HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | jecel's commentslogin

I have seen some recent interviews with Leonard Tramiel, so I don't think he is dead yet.

The Unscii bitmap font for the PET came with no information at all. Thank you for that. I've just discovered https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29723782 too. So I'm going to add attribution at the top of my copy.

Some prototype based languages use delegation instead of inheritance, so people assume that is the case for Self as well. The difference is subtle. But as you pointed out and Mario Wolczko said: "Self is like Smalltalk, only more so". There were also languages with neither inheritance nor delegation but that still included some scheme for sharing.


The original Smalltalk-72 focused on teaching children, but for Smalltalk-76 Alan Kay and Dan Ingalls wanted different things. Alan wanted to continue the kid focus while Dan argued that a language focused on advanced programmers could be used to implement a children's language on top of it. He was proven right decades later when EToys and then Scratch were implemented on top of Squeak Smalltalk, which closely followed Smalltalk-76.

This confusion frustrated me when I first read about Smalltalk in the August 1981 issue of Byte magazine. I couldn't figure it out and at that point I had learned several programming languages and none of them took me more than two hours to become reasonably fluent in. So I was having problems with a language that kids were using?!? Later on I found out about the differences between Smalltalk-72 and -80 and that the Byte articles explained things that made sense if you already knew them but didn't help you learn in the first place. All variations of Smalltalk have become my favorite way to program ever since.


You are in luck: Alan Kay's original Smalltalk, also known as Smalltalk-72, doesn't have a syntax but instead allows you to define your own. Each class includes a single method that parses incoming messages however it wants.

The two problems with this were a lack of performance and the difficulty of understanding other people's code.

Dan Ingalls looked at the most popular styles people had created in Smalltalk-72 and defined a fixed syntax for Smalltalk-76 with the same flavor. This allowed him to "compile" -76 into bytecodes which would then be executed much faster by an interpreted virtual machine (and years later a JIT compiled one).

The analogy is putting grass everywhere in a new university campus and after a while seeing where the grass has been trampled and putting concrete sidewalks there.

For Smalltalk-80 they wanted people to be able to use it on their own computers and not only on the special Xerox PARC ones so the patched the syntax to use ASCII instead of their own character set. That made it uglier, in my opinion.

I can understand many people not liking the Smalltalk-80 syntax, but we do get some new people to the language every year and quite a few of them find the syntax one of the nicest features.


The first line of https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Logo_(programming_language) is "Logo is an educational programming language, designed in 1967 by Wally Feurzeig, Seymour Papert, and Cynthia Solomon." so you are correct but it is nice to mention his co-inventors. I agree about the book. I had to borrow it from a friend, read it quickly and give it back in 1983 so my memories of it are a bit fuzzy.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: