HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | ihumanable's commentslogin

I've heard the term "frecency bias" a portmanteau of frequency and recency to refer to people focusing intently on a set of outlier events that happen to occur with a heightened frequency very recently.

I'm sure most of us here have been on the receiving end of managers suddenly obsessed with a failure mode because it happened to occur twice in one month.


If the reporting is to be believed, they ended up selling around $7.5B to China through Singapore.

They did ~$90B in revenue last quarter.

I sometimes can't imagine the avarice it takes to do things like this. Could you imagine having a $100 bill in your hand and going "Yea, I'll break the law and possibly destroy my life to steal $7.50"


The difference between 100 billion and 107.5 billion is a 7.5 BILLION dollars.

Another way to put it is the difference between 75 MILLION and 7.5 BILLION is rounded to 7.4 BILLION.

The scale of numbers is huge and it is not just another 7.5 billion dollars.


>"Yea, I'll break the law and possibly destroy my life to steal $7.50"

It's worse than that. Much much much worse than plain greed. Supply of manufacturing capacity for this kind of hardware is severely limited. TSMC can't produce enough to meet all that demand. NVIDIA not selling 7.5B worth of chips to China does not mean they would lose the 7.5B worth of chips. They could have sold them to American companies, which are all in a frenzy to build datacenters.

No, this is just a classic case of treachery. Jensen Huang, whether bought, blackmailed or because of tribalism, has decided to support China. In an interview, he was getting very angsty when someone asked him why sell chips to China, and said "victimizing them, turning them into an enemy, likely isn't the best answer":

https://youtu.be/Hrbq66XqtCo?t=3517

People refuse to believe it when it's a billionaire, but they too can be very tribal, even if they lived most of their life in the so called melting pot of the United States of America.


I have no idea why AI bots want to troll so viciously as this.

Trump went on 60 Minutes and said as much

PRESIDENT DONALD TRUMP: I think that the risk is not nearly as real as it-- as they talk. And I think the risk can be managed. And it's managed, you know who? By who? The DOJ. We had a situation where somebody was reported to us to be doing something bad with AI. We called them very strongly and said, "Get ready to go to jail. Please give your wife a kiss good night."

ROSS DOUTHAT: Who was this person?

PRESIDENT DONALD TRUMP: I can't tell you--

ROSS DOUTHAT: Or this company?

PRESIDENT DONALD TRUMP: I can't tell you. But we said-- "Do you like the color orange because get rid --" said, "Go home right now. See your wife and children. Give 'em a kiss good night, and--"

ROSS DOUTHAT: If--

PRESIDENT DONALD TRUMP: --"that's the story because--"

ROSS DOUTHAT: If the Democrats--

PRESIDENT DONALD TRUMP: --"because tomorrow morning--"

ROSS DOUTHAT: --wanted--

PRESIDENT DONALD TRUMP: --"you're goin' to jail."

ROSS DOUTHAT: If the-- if they--

PRESIDENT DONALD TRUMP: Let me tell you--

ROSS DOUTHAT: --wanted to make a deal--

PRESIDENT DONALD TRUMP: --this person--

ROSS DOUTHAT: --to put that (UNINTEL)--

PRESIDENT DONALD TRUMP: --this person totally changed everything. Totally. "Yes, sir. Yes, sir--"

ROSS DOUTHAT: "Yes, sir"?

PRESIDENT DONALD TRUMP: Okay--

ROSS DOUTHAT: Was it a leader of a major AI company?

PRESIDENT DONALD TRUMP: One of the big ones. Yeah.

ROSS DOUTHAT: Okay.

PRESIDENT DONALD TRUMP: One of the big ones. And--

ROSS DOUTHAT: If the Democrats--

PRESIDENT DONALD TRUMP: --and-- and I don't think--

ROSS DOUTHAT: --said, "We wanna put th-- we wanna--"

PRESIDENT DONALD TRUMP: --I don't--

ROSS DOUTHAT: --"codify this into law--"

PRESIDENT DONALD TRUMP: --I don't think it was--

ROSS DOUTHAT: --would you work with them--

PRESIDENT DONALD TRUMP: --done maliciously. But it coulda been malicious, but--

---

This is what losing the Rule of Law looks like by the way. The sitting president is on TV saying that he found out someone rich and powerful is suspected of wrong doing serious enough to get a call from the president threatening him with prison, but that that's the punishment. Once that rich and powerful person bent the knee, said "Yes sir" with the right tone of voice, all was forgiven.

Equal Justice under Law means that we shouldn't punish people we don't like with harsher sentences it also means that wealth and power shouldn't be sufficient to skirt the law.

We often speak of a two-tiered justice system, but I've never seen the president go on TV and tell America in no uncertain terms, it exists, I'm a part of it, and it went very well, he said "Yes sir" just the right way and so you don't need to worry about it.



This conversation is completely unhinged and unintelligible.

Thank you for the transcript, I can hear it in my head with all the inflections and combativeness. Douthat reads as "Doubt That" to me, chef's kiss to whomever is writing the script for this simulation, haha.

You're just NOW noticing that we have lost the rule of law?? The constitution has been continuously violated for over 100 years, we are clearly a post-constitutional republic? I guess? I think we entered full clown world in the 2000's where the currency, government and war systems started glitching out.

What I am noticing is that the high trust society we inherited has finally eroded to the point that we no longer tell ourselves that we have rules and laws that are equally (or sanely) applied.

Which is a good, scales dropping from eyes, innocence ending sort of thing. Makes me hopeful for change, in a way.


Homer attempting to fix a stuck drawer with a firecracker

Marge: Homer, what are you doing?

Homer: Listen, do you want the job done right or do you want it done fast?

Marge: Well, like all Americans, fast, but...

Homer: Clear _lights firecracker_


Homer: Kids, there's three ways to do things: the right way, the wrong way and the Max Power way!

Bart: Isn't that the wrong way?

Homer: Yeah, but faster!


Move fast and break things- FASTER!!!


Capitalist using money to buy capital and then sell services, brilliant.

Government using money to buy capital and then provide services, deadly socialism.

It's always just been about capitalists wanting less competition. That's why they don't want the market to decide and fight for laws to literally outlaw stuff like municipal broadband. If they are so much more efficient, they should be able to offer an equal or better service for the same or better price.


Government using people's taxes to waste money with 0 accountability


They have so much accountability. Everything is in public for inspection, they're subject to elections happening whether they like it or not, they have to follow strict laws and can be sued or even imprisoned, there's oversights and review boards. Depending on the position there's even television cameras broadcasting their work live. You can just walk in and sit down on them. In the federal government everything you do becomes public property and enters the public domain immediately upon creation. There's way more accountability...

In practice what the "small government" ideology actually does is get rid of these accountability mechanisms and put scammers and corrupt people in charge instead or relabels corruption as the policy through public-private partnerships.


Not everything is up to inspection; elections are about gathering votes - not actually improving infrastructure - and conflicting interest often result in heavy and broad compromises; oversight/review boards often just do the bare minimum. Get rid of intellectual property, and everything will be public domain.

Furthermore, nothing prevents applying these oversights over public-private partnerships (which is just a fancy term for outsourcing). The government decides who gets hired and on what conditions, so it can just enforce transparency requirements.


In many places I can see every single government employee's salary, down to the janitor. Which public company has the same level of transparency?


Yes, a government has never wasted tax money by giving a contract to a private company before.

Those companies that win big pork filled contracts would never have any incentive to get the company to waste tax dollars.

Adding the profit motive in here definitely helps prevent waste


It's a lot easier for me to vote for someone with better policies than it is for me to get the CEO of a utility company fired.


What are you talking about? I can vote out my government leaders in a democracy. I can't vote out Mark Zuckerberg or Elon Musk that run their organizations autocratically.


> After Claude Code (AC), the economics that gave us every single piece of software we use today have inverted. Building software has become cheap, with the marginal cost of building a new feature approaching zero, while running it, now that AI sits in the critical path, has become expensive.

This is such a weird take, if I need some piece of software why would an ongoing operating cost be having an AI sitting in the critical path.

If the argument is that making software has become cheap because you can use AI to generate software, it doesn't seem to follow that you would build all software as some sort of shell around AI. If I ask claude to build me a task tracking app, I imagine it would build me something with some bog standard data storage and not decide that it needs to keep the tasks in an LLM.

I don't agree with most of this post, but this part stood out as supremely odd. There is a lot of software that isn't made any better by having AI jammed into it as an always on piece of the operating puzzle.


> This is such a weird take, if I need some piece of software why would an ongoing operating cost be having an AI sitting in the critical path.

The inversion only applies to products where an AI model sits in the request path, which is a growing share of what’s being built. It definitely doesn't mean all software that will get built (and that wasn't my intent anyway), so maybe my initial sentence in the essay overreaches. I'll make an edit to address this.


I'm also a bit confused what Anthropic needs all this code for. Their main product is selling access to their model, but the model isn't comprised of code, it's a bunch of weights right?

So the code is for the stuff around the model, claude CLI, the website, the API... that probably shouldn't be infinitely growing right?

Is there a bunch of code they are using as part of training, or as pre-processing or post-processing the requests to the model?


I did RL and evals at Amazon for a bit on Nova Forge (laid off in July! :D). I would have to push several thousand lines of code a day in new evaluations that our applied scientists requested since new ones are always being made along with having to create custom ones for whatever new model they were working on. Also, in RL, adding new environments for the agents to actually complete activates was also a shit ton of lines of code. So if I had to guess, just adding new stuff around model training and testing alone accounts for a ton of these changes.


The moat isn't going to be the model (short of AGI). The moat is going to be what surrounds it. The harness and, I have suggested elsewhere, memory. The more personalized the AI is to you the more valuable it will be.

Also, as tech companies grow, a significant portion of the dev body count is for internal tooling. I was always flabbergasted at Twitter's headcount growth back in the day when it seemed like the only innovation increasing the number of characters in a tweet.

Right now we are in a weird spot where a lot of people are flailing around inside corporate America trying to figure out how to leverage AI. Few have enough vision to see what the companies of the future will look like and work towards that.


With how easy it becomes to write software, I'd say that both the model and the harness are already being commoditized. I don't see a reason to believe there would be moat in any of them.


Software engineering is a sliver of overall economic output. It is an input for tech companies who sell something else (ads, subscriptions, etc.). It is a backoffice expense for non-tech firms that do engineering.

I anticipate that the harness (and memory) will evolve far more outside of engineering. Muse/Dots are an example of that.

I've been writing about this thesis for the past year or so and here is a bit of a summary of where I think it is going: https://zero2data.substack.com/p/the-future-of-consumer-ai


Could you point me to something that their harness does exceptionally well as compared to their competitors, and why that can't be accomplished by a third party?


This was also my question, and I'm surprised this hasn't come up more prominently in the discussion here at HN.

I don't use Anthropic products at all, so I was not really sure myself but apart from the models they pretty much only have Claude Code afaik.

And now they're publishing a blog post about writing their own vcs because they have 30000 commits a day. For what? Isn't Claude still based on react?

Do they need this many commits just for claude? Or is that about the model, do they develop that much extra internal tooling?

I admit it is very much possible I am wrong, but without further information this seems a bit like a red flag to me.


Probably lots of internal competitor apps ready to release to wipe out SaaS/Adobe/etc. companies.


Lack of focus, like building your own SCM


But the article clearly describes how this SCM is just instrumental in their goal to build and serve better models. It's not some unrelated product they hope to sell.


No it doesn’t, it doesn’t even talk about what they’re building


it takes orders of magnitude more focus to target "Market: World" vs targeting "Market: my company's employees". For example in enterprise software, you need sales people. for internal software, usually the dev build it is fine for the job.


> He added that he felt the video was “genuine, that his obvious forgiveness of Mr. Horcasitas reflects the character I heard about [Pelkey] today.”

It's an artificial video that is *literally and verifiably* not genuine.


boomers are so cooked


If a judge says it is, then it must be. /s


Tens of thousands of elderly people can’t be wrong!


It sorta feels to me like extrapolating from "the internet has all the knowledge for free" to "we won't need tradespeople anymore"

Why hire a plumber when you can just watch some youtube videos and do it yourself?

Why pay someone else for their software when you can just make your own?

Because the hard part of making software wasn't *just* writing the code. It was about understanding the problem well enough to understand what the solution should look like.

I feel like as software engineers we should be pretty familiar with what it's like talking to your average user, they will sometimes understand the root cause of what's making their task difficult (although often will get focused on some annoying but ultimately trivial symptom) and have very disasterously bad ideas on how to solve it.

What we've given them with generative AI is a machine they can put their sometimes ok, sometimes questionable understanding of the problem and their dreadful solutions and it will happily churn away building it regardless of how pointless and silly it is.

A future where every user can tell the AI "We keep getting the sales tax wrong, remove charging sales tax from the checkout flow" isn't one I'm terrifically worried about.

In the same way that having access to information about plumbing didn't suddenly make everyone plumbers, having access to a machine that will implement every idea you have regardless of quality doesn't suddenly make everyone a software engineer.


The plumbing analogy doesn’t match software. You pay for a plumber once and you can always choose a new plumber. With software, it’s a monthly fee that will continue to increase over time. More features behind higher tiers. And probably taking and selling your data. So why wouldn’t a person try to build something custom for their needs? They have the ultimate feedback loop of actually using the product and telling AI the issue and having AI fix it. Most software people create are probably something they never used it their lives. But the best software comes from people building it that also use it. Even Shopify started when Tobi started a snowboarding store online and couldn’t suitable e-commerce software.

You’re right about people not watching plumbing videos and doing it themselves. But the equivalent example would be open-source software in the tech example. But instead of reading open-source code to see how different features were implemented, AI can go and dig into the code and figure it out.


> With software, it’s a monthly fee that will continue to increase over time.

The fact that you think this is the way software is priced is telling.

The model being destroyed here is that every piece of software is something that needs to generate recurring revenue.


You’re right, the monetization of software is fading and building actual moats is becoming difficult. If you have distribution, regardless of your app, you still have a long run way.

I was more pointing out that software gets enshittified. A plumber necessarily doesn’t and if the plumber does get worse, you can call a different one next time. Software, especially B2B, has switching costs and lock in. So you just have to put up with it.

Another point is that most software started with a few features and to get more market share and support more use cases, it became worse for the users using the early features. That’s why they try to build their own so it’s not bloated with features you will never use.


> A future where every user can tell the AI "We keep getting the sales tax wrong, remove charging sales tax from the checkout flow" isn't one I'm terrifically worried about.

You couldn't move the goal post further from "Letting AI basically control everything and us not having any mental understanding of sorts and sort of becoming the meat-proxies just for economical reasons".

So this one falls under denial for me.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: