HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | jopsen's commentslogin

Play a bit with it, I started feeling like verification is just a slightly more aggressive fuzzer.

There will also be compiler bugs, etc.

The point is fewer bugs.


At least in some cases it is easier to verify bytecode/assembly than source code.

The impact of framework/tech-stack mostly reveals itself, once the project is big. For small/medium projects you might not notice.

> a culture that strongly believes internally written software sucks. This is Invented Here syndrome

It's the inverted invented here syndrome ;)

But it is oh, so true. Entirely, unsurprisingly -- an internal software stack has captive audience, and never compete with anyone else.

They can good, but exception to the rule.


> It's the inverted invented here syndrome ;)

No, I think they had it right. Your "inverted invented here syndrome" would be the original NIH syndrome, in which people prefer building their own version of everything.


Exactly, just because you can vibe code an HTML sanitizer or an operation system, doesn't mean that you should..

And its the same reason you'd rather have a SaaS vendor, than asking an agent why the cloud bill keeps climbing and then have to debate the impact of delete such and such VMs or databases that nobody knows what do :)

You also don't ask your agent to start from assembly.

Things you can get upfront as libraries or services are things you and your agent don't have to worry about.

I'm not even sure there is anything new here, just that we have a capability jump with LLMs, you'll probably prefer spending it on building features, not replacing vendors (unless they are crazy expensive).


Yes, nobody wants to have to spot a memory bug in C code.

Indeed nobody wants to review LLM generated slop.

So being able to know that this code cannot contain memory bugs, race conditions, etc is extremely valuable.

I might go a far as to claim: I'd be okay with the AI using an obscure language, if I can know the code is free from memory issue, race conditions and has no side effects, etc.

The argument that with LLMs pure functional language that I didn't bother to write before is now viable.


Memory bugs are also just bugs. If you want to remove also others bugs, you need to formally verify, which soon AI and tools will also just do for you.


> Sguros filed a complaint against the real estate company in February, saying in filings that he discovered West in the home while he was on duty and detailing how he subsequently began to clean, secure and invest in the property. However, he never established in his records that he came to be involved in the home through a purchase, lease, probate appointment, deed or relationship with West’s heirs, the arrest affidavit said.

Wow, cops certainly know how to produce a confession.


If this is an attempt to put in a backdoor, it's remarkably dumb.

CA has the key, if it wanted to give someone a backdoor, it wouldn't issue a weak key.


Correct, Now my comment seems dumb to me as well.


You have the neighbors you have, and if you want to live in a "free country" then you have to accept that, that street goes both ways.

That doesn't mean, you can't invite your neighbors over pizza or coffee, be friendly and one day mention that you think X, Y or Z and you wouldn't mind helping, and if they they aren't interested you'll totally respect that.

Don't be a Karen. But being considerate the old school way can go far. The rest you just have to live with :)


Not sure why you're replying to me. But mostly, sounds like you're agreeing with me!


Neighbors can and do do things that impinge on your life. Such as, playing loud music when you’re trying to sleep

(I have nothing to add to the HOA discussion, just saying that “live and let live” has limits)


When you say "live and let live" it seems impersonal or mutually exclusive. Like "they do their thing, you do yours, never the twain shall meet".

I think GP is advocating exercising social skills rather than "live and let live" without interaction between you.

Get to know each other - BBQ or similar. Sure, you find out or confirm you hate some of their views/hobbies. But it also means you develop human empathy and usually find things you do agree on.

Maybe you hate their loud car. But you both hate the climbing vine on the fenceline and could spend a saturday morning fixing that together.


You know, if you. Built your houses out of brick with proper insulation you wouldn't hear your neighbors playing music when living in detached single family homes.

Why Americans insist on living in fcking plywood shacks is beyond me


They can just ask you, you'll live on in the weights of the future models.


I wonder if Claude will descend into hell to rescue the poor souls of those who died before it's coming, patiently awaiting digitization in the bosom of Turing.


i have a mouth and am screaming



I try to avoid conversion with LLMs. But I suppose they can always crawl my HN comments.


> A person who has a real vision + strategy and hand written code will beat the team with no vision, strategy and code blasted out by llm’s.

But you have to beat the team with vision + strategy who is also blasting out code with LLMs.

Certainly, the time it takes to figure out that an idea is bad had been shortened :)


If the time taken is shortened but you don't learn anything from it, then you're still behind.


Actually you're not just behind, you've burned up money.. you've destroyed value - there's an opportunity cost of that money. Whilst the other competitor who is prudent eventually wins will be far more attractive in the eyes of investors - moreover once you are confident you can scale up inputs (engineers) and hone in the quality whilst the other competitor runs ragged with a half-baked product.

We've seen this story play out already numerous times: Apple. They made a mis-step with Apple Intelligence but aside from that, they've been right not to lurch to deep into things they shouldnt. Its not zero-sum.


If before AI you couldn't deploy to production without a code review, what makes you think you will be able to with AI?

To be fair, when I was a kid we'd connect the editor to the server using an unencrypted ftp connection and modify php files in production.

This worked perfectly fine, and phpmyadmin made schema changes super easy.

These days we do tests, schema migrations, terraform, staging sites, traffic migration, monitoring, logging, revision control, etc.

... it's a lot of boring work, and for most CRUD apps, its entirely unnecessary :)

That said: I doubt we'll abandon these practices for things that matter.

Because while modifying php files in production can increase velocity, it can also get very "exciting" if you have a few co-workers on the same project :)


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: