HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | johnnyo's commentslogin

> Can it take notes of last night's D&D session?

Summarizing meeting notes is one of the most common AI use cases, so I definitely think that would be an easy one.


Sure, as long as it can parse multiple people speaking at once, sometimes about different things. As long as it understands the context of the campaign thus far. As long as it can parse fake names. As long as it also has video of the table, I guess, for when we're doing combat on a grid, and also understands which minis represent which PCs and NPCs, and infers what's going on when we're not explicitly talking about what we're doing.

Here’s a specific use case I’ve successfully used an agent like this for.

I booked a family trip. The tickets are refundable up to 30 days out, which means if the price drops between now and then, I can get the lower price, but only if:

1. I notice the price has dropped

2. I call and get the lower price

In the past this was hit or miss. If I remembered and happened to check, I might get lucky. Now my AI agent is checking every day between now and the deadline. It already saved me $250.


this is really the only useful thing i've seen. cron as a service

That’s how I’ve been using them. Basically things I know how to do, but don’t have the time to do regularly.

Examples

1. Keep an eye on all the various marketplaces for a specific make/model car I am interested in.

2. Scour various local news sources and entertainment venues for news of concerts, shows, movies it think I or my family might like.

3. Pulling together dates/prices/options for various family vacation scenarios.

4. Monitoring things I’ve already bought for discounts.


You can set an alert on Google flights and get alert for free. You don't need an agent for this.

I wasn’t looking at flights, I was looking at vacation packages.

Would you pay an agent for this the whole year?

Why would you need to pay?

The point being that this is not a good business opportunity.

The set of great ideas is much much larger than the set of viable business opportunities in any given year. So, the point... is missing the point :-)

If this is govt-owned data, shouldn’t it be available with a FOIA request or similar?

Can someone with expertise in govt data rights explain? Do any other US govt agencies sell data to the private sector?


Congress keeps passing laws to make USPS appear to be as "unprofitable" as possible. Such as pre-funding pensions & healthcare for people who have not been born yet [0]. I suspect the goal is to sell off a "money losing" USPS to some campaign contributor for $1 so that person can reap the $60B in pension funds.

One of the features I would try to add at employers was address correction. The addresses API used to be free (became a paid service in August 2026). If you've ever seen a popup at on an order/address form which says something like "you entered X, but the Post Office recommends Y" (or similar words), then you've seen the results of the address API [1].

Notes:

0 - 2022 changes to the 2006 law let them stop prefunding 75 years ahead of time.

https://www.uspsoig.gov/focus-areas/did-you-know/what-did-po...

> To qualify for regular retirement, employees must have at least 30 years of service and be 55 or older; or 20 years of service and be age 60 or older; or 5 years of service and be age 62 or older.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Postal_Accountability_and_Enha...

1 - https://developers.usps.com/addressesv3


Why is the government expected to be profitable? Is the military profitable? What about the national park service? I don't want government to be profitable--I want them to provide the service they are asked to provide in a way that his highly available and accessible.

It is ideological. Many point to private courier services as an 'obvious' point of comparison.

However, what I believe many are missing is that having a physical mail network that is accountable to the public good and our government is an advantage for many important situations that should not be dependent on the free market.


> It is ideological. Many point to private courier services as an 'obvious' point of comparison.

On a couple different levels:

1. Some people (like libertarians) have an ideological opposition to government-provided services, and believe all or nearly all services provided by the government should be abolished and replaced with the "free market."

2. An ideological belief that private business is "efficient" and government is "bloated and wasteful" by definition.

3. An lazy belief that "the government should be run like a business," therefore the tools you use to evaluate a business (like profitability), should be used to evaluate government.

4. etc.

I think those are distinct beliefs, but they kind of feed into each other and support each other. Like if you believe government services are wasteful and business efficient, it would follow you would improve things by abolishing the government services.


> 1. Some people (like libertarians) have an ideological opposition to government-provided services, and believe all or nearly all services provided by the government should be abolished and replaced with the "free market."

This is achieveable with “If you want to be licensed to deliver postal services, you have to deliver everywhere without discrimnating on price”. And the free market will find ways to make that work.


There are good libertarian arguments for a government run post office -- particularly in how it support free speech, the right to petition, free and fair elections, how it uniquely protects 4th amendment rights, etc.

Key difference though is that the people/lobbies using libertarianism as a platform for support don’t actually care about free speech, etc etc. They care about money.

Yes, very ideological. Some people want government to run like a business. Is your state/county/city not profitable enough? Then your state gets fired or downsized. Or maybe sold to the highest bidder.

In any event, the US Constitution requires a post office.

US Constitution, Article 1, Section 8

> The Congress shall have Power ...

> To establish Post Offices and post Roads;

https://www.archives.gov/founding-docs/constitution-transcri...


Not that I think they should, but Congress could legally vote to abolish the postal service. They had the power to create it but they weren't required to.

I think my state has already been sold to the highest bidder.

A profit is the net value given to society minus the cost taken from society. Example: you take floor worth 1 from society, make a cake and sell it for 3. You gave 3 and took 1, enriching society by 2.

It means that you reduced the poverty of other people by 2. Somebody who could not afford a cake before, now can.

This is why making a profit is philanthropy, and for the same reason, losing money impoverishes the rest of society. If you lose money, you impoverished other people. If the state loses money, it impoverishes society, but is the poorest people who gets the worst of it.


That's a twisted and myopic logic. You've gone from net value and cost to society, which have broad definitions, and then in the next sentences equated both strictly to money.

Free market prices are a valuation of costs to society. It's the valuation that produces the best results. Humanity doesn't knows a better one.

Twisted and myope logic is the concepts of price and value that socialists have. That's why socialism always fail: socialist don't understand the value of things.

The proof is the experimental results: life is always better in capitalist countries, and socialist always escape from socialism towards capitalism. Even socialists don't want to migrate to cuba or Venezuela.

Marxism is twisted and myope because Marxist define Marxism as the rejection of logic. Your Marxist posture is incompatible with reason.


There is value outside of money, mainly in our rights. A public post service protects your rights, like free speech and freedom from search.

It is highly unlikely that any private service will respect your free speech; naturally some post which is unpalatable to corporate PR will be censored. Moreover, your post will almost certainly be searched and data mined for additional profits.

The government is required to protect certain rights you have, the private sector is not. There is value in that which we cannot ascribe a monetary value to.


Marxist are the worst enemies of freedom of speech, and the government is socialism.

individuals need protection from the government more than anything else, and the government is the one always eroding all your freedoms


I'm sorry, what? You didn't give society 3, you gave it 1+the value of your added work, and pocketed the difference between that amount and 3. And before anyone jumps in to claim that people paying 3 means the item is actually objectively worth 3 - no, government services are often essential and irreplaceable, people are often willing to pay anything for them. This is like saying I somehow added 10000 of value to society by refusing to extinguish someone's burning house for anything less than that amount, despite the actual work costing me far less to perform. As for any non-essential services, that difference is covered by advertising and all sorts of manipulative tricks humanity has come up to force people to make irrational choices, especially over the last century.

Profit-seeking for essential services is the epitome of selfishness that can only be justified through twisted ideologies. When applied to governments that are supposed to take the least and give the most, it is pure evil, just skimming off goods and services someone desperately needs to put that in your pocket.


Your argument is that "essential services" have infinite value, and that's false.

Because value is relative to other valued things.

Resources are limited, so what you spend on "essential services" cannot be spent on other things.

Healthcare is "essential", but if you spend 100% of resources in healthcare, it will never be enough. You can spend billions to keep alive a person more minutes, and he will die anyways, but society would lose all housing, all food, all clothing, and would be miserable, so healthcare doesn't had infinite value.

If you find any "essential services" too expensive, is because you need other things more important, like having food or a house.

If the state pays for "free" healthcare, it has no limit to spending, and you cannot more get a house, food, clothing, or anything else.

That's why "essential services" have a price, like anything else, and should be restricted to be profitable.

Profit means that the value produced is higher than the cost, because the cost are other things that you need more.


YES, "people paying 3 means the item is actually objectively worth 3", because labor is not the value of the cake minus other costs.

You can spend exactly the same labor building the cake or smashing trash, but the smashed trash is not worth the same as the cake despite spending the same labor, so the labor value doesn't explain the value of the product.

You pay 3 for a. Ake only if you value what you buy more than what you pay, so you win by buying. Otherwise you would not buy. The seller had no power on how much you value it, so you decide how much is the cake valued when you decide to pay or not pay for it. That's independent of the cost of manufacturing. You don't care how much it had cost something you buy in the supermarket. You don't even know. You decide by judging if you are better buying it or something else you could get with that money.

Prices are created by consumers and represent priorities, not absolute value.

Because the value of things is decided by consumers, the value is independent of the cost of production, and for that reason is a lie that the difference between value and cost is the labor.

If labor were worth the difference between product value and cost, it would not be justified to produce anything, because at the end of day, nothing would be won by working. The final value would be the same than at the start of the day. It only makes sense to work if the final product is more valuable than what was spent, including labor.

Labor has limited value. You decide if you spend your labor cleaning your room, or if you are better doing nothing, or playing a videogame, because your labor has a limited value. You would not do any work if the benefit is smaller that the value of your work.

If labor were worth the final value . Minus other cost, you could not decide were to work. You would spend the same labor building a pile of trash or something more productive. A car would be worth the same as a pile of trash, despite requiring the same labor.


I like this analogy. The government should of course aim to make as much money as possible

The Post Office was established before telegraph. Before the phone and Internet. Before 37 of the states were part of the Union. Perhaps we don't need to subsidize it to the degree we do anymore?

(subsidize: not only do we incurring retirement obligations from the general fund, we charge the same amount to deliver a letter to rural Alaska as we do to a place across the street)

We could cut costs by reducing mail delivery frequency country-wide and more in costlier areas. In the age of satellite Internet, the need for delivering a physical thing quickly is not something we need to federally subsidize (argument for slowly: yes). In my suburban area I'd be completely unaffected by 2/week delivery. People in rural areas need to pay the cost of living rural now that we don't have anyone subsistence farming.


What's the alternative? Be consistently underfunded and cut postal worker wages year after year? Somehow arrange to sell exactly the correct number of Forever stamps on Dec 31 to cover all expenses incurred over the year?

Umm of course the government should be profitable. How do you expect it to work if it doesn't make money? Government makes money from oil, trade, taxes, fines, etc. I don't think the government being profitable has been an issue at any point.

If the government is profitable, where did the national debt come from?

In my experience that API is also wildly inaccurate and is responsible for many misdelivered/undelivered packages because it will return random (well, previously used by someone else), different building/suite/apartment numbers for the same address line that already contains the correct one.

USPS is being slowly killed at the behest of the real estate lobby who are licking their lips at the Post Office's multi-billion dollar real estate portfolio. There's no reason USPS needs to be profitable as a government service as a sibling comment has already pointed out.

Easy for private capital to make money of something everyone depends on that actually keep it free even if it “loses” money.

> I suspect the goal is to sell off a "money losing" USPS to some campaign contributor for $1 so that person can reap the $60B in pension funds.

it's not that complicated: FedEx and UPS and several other related business types have been trying to kill it for years

the "privatize everything" crowd that would charge you for air if they could.


Probably because of the silly idea of quasi-privatization,

> But, beginning in the 1970s, the Postal Service largely stopped receiving any taxpayer money for ongoing operations. Postal operations are instead funded by sales to you, the postal customer. Now it depends almost entirely on sales to keep the lights on.

https://www.uspsoig.gov/focus-areas/did-you-know/postal-serv...


> Postal operations are instead funded by sales to you, the postal customer. Now it depends almost entirely on sales to keep the lights on.

If you ever wonder why you get so much postal spam, this is why. The USPS is mostly funded by advertising. They could, for instance, stop the practice of accepting "deliver this junk to every mailbox in this region"...but then they'd go bankrupt.


Bipartisan effort concentrated across many years to destroy one of the most useful services in the nation.

It is not for the USPS to decide which mail gets delivered or not. They get paid to deliver mail, and they deliver it. This is a wild take on “the postal service should now do anti-spam”.

It is absolutely the job of the USPS to be a public service. Many countries' postal services have the concept of letting individual recipients opt out of bulk mail; for instance, in the Netherlands, you can put a "NEE" sticker on your mailbox. Or, better yet, entirely discontinue the specifically designed bulk mail programs that exist to deliver postal spam.

I'm not suggesting the USPS should be filtering by content, just taking the programs that exist specifically to facilitate postal spam and consigning them to the dustbin of history. Those programs essentially exist because they're a primary funding source for USPS.


Yeah, it is definitely one of the most tortured organizations I know of. Congress as usual wants a ton of conflicting things:

1. Mandate universal delivery of letters regardless of distance or remoteness, even out in some wilderness region of Alaska, guarantee everyone the right to get a letter for the same stamp price as to deliver a letter from one office in the Chrysler Building to another one.

2. Have USPS not get taxpayer funds for anything

3. Impose arbitrary price controls on postage based on Congressional vibes

4. Have postal employees still be federal employees and qualify for cushy benefits and retirement (I assume this is there because their unions would strike if it was taken away)

5. Micromanage how that retirement plan is funded

6. Give USPS special privileges like the one being discussed... or like the basic monopoly on 'delivering non-urgent letters' that bars UPS from delivering mail into your mailbox.

If all the above sound extremely confused, that's because the USPS has been the object of political meddling for at least 5-6 decades, so it still shows the fingerprints of many ideologically-conflicting schemes and agendas all at once.


> I assume this is there because their unions would strike

If postal employees are federal GS employees, they are not legally allowed to strike:

https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/5/7311


Exactly. Therefore "Have postal employees still be federal employees [...] because their unions would strike [...]" can be translated to "If we allow them to strike (by them not being federal employees), then they will strike".

Why shouldn’t they be federal employees?

I mean, I don't care what they are personally. But with making the USPS self-sufficient and not requiring infusions from the taxpayer being a goal that has been pursued and achieved, you could construct a world where the USPS simply IPOs, or its ownership tranferred to a weighted consortium of all 50 states or something, and a change in ownership like that would render those postal employees not federal employees anymore. So it was more that "keeping them federal employees" places some constraints on what we can do with USPS.

Don't forget, pre-fund pension accounts for future 'yet-to-be-hired' employees.

Wasn't that requirement finally repealed recently?


Apparently it is because the USPS has a special carve out from congress exempting it from disclosure of "information of a commercial nature", subsection (c) here: https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/39/410

TIL: USPS makes money with its own budget while USPS get some funding for government programs like rebates.

So yeah, they can sell that data legally.

https://about.usps.com/who/profile/

> he Postal Service generally receives no tax dollars for operating expenses and relies on the sale of postage, products and services to fund its operations


Pretty much every state charges for some data and not others.

The USPS itself is a quasi-government corporation, so it probably functions under a different set of laws. I know that they will sell you a list of all the addresses in the US for a price. I've never thought about doing a FOIA request. You can try?


This move roughly aligns with the administration's broader desire to take data generated by the government at taxpayer expense, and hand it over to his buddies to privatize and profit from it. See also weather data.

I asked a question, server hung, then told me I had no more free questions without giving me an answer.


1. AI company buys and trains on an author’s book when it gets published, it’s now part of the training data.

2. Attacker asks the LLM for the opening sentences of the book, it goes into the generated responses database.

3. Later, a malicious user shows that the first few sentences of the authors book are identical to a previously generated response.


Ignoring the other technical hurdles of the idea...this problem you outlaid is solved with a timestamp in the database, right? You can easily prove if the prompt was before/after publishing date?


If it’s before publication date, does that prove the author used AI inappropriately in their writing?

Not really, there are any number of reasons why they might do that.

In my own personal writing, sometimes I run it through LLMs to give grammar or writing suggestions.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: