

And, if they weren't, backs up that the government is not typically a good overseer when it comes engineering programs

(although, still seems like when there is a very strong need, governments can be very good partners).


There is nothing inherently wrong with 'government' providing the source of funding for these programs, and there's nothing wrong with spreading parts of the program across different regions. In fact, in a way it can be cheaper. With the Apollo testing facilities in Mississippi, the Apollo program being built out of Huntsville, and the other 7 locations across the US--you can adequately tap higher end talent while moving some components to cheaper locations to work on.

Agree actually. The government basically funded Spacex for Falcon 9 through the Commercial Orbital Transportation Services program, and probably some of Starship's development too. Yeah, the funding wasn't the question, it's whether the government is a good overseer of programs like this.

Regarding spreading the parts of the development/manufacturing across different regions, am sure there are good benefits to doing this, and cost efficiency is definitely one of them (Boeing's manufacturing is a great example, as well as most auto companies). So yeah, you're right there. But when the government does it, it often is for political reasons, so you wonder if they really do gain cost efficiencies? Hmm...

Personally, my take is the earlier in the development process you are of a product (or vehicle), the better it is to keep everything tight knit (yeah, am a believer in the major concepts of agile development - small, integrated teams working close together, able to iterate fast). And feels like this is also true for design teams in general, no matter what the size of the company. It pays to keep them together as much as possible.

But the more mature a product gets, like a car company that's been building cars for decades, it seems like spreading out manufacturing could be a cost savings.


The Fed spent about $500 million partially funding F9, not counting service contracts. Starship is completely funded by SpaceX.

Hmm, this is an interesting question. Because the service contracts are what keep spacex going, before starlink generated so much money.

According to this link, in total, Spacex has received $38b overall in government funding: https://www.congress.gov/119/meeting/house/117956/documents/...

Still, it was amazing how much Spacex was able to do in the early days with relatively very little money.


You are poking at the point that I was trying to get at elsewhere that seems to get lost.

Yes, SpaceX got considerable early govt funding. But it also is much less than their current revenue. People seem to disregard that the timeline matters.

The govt contracts were important, not just for the early dollar amount, but because they provided leverage; they were collateral that could be borrowed against. Early on, when SpaceX was a risky unproven entity, private industry would not take a risk on them, either for payload or for loans. The govt was the only group that should bear that risk. Once they had a proven track record and reduced risk through redesigns, they could leverage that for private work, Starlink, etc.

It's the way the hybrid public/private model works best. It's just weird when people get so dogmatic they refuse to acknowledge that SpaceX was dependent on the govt. It seems to shake their worldview of the great man theory or something. It's not bad that SpaceX needed the govt and the govt needed SpaceX but it does go against a lot of people's internal narratives.


Two Shuttle crews would be alive if they hadn’t spread the the manufacture of the SRBs. So yes, paying more for worse work is something wrong.

That's not the alternative being discussed though, it's a fiction in your head.

The alternatives are: a) work spread out or b) no work because the political risk shut down the project.

It's also not clear why you think spread out work caused the SRB issue. It's also notable that Columbia was not because of the SRBs.


Because the SRBs only had to built in segments so they could be shipped to Florida to be used. If they had been built in Florida, they could have been built in one piece.

That’s a good point. But the Columbia disaster was about foam shedding not the SRBs.

No, he's trying to bully his way into forcing the government to do what he wants, and he can because he is extremely wealthy. It just happens that in this case, it yields something useful. That is a poor model, the rich should not arbitrarily get their own way.

> Isn't the fact that spreading work across many congressional districts is necessary rather evidence of government incompetence?

Government issue? Or, let's be more honest, the issue here is with the people expecting government programs to become job programs?


I wouldn't call it incompetence. It's more a sign of government misalignment.

I see misalignment as a form of incompetence.

Incorrect. Governments can - and should - have goals beyond simple engineering problems. Traditionally government funds corporate and academic R&D which is then productised and commercialised by the private sector.

This is literally how the computing industry was built.

Ignoring those goals for short-term corporate profit is politically incompetent, and has terrible consequences - as most of us are about to find out.


What you describe isn't an issue of misalignment. Re-read the discussion thread. It's perfectly consistent for the government to prioritise long term prosperity. The issue is when government chooses not to prioritise aggregate social benefit because it is beholden to, for example, local and special interests. Maybe a particular local race needs to be won to secure a House or Senate majority, and in strategising and negotiating that win, they drop important policies which would have maximised long term prosperity. This is baked into how democracy works. It is messy, inconsistent, and frequently misaligned with long term prosperity. This is why government could not do what SpaceX has done.

publicly funded means funded by the people. its not really unreasonable that people demand the economic benefits of investing their money to be spread around a bit.

its not ideal from logistics POV, but it is not what I would take as the prime example of incompetence. its just the government way of doing thinngs.


If the economic benefit summarized as employment, then the goal is wrong. And indeed space conquest oftem just makes our child brains dream, instead of being something useful per itself. So we tout employment and side-effects as a prime benefit of space. Why not create a broken-window factory, it will create more jobs.

A broken-window factory like Microsoft?

Can we stop pretending the private sector isn't a labyrinth of idiocy, opportunism, petty infighting, and inefficiency?

The private sector is very, very bad at thinking strategically in useful terms. Profit is a fool's proxy for progress.

Corporate values have been the single biggest brake on human development since the 1970s. We would be far further ahead on every metric with the kind of smarter strategic management that corporate culture makes unimaginable.


Comparing SpaceX against any other government rocket program says otherwise. Why was Tesla first to promote BEV before government? Why isn’t government promoting rooftop solar? Why is highway maintenance so terrible in the US?

The problem is smarter strategic management is never the goal of government. Profit is a good proxy for economic efficiency and leads to better results (at least, before short term stock price thinking started to dominate).


It's more like the cost of the political system we run. Yes, it's not the most streamlined, but it's stable. Quite a number of people yearn for the efficiency of a system under one will of an enlightened monarch. We have a bunch of examples, from Lycurgus and Cyrus back in the day to Mr Putin today; there is a cost to such a system, too.

It’s always entertaining to hear engineers ridicule inefficient government programs while simultaneously setting up a load balancer, backups, or a high-availability db cluster. Completely unable to generalize the lesson that redundancy and overhead aren’t necessarily bad, and that efficiency is in tension with other desirable attributes in every system, political, biological, computational, whatever.

There is a difference between inefficiency and reliability. The ridicule is for things like the SLS that costs too much to launch more than once or twice a year, yet has unknown reliability and no redundancy.

I think you are conflating engineering reliability and political reliability. Speeding work out is meant to address the latter.

It's evidence Congress is/was little more than a bunch of clowns.

The government engineers and scientists that worked on the space shuttle were not.

Also it's trivial to be an armchair expert decades removed from actual events.


There’s a common theme in HN discussions where people mistake understanding a system for evangelizing it. Really nothing could be further from the truth.

this is well and truly common all over the internet -- you explain how some system, something fairly non-technical even, say, a common social failing, some institutional bias or what-have-you, works, and you have a bunch of people go on the offensive as though you've just endorsed the thing. so you have to hedge practically anything with a token virtue-signal, even in communities where it's pretty strongly implied that you're on the same page about considering the thing bad.

if you'll indulge a tangent, i can only chalk up the increase in this phenomenon over the time i've been online to the consolidation of online discussion to a handful of sites that have become ever more adept and efficient at creating filter bubbles. and it's always the sites where that hasn't taken root, where everyone's seeing the same thing, that then catch a reputation for being hellholes full of terrible people, because naturally, the majority of people engage with those sites not directly, but through screenshots shared on the major socials, and those major socials are incentivised to push you content that you engage with. then, as we all know, angry people click more. so of course as a user of one of those major socials, a majority of those screenshots the site pushes you end up being those that depict speech your own filter bubble cohort finds abhorrent. hn is actually subject to this dynamic a little bit.


The "government" doesn't make those decisions, it's the political class that chooses to do those choices of putting money in each district.

The “political class” is the government.

What's good about cookie consent dialogs?

A lot of pages don't work when an adblocker removes the Dialog.

I mean, rather than just out-and-out removing them, I would think that the proper thing to do to get those dialogs out of the way would be to have a separate extension that detects them and automatically interacts with them to dismiss them (in whatever way you'd prefer.)

FWIW (and I know I didn't mention this) the cable I was originally using for the 6040 CNC router is a "double shielded" one which I bought in the past specifically for EMI reasons, but it wasn't immune to the pilot arc ignition.

I haven't tested it to see how good the shielding is but I haven't had any EMI-related disconnections since switching to that cable. (Other than the plasma cutter ones).


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: