HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | jmilloy's commentslogin

Personally, comments like this are against the guidelines. Please either downvote and move on, or comment about the parts that are interesting and substantive.

> Please don't post shallow dismissals, especially of other people's work. A good critical comment teaches us something.

> Find something interesting to respond to instead.

> Please don't complain about tangential annoyances—e.g. article or website formats, name collisions, or back-button breakage. They're too common to be interesting.

> Omit internet tropes.


It's not a shallow dismissal. Writing quality is core to the value of an article.

It's likely that but for LLMs, the article would not have been written. I'm glad it was written. It's also true that it's unpleasant to read LLM-written prose for those of us who have to read it all day for work.


Do you think your comment is a good critical comment that "teaches us something"? If not, it qualifies as a shallow dismissal according to these guidelines, even if it's not a shallow dismissal according some other definition or criteria.

I don't think it's shallow because writing quality isn't important, I think it's a shallow dismissal of the writing quality because it doesn't discuss anything interesting or substantive about the writing quality.

Also, what about the other guidelines? Comments should meet all of the guidelines, not just some of them. (I do get that some of these are borderline.)


My comment? Please review the username of the comment in question.

If you feel a given comment is not within community guidelines you are free to flag it. I do not believe that we agree about the substantive value of noting an article was written with the heavy assistance of an LLM. I usually look at comments prior to reading an article; it's an effective time-saving measure.

I do not accept your attempt to make a blanket ban on noting an article was LLM-written.


They only tax the assets that are held in the state. I don't know where you're getting that they will tax out of state cars.

> If anyone running the business is a California resident (by the updated definition outlined above), then the whole business is a California resident, and any assets (including Lamborghinis and Bugattis) held in the state are subject to California taxation.


> If anyone running the business is a California resident (by the updated definition outlined above), then the whole business is a California resident, and any assets (including Lamborghinis and Bugattis) held in the state are subject to California taxation.

I'm relying on the paraphrasing in article rather than the text of the law itself, but this says that it only applies to assets held in the state.


My take is that it isn't about serving non-committal matches and withholding promising matches or whatever, it has more to do with whether you feel like there are better matches on the app if you just keep lookin or waiting. I can see how and app using the stable matching algorithm could really make you feel like you're getting the best match you're going to get, which I think could have a real impact on commitment.


"it has more to do with whether you feel like there are better matches on the app if you just keep lookin or waiting."

Yes, the FOMOism in dating app user psychology is extremely real, but this isn't a product problem, it's a human psychology problem. In theory, you could make an app with, say, a lifetime number of swipes to prevent infinite FOMOism, but it would fail to be a viable product model because the #1 thing that I found users wanted -- more than everything else -- was optionality. And if you don't offer it, they'll go to someone who does.

Hinge actually already uses Gale-Shapley and it doesn't seem to be producing meaningfully improved outcomes.

https://blogs.cornell.edu/info2040/2021/09/30/hinge-and-its-...


Right, FOMO is a human psychology problem...

...that many businesses exploit for profit.


But a business model taking advantage of it and causing it are two different things.


I'm curious if/why you think these considerations apply to this situation. This isn't a case of someone routinely destroying data and happening to do so right before a border check. Isn't this a case where the person wiping their phone right before a search, or actually tricking border patrol into wiping it, should know he had "a duty to retain it"?


Not necessarily, no, it's not clear that the person knew they had that duty. If you strongly believe the search is illegal, e.g. after being denied a lawyer, you might not think you're destroying evidence illegally.


I think in Gibson, most people and most corporations are boring. Capitalized and homogenized slop. The plots revolve around individuals and nooks and crannies that are cool, against the grain, hence the pink in cyberpunk. I think that exists in reality, too, but of course you have to go find it.


This video does not look cyberpunk to me. I see cyber, but where's the punk? Where's the "lowlife" or the societal collapse? This is high tech and highly controlled by enormous economic actors, but that doesn't make it cyberpunk at all.


I'd argue that currently the closest thing to that is queer culture. The vibe of social rejects reclaiming their own sense of style is very cyberpunk!


china has something like 50million homeless people. You are seeing the Arasaka quarters. There are much dodgier areas in all of the big Chinese cities (though surprisingly safe as the Chinese are quite docile)


I read your entire jumbled stream joyfully and hated the llm article that was spit out.


That sentence doesn't read as llm to me.


Can you give an example of long-form writing that sounds like this from before 2024?


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: