HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | jacobsimon's commentslogin

This is shortsighted (no offense). We should collectively stop personifying AI tools like this before we’ve completely lost our way.

If you’re building and producing valuable software, you are still a creator or software engineer full stop. We can argue over titles, but don’t demote your own creative process to passive consumption.


I think “about Apple” was the operative part. For example, if you know that Nokia had a bad quarter, then perhaps you might infer that Apple had a good one. I believe this is also illegal but obviously harder to prove.


They’ve been trying to build housing there for a decade and it keeps getting blocked. https://sfist.com/2023/12/06/former-monster-in-the-mission-n...


First, your article is from 2023. Second, that law only came into effect three months ago. How is your comment relevant?


Chill I’m just giving you the history of why there is no housing at that intersection. I don’t know about your bill, I moved away out of SF in 2023.


No true Scotsman uses AI? :)

Jokes aside, I think you’re valid but if you take the macro view, it’s clear that there are now more people doing some form of engineering, the same way the digital camera led to more people doing photography, and so on.

I think we can make separate distinctions around the act of consuming vs creating—a lot of vibe coding is beginning to look more like “consuming software” but that’s not what I was intending to describe here.


Precise terminology is important. Just like there's a difference between "taking a photograph" and "photography", there's a difference between "making software" and "software engineering". Digital cameras let more people take more photographs, and some decided to practice the art of photography. Every technological advancement, from personal computers to widespread Internet access to AI tools has made creating software more accessible, but it hasn't inherently made more software engineers.


You can define it however you like, but my point was that all of the following appear to be increasing:

* the number of people creating software

* the number of people who are educated in creating software

* the number of people who are paid to create software


By your logic: people who use calculators are mathematicians


I can’t speak about other languages but in my head the simplest reason is that English “a/an” specifies “one”, eg “I have a cat and two dogs.” I googled and confirmed a/an is Old English for “one” but otherwise they didn’t use articles. I assume it’s a similar origin story for other languages like “un/una/une”. In that case, it’s equally strange that other languages would make “one” plural imo.


> In that case, it’s equally strange that other languages would make “one” plural imo.

Why? It's very common in English:

I don't want those ones.

In this case the number has been repurposed as a placeholder noun, and the noun is what's pluralized, but that's also what happens when the number is repurposed as a determiner and the determiner gets pluralized.


Good point!

I think it probably just boils down to whether the word is functionally necessary to understand the meaning of the sentence and how the language evolved...

For example, in French you don't usually pronounce the "s" at the end of a plural noun and lots of singular nouns end in "s", so the articles become necessary for determining if you mean plural or singular. In English you pronounce the "s" clearly and very few singular words end in "s", so you just don't need the article to distinguish anything, it becomes functionally redundant.


This is not a good explanation, because you could just as well say "I have cat and two dogs". The fact remains that "a cat", "cat", and "the cat" (and "one cat") all have separate meanings; while for plural, you only have "cats" and "the cats".


There are some nouns that are always plurals e.g. "scissors" or "pants", and those things still arguably need indefinite/definite distinction, right? Actually no, the very use of plain "scissors" instead of "*a scissors" demonstrates very well the redundancy of the indefinite article, but let's pretend.


That's just an oddity due to nominally singular items having plural names.

"*a scissors/pants" is correctly "a pair of scissors/pants" and you still use the definite "the scissors/pants"

So "get me scissors" is a bit odd but works only because the singular item happens to have a plural name.


Again, e.g. Bulgarian uses едни ("ones") as essentially plural indefinite article, and for genuinely plural things too. It's not nearly as pervasive as the English usage (the null article is used in most cases), but it exists. While in English you could reply to "Where are you going?" with "To hang out with some friends" ('it doesn't really matter to you which ones exactly'), in Bulgarian that "some" would be translated as "едни", not "няколко" or "някои" (technically, you could use that last one, but the meaning would be that you're yourself not sure with whom exactly you're going to hang out there).


Yet other people claim to not have an internal monologue (including my wife and brother) and say they don’t hear anything when they think to themselves, and don’t really even “think” in words for that matter. So this comparison is also tricky because not everyone agrees on either of them. I have a weak visualization ability and strong internal monologue, I’m not sure if they’re correlated in some way or not.


No visualization, no monologue or other auditory thinking ability. My thinking process is more like reading and writing than speaking and hearing. The concepts flow at the speed at of thought when active, much faster than I could comprehend spoken language or images, but completely still otherwise. When I have to think in words, I'm quite slow (it took around 20 minutes to write this post).


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: