Netbird doesn’t have proper network isolation, due to its shared policy space compared to one gateway interface per customer/organization. Which is not an issue if you are the only user, but if you are building a service for customers to use, and there’s a potential scale up, it will be an issue, either having multi account mode which will results in many resources you need to deploy or containers per customer, or, having them all shared policy that could potentially allow customer to customer access if misconfiguration happens, alternatively, building a gateway in the middle to broker it all but traffic must pass through which is operational cost plus extra latency, and even privacy concerns.
Pangolin is a similar project to Netbird and Tailscale/Headscale in that it's automatically managing wireguard tunnels but it is natively multitenant by design. Even as the super-admin I have to pick which tenant I want to be "connected to" at any given time to access private resources while my SSO still gets me access to all the secured "public" resources no matter what (if any) tenant I'm connected to.
Pangolin is great, I love it and I use it in my homeserver, but it’s only useful in those scenarios, like clients-sites. If your usecase is site-site (Like my case edge computing) it won’t work, also their newt client is being phased out for the cli, and also they don’t have “headless” setup so it can’t be used as a core of your saas for example, it will be a separate extra dashboard to deal with, and last I remember when I checked their license changes if you make $100k revenue. Headscale and tailscale clients also have single tailnet per server, and is policy file based. What I opt for in my use case (think of robotics and embedded) is iroh and build from scratch, since none of the existing solution worked well, the closest was netbird besides the issues I had above.
> If your usecase is site-site (Like my case edge computing) it won’t work
Isn't that what the "machine" client mode is for? You can grant it access to any resources in its organization.
> also their newt client is being phased out for the cli
Not sure I'd call this a downside, setting up Newt on every system was part of why I stopped setting up my test environment a year and a half ago, having Pangolin CLI when I returned to it was literally what made me start using it more widely. It's still using Newt under the hood as far as I'm aware, and my sites set up with Newt still work just fine.
> also they don’t have “headless” setup so it can’t be used as a core of your saas for example
> it will be a separate extra dashboard to deal with
True, though there is an API if that matters to you.
> and last I remember when I checked their license changes if you make $100k revenue
Not as far as I've seen. If you want to go over 50 users/100 sites self-hosted or 250 of either on their cloud service you step in to "Enterprise" licensing which has "Custom" pricing and I'm sure sucks, but I see nothing about revenue being relevant to anything.
I'm using it in a MSP context where I have literally three users but over 100 sites so I'm going to be sticking to the AGPL version unless I have a really compelling reason to change but even that's very powerful.
I also love the fact that they give me a single flag I can set to make all of the "this feature exists but only with a commercial license" stuff disappear.
Thanks for the details, I actually revisited my notes I had when made the architicture of what I am building and checked why I rejected it, and if pangolin now is a choice, that would save me the time of building from scratch on iroh.
>Machine clients
so that's partially right: their docs explains client-site, I don't see anything about site-site, except using a client (now CLI), so if an operator wants to access a machine, this machine-mode works well, but if machine1 wants to access machine2, it needs a client, which is pangolin CLI as a machine client. Newt's native mode and remote-node routing exist, but the docs link them to routing a sites network and to Pangolin Cloud's (or your own server maybe) remote nodes, I can't find anything about site-site unless you have other docs about it, that means V2V still needs client and newt's cli. Additionally, the traffic by default goes through the centerlized server, direct happens by punch holing with fall back to centerlized one, you can't control which is which, and this will have big impact on latency, think of realtime robotics work not just connected machines, every 1ms counts. Lastly, it also grant the permission per resources, not pair of devices.
Actually I mixed it as I was recalling from memory, Olm that being phased out, newt is still there but accessable by the cli
>Version 1.17 actually added this
That's great update actually, it's very similar to netbird in this update. Regarding the API, you are right, but it's its own users, org, and roles, and if your usecase (like mine) where pangolin is only part of the platform, and you have other authintication system, your tenant isolation lives in two seperate systems and you need to mirror both.
I also have other notes I had listed on why I rejected it, so they have no docs about post quantum for the tunnels, netbird has rosenpass, iroh has the hybrid handshake. Also, newt is built by Golang, and it's big for certain boards with 64-128MB. And also more moving parts to maintain (Pangolin, Gerbil, Traefik) compared to netbird or iroh.
The good thing about Pangolin is the login-protected access to web apps and services, which works well in your MSP and also in my server setups, but not in other use cases, where for example you don't expose anything to start with.
Netbird also, at least to me, has much too much stuff in it, perhaps even more. I would love to be able to connect to everything reliably no matter the network, the daemon doesn't need a reverse proxy, Ai agent routing and billing, in browser SSH client, it's all just attack surface. Tailscale allows you to compile a lot of it out as of a couple of weeks ago, but it's still an awful lot of code.
This. Call their offices a hundred times per day to reinforce the point. Leave voicemails each time. Use different personalities and names and numbers on each. They might not get each literal message, but they're get the figurative message.
the number of spam calls I get on a well published number has gone way up since 2024. Like dozens per day. Twilio filters don't work, support doesn't "get it". I recently ported in an old-persons number and holy CRAP! Calls starting at 7am their time and lasting through dinner!
The news is that the FCC approved the acquisition. It was already announced back in April that Amazon would be purchasing Globalstar. I don’t think anyone expected it to be held up by regulators.
Required watching for more on the extreme Kushner family corruption, I see other comments going on about his father-in-law, why not learn how fucked up his father is as well: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=U-xT3ilk51c
netbird's a thing to check out if you want an alternative to tailscale you can self-host.
reply