HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | hardbass's commentslogin

What is pain in a human? What if I find the neural activations that cause pain and activate it in you? I think its hard or impossible to know from outside, some might say, but you just read out some electrical signals so what, so I prefer to keep the view that be cautious about mistreating anything you might think has a good chance of being conscious.

That depends on if you believe brain in a box can exist or not. We can bit by bit replace all the sense organs and muscle inputs of a dog with the neural signals that feed its brain. Then what? Is this dog alive? This dog stops doing anything if we leave it, does it mean its not alive?

A 40V line is only that which is a 40V line. ENd of story, nothing more to see. Problem solved.

I don't know if you have any self realization. I can beat you all I want, you will make some really funny noises. Obviously a simulated machine noise. I will continue hitting you because I see no issue in hitting an object without consciousness.

Yes, I dont give a shit about inflicting suffering to xyzparetimexyz because I am not it, whatever thing a xyzparetimexyz is.

Yes definitely, some people are p zombies. Also some people have an imaginary running unicorn in their head that doesn't interact physically at all, but somehow they do, and they are real people and people without the unicorn are not real people.

And perhaps in some people that little unicorn leaps to conclusions and responds to online posts before fully appreciating the nuances of the post they're responding to...? ;p

The unicorn cannot ever be detected, but it exists. You see some people have unicorns some don't . The unicorn makes no difference whatsoever to anything.

And perhaps in some people that little unicorn leaps to conclusions and responds to online posts before fully appreciating the nuances of the point being made..?

Worse, "philosphers" like this have choice quotes demonstrating complete lack of understanding of Turing computation such as assuming we can already hypercompute or quotes like these genius passages:

>The sharp division between software and hardware in modern computers is imposed by human design, following Turing’s principles.

Another even more "genius" passage:

>This matters because the idea of the brain as a meat-based (universal) Turing machine rests precisely on this sharp separation of scales, on the substrate independence that motivated Turing’s definition in the first place. If you cannot separate what brains do from what they are, the mathematical marriage of convenience starts to fall apart, and there is less reason to think of biological wetware as there simply to implement algorithmic mindware.

Any "philosopher" of consciousness who can't do basic thermodynamics and theory of computability should be completely ignored and laughed out the room.


Yes, a very painful and unpleasant electrical response. Would you mind if I shock you?

Found a gem of a quote from there:

>The sharp division between software and hardware in modern computers is imposed by human design, following Turing’s principles.

Another even more "genius" passage:

>This matters because the idea of the brain as a meat-based (universal) Turing machine rests precisely on this sharp separation of scales, on the substrate independence that motivated Turing’s definition in the first place. If you cannot separate what brains do from what they are, the mathematical marriage of convenience starts to fall apart, and there is less reason to think of biological wetware as there simply to implement algorithmic mindware.

Any "philosopher" of consciousness who can't do basic thermodynamics and theory of computability should be completely ignored and laughed out the room.


That's painful to read.

Imagine opining so much about a topic and getting the basics so wrong.

What a dreadful article.


As often I suspect some supernatural hangup is behind all this.

I do not grant andsoitis consciousness, it is just a tool for use.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: