HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | holbrad's commentslogin

I can make it's usage fit inside my companies budgets and it produces noticeably better code that Sol 6.1 and needs less handloading because of that.

If the code doesn't matter and it's not that hard, Sol is fine and much cheaper.


Their recently released S-1, though I don't think they do a detailed breakdown.


They state their operating cash flow and their capex. FCF is defined as OCF-Capex


I couldn't agree more around the ideological friction slowing things down, especially code review. I'd be really curious to get people's thoughts.

Personally I do code review, it's what we do at my workplace, and we regularly improve the agents' code and design though human review, even with Opus 5.5.

But looking at some of the people who are pushing AI development the furthest, I do see the trend towards it just not being that useful anymore.

Real world example:

I use T3Code as my agent orchestrator and it's consistently pretty high quality and works well + regularly gets new useful features.

And with just a handful of maintainers, they're doing anywhere from 100 to 200 PRs a day!

And there are a ton of users of their nightly, which is a rolling 5-hour release, and nothing really breaks. And they have more real-world users than almost all the projects I've worked on before.

So I just can't really in good faith say that this extremely challenging to my world view.


I think there are certain parts of certain products where the implementation details are really important, or where you need to make sure the behavior is fully reviewed/understood, or some invariant maintained. In some places that's the entire job and in other places almost none of it.

If you're running tons of product/UX experiments code review is just going to waste everybody's time. But the volume of changes you can make now is so large, someone could touch something important about at any given time without proper oversight.

IMO an effective team has to be able to either trust each other enough/be accountable enough that code review is mostly unnecessary, or everybody just works really independently on mostly separable things, or you regularly pair/mob-program.

If you can trust your colleagues not to pump out code without messing it all up or turning everything into slop, or creating large amounts of work for other people, things are great. Realistically most dev teams have a wide range of skills and personalities and people also make mistakes, and code review helps us build shared knowledge and collaborate.

Maybe there is too much of a moral hazard from the reviewer's role as a cosigner, or some people are only as conscientious as necessary to get things done (not a problem writing every line by hand)... but people can ruin code review for everyone else by demanding an asymmetric level of accountability/judgment and oversight.

The bigger issue for me is whether or not you still do code review, you need to build shared knowledge within teams. I really think we should be reviewing our colleagues' coding agent session logs

Not even to critique them (but that could be useful), but just to understand what it is they are actually trying to do/what mental model they're operating under, and if there are issue in the PR, what miscommunication or technique or process could help fix it? I think a lot of people feel that asking to see those logs is invasive or embarrassing, but the problem is that it's just really hard to build a model for how someone works or thinks without it. You don't need that in a deontological sense, but you do if you want to fix coordination problems.


This is such a hilarious comment when we've literally just had Sol 6 and Opus 5.5 drop that are massive wins for efficiency. I mean, how out of touch can you be? Especially if you think power saving and efficiency come from local AI enthusiasts. What a fucking joke.


I was under the impression that GitHub Copilot was much more expensive because you're always paying API rates?


Enterprise pays API rates everywhere afaik. Our Claude Enterprise is pay per token too. Maybe some volume deal idk.


it's expensive as hell


That's only true if you're paying API prices, but you really, really should be using the subscriptions. Both the personal and business ones are still really good value.


Well, we're stuck between a left-wing party and a left-wing party, both of whom, despite what they say, hate economic growth and try to restrict it at every opportunity.

And that's largely because the average Brit has terrible beliefs that actively make them poorer. A shockingly high percentage of people believe that building more houses won't lower costs.


I live in amerifatland. They're building new houses all the time, everywhere I look, entire complexes of them. "McMansions," we call them.

I make average US wages, have my entire adult life. I cannot afford a house in my city unless I buy a literal ruin in the ghetto. The suburbs are far more expensive, and that's where the McMansion complexes are. I don't know who's buying them, but it isn't me and likely never will be.


That's because we regulate growth. Seriously. It's exactly the same root cause. Have you heard about why zoning drives up housing prices?


Do you want a strip club or a dispensary to open up next door to where you live? Or maybe a glue factory down the street? There are reasons zoning laws exist, and it isn’t to regulate growth in the sense you’re implying.

Very disingenuous counterpoint.


When people talk about zoning ruining things, they're talking about restrictions on housing. A good system would get rid of 95% of those.

Also corner shops should be allowed everywhere.


Yes, all those things are fine.

People should be able to build where they want.

We can have reasonable restrictions around noise and pollution, but not on the land use itself.


99.9% of the work done in zoning is about restricting housing. And no, you shouldn't be allowed to stop any of those things, you can regulate any negative impacts directly if you like.


Actually, yes. I would unironically like the first two things, and what's the issue with the glue factory?


Smell


We already regulate bad smells separately. You can't operate a new glue factory without capturing it.


A shockingly high percentage of people don't want house prices to fall.


Left-wing in what sense? Who is opposing building houses?


Home owners


For left-wing governments in Britain, building houses is putting yourself out of a job.

Scotland is a good example: every government since the mid-2010s has been elected on the explicit promise to build more houses, they cannot do so because of the electoral consequences so they attempt to build council houses, it is impossible for the government to build enough council houses to make up for multiple decades of underbuilding (this problem has accelerated significantly whilst they have been promising to build housing, had explicit targets, etc.), but at the next election they make the same promises (and people vote for them because there is no alternative).

The really strange thing is that people also see the massive growth in student housing in Scotland. Again, very good for politicians: more conservative foreign students can't vote, domestic students will vote left-wing.

The politics of this topic are very strange. The public is still at the stage where they think in vague terms that the problem is a lack of housing.

I believe the problem is worse in Scotland because the growth in council housing in the 60/70s was organised in order to create this permanent bloc vote. The same has happened in London where you have whole constituencies where 70% of the effective vote is void.


> every government since the mid-2010s has been elected on the explicit promise to build more houses, they cannot do so because of the electoral consequences

This doesn’t add up. Promising to get more housing built is getting these people elected, but they can’t make good on this promise because then they will lose their election?


It depends what you mean by add up. Logical? No. Reality? Yes.

Politicians continue with the lie that they will build council houses. Voters continue with the lie that voting will change the outcome.


> The really strange thing is that people also see the massive growth in student housing in Scotland. Again, very good for politicians: more conservative foreign students can't vote, domestic students will vote left-wing.

That's a conspiracy theory and a half!

A lot of the new student accommodation being built is privately owned. They're chasing the (pre-Brexit/pandemic) overheating market for student accommodation that resulted from the universities targeting international students for the inflated tuition fees they can charge, and in some cases have features explicitly advertised to international students as positives (e.g. some of the ones in Nottingham have built in rice cookers as standard).

However, some of the properties are at risk of becoming unviable (i.e., lying empty or having to be turned over to housing non students [0]) because of a combination of Brexit and tightened immigration rules reducing international student numbers.

If they're being built as some kind of social engineering it would be a really convoluted way of going about it.

0: https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/ce3l09p664ro


>truly air-gapped environments

I don't think people have given much thought about just how hard this would be for large AI models, that need super powerful hardware/cooling etc.

Are you going to air-gap your entire data center?


You don't need data center for inference. Even largest models run on a single server. You need data center for training; or for serving millions of users. Evaluating the model is neither of those.


Why not?


>token-hungry model

It's kind of funny how this is the exact opposite of the truth. It's one of the most token-efficient models ever.

The claims aren't bullshit. Every conceivable benchmark and test you can throw at it shows Sol being good for token efficiency.


It's highly dependent on workload

If Astra is per benchmarks so much more token efficient than Sol, why did they limit its use in ChatGPT to ~16% as many messages compare to Sol? When Sol is 40% the price of Astra, why do they give Sol Pro (in ChatGPT) 6x as many tasks?

If it were strictly true that token efficiency makes Astra cost around the same per task as Sol then there'd be no need to limit it to 16% as much access.

It's because per-task token use is highly variable, not as universally true as you claim


As someone from the UK, Techy, nerdy people can know, but normies don't.

Also, I'd add that gym bros definitely have heard of them, especially if they are familiar with steroids.

The GLP-1 drugs are probably the main cause of this. We have this amazing class of compounds that work really well, But are priced pretty high, at least considering lower UK wages.

So there is a big incentive to look at getting these much cheaper from China. You hear about this happening, and then you see the fact that these companies have big catalogues full of other peptides that are a crypto payment and a click away.


I strongly suspect that peptide use is more common amongst the botox/filler crowd than techies in the UK. Most aesthetics clinics have been pushing peptide-based skincare for years, so it was only a small step into injectables for them.

And, as you say, the gym performance / sports crowd.

The BBC and the Guardian have covered it fairly neutrally, but the likes of the Daily Mail and gossip mags have been both more frequent and more breathless.


Not just clinics, but mainstream skincare and cosmetics companies have been doing topical peptide products for the past 10 years. You can get a peptide serum from a drugstore for ~$30.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: