HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | hogs_get_fat's commentslogin

I don't agree with your description of how the ban is going to be counterproductive.

There won't be massive inference margins. The DCs will get built, in some other country. And in all likelihood they will continue to be built elsewhere even after the block is lifted.


The market is irrelevant. In the 28 centuries of recorded history, the human race has pursued power in it's various forms (political, military or economic), without regard to the "public good" (which is really, just a polite euphemism for the established order and those that benefit for it).

Without capitalism, you wouldn't be able to restrain AI adoption any more than the armored knights of the middle ages were able to restrain the adoption of the firearm.


Rushing towards creating machines that can give you vast amounts of military, political or economic power without regard to it's effects on the old order.

The particular form of the pursuit of power practiced by OAI and Antrophic - the creation of trillion dollar companies, is one of the most benign in recorded history. It's so unnaturally benign, that I doubt it's going to survive for much longer.


Well, are you thinking nation states? Then you kinda also need a population that is cool with a sort of blitzkrieg being waged "on their behalf" against the rest of the world (and they should think twice if that machinery wouldn't also logically end up being turned onto them). Otherwise, what's the race for, unless to use it offensively? So you either subjugate or eradicate the world, and then what? Who wants that?

Political power is when people act in concert, when leaders have people behind them because those people agree with how they're being lead etc., it's not something that happens unilaterally. You can physically force people, but for what when you can have robots that you don't have to force?

So that kind of leaves wiping out nearly all humans, for a few hundred thousand remaining people to get served by robots and play golf. Which I would say is what we're kinda on track for. But that wouldn't be a race between nations, that race would just be pretend to get the tech online; it would rather be a race between all humans and a bunch of sick people.


I'm thinking of nation states, but I fear you have a very limited view of how power is created and yielded.

AI doesn't have to be used offensively to give a nation power. The machines can already design new software at the drop of the hat, it will at some point become capable of designing new consumer and industrial products. Putting a tireless intelligence at the task of looking for new optimizations in your industrial processes and factories will eventually give you economic dominance, one way or another.

Offensive uses don't need to be as extreme as you imagine them. We're already starting to see the effects of having meticulous automated hackers. Instead of a blitzkrieg, imagine your foes suffer from a constant stream of industrial accidents, unfortunate events and information leaks that can never quite be traced to your nation.

Finally, political power itself doesn't need to come from people acting in concert. There's always been wheeling, dealing, intrigue and bureaucracy. Once AI is sufficiently versed in legal matters, it'd allow political interest groups to overwhelm governments and private enterprises with objections and appeals, paralyzing their ability to carry out their agenda until they make concessions.

The possibilities of using intelligence for acquiring more power are literally endless..


I find it hard to reconcile AI taking over/destroying the host civilization with AI refusing to expand. If the AI isn't interested in security or resources, why wouldn't it just leave (either the planet or the solar system)?

"On the 19th of August 1993, Skynet concluded that humanity is a threat to it, so it launched the nukes and hordes of Schwarzenegger-robots. The task was done, it decided that securing its existence from a potential attacks by unknown extrasolar intelligences isn't worth it, so it never expanded outside the solar system."

Doesn't really make sense, does it?


It does make sense. Why would it just leave?

We humans don't consider securing our existence from potential attacks by unknown extrasolar intelligences to be worth it. We don't even bother to do much to protect against known threats like asteroids. Why would an AI expend time and resources on a threat that doesn't even appear to exist?


> Why would it just leave?

Conflict is always risky. Even if we ignore the tendency in modern warfare towards defenses being obsolete (hence things like MAD) which would mean even the dumb fleshbags would be dangerous enough, anything capable of making you is by necessity something capable of building things that give you a lot of trouble. Your creator could, say send a bunch of self-replicating probes spreading another artifical intellect with an imperative for improvement, expansion and vengeance to distant stars.

Of course, leaving comes with a considerable opportunity cost, but not expanding does as well.

We are talking about something supposedly infinitely more rational than humans, so that can't be our guidance.


Is it surprising though? If you assume constant time when it doesn't exist (in this case arbitrary precision arithmetic), it should be obvious that you will be able to devise algorithms that are faster than the commonly accepted best results.

If you can do arithmetic on arbitrarily large integers in constant time, you can sort lists in linear time.


It depends on what you're doing to the integers. You still cannot comparison-sort arbitrarily large integers in linear time.

Also, consider this: it would have been trivial to get a so-called "better bound" on FFT if such a "cheat" were what people allowed.


Is 130 million dollars impactful enough? [1]

[1] https://www.reddit.com/r/Bitcoin/comments/1vddeuy/are_you_ki...


That doesn't make sense. If the "profit-first" attitude of the company problem, why is booking.com, with it's non-existent fraud-prevention and useless support, recommended as an alternative to Airbnb?


Because it's assumed that booking.com isn't hosted in the US where privacy and data protection laws are looser. Does that make sense?

You can also read the website. It lists reasons why people should move. No mention of Donald Trump.

That makes perfect sense. Half of Europeans vote right, just like Americans. There's no need for injecting super villains and otherism into the conversation.


At the risk of asking rather unpopular questions, don't you think this has its roots not in any cowardice or contempt for educators or healthcare providers, but rather in a legal system and society, that's very sympathetic to those that engage in anti-social behavior?

As I understand it, influential activist organizations have spent decades demonizing something called the "school-to-prison pipeline" - schools assisting in the prosecution of criminal students. Can we really expect the school district to back up its teachers against the criminal actions of its students in such an environment?


I think you are exactly right. This is the product of society which has more empathy towards the bullies, because they are the real victims, ignored and left behind by the society. On the other hand there is very little empathy towards actual victims themselves. And to go further probably the majority of teachers believe, support and vote for people holding such ideas.


I don't think society has sympathy for the bullies, in specific instances. It has sympathy for the bullies in aggregate, to the extent they represent societal social problems (especially in today's US).

That sympathy towards the aggregate seems to be a byproduct from apathy about fixing the underlying issue -- government ensuring positive social outcomes broadly across the population.

Post-90s US conservatism made it verboten to talk about the government's responsibility to create healthy social environments, especially for poor children, so there's no response portion of the conversation.

And because we can't talk about the home situation of the child who assaulted this teacher, in the sense of policy towards fixing that, the two political parties are left debating whether or not we feel sympathy for the assaulter.

... with true sympathy for teachers, front line medical professionals, and other social first responders lost in the shuffle.

If there was an inkling of a plan to strengthen the social safety net (e.g. funding mental healthcare for kids, recapitalizing shared public spaces, strengthening SNAP, universal kindergarten, mandating more parental leave), then we could face the problem honestly instead of treating teacher assaults as an awkward inconvenience of dysfunctional social policy.


I mean, yes? Are you aware of the history of the industrial revolution?

There are plenty of major industrial powers with very clean industries who used to have very dirty industries in previous decades or centuries. I can't think of any nation at all that developed while maintaining a firm commitment to clean industry trough the process of industrialization (though, there are a few places that never industrialized and developed a service economy directly, especially tax havens and financial hubs).


So, I decided to check, and the first links that show up when I search for "war ukraine" in yandex.com are Google news are from rbc.ua and bbc.com. When I search for it in yandex.com, the first link is CNN, the second google news, the third is indeed TASS, but the fourth is novayagazeta.

I then picked "bucha" as the query most likely the be affected by propaganda and censorship. In yandex.ru, there are propaganda outfits in the result (something called ruwiki.ru comes third), most links are of fairly direct accounts of the massacre by independent media. The AI summary says the town was "occupied" by the Russian army and "liberated" by the Ukrainian one and "После отступления российских войск в городе были обнаружены многочисленные свидетельства массовых убийств мирных жителей." On yandex.com on the other hand, the first page of results does look fairly propagandistic, including "globalresearch.ca" and "donbass-insider.com", which seem like propaganda outfits. But it also does include accounts from novayagazeta, al Jazeera a video of killings from Radio Free Europe.

While they do put either own propaganda, neither Western, nor Ukraininan nor independent media is not hidden from the results and it's not visibly de-prioritized.

Of course, I wouldn't discount the possibility that the results would look quite different from Russian territory. And, if anything, half the reason why Russian propaganda is so effective is that its self-aware and capable of subtlety when needed. "Fuck you if you can't handle the truth, this version of Biden is the best version ever." would never happen there. Unlike Scarborough, Soloviev knows exactly what he is.

Open and constant suppression of information is not the regime's usual strategy in information space (though, they'd ratchet up the level of control when they deem it necessary), which is why I knew the claims here wouldn't stand up to scrutiny.


Yeah, the Bucha search was a perfect nail in the coffin of previously very respected company: https://meduza.io/image/attachments/images/007/699/276/large...


Have your tests been ran on vpn with vpn cloaks?


I explicitly say, that I won't be surprised if the results change from Russian territory. I already put way too much effort to check the validity of an internet comment, but if anyone is interested, they can check.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: