HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | igor47's commentslogin

I had a teacher in middle school who would assign a version of this over winter break with the digits of the new year. I had a lot of fun with it in 1996. Sad to think she must've stopped in 2000...

I would have to say doge, that ill conceived "chainsaw" to the federal government that saved $14B, or 0.26% of the federal budget, but which according to the Lancet will result in as many as 14M additional deaths, including 4.5M children, by 2030.


I feel like I would have loved this a year ago when I still reviewed PRs by reading diffs. Alas these days I do my reviews inside a harness using my code review skill: https://github.com/igor47/dotfiles/blob/master/claude/skills...

I don't see how I could keep up with the volume of code my team now produces without this. How do other people do it?


By having policies in place of at least doing reviews by reading and understanding what is going on.


I recommend picking a random sample of commits to review more thoroughly by hand in parallel with the harness review.

That way, you get the opportunity to measure how many and what kind of issues your harness method misses, and with an estimation of their cost, you can make an informed decision about what magnitude speedup pays for the change in detection rate.


> Unfortunately, Nadella also refers to AI as “super intelligence” throughout the post.

What's the deal with these clowns? Nadella's estimated net worth is like $600M. Is that still not enough for him to buy himself a spine?


At 600M, if keeping a spine has a risk of slight reduction in that wealth, then the spine is thrown out in a jiffy.

No rich man or woman is a friend of society.

That is why governments fear revolt from the poor. They have nothing more to lose.


They are so proud that they have "earned" their obscene wealth but terrified what would happen if they had to do it again.


Not having a spine goes a long way when you're trying to make billions.


If he stands up to Trump, Trump declares Microsoft a national security threat and decimates the company. That’s what this is about.


On one hand I don’t mind the government keeping corporations in check. On the other, the government doing business via random threats and bullying seems worse than corporations.


Yeah it makes the USA a "shithole country", to borrow a term


No he's an automaton optimizing for status


Otherwise suddenly MS is excluded from government contracts (even ones awarded or in progress), justice department will start attacking it etc.


Let's not be confused, it's not about spines, it's about shared interests.


That's the thing though, he has $600M dollars worth of reasons to bend.

People think that money makes you strong, maybe it does but only upto like a couple million dollars if at all, well whatever amount will give you a lifetime of comfortable life, after that it's all about how to preserve or make more money.

The more you have the more reason you have to do the wrong thing.


To me, this is a confirmation of how much of a free man I am and how unfree these tech billionaires and CEOs are. Because I can choose to say AI, whereas they seemingly cannot.


I'm not a number, I am a free man. /s


I would expect people selling AI to like that term for marketing reasons, completely independent of their opinion of the person who provided a crystallization point to organize the terminology change around.


You assume he’s a human and not a super intelligent being himself


I am pretty sure he's not super intelligent.


He has to keep The Orange House happy.


ELI5 why he needs to please the Dutch royal family?


The Orange House, not the House of Orange.

See also: Peoples’ Front of Judea vs Judean Peoples Front.


> ELI5

1337 bro.


600M is not that much actually, just three proper celebrity houses in LA or sth… he’s still poor-man to run a trillion dollar company. SteveB had better deal out that responsibility.


Was also wondering. Sounds low. Forbes puts him around 1.4B. Still lowish compared to his CEO peers. https://www.forbes.com/profile/satya-nadella/


He wouldn't have this net worth if he ever had a spine. Mind you, he's very tough to people under him, and that's a very important characteristic of this kind of people, but he really doesn't have a spine.


Super Intelligence is a term of art that has been around for a few decades now. Nick Bostrom gave a the canonical definition for it almost 30 years ago. Super Intelligence is more relevant to the concerns articulated in this article than AI which is rather broad in its purview. Maybe this is Trump stuff? I don't know. If it were something stupid like Freedom Intelligence then I'd be pretty annoyed, but there is a lot of plausible deniability that Super Intelligence is just a better term for what we're all freaking out about. A world where GPT 4 hits scaling limits and it costs $500 a month to run is definitely AI but none of the catastrophes emerge at that level of intelligence. That would actually be a pretty sweet world. But now we get to have our whole civilization ground up into dust by super intelligence instead.


True, but for Bostrom Superintelligence was a capability level for AI and not a replacement for the accepted scientific term. Narrow -> General -> Super.


Stop being obtuse, it’s clearly Trump’s hand up in his ass. No one’s used "super intelligence" before


It was definitely a common term well before 2024, you could please refer to the Wikipedia:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Superintelligence

Or any of the literature on the subject from the past 30 years: From here

[1] https://nickbostrom.com/papers/how-long-before-superintellig...

to more recently:

[2] https://openai.com/index/governance-of-superintelligence/

For context, Nick Bostrom, Sam Altman, Greg Brockman, Ilya Sutskever are big names in AI. There is a reason they were using this term back in 2023.


Superstupid. These people are high on their own hype, oblivious to how ridiculous they sound.


It is actually a very common part of the fascist playbook to demand ridiculous things as proof of loyalty and then declare those not following the enemy. Absolute loyalty is required. For unprincipled people like Nadella and the rest of tech leadership, it is a small price to pay to not get hit with economic sanctions in retaliation.


Actual Indians > Super Indians


the spine here is going with a deeply unpopular guy's dumb opinions and getting the hate mail


Bootlicking is good for shareholders. Shareholders are more important than citizens. Money is speech.

Anyone who doesnt see the calculus is a mental gymnast.


His own net worth isn’t the point.

Bend the knee or Trump will destroy your company. And every Republican in Congress is cool with that.


I don't quite see the problem here.

My AI is regularly solving master's thesis level, and sometimes Ph.D thesis level problems for the purpose of, e.g. routine tasks like filling out random paperwork.

It's been very odd.

I'd only assume Nadella has access to more advanced models than I do, just as much as I have more advanced models than my relatives.


Can you ask your AI to answer the ultimate question, that being the answer to life, the universe, and everything?


I hadn't tried that question before. Gemini knew the answer.


Because it's a political loyalty test. Nobody started using it organically until they were ordered to in order to prove their loyalty.

Using it is embarrassing.


I feel like I'm missing some context. A lot of context.

Whose loyalty test? How?

I mostly heard "super intelligence" a long, long time ago in the context of work on AI / philosophy / futurism which, honestly, sounded pretty detached until the current deep learning sprint, and now sounds pretty prophetic.


You missed yesterday's edict? https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50019684

Wait, the renaming was from a speech on 11 September in fact, I lost track.


Yes, I did miss it.

Thank you.

That sucks. It's a helpful term. Now, it's politicized.


It's a bit more than a mere loyalty test, in that Trump knows it is humiliating for them to listen to him on anything like this.

He knows humiliation (from his father and from Putin) and he loves to dish it out to others.

This is Reek, basically.


Right, and humiliation rituals are not just about the authoritarian's ego, they do damage that the authoritarian exploits.

People who comply scar their reputation and trustworthiness, so that it's harder for them to build any alliance against the authoritarian in the future, ex: "We all know Bob lied to keep his job... But if they threaten his job again, doesn't that mean he might lie to us too?"


Right. It’s absolutely crucial to understand what is going on here.

He has a litany of weaknesses, failings and shortcomings, but he is an international expert at humiliating, suborning and breaking people. His mendacity is very nearly unparalleled.


Let those consumers pay for it then!


What does this have to do with internalizing costs to businesses? By your logic, the government should just subsidize all consumer goods... Which, okay maybe I actually agree with you? (Jk I'm not that much of a socialist. I think markets are great, and we should leverage them by fully pricing externalities like road damage or pollution, enabling the market to solve some of our big problems)


If the costs of trucking is internalized, it then factors into the cost of goods shipped by truck. This makes it possible for competitors like rail or local produce to complete, which then allows consumers to save money. On the other hand, if the cost is externalized, we secretly pay more without even having the possibility of paying less.


I listened to this podcast and it was maddening. A few of his frames :

AI is just software, nothing new to see here.

AI safety is primarily a sandboxing problem.

There is no collective action problem, and every company should just slow down if they think they need to slow down.

There is no need for regulation because the existing incentives in the market keep companies from acting badly, which is why no company has ever done anything bad.

If something bad does happen, then we can regulate after the fact.

We will end up creating more jobs than we destroy, so don't worry about it.

Our kids might forget a whole bunch of stuff or never learn it in the first place. But don't worry, they'll come up with new things to learn instead.

The only way to get safety is to move faster because then we will more quickly arrive at safety.

Recursive self-improvement is just what we've always done.

The real danger is alarmism that might scare the public and the young people.

Nothing bad can happen, it can only good happen.


>We will end up creating more jobs than we destroy, so don't worry about it.

The destroyed jobs and the persons doing them will be different from the new ones created..

>If something bad does happen, then we can regulate after the fact.

How does regulating after the fact undo the harms caused?

> they'll come up with new things to learn instead.

Like they forgot how to communicate face to face, but have learned to communicate via social media?


A whole bunch of fluff without any evidence to back it up.


I unironically agree with most of these points.


The implication being that you only ironically agree with the rest?


Happy path coding is certainly the most fun.


[flagged]

It’s feeling less and less like human progress and more and more like progress for a small group at the top of our economic structure who are hoovering up everything for themselves.

Who gives a fuck if some techno barons can deploy novel software at the drop of a hat if it means I lose my career in an environment without social safety nets.

It’s not progress from my perspective when my life quality regresses.


Who else is going to save you? You might as well shake your fist at a tsunami.

AI is the ultimate social safety net, if you'll just get out of the way of the people weaving it.


what an insane thing to say


Answer the question: who's coming to save you? Bernie? Donald? AOC? J.D.?

Better if you don't need saving at all, because you've been empowered to help yourself at your job. Ultimately the goal is to free you entirely from dependence on a day-to-day occupation.

You may have noticed that no one else is even trying to help.


Is the AI coming to save us in the room right now?

Don’t hint at it. Lay out the mechanics of how you think AI is going to become a safety net for the average person.


lol, no. It’s currently being deployed in feverish attempt to remove jobs.

I see company doing layoffs left and right because they can do the same or more with less employees. I’m not seeing any companies feverishly hiring engineers because the productivity per hour of labor is higher.

There is also no guarantee that AI will lead to any social safety net, they are orthogonal concepts.

The only thing that would lead to a social safety net is political will and currently all the political will behind the technology firms building AI appears to be firmly behind dismantling democracy and becoming oligarchical leaders of their little fiefdoms while the rest of us can get fucked.


Who?


Two questions: 1. Have the "fud-spreaders" actually held anything back so far? Seems like we're barreling forward, even though some of the FUD spreaders appear to be in charge of the main companies. 2. Do you, like Huang, see absolutely no risk in our current approach? Is everyone who disagrees with your perspective on this subject just plain wrong? Misguided, or actively malicious/in bad faith?


Have the "fud-spreaders" actually held anything back so far?

I don't know. Astroturf campaigns to subvert data center construction seem to have had an impact, for example, but ultimately I can only fall back on vague vibes picked up from the news and social media. I don't know the specific success rate.

Some of those campaigns seem justified to me (why in the world do these things have to be built in populated areas?) while other arguments made by the anti-data center movement are certainly propagated in bad faith (Water usage? Really?)

Seems like we're barreling forward, even though some of the FUD spreaders appear to be in charge of the main companies.

That's just so much kayfabe. Don't listen to what they say, watch what they do.

Do you, like Huang, see absolutely no risk in our current approach? Is everyone who disagrees with your perspective on this subject just plain wrong? Misguided, or actively malicious/in bad faith?

I can't speak for Huang as I don't know him personally, but he has to walk a tightrope between an infantilized POTUS with essentially unlimited power to wreck his business, and his own stockholders who have elevated his company's market cap to a level that probably doesn't make sense even to him. As far as I can tell he's just going the obvious, predictable, and safe route of trying to sell as many shovels and tents as he can while the selling is good.

I see a bigger downside in the precautionary principle than in accelerationism. We are going to face immense societal disruption due to AI over the next couple of decades. That is as unavoidable as an earthquake. It is going to happen regardless of who prevails in the political and social arguments going on today. There is no possible way that every actor in every country on Earth is going to be convinced or compelled to "pace the frontier." Consequently, all that matters is how we react, adapt, and take advantage of the new ground rules of reality.

As usual, there will be those who thrive and those who get steamrolled. But I see no reason why we won't all end up better off in the end, as with the rest of the history of technology since the invention of fire.


Several technologies have made us far worse off.


But your shoes fit a lot better if you use the fluoroscope..


For every person killed by a fluoroscope, a thousand have been saved by radiotherapy. Did you have a larger point to make?


> sell as many shovels and tents as he can while the selling is good.

sounds like, based on your next-to-last paragraph, he’ll be good on this for next couple of decades


No dude, it was an analogy. Sorry to pick on you, you're just another ignorant uninformed take in this thread, but come on. This technology is progressing at an insane rate, the shit it's doing now is science fiction from just a year or two ago, and people just keep on moving the goal posts, it's maddening. The technology is unpredictable and that in itself has risks. You must realize that the window of possibility is widening the further into the future we go! Can you pick people with epistemology you trust and see if there's anything you can learn in this moment? Can you try to challenge your own ideas instead of retreating into comfortable certitude? There are real risks here, they are worth taking seriously, and serious people are doing so!


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: