HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | hedgerow-dev's commentslogin

Great input, thanks! My next step is to deploy on a normal ISP and not on a cloud provider. Just let it sit there. I think we should give back to those companies as much as possible. OT is not where the big money is and all security experts are flocking to. I've already started some actions in this direction btw.

The more people that can deploy it, the higher the chance of discovering something about the attacks. Also this gave me an incentive to look deeper into the real software.

Agreed, that's the real fix. The honeypot is just to see who's looking while they're still out there.

New ideas are popping up. I started with fridges because of the recent attacks, but the code makes it easy to add personas. Electric car charing stations and coffee machines were my initial idea, but HVAC and building controllers are probably better ideas. Thanks!

An extra insight, there was some news of 'blood banks' also being targetted. This is possibly a stronger (painful) target. It would demorelize people that are donors. https://www.independent.co.uk/tech/security/blood-hack-fridg...

Why would it, scarcity generally motivates

[flagged]

> fluid market

Heh.


Plot twist: the hackers are members of the Van Helsing Society and the supermarkets were just a trial run in their war against the International Vampire Cabal.

One thing keeps coming back, (and it's the story of industries where security and patching is an afterthought).

a supermarket has no security team. If a fridge controller needs patching, a VPN and a strong password to be safe, that work has to come from the vendor or installer by default. One would hope that all these come by default or as a feature on these devices. It could even be a selling feature and not part of an expensive maintenance contract. A supermarket manager cannot be expected to do this work.


This is how it should work: supermarket wants to use high tech stuff such as connected fridges, they get a cyber insurance policy as part of all the other insurances they have. The insurer then has domain experts to figure out what the insured needs to do to meet a risk threshold (or they adjust fees accordingly).

This model has worked fine for many other types of risks.


In practice this insurance (which already exists!) just creates another compliance checklist and not a meaningful focus on actual security.

That's a problem for the insurance company (in a simplistic way): if they aren't efficient, they'll eventually get replaced by a company which is.

Obviously, the incompetent insurance company will entrench itself by lobbying for laws / making it harder for other companies to compete / get bailed out by a state or country when they fail.


Or, more likely, they will make a compliance checklist that is sufficiently difficult to comply with fully they'll have a means to deny most or all of the claims against the policy. I don't think the insurance industry is very efficient.

Many of these supermarkets are part of big brands but operate independently. I doubt cyber insurance is top of mind for those small owners

It will be soon. How many refrigerated cases of product can they afford to lose?

Not to mention other ways cyberattacks can paralyze their business, eg. their POS system

If they want to. They're also free to not insure.

That seems pretty location dependant. In Australia at least the two major supermarket chains are not insignificant (e.g. EBITDA ~$5 billion and ~$2.6 billion) and have large internal tech and cyber teams.

I think this is more indicative of the plethora of technical debt and straight up technical negligence that's accompanied the past 10-15 years of internet connected everything. What's happening today is the predictable result of project based works funded by capex deploying assets (of all types) with no consideration of opex funding for the technology components.

Just because a webserver is running in some physical device (fridge, camera, vacuum, washing machine, pump controller, lighting system, audiovisual equipment, access control system etc) does not magically exempt it from the same sort of ongoing sysadmin and maintenance you'd expect as a baseline for something running on standard compute. That applies equally to manufacturers publishing firmware, and the asset owners/service companies that have the responsibility to apply.


Agree with all of what you're saying, wholeheartedly.

But I keep coming back to: why do supermarkets need networked freezers anyway? Most supermarkets are open most days, with long hours. Can't any adjustments just be done manually by staff on the rare occasions when that is needed? I've seen some people argue that the major usecase is defrosting. But when you're defrosting, you certainly have lots of people on site engaged in emptying the fridge in question. Surely flipping the thermostat is a rounding error as far as costs go?


Networking freezers is good for:

* continuous monitoring and logging of the freezer's temperature (supermarkets are obliged to do so)

* sending alerts when something's off

Regarding the defrosting: Commercial freezers can defrost while the groceries stay in, just like the "No-Frost" freezer at home.


Monitoring/logging/alerting can all be done without storing the network connected computer up to anything that can change the temperature settings. It can and should be a completely separate system.

Also, networked != internet reachable.

Of course. I should have phrased myself differently, sorry.

These are read-only operations. I'm talking about the write operation of changing the thermostat setpoint. I'm saying it's a meaningless feature.


I work at a company that sells security software, and one of our customers is a major grocery chain. They definitely have a security team, I’ve talked to them.

It's most certainly a form or hybrid warfare. While being very easy to perform, it's still quite effective. Empty supermarkets and supply chains being disturbed. Hopefully this is a wakeup call for the industry.

> Hopefully this is a wakeup call for the industry.

Would be nice but none of the other events has been.

It seems like something horrific is going to have to happen before this is taken as seriously by government and private orgs as it should have been, that seems to be how it works with other stuff historically.


I agree, I rushed this one a bit. Glad to share with the industry at least.

TBH, I think at this point it is the "holier than thou" people pointing out every instance of slightly AI sounding text that are getting annoying.

I was happy reading you post and I imagine there are many many more people like me than the grinch.


Thanks! To be honest, using AI helps 'gettings things out' instead of shelving it because it's never perfect.

While it might help you get things out faster, it's still counter to this one fundamental rule:

If you couldn't be bothered to write it, I can't be bothered to read it.


I have met super intelligent people who speak multiple languages but need a bit of help writing stuff in English.

I have no idea who you are, but I would rather give you the benefit of the doubt then try to get a dopamine hit by attacking you.


> I think at this point it is the "holier than thou" people pointing out every instance of slightly AI sounding text that are getting annoying.

I don't think it's unreasonable to spend literally 3 minutes writing your own submission. I'm not asking to rewrite every code comment.

And it wasn't "slightly" AI sounding text. It's very obviously AI.


My view is that some companies installing this have not implemented any defense in depth and cut corners all around. Installing a firewall with a simple vpn service would probably have prevented lots of pain (unfrosting). In general we also see almost every security expert working at banks or other high paying companies and not for supermarkets. My feeling is that this 'niche' is probably interesting to spend some 'tokens' and time on.

At this point the honeypot I'm running is not marked as honeypot. Guess that it's a good sign?

What I meant is that I'd find some way of ensuring that I'd want to ensure that the responses you're serving up are real. If you are happy with what you have, we're good.

[flagged]

Did AI write this comment?

The comment, and the Show HN post.

> Default logins open a fake store dashboard with defrost buttons, so you see the second move, not just the first. Nothing behind it is real.


The tell is the biggest tell. xD

Danfoss was misspelled, so probably not.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: