HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | jshen's commentslogin

I think this will depend on the commoditization, or lack thereof, of the AI models. If they are more or less interchangeable, Apple will have made the right bet.


Everything anyone does comes with resource constraints. Does everything warrant a custom designed web page?


If you cannot make the effort to communicate to me about your project, I don't know why I should bother reading it.

Frameworks in the past didn't always have custom designed web pages, but at least one could understand if the author spent time actually building documentation.

If Claude is writing all the documentation, that has freed up "resource constraints" that you can use to actually make sure your site is legible. If you can't pass that bar, I don't know why anyone should seriously consider your framework - just like if someone had created a framework without documentation in the pre-ai days.


If you can't take the time to write me a hand written note, I don't know why I should bother reading it.

You are picking an arbitrary thing that isn't the substance of the work, the styling of a page, and insisting it matters. Seems odd.


Not everyone needs you to read it. There's 8.4 billion people on the planet. Nothing is lost if you don't care.


well not everything, but one would expect some effort to have a good web from ... a web framework?


Web stacks? Probably.


Rugs aren't live running systems, so not analogous.


This is very similar to George Lakoff's work. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/George_Lakoff

A good place to start for anyone that is interested is his book Metaphor's We Live By.


Hoftstader's video is pressumably based on his own book "Fluid Concepts and Creative Analogies".


Very interesting book. You don't really think about how often metaphors are employed in language, and their influence on how we think. The book makes some rather strong claims regarding science and philosophy being misled by metaphorical thinking, but still a good read.

And it's relevant today given how people like to anthropomorphize LLMs, and compare biology to digital machines we make. Of course there are similarities. But the point about metaphorical thinking is we are mislead by treating metaphors as literally true.

Anyway if the stronger claims in the book are at all true, it might impact how an alien species thinks differently than us (given a lot of our metaphors are biologically based). And could present significant difficulties for decoding an alien signal.


One of the best examples of a clear issue with metaphorical thinking came from discussions about the plaque installed on Pioneer 10. Some clever people thought up the idea of using a pulsar map to define where the sun/earth were. Some other clever people noted that pointing to the location with a line that ended in an arrow was very, very deeply rooted in the history of human hunting techniques and could be very hard to understand if you have never seen or even conceived of an arrow(head).


Add a slight trailing decay and I think the basic arrow motif could be intuitive for trajectory for any observer who experienced aerodynamics?

Whether it is the evolved shape of a flying creature or an abstract depiction of a meteorite (or even a comet!), there is a kind of intuition about the sharp end and the flaring of air or fluid around it, with some sort of trailing tail from whence it came...

One can imagine many observers who could find our space probes would also have some of these experiences?

Of course, all of this assumes some kind of visual perception and cognition to even recognize the plaque as having markings made with an intent to communicate some abstract ideas...


> According to Lakoff, an individual's experience and attitude towards sociopolitical issues are influenced by being framed in linguistic constructions. In Metaphor and War: The Metaphor System Used to Justify War in the Persian Gulf (1991), he argued that the American involvement in the Persian Gulf War was obscured or "spun" by the metaphors which were used by the first Bush administration to justify it.[3] Between 2003 and 2008, Lakoff was involved with a progressive think tank, the now defunct Rockridge Institute.

I will never not find it amusing how a simple thing like money is obscured or "spun" by a thin veil of pseudointellectual bullshit.


Sure, but that's not generational wealth.


We must be operating on different definitions. Generational wealth means you have enough money to meaningfully improve the lives of your kids and give them a leg-up on life. A million dollars is enough to buy a house for each of your 2.5 kids.

If getting a million dollars wouldn't affect how much money you can leave your kids, you already have generational wealth.


> If getting a million dollars wouldn't affect how much money you can leave your kids, you already have generational wealth.

Well said.

Where I live, one million dollars would allow me to pay off my house, open healthily sized investment accounts for my kids, pad my investment account, setup a trust and, overall, set my family up for a comfortable life in the future. I don't see how that isn't generational wealth.


Generational wealth is where you can also do all of the above for your kids and potentially their grandkids as well.

Basically the bar is higher than "something you can pass down". It is enough that the next generation does not need to worry about making money either.


Generational wealth generally is used to mean something like you and at least your children can live very comfortably off of investment income for the rest of your lives, I.e. none of you have to work for a living. That’s why sibling’s def of 1.5-5m per child is much closer to the commonly understood meaning.

We can debate “live comfortably” if you want, but no 4.5 people are doing that from the investment proceeds of 1m.

What you are describing is kind of more like social mobility.


The commonly accepted definition of generational wealth ranges from around 1.5 to 5 million per child.


I can only find sources that define it the way I said, but I'm sure that folks who think a million dollars isn't enough to buy a house disagree.


> If getting a million dollars wouldn't affect how much money you can leave your kids, you already have generational wealth.

Generational wealth is definitely not "affect[ing] how much money you can leave your kids." That's an equivocation - if you're leaving your kids a dollar, another dollar will "affect how much money you can leave your kids."

edit: you need a million dollars to securely retire at all, and that's if your parents, kids, or you don't get sick. If they do, a million is not only not "generational wealth" but it may not even last you three years.


You're right of course, I should have said "meaningfully affect." Obviously every penny counts.


Generational wealth is generally used to describe not just a comfortable personal retirement but your children and their children and so on never needing to work if they are remotely responsible with the money.


First, don't park it in actual cash or you'll lose value to inflation which is currently running high. At a minimum put it in treasuries.

Second, trying to time the market is almost always a suboptimal strategy. The question is when will you likely need the money? If you won't need it for 10 years or more, keep it in index funds. Otherwise, treasuries.


Personally I tend to assume anyone talking about VTI knows about the risk-free rate.


Yeah, I would also assume that anyone talking about VTI wouldn't try to time the market, but that's what he was talking about so :shrug:


If the primary user concern is "all data is public", then the utility of ATProto is extremely narrow and will likely lose to something with a different philosophy.


That is about to change very, very soon though: https://dholms.leaflet.pub


Or you just use a different protocol for private stuff. Square peg, square hole. Round peg, round hole.


Is kimi making a profit? How subsidized is it by the Chinese government?


Is that any worse than being subsidized by VC? They're playing the same game as the western labs, just with slightly different players.


Chinese government vs American VCs doesn't equate to "slight different players."


True. The Chinese Communist Party's motto is "Serve the People". [0]

They might not always live up to that, but at least the aspiration is there.

No such pretense from American VCs.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Serve_the_People


This is the most naive comment I've read in a long time.


American VCs and American Government mingle at the deepest levels. Yes, slightly different is correct.


This isn't true unless you're limiting your reference point to Trump's second term.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: