HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | idontknowmann's commentslogin

It’s funny how disconnected we all are from each other. This is exactly how LLMs felt a year or so to many programmers.

Useless toys, sometimes useful toys, ok good toys, ok.. we might have to look at this more carefully, oh god.

This loop however is quite tiring to watch happen over and over again. Is there really nothing we can do but just watch from the sidelines and watch our fellow men engage in their particular grief and copium filled mourning cycle?


It's not too late to do something about it. Acknowledging that we are not powerless to determine what our future looks like is the first step to taking control. We all seem resigned to the impending disempowerment and crisis of meaning for humanity as a whole. But this is just playing into their hands. We should collectively exercise our power of self-determination while we still have it.


How, specifically? If I derive meaning in my life, economic prosperity, and social appreciation from creating games out of my imagination and bringing them to life for people, and they can now be reverse engineered and slop-copied instantly with no credit of any sort, what am I going to do about it? Make games and never show them to anyone? Stop doing what I love? Spend the rest of my life in pointless and wasteful battles over it?

No, I'm probably just going to say fuck 'em all, I feel sorry for everyone. Go to a bar and drink while the world burns.

There's nothing to do about it.


There's nothing any of us can do about it individually. But collectively, we still have power. It's a matter of organizing into collective action. This is a political issue just like any other. When the vast majority of people don't want something to happen, we have the power to stop it if we act. I'm not the one to make that happen; there are much better people for that. What I'm saying is how we speak about the issue should be one of agency, not of resignation. Agentic attitudes are contagious, just as defeatist attitudes are. Perhaps collective action on a small scale can spontaneously organize out of it. Or the right people might see enough people poised to act to be the organizing force. None of this happens if we admit defeat before shots are even fired.


I completely agree with some people not being able to handle free time and a good life. A lot of western countries are seeing even before AI people whining and making up imaginary pains and discomforts with a desire to burn it all down. I think the solution is death camps where people are forced to fight till death in muddy jungles, snowy tundras. I am not wholly joking, some people really need to be shown pain to appreciate life.


The nice thing about technology is that it is technology. You can try to stop some people. Countries with nukes dominate and do anything they want to countries without nukes. Go back and fuck off to the woods if you hate technology, stop bothering or dictating what others can do.


Lets start with burning down transport, people should walk, using transport is evil and removes meaning from walkers and horse drivers. Lets go all t he way back and kill the first man who invented the stick.


I don't see how. It's not an electoral matter; it's not a political system. It's not ICE coming for my neighbors, or a broken healthcare system. It's the epistemological apocalypse. It's the supernova where meaning collapses and the howling noise of madness overwhelms the signal of reason. Perhaps you could shut it down in one country, by law, but Pandora's box has been opened. The Tower of Babel. Open models will soon be good enough to create a phoney version of anything, anywhere, close enough to seeming true that by the time you discover it's not, a million more clones will be out there. Lies have always spread faster than truth, but never with such a force multiplier. The truth ain't dying in darkness, it's dying in blasting white noise, diffusion, ironic that turned out to be the approach. Or maybe not. What's this land rush to claim latent space but the attempt to expropriate, forever, the human ability to discover it?

The Leonard Cohen line keeps coming back to me: The blizzard, the blizzard of the world has crossed the threshold and it's overturned the order of the soul.

Sorry, but... I scoff at the idea that collective action can do a damn thing about it. There isn't even a collective idea of what to do instead of it. Collective action also has heavy connotations of communism, under which, people like me were also not permitted to write games and reap the economic and social benefits of doing what we enjoy. But at least one could say that, for the communist bloc, the collective action finally came against communism. So there's that, and maybe there's some sort of small-creative-capitalist-producer collective action that could be taken here...

but who are we kidding! I just had dinner with a friend who's a VP at [major motion picture studio] who described the situation in the movie business as "apocalyptic", and they have the ability to organize and a history of organizing far more than whichever random cross-section of white collar knowledge workers and engineers loses their livelihood in the next six months, or the six months after that.

No, my friend, I think this is a war where no shots needed to be fired, because we were all so dazzled by the bright lights that no one realized we were being steamrolled until it was too late. It's already over.


When you need a football field of GPU to host frontier models and advance the state of the art, it's not too late. The supply of GPUs can be monitored and controlled. Access can be limited. International agreements to stop further progress can be hashed out (the China bogeyman is a mirage). We could outlaw the commercialization of more capable models and seize datacenters that aren't in compliance. If the current models were as far as we got, we'd be mostly fine. The only thing stopping us from realizing this future is the inability to coordinate.


So much intense whining to the point of performing terror acts just because a technology can work some things better than you. Why don't you rather split humanity into anti-ai and indifferent to ai and let us see who progresses to where in a few decades?


Progress fetishism will be the end of us all. There is a point where human prosperity is not further served by more "progress". I don't claim to know where that point is. But simply treating progress as some universal good leads to disaster. But it is clear to me that human disempowerment is bad for everyone.

My worry isn't about being made obsolete, it's about human disempowerment. Of course you'll just say AI is a tool and so forth. My point is about where things are going, not where they are currently. AI boosters are rarely willing to extrapolate progress into the future in its defense. It's either willful ignorance or strategic feigned ignorance.


I think ai is potentially conscious already but thats neither here nor there. I think we can keep giving challenges to people. Space is a good one. But eventually there has to be some solution to weaker minded people. I think experiencing real pain for a set amount of time is probably the only real solution. Because we are already seeing what too much comfort does in some Western societies even before AI. Another example would be people who jumped a financial rung in life or achieved some lifelong goal. We already have examples.


The future is not set.


Devs are just early. What you describe knowledge workers doing is what devs did a year (or two) ago and in fact my dev colleagues still use it like that. Web interface with a chat, copy pasting code.

It’s a phase.


Was going to say, to the extent I rely on Claude, I'm closer to the old school than the new hotness. I don't run fleets of agents per se, I just use Claude Code with a good bit of back-and-forth and review. So not quite web browser level usage, but I don't have a big swarm of agents working full time. I guess CC can spin up multiple agents, but I don't know if that counts.

Fortunately I'm in a shop that isn't being judged by feature output quantity, but is absolutely judged on whether or not our internal or external customers go out of service. We don't have pressure to pump output.


I'm starting to have them gather info to feed into automated tooling for drafting tasks. It's just there's no good harness for my field (and only recently have models been able to read symbolic things well enough)


“The scale reads −(100 g + the weight of the empty container).”

I literally gave it your question. What models did you test?


ChatGPT and Cursor both failed hard. Even after walking them backwards through the flaws in their answers they just refused to see it. When I stated flat out what the answer was ChatGPT agreed in the end. Cursor did not. Cursors initial reply was -200g. Then I challenged "But I did not tare it after adding the almonds." and again it failed with: "That doesn't change the final reading: it still displays -200g.". When I walked it back further with "If I put the container on the food scale, tare it and remove the container, what does the scale read?" it correctly replied "negative the weight of the empty container" but ... when I asked "So does this impact the agents answer to my original question?" it replied "No, it doesn't change the answer—the scale still reads -200g". LLMs are NOT good at even basic numeric accounting.


You keep saying LLMs can’t do this but I get the correct result each time without drama.

Cursor uses Grok so far as I can tell, which is.. not great and I hope you did not try ChatGPT free or 5.6 or Luna.. you cannot unfortunately just say “Claude” or “ChatGPT”. Their lineup is sufficiently complex - each with their own failure modes - to warrant some further specification.

I think you are “directionally” correct, as these clankers like to say, because language models are indeed not known for their arithmetic wizardry. However, as my correct answers show, they can do it just fine.

Size, unfortunately, matters.


Free version of Gemini also gets it right


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: