HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | jryle70's commentslogin

I disagree with you, and I detest anything that tries to appeal to emotion such as saying "maliciously steal", for the same reasons that I don't like the MAGA crowd or populist politicians.

If you are serious, state your case.


Let's come up with a better solution. What would you do to monitor supermarket's fridges?


Honestly, that's overkill for this sort of application.

It'd be enough to have a bog standard segregated network with a basic security elevation mechanism, together with some reasonable amount of logging and monitoring. The sort of configuration that tech companies use to protect their database server.

Data diodes make sense in situations where you need security clearance to even be in the same room as someone who's accessing the high side - they're expensive and painful to use, and nothing a supermarket does is ever likely to justify it.


Connecting them to a network is essential; but they don't need to be publicly accessible, and it would be easy to just not do that part.

Store central console with all the information and alarms, not iot. Daily uploads to the command center, read only. More clerks, like before.

There is no short sighted thinking. The reality is: AI is replacing regular search, whether Google like it or not.

As for content providers, many will be killed. The challenge is how to keep the genuine ones. Nobody knows the answer yet. Maybe Google will have incentives to entice them.


And that is the short sighted thinking.

Starting the killing without a plan to keep the genuine ones.

What of the don’t come up with a solution fast enough.

That’s like jumping out of a plane first and then thinking about the parachute.

And the reasoning if I don’t do it then somebody else will was called stupid long ago by Joseph Weizenbaum


> And that is the short sighted thinking.

ChatGPT offered Web search at the end of 2024. How long do you think Google should wait? 3 years? 5 years? Then we'd see HN posts saying Google is doom from the start, citing "The innovator's dilemma".

Google offered AdWords 2 years, AdSense (with which websites could earn shared ad revenue) 5 years after founded, and waited until 2008 to acquire DoubleClick, the biggest competitor at the time. One could argue that they didn't act soon enough. They still won the ad war in the end.


The plane is crashing in a giant fireball, so you can jump without a parachute or stay on the flaming wreck.

You can say "the plane is fine and will land fine" but we're all in the cabin and there's a lot of smoke we all see (AI that were all using).


The plane is crashing so put the thrusters to full speed and make a steep nosedive so you can crash it before others do it.

Google is not a passengers in this metaphor, they are the pilot.

There are lots of people who know only google for search


I mean in this metaphor the plane is Search and the pilot is Google. The pilot ejects which hastens the crash since there's no one controlling the plane anymore but the pilot also lives. They could very realistically go down with the ship and keep the plane in the air longer but they're still being shot at by enemy fighters.

Without Google it would be much slower. They didn’t left the plane, they accelerated it.

How many people know AI companies beside Anthropic and OpenAI. How many use them for search, how many still used Google? Google brought AI summaries to search even for people who didn’t look for AI results.

They are a fire accelerant.

First they destroyed search with their ad business, so you hardly found the good sources and know they kill the sources as such so that there is nothing to find.


What do you mean besides Anthropic and OpenAI? The existential threat that Google is responding to is ChatGPT full stop. After years of companies trying to take on Google at search but never getting further than just copying them ChatGPT emerged as a free service, a credible threat, and was legible to consumers as a direct search alternative that for many things returned better results with less effort.

I think Google made the only move they could which is cannibalize Search but crucially keep people on google.com. The fear that if people leave they might not come back this time I don't think is that far fetched.


Me: Tell me about a data structure I may not know? Suppose I am a software engineer with 10 years experience

Claude: Here’s one that a lot of experienced engineers haven’t run into: the XOR filter, along with its newer variant, the binary fuse filter.

What it does. It answers the same question a Bloom filter does: “is this key possibly in the set, or definitely not?” The difference is that it uses noticeably less memory and answers queries faster. The trade-off is that it’s static. You build it once from a known set of keys, and you can’t add keys afterward.

...

Does that sound like something a developer with 10 years experience may not know?


I'm not a professional developer, only a scripter. I wouldn't know.

Suppose you're a college student with barely any concept of CS, let alone the capability to know what kinds of questions to kick-start your own education.

Nothing is new in my argument. AI is particularly useful for professionals that already know how to learn, and know how to sniff out BS and second guess the tool.


Can you provide an example of subsidy for SpaceX? Who else got taxpayer money for space flights according to you?

> Who else got taxpayer money for space flights according to you?

All of them. That's OK! SpaceX was a phenomenal investment by the government. But it was undoubtedly one.


Here's an example that answers both your questions:

https://www.gao.gov/assets/a586368.html

It includes $396 million for SpaceX and $288 million for Orbital Sciences to "develop and demonstrate commercial cargo transport capabilities." I.e., it was not a procurement contract for some deliverable for the government, it was a development subsidy.

Here's another one, which provided about $545 million to SpaceX: https://www.nasa.gov/humans-in-space/commercial-space/commer...

Those two total almost $1 billion for SpaceX. A lot of the other money to SpaceX has been in the form of procurement, such as cargo services to the ISS. There have also been mixed contracts which included both subsidies and procurement, such as the Commercial Crew Program. NASA describes it like this:

> "CCP has invested in multiple American companies that are designing and developing transportation capabilities to and from low-Earth orbit and the International Space Station. By supporting the development of human spaceflight capabilities, NASA is laying the foundation for future commercial transportation capabilities."

--https://www.nasa.gov/humans-in-space/commercial-space/commer...

SpaceX has received at least $2.6 billion from this program, but some of that is procurement.


First of all GP mentioned "SpaceX has received more than $22B in subsidies from taxpayer money". I wanted to know what they would include in that number. Do you think that's in the right ball pack?

Secondly, CCP includes two different kinds of agreements -- Space Act and Contracts. Only Space Act can more or less be considered subsidies. From your link:

When NASA decided to support the development of new U.S. human spaceflight capabilities to low-Earth orbit, it relied on its commercial partners to propose specifics, ranging from the design and capabilities to private investment ratio, milestone achievements, success criteria and timelines. Once an agreement was accepted, CCP and its expert teams worked closely with each company to provide technical support and determine when milestones were met.

SpaceX got more than $500 million from that. The $2.6 billion number was not an investment but contract for the crew flights.

Nobody denies that SpaceX owned a lot of its success to NASA. I don't know what OP wanted to spin here. ULA got even more money than SpaceX from the government (NASA and DOD). Look where they are.


You asked for an example, I gave you some.

> Secondly, CCP includes two different kinds of agreements -- Space Act and Contracts. Only Space Act can more or less be considered subsidies.

Yes, I addressed this. Perhaps reread my comment.


> shuttle costs per-launch were on falcon 9 level

Huh, in what world is that true? SpaceX quoted $75 million to external customers per launch according to their IPO.

Shuttle launch costed $1.0 billion in 1992, or $2.41 billion today, inflation adjusted. That is without R&D cost.

Thus, average cost per flight including development costs and flights through FY 1993 is $1.6 billion. Average cost per flight not including development costs or flights, up to FY 1992, is close to $1.0 billion. - [0]

How much was the maintenance, refurbishing cost for each launch? the cost of a new external tank for each launch was $52 million in 1992, or $120 million today - [1].

How much do you think they could get it down if they could launch more?

Do you think NASA could fly 150 times annually even if there was demand, when it only flew 135 times in the shuttle's 30 year lifetime?

[0] - https://sciencepolicy.colorado.edu/admin/publication_files/1...

[1] - https://www.gao.gov/assets/nsiad-93-115.pdf


> Do you think NASA could fly 150 times annually even if there was demand, when it only flew 135 times in the shuttle's 30 year lifetime?

why not? if there was demand, especially internally from the government as planned - it would've been accommodated

> Huh, in what world is that true?

in the world where demand for Shuttle was 150 annually and not 135 in 30 years, duh?

> How much do you think they could get it down if they could launch more?

my main point is the per-year costs, like all the crew training complexes

LARGE part of the billon$ number you quote comes from that and would get spread a lot. 50 million$ is a nice floor to exemplify where it would've ended up


If the external tank alone costs $120 million per launch, how would more launches get it cheaper to run than F9 at $75 million retail?

> shuttle costs per-launch were on falcon 9 level

Mind to share how did you get that?

> why not? if there was demand, especially internally from the government as planned - it would've been accommodated

Which demand? For how many launches?

> in the world where demand for Shuttle was 150 annually and not 135 in 30 years, duh?

So the demand is in your imagination?

> my main point is the per-year costs, like all the crew training complexes

You need to be specific. How much did training complexes cost?

Shuttle maintenance and refurbish were very labor intensive. It took months to get one ready for the next flight. For fewer than 10 flights a year (generously speaking). How do you propose they could scale up to support 150 launches annually? Again, be specific. You can't be hand wavy when you call other people lying.


That doesn't say much without knowing how the fuel was used. They may have pushed it to the max to give Starship more room, therefore didn't save enough fuel for the booster's return. They may have set higher safety margin. They may have used more conservative thrust settings.

There are so many knobs to turn. Everything is conjecture because it's only the beginning. One thing for sure, Superheavy/Starship in the future -- a year, two years, five years from now, will be very different that what was used for this flight.


Who says anything about heatshield tile being revolutionary? The whole package is, however -- Raptor engine, reusability, refueling, mass production, and so on. Together, they allow low cost, fast turnaround time launch service.

As for a different approach, try Stoke's active cooling solution:

https://www.stokespace.com/news/building-rockets-to-fly-and-...


Stoke is amazing. SpaceX briefly considered active cooling, but with methane the physics isn't so favorable.

That's called cherry picking to suit your opinion. I imagine train executives of Nord Express weren't very worried about air travel in 1910s

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nord_Express


How often is it wrong? Is it comparable to human tutors?

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: