A functional modern civilization needs to reward workers and smart people (often these are the same people - I don't mean "smart people" as in academic geniuses, though they are a subset of smart people), especially those who give a shit. Money is part of that, but is nowhere near the whole picture. We have been slowly reducing worker rewards for many decades, and we started doing the same for smart people in the past decade or two (AI has just been an excuse to accelerate the reduction, it's not the cause).
The key thing is, you need to reward these people regardless of the reason. You need to figure out what your citizens can do to earn the reward, but what they end up doing is not actually the final goal, but rather a means to the more abstract end of fulfillment. That such means have historically had useful side effects (like producing everything we use) just made it easy to avoid having to think about this problem much.
A worker or smart person who gives a shit, but is miserable, is not useful.
>What Israel did in Gaza may well go down in history as the most humane and precise urban warfare environment the world has ever known—the very opposite of genocide.
I have no motivation to label what they are doing as "genocide", but this seems flatly untrue. I'm a little astonished to see this degree of speech about such a complicated issue on HN (it brings to mind Trump's absurdist word choices).
You are evidence for one of the most ruthless and successful propaganda campaigns in human history.
What I wrote is true. Yet even somewhat reasonable people have been so convinced of the opposite of the truth that they consider even the most obvious facts that dispute The Narrative as so beyond-the-pale as to be not even worthy of consideration, never mind discussion.
I'm happy to believe that they have done a better job at minimizing civilian casualty than is the popular image, but this doesn't seem to refute my comment (or convince me that you're coming at this from a holistic place).
Yah they literally just razed the entire city to the ground. Before and after pics make it obvious, which is why Izreal fought so hard to stop any pics from getting out. Before: a city. After: a desolate wasteland of rubble.
That's a pretty tepid example, frankly. Arguably that is a neutral definition of Zionism. And arguably it is not. Either way, it certainly doesn't represent unreasonable anti-Israeli sentiment to the degree you are implying.
When a ethnic/cultural/religious group of people have sins to be documented, it is an almost intractable problem how we describe those sins neutrally. But your example is comfortably within the window of reason, considering the problem space. Your conclusions are too dramatic, in this light.
I don't think the definition is necessarily racist, except in the casual sense where we tend to over-apply the word. Regardless, this seems like a semantic argument. Which is fine, I don't have a strong feeling about what exactly the word "zionism" maps to, but it does mean there is no "right" answer until usage dictates one, and clearly usage is in flux at this point in history.
> Again, that's not the issue discussed under this current article.
You brought the definition of Zionism up, now it's off-topic. Huh.
> It seems like you yourself think that the definition should bias the reader against Zionism and Israel.
Should a reader of https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hamas be neutral on the subject after reading? Should every Wikipedia article be held to this standard, that you end the read with zero feelings for/against the subject? Should the article on Hamas leave you (correctly) biased against them?
> And given the fact that the definition was modified in this manner during the current war, it's clear that there are editors on Wikipedia with an anti-Israeli agenda.
Or, starting a giant regional set of wars of aggression and flattening Gaza and having prominent Israeli government officials get all genocidey in their public statements added some new evidence.
The Wikipedia articles are factual though. That’s like saying Wikipedia is anti-Nazi because it portrays them in a bad light. No, it’s that Israel’s actions are abhorrent and Zionists don’t like to see their reflection, especially when they know others can see it too.
Your quote is totally irrelevant to whether or not Zionism is a racist policy - including Arab parties in the coalition is a political consideration. A key characteristic of the Arab parties is their priority of the non-Israeli Palestinian cause. And their lack of support for what most Israeli Jews consider to be necessary security measures.
If the Arab parties in Israel exclusively focused on the wellbeing of Israeli arab communities, and didn't function as a mouthpiece for what many Israelis consider to be the enemy - that 70 percent would go down significantly. Sure, it would never reach zero, like in any country there will always be racists and bigots, but it wouldn't be anywhere near as unanimous as it is right now.
Case in point, none of the Arab parties will openly call Hamas a terrorist organization - which most Israeli Jews consider to be fact. Whether or not you agree with that assessment, it should be clear why Israeli Jews would be reluctant for Arab parties to join a coalition during a time of war against said terrorist organization..
> If the Black people in the American South exclusively focused on the wellbeing of Black communities, and didn't function as a mouthpiece for what many white people consider to be the enemy - that 70 percent would go down significantly. Sure, it would never reach zero, like in any country there will always be racists and bigots, but it wouldn't be anywhere near as unanimous as it is right now.
Don't worry, it's not racist! It's just political!
> Case in point, none of the Arab parties will openly call Hamas a terrorist organization - which most Israeli Jews consider to be fact.
This analogy doesn't hold up to any level of scrutiny and I don't want to entertain it.
> Oh, you'll be happy to hear some good news.
Are you kidding me? First off, if you read the article - they haven't done it yet, they've only signaled willingness to do it. Second of all, do you think that recognizing Hamas as a terrorist organization only as part of parliamentary negotiations is going to make anyone happy?
> This analogy doesn't hold up to any level of scrutiny and I don't want to entertain it.
This response doesn't hold up to any level of scrutiny and I don't want to entertain it.
> Second of all, do you think that recognizing Hamas as a terrorist organization only as part of parliamentary negotiations is going to make anyone happy?
There it is. You set up a condition for them to meet, but admit it still won't count if they do.
Man, your approach to the political realities and nuances of the region is just so detached from reality - you're revealing your own naïvety by thinking that when people want the Arab parties to recognize Hamas as a terrorist organization, they'll be satisfied to hear reluctant words forced out as part of a cheap concession. That's not what anyone wants, this isn't a game but rather a serious matter of how a political party in the country operates and thinks.
No reasonable adult would be satisfied with that after three years of non-recognition of Hamas as a terrorist organization. Keep in mind that as you and I speak, there is no recognition from their side. Just reports of them considering it.
> you're revealing your own naïvety by thinking that when people want the Arab parties to recognize Hamas as a terrorist organization, they'll be satisfied
I am, under no circumstances, naïve enough to believe they will be satisfied with anything the Arab parties do to appease here.
I just appreciate your openly demonstrating that, in complaining they won't do something, and then indicating you won't accept them doing that thing. It helps reveal the sleight of hand.
> No reasonable adult would be satisfied with that after three years of non-recognition of Hamas as a terrorist organization. Keep in mind that as you and I speak, there is no recognition from their side. Just reports of them considering it.
Yeah, the rest of the world feels that way about your genocide denialism. (Except the reports of consideration, of course.)
> I am, under no circumstances, naïve enough to believe they will be satisfied with anything the Arab parties do to appease here.
You're wrong here. The majority of Israeli Jews are perfectly fine with Arabs like Yoseph Haddad who strive to be productive members of Israeli society. He was second place in his party, directly under a hard-right Jewish religious Zionist.
Yoseph Haddad is an outlier, but an example. Imagine an Arab party that has an unequivocal stance in favor of Israel's security, a neutral/status-quo stance on the Palestinian issue, and a relentless focus on improving the socio-economic status of Arab Israelis. You have to imagine it, because such a party has never existed. Not even close. And when it exists, it'll have no problem being a part of any coalition.
> Yeah, the rest of the world feels that way about your genocide denialism.
I don't know what country you're from, but the United States of America as a political entity - itself does not recognize the loss of life in Gaza as a genocide. Ditto for many other serious Western countries. It's a somewhat important country, with meaning and influence and processes behind its words and stances. So I don't know what you mean by "the rest of the world", tbh - you might spend your time in echochambers, but thinking it's a genocide is far from a worldwide consensus.
Biden didn't recognize it as a genocide either - and it was under his administration that the majority of the loss of life and property destruction happened. Or did the genocide to your judgement only start after Trump took office? Or is your point that all American leadership is fuckwits and you and your echochambers are smarter than everyone in charge?
> Only if they stay "exclusively focused on the wellbeing of Israeli arab communities", right? Per you?
That was poor phrasing on my part - obviously they can be focused on other things too, the underlying point is that Israeli Jews won't want them in coalitions so long as a major part of their party ethos is being against the mainline of what Israeli Jews consider to be necessary security measures.
Edit: just realized you misquoted me and I never wrote exclusively, I wrote relentlessly in the context of an imaginary party - still non-ideal phrasing but your misquote made it worse than it was.
> If the Arab parties in Israel exclusively focused on the wellbeing of Israeli arab communities, and didn't function as a mouthpiece for what many Israelis consider to be the enemy - that 70 percent would go down significantly. Sure, it would never reach zero, like in any country there will always be racists and bigots, but it wouldn't be anywhere near as unanimous as it is right now.
Not a liar... just wrong. I didn't look all the way up in the thread, I only looked at the message directly above yours. My point regarding my poor phrasing stands.
Are you kidding me? Yes, I wrote that writing "exclusively focused" was poor phrasing, softened it to non-ideal phrasing when I thought I was misquoted, and when I realized that I was accurately quoted I went back to saying that it was poor phrasing. What more do you want?
This is a long thread stretching over several hours. You quoted me writing "exclusively focused", I looked one message above and saw I wrote "relentless focus on.." which is really similar phrasing so I thought you misquoted me, because I didn't remember the message I wrote hours ago and its phrasings. So I thought it was as simple as a misquote.
> I wonder if that reflexive "no!" perhaps happens sometimes when reports come out about atrocities in Gaza.
You know, many times I've thought about the difference between Holocaust denial and "Gaza genocide denial" as you might call it.
The difference is that while Holocaust deniers will outright deny scholarly consensus statistics, or in-your-face evidence of concentration camps, etc. most "Gaza genocide deniers" - don't deny the loss of life in Gaza, or even many war crimes committed by Israel, or the destruction, etc. There's no denial of most of the evidence. Sure, there are some fake stories out there, some with agendas, etc. - but the loss of life isn't under dispute.
The difference is whether or not the loss of life is attributable to Israel, or to Hamas - and the semantic argument of whether it constitutes genocide.
"Although many international experts have accepted the Health Ministry's data as reliable, and even conservative relative to the true death toll, Israel had refused to accept the Health Ministry's count until now."
"Israel’s military has accepted the death toll compiled by health authorities in Gaza is broadly accurate, marking a U-turn after years of official attacks on the data."
"For more than two years, Israeli officials and media had attacked the Palestinian figures as “Hamas propaganda” and dismissed them as “not accurate”."
I don't know what circles you spend your time in - I've been involved in many discussions across many forums both online and in real life, I've heard many pro-Israelis, pro-Palestinians, anti-Palestinians, etc. I've never heard anyone deny the loss of life in Gaza.
Yes, I've heard people cast doubt on the exact numbers reported by the Gaza Health Ministry (which is indeed Hamas-backed) - but it's doubt along the lines of "is the reported 30,000 dead actually 20,000 dead", not "is the reported 30,000 dead actually 200 dead". I've never seen the widespread extent of the loss of life challenged by anyone. And surely to your accusations of genocide, 20,000 and 30,000 are both genocidal, unless there's some strict numerical threshold?
Casting doubt on the source of the numbers themselves - is not equivalent to denying the loss of life. The IDF delaying acceptance of the Gaza Health Ministry’s numbers is not the same as "the IDF denying widespread loss of life in Gaza".
> This is a political tautology. Anyone voting for a party is opposed to other parties being in government.
Coalitions are very common in parliamentary systems, including Israel's.
> Now do a poll of Arabs who are happy with Jews being in government.
Done! Per the article:
"According to the Democracy Index poll, 71.5 percent of the Jewish public in Israel oppose their inclusion, and 77 percent of the Arab public support joining the Israeli government."
Still not answering the question, so I'll answer it for you; a similar amount, at least 50%.
> Why are there even “Arab parties”, isn’t that racist?
If so, the widespread existence of Zionist parties would be similarly discriminatory.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dov_Khenin was a Jewish MP in one of the Arab parties in the Joint List. Has Likud ever had a Muslim MP? Or are you inventing new double standards you ironically can't even actually pass?
Sorry it is more related to AI clones. He doesn't want people cloning his ideas before his games are published. I just wanted to bring the fact that Lucas Pope had taken a stance on those clones.
I thought he wound down publishing devlogs before AI clones, were there more than the ones on https://dukope.com/devlogs/ I can try to hunt down to read?
That's what "full" means in practical terms. Obviously the parent doesn't mean "the entire city is a contiguous matrix of one-cubic-meter boxes, each with a person inside". People will have different opinions on whether it's "full", of course, based on how much they are willing to fundamentally alter the nature of the location, traffic, desirability, etc.
This is true of every location, of course. Major metros are just where the population, and acceptance of density, is highest, so it's the obvious example to look at.
You can just disagree with their opinion. I don't think you really believe that we should mock people for fighting against something inevitable, unless you disagree that the thing is bad, in which case the inevitability is not the salient part of your opinion.
The key thing is, you need to reward these people regardless of the reason. You need to figure out what your citizens can do to earn the reward, but what they end up doing is not actually the final goal, but rather a means to the more abstract end of fulfillment. That such means have historically had useful side effects (like producing everything we use) just made it easy to avoid having to think about this problem much.
A worker or smart person who gives a shit, but is miserable, is not useful.
reply