HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | jmkd's commentslogin

Anyone who thinks AI is immune to the same promise made by all major technologies of the last 150 years needs a little more...experience.


When legacy systems are already diabolical, throw in another language and they become close to impossible.

Technically-minded people have a responsibility to either:

1. Contribute to improving these systems in some way 2. Find ways to legally and efficiently shorten, circumvent or outsource them

There are other far more pleasant and productive ways to embrace a new language and community. Diving in to red tape is not one.


A shame that this took the threat of war to be taken seriously, rather than the reality of disenfranchisement faced by the elderly, immigrants, the homeless and the unbanked for whom cash remains a lifeline.

It is of great convenience to governments that digital payments require registered accounts on easily-tracked systems.

Just let people buy vegetables without becoming a cell in a Borgesian spreadsheet.


The elderly can't handle a debit card?

It would be straightforward to establish the right to a free basic bank account (with transaction limits) for the homeless & (formerly) unbanked.


>The elderly can't handle a debit card?

In my experience, the elderly can forget or mixup their card pins frequently enough to be annoyed by the ordeal. They are also more prone to expose their pins to others and be the target of theft.

>It would be straightforward to establish the right to a free basic bank account (with transaction limits) for the homeless & (formerly) unbanked.

The whole point is that in a cashless society the dependence on digital bank accounts is considered a single point of failure even for the banked, never mind the unbanked. The elderly and the homeless are also less equipped in knowing how to resolve problems that require digital solutions compared to the others.


Do places in Sweden not support tap top pay?

The point of failure around scams with pins and such is very valid, see gift cards.


Usually, tap to pay triggers randomized PIN requests too, which is even worse for elderly - entering a PIN only once every 100 transactions than every time.


> the reality of disenfranchisement faced by the elderly, immigrants, the homeless and the unbanked for whom cash remains a lifeline

On the one hand the disenfranchisement is real. On the other hand many of these people are able to learn lots of new technologies if properly incentivized. It's generally an opt-out of society that's enabled by workarounds being available.

Should we forego on convenience because we have a bunch of naysayers?

Forget about cash, try living life in de Randstad area without a smartphone and half a dozen apps setup, configured and tuned for you life. It's definitely possible, but you will be living at a different level of velocity than if you have all the tools at your disposal.


> Should we forego on convenience because we have a bunch of naysayers?

It wasn’t so convenient during the Iberian power blackout last year when all the electronic payment machines were out of action.

Cyberattacks on infrastructure are increasing.

National resilience/contingency is worth thinking about too.


For an example that may be closer to home to some, see the 2022 Rogers outage that lasted several days and took out payment terminals:

https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/british-columbia/rogers-debit...


I live in a country with sky high tax evasion where cashless is conveniently out of order / broken most of the time. Despite the drawbacks you highlight, I really really really wish for a cashless society, so the evaders are forced to declare EVERYTHING. The net benefit would be incredible, for everyone.


Wouldn't it be better just to collect taxes at more manageable points; where scale starts making ripples?

Besides this, people should be rewarded for using cash for purchases, as they both forego convenience for helping build a resilient society, and are more likely to be funding local businesses than large multinationals.


If you buy a coke can with cash who are you funding?


"More likely" is key here. Cash, by virtue of its physicality, is more likely to stay in the local area and prop up local jobs.

The act of handing cash over to someone heavily implies they're getting a cut of that.

The moment we introduce a card payment, 2% or whatever has instantly evaporated. Card payments are likely to be done online, too, which means further evaporation.

You only have to take a walk around UK towns to see the damage which digital transactions are doing to communities. They're devoid of life, and full of drugs.

I'd love to see an experiment of what'd happen if just legalised tax-free cash transactions in retail. Why bother paying tax at this level if the transaction itself it helping communities? It's far more efficient than letting % drift upwards to central government before being allocated back downwards.


Letting the government have control of everything when it's not very competent doesn't always lead to incredible net benefits.


Nor when it is very competent...


Hey THE GUBMINT exists also to collect taxes. Why are you so defensive of evasion?


Still cashless in practice, and largely has been for 20+ years so its not a surprise for the elderly.


The tax service here takes money laundering quite seriously so there's been a lot of regulation added for businesses handling cash, most affecting is probably the requirements of "certified tellers" that shot up the price for many smaller businesses (some even closing down or just switching to Swish).

Not entirely sure if those rules were relaxed, but the state and banks with higher cash handling fees did have a fair share in pushing cash out.


Especially after Swedbank and Danskebank got busted for laundering Russian money. But the banks now have numerous checkboxes to fill in when money comes from overseas, as if people receiving like 5000sek are laundering. (case in point, my dad wired me some money for my birthday, US->Sweden, Swedbank had to do a thorough check out of my dad, a University prof.) That said, I have heard of some system in place whereby people use a word-of-mouth banking system—mostly islamic communities, perhaps only that, to transfer money to and from overseas, so it's completely off the books. I don't remember what it's called, though.


The rules for laundering - know your customer - are ridiculous, governments don't need to turn banks in quasi-state actors to squash laundering if they really wanted to stop it.

Good on Sweden for going against the trend of ever increasing digitisation which is only going to be used against their citizens in bad ways.


That stuff can be not very good at doing what is intended. If I want to make a legit regulated transfer they now ask where the money came from and a lot was inherited forty years ago for which the records generally don't exist anymore. Meanwhile the actual criminals still manage to circumvent the system. It mostly creates hassle and expense for the law abiding.

I actually invested in a kyc business after being a bit horrified by the scam compounds in Cambodia but was disappointed when I heard a presentation of their successes which were mostly fines for legit people filling the forms wrong. Meanwhile the scam compounds got closed by raiding them and imprisoning or executing the criminals. I think the latter works much better than the former.


I sold a property earlier in August, my solicitor had to “verify my identity” this time even though she acted as my solicitor when purchasing said product.

Now tell me how intelligent the system is in that scenario.


Despite knowing the correct answer to the question in the first section, the diabolical wording on it absolutely threw me:

"Erase the shaded background: does the share of ink that shows the five numbers go up, down, or stay the same?"

In the spirit of the project, try asking me instead,

"Remove the shaded background: is the amount of ink now left on the chart more useful, less useful or the same as before?"

Damn...even that was hard to write.


And the same question was answered in the opposite sense in section 4, in which adding a colored background was deemed not to affect the data/ink ratio.

... Mumble mumble metric vs. target. Data/ink is a useful thing to keep in mind, but it's just one factor in selecting designs that communicate your data.


... Mumble mumble LLM-generated document problems.

It's even more frustrating/hypocritical considering that the underlying topic is about carefully and clearly communicating to other humans.


Max Junestrand has consistently said Legora treats the model layer as swappable, selecting across frontier providers rather than building the product around one.

OpenAI didn't need to name Legora and Harvey in the second paragraph of the launch post.

They are pre-empting the obvious interpretation of Astra for Law: that moving this far up the legal stack puts them in direct competition with their biggest legal AI customers.

“Don't worry, they can build on us” is a pretty conspicuous message to include on launch day.

They have clearly thought about some pessimistic outcomes.


>Max Junestrand has consistently said Legora treats the model layer as swappable, selecting across frontier providers rather than building the product around one.

Vendor-neutrality for LLMs is such a weak thesis all around, whether for providers or consumers. It weakens the product by being promiscuous and gains no material benefit at all.

LLMs are magic byte(byte) functions, it doesn't make sense to say "we have different providers for magic".


Different flavors of magic require different ritual components and in the name of all that is stable and production worthy, please don't get a necromancer to do your civil construction magic.

Vendor-neutrality helps reduce lock-in, and OpenAI and Anthropic are big enough that the reduction is valuable.


Really? Even when the magic is differently priced across magicians?


This is exactly how I would explain inference to a medieval peasant.


Switching from ChatGPT Enterprise to Legora at my firm was a godsend, it's so much better for legal work, even with the frequent changes to the underlying models.


They are cutting into their market. They can dress it up however they want, they might not be competing for enterprise contracts yet (hence the fluff statement), but they will.


Try Spanish roundabouts. On the whole, poorly designed, implemented and regulated. On roundabouts with two or more lanes, laws favour those on the outside lane, so everyone takes the outside lane even if they are travelling 3/4 of the way round. As a result drivers who are in a position to take an exit, do not take that exit. In addition, indicators are not used by most drivers, or they simply leave their indicators on all the way round. In addition, it is not allowed to exit a roundabout from the inside lane even on to a two lane exit. In addition many roundabouts have three lanes to enter onto a two lane roundabout, or two into one, etc. No one knows the rules, or follows them, and no one seems to care, from the civil engineers right down to the end users. The only winners are repair shops.

In comparison, UK roundabouts are civilised examples of harmonious intellectual etiquette. Enjoy them.

[source] I learned to drive in Swindon, home of the Magic Roundabout.


I live in the UK, drive occasionally in Spain due to Spanish in-laws, and agree wholeheartedly. I didn't know about the "outside lane has priority" rule though. I'd noticed it happening, but just thought it was a national quirk rather than gaming the system.


If you complain about Spain, then go live and drive in Italy :)


Home of the double red light, “you really have to stop”


One is reminded of Damien Hirst's famed retort to a critic who said "Well I could have pickled a shark" ... "But you didn't, did you. I did."


Reminds me of Teddy Roosevelt's "Citizenship in a Republic" speech, where he talked about the man in the arena:

> It is not the critic who counts; not the man who points out how the strong man stumbles or where the doer of deeds could have done them better. The credit belongs to the man who is actually in the arena, whose face is marred by dust and sweat and blood; who strives valiantly; who errs, and comes short again and again, because there is no effort without error and shortcoming; but who does actually strive to do the deeds; who knows the great enthusiasms, the great devotions; who spends himself in a worthy cause; who at the best knows in the end the triumph of high achievement, and who at the worst, if he fails, at least fails while daring greatly, so that his place shall never be with those cold and timid souls who know neither victory nor defeat.

https://www.presidency.ucsb.edu/documents/address-the-sorbon...


My favorite related pithy quote is "criticism is a minimum-wage job."


Somewhere there are tiny people going "Don't let the giants eat those mushrooms!"


Stefan Sagmeister talks about taking 5 years of your retirement and interspersing them into your working years in this great talk, pertinent moments at 01:30-02:00:

https://youtu.be/MNuOmTQdFjA?t=79&is=0GYzcLwy9fhQWqHR


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: