I just used Claude opus 5 high to refactor our permissions model to an hierarchical one. In the validation function, if a part of a permission grant was missing in the hierarchy, claude happily granted them approval instead of rejecting, fail open for permissions.
Always review the code an LLM creates.
(When I told Claude that this is very bad, its reply was “Good catch!”)
Tbh I'm not entirely sure I'd trust a partial plane body to have the mechanical strength for the job. In flight the pressure is pushing out not in, and I assume that's what the thing is designed for.
Though the thing is only barely buried so I suppose it doesn't actually have much external pressure to deal with.
He is pouring concrete re-enforcement around it. Biggest issue is during the pour which he seems to have planned in stages to not put too much pressure on it.
This is exactly what I need when I need it. The amount of pull requests I reviewed with a mess of codes that can be switched to 2 lines of modern features made me write such tools myself, only half assed since I have other things to do.
1 - all logic needs to be written in 1 statement. That forces you to use nested ternaries, nullish operators, and array fns where simple workflow controls would read much better.
2 - it’s designed to render html but conflicts with JS and TS, so you can’t have a class attribute, and weird escape hatches around generic fns.
If I understand you correctly, #1 is just plain wrong. JSX is transformed into standard ECMAScript[0]. You can store JSX-nodes in variables and pass them around however you like.
// this
{
shouldShowAnswer(user)
? no
:
Text Content
}
// ...can be written like this
const answer = (
no
);
const comment = (
Text Content
);
const result = shouldShowAnswer(user) ? answer : comment;
{result}
In React at least, null won't render anything.
#2 is a known trade-off, and so marginal and well known that it's almost not worth mentioning it.
It’s not wrong, this is a limitation of JSX, every interpolation needs to be a statement.
Ofcourse you can split every control flow into separate component and combine them together finally, but that means exactly that - that every minute condition or iteration is deferred elsewhere. And it makes the actual render result hard to understand.
At this point I honestly don't know what you're on about...
> every interpolation needs to be a statement
Interpolation??? JSX extends the PrimaryExpression in the ECMAScript grammar. So yeah, every JSX element/fragment is an expression, not a statement. You can't seriously consider an ECMAScript expression a limitation?
> you can split control flow into separate component[s]
You do realize that none of the variables in the example above are components, do you? They are the result of JSX elements, and if we're talking React they'd be React elements.
> combine them together [...] makes the actual render result hard to understand
So, for you, a long ECMAScript expression is a limiting factor, but composing shorter, simpler expressions into a longer, more complex one is hard to understand. Even though in your comment above you wrote:
I may have mixed between expression and statement, however in JSX {} must return exactly 1 expression, so that limits the amount of code you can place there.
Your'e missing the point arguing about semantics of components or JSX elements, the point is that if you want to avoid control flow via expressions, you must destruct you template (however simple it may be) into tiny template fragments that makes it harder to understand the complete rendered picture.
Imaging if JSX could look like this:
My list
@for(item in list) {
{item.name}
@if(item.loading){
Loading...
} @else if (item.error) {
Error loading item
} @else {
{item.description}
}
}
This is much easier than the suggested JSX approach:
The suggested JSX approach depends on the example you just made up, and EMCAScripts statements are enough, there's no need to redefine them in JSX.
My list
{
list.map((item) => {
let text = null;
if (item.loading) {
text = "Loading...";
} else if (item.error) {
text = "Error loading item";
} else {
text = item.description;
}
return (
<>
{item.name}
{text}
>
);
})
}
or (btw, I have never seen somebody creating a component for a list)
function Item({item}) {
let text = null;
if (item.loading) {
text = "Loading...";
} else if (item.error) {
text = "Error loading item";
} else {
text = item.description;
}
return (
<>
{item.name}
{text}
>
);
};
My list
{list.map(item => )}
I still don't see any limitation. The @statement-things don't read better either.
Anyway, thanks for the quick human exchange of opinions!
In my suggestion I demonstrated a theoretical approach to how I think JSX shouldve been done.
JSX eventually is not a templating engine, it’s just sugar over createComponent/createElement functions, and thats its downside, we are creating html components that need templates to render.
For 1, you're supposed to break up more complex logic like that into functions and variables, so that acts as a forcing function which works as intended. For 2, 99% of HTML is just fine, just className would be different but it's not a big deal in practice.
I know WHY it’s not possible, but that’s a design limitation of the parser being templating on top of JS, instead of a separate DSL with escape hatches for JS, like most other templating engines
It's not really a design limitation, as this way it simplifies the parser, the DSL, the templating... Basically everything. And your entire templating/parsing could be just "convert this to a function call"
> Yes, it simplifies the engine, at the cost of developer experience.
Given that its taken the world by fire and nearly everyone adopted JSX/TSX as the templating language, doesn't seem like developer experience suffered.
> Like useMemo, that now is compiled in automatically
A completely different beast, and this one definitely makes DX suffer.
The rationale was to follow the DOM property names to avoid clashing with reserved keywords; not because mirroring JS was the goal. Data attributes for example have always been data-*, readonly, contenteditable in lowercase, mirroring HTML.
I just checked the first comment about crowdstrike, and it’s not generally a negative review (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50315965). I think this app confuses a negative connotation of a post, with a mention of a product inside that post and assumes the negativity is towards the product.
Edit - I checked a few more and it’s a total crapshoot, some of the comments are just informative, not negative at all. I wouldn’t trust this list.
Watching him in Star Trek TNG made me reevaluate how management of people should be done, his character was assertive but compassionate. High morals coupled with grounded reason.
I also want to mention his hilarious role as bullock in American dad, the way he takes a role both so seriously and ridiculously makes him so fantastically hilarious.
Star Trek TNG as a whole was a masterclass on how to effectively manage a high performance team. It's a favorite watch in tech leadership circles for this reason. Every now and then I re-watch this clip of Data taking over the enterprise and the inevitable hiccups he runs into [1].
Keep in mind that Star Trek is a fictional utopia. When writing a script, one can make anything work out well.
The original Star Trek was Roddenberry's vision of utopia. The benevolent dictator always makes the right decisions. He's surrounded by his loyal band of perfect lieutenants, who apparently have zero desire to advance, and have no flaws at all. Any and all of them are willing to sacrifice themselves for the others. None do anything bad (unless it's a plot device with an explanation that absolves them).
Don't get me wrong, I've enjoyed watching ST very much. Just keep in mind that that it's a fiction.
It's a utopia, which is rare amongst sci-fi futures. Ask about sci-fi and what comes to mind first is almost always some kind of dystopia. Terminator, 1984, Deep Space 9, Star Wars, Battlestar Galactica, Blade Runner, Dune, Tank Girl, Minority Report, iRobot, Westworld, Altwred Carbon. Those aren't worlds that seem like great places to live if you're not rich! So Star Trek is much a work of fiction as the rest of those, but for all its flaws, at least is paints a mostly nice picture of the future that someone might want to live in, not crushed under the heel of a corporation. It makes sense; a story with no conflict isn't interesting, and dystopia provides for conflict. To philosophize, it's why I think we're so afraid of AI and robots and the future. It's why I wrote my book the way I did.
> It's a utopia, which is rare amongst sci-fi futures.
Utopias used to be the most common scifi futures. This is what the so called Cyberpunks (Sterling, Gibson, Cadigan, ...) rebelled against.
It used to be all about what wonders technology will bring us. By the time of the 70s it became clear that technology doesn't necessarily make everything better, but can be a burden in itself, or even widen the gap between the haves and haves not. And that is what they wrote about. It turned out to be the most popular scifi with audiences deeming it more believable.
They used to be more common maybe, but even the titular "Utopia" by Thomas More had slavery. Sometimes the "perfect" settings were imperfect due to the times they were written, often they were intentionally imperfect, and that was the point.
E.g. consider HG Wells The Time Machine, where the future start out seeming quite like an utopia but then we meet the Morlocks.
But lots of books were downright dystopian much earlier. Heck, several of the "standards bearers" for dystopias pre-date cyberpunk by a lot, like Brave New World, This Perfect Day, 1984.
Particularly stories like The Time Machine where the setting as a whole very much was revealed not to be an utopia were among the most common "utopian" settings pre-cyberpunk.
Pure utopias were very rare for a reason: They're really hard to set compelling in stories in, and so most of the ones that do exist tend to set stories on their edges and fault lines.
What changed with cyberpunk wasn't that (surface) utopias went away, or even that we get to see the imperfect underside, but that the script is flipped so that the protagonist isn't a tourist on the underside, but belongs there, and is often alienated from any seemingly perfect parts of the world they inhabit.
Compare settings that do show both sides, like The Time Machine, and a cyberpunk version of The Time Machine would probably have a protagonist that was a Morlock. The world itself wouldn't change, but we'd get to see it from the opposite POV.
> Pure utopias were very rare for a reason: They're really hard to set compelling in stories in, and so most of the ones that do exist tend to set stories on their edges and fault lines.
True, and I think Iain M. Banks specifically commented on this in interviews and essays. The Culture novels are mostly set outside of The Culture. Star Trek is mostly set on the fringes of or outside of Federation space, but especially during Roddenberry's lifetime, no matter what the crew was dealing with, they were very self-consciously people from a utopia.
Yeah, I specifically had the Culture in mind when I wrote that, because Banks seemed a lot more self-aware of that and playing with and actually telling us fun things about his utopia and trying to actively flesh it out, while to me at least it feels like Roddenberry was caught up in wanting Star Trek to be morality plays in space that had to teach a lesson to the point of getting very heavy handed with it at times (and he might be right the heavy-handedness was necessary given some of the takes I've seen on various episodes), while still telling us frustratingly little about his utopia itself.
> America's poor have a higher standard of living than medieval kings.
False Equivalence, Red Herring, Chronological Snobbery, Fallacy of Relative Deprivation, Contextomy.
So, by this logic, a homeless person with a used iPhone is better off than Louis XIV (who literally owned all of France) just because the king couldnt play Candy Crush?
This statement confuses global technological progress across centuries with an individuals actual financial security, social power, and quality of life within their own modern society.
I simply just cant understand why would someone repeat such a statement (and I have seen it everywhere).
> > America's poor have a higher standard of living than medieval kings.
> False Equivalence, Red Herring, Chronological Snobbery, Fallacy of Relative Deprivation, Contextomy.
There's a lot of reasonable arguments to unpack here.
But no, it's not that Louis XIV didn't have an iPhone, it's that the vast middle class in developed countries has central heating and access to penicillin and don't die from giving birth as much.
Also, America's poor are definitely worse off than medieval kings. They don't have access to those basic things that keep most modern people wealthier than medieval kings, like food, shelter and health care.
Some of the older (pre-medieval) king's ruins in Denmark are (by our standards) small stone houses with a moat, and what makes them remarkable is that they're made of stone, and the moat is rather big, so it keeps people out. Like metal doors in apartment buildings, sort of. (Correction for the historians: The oldest king's ruins are of course just holes in the ground where wooden beams used to stand.)
s/America's poor/Europe's lower middle class/ and you're there.
I think that we are both well aware that the statement was not about "Candy Crush" or "Louis XIV". As the "America's poor have a higher standard of living than medieval kings" was not about technological progress.
Some more thoughts for you: since 19xx workers are productive to the scale of 10x (feel free to downplay it to whatever factor over 3x as this is the minimal amount, everyone agrees on except of those that harvest the difference) against those times. But we are still working 8/8/8. Who takes the difference? Of 10x (or 3x)?
You think the biggest difference is Candy Crush? Have you forgotten about clean drinking water, plumbing, abundance of food, air conditioning, medicine, healthcare, etc?
Is there a definition of standard of living? A king would be entertaining, socialising, and strategising most of the time (along with a lot more pursuits of hunting, etc for leisure). While I understand they had less access to healthcare and variety of food, travel, etc...id still argue they had a better standard of living than someone that works 8-10h/day and then comes home to cook and clean?
America's poor today have clean water, health care, washing machines, central heating and air conditioning, flush toilets, hot and cold running water, electric lights, hot showers, fresh vegetables and fruit year round, glass windows, cotton undies, ice cream, TVs with 24/7 entertainment, talk to anyone in the world at the push of a button, need I go on?
The poor have those things because they still have some amount of power. They're still needed for work, and if you make too many of them too desperate, they can threaten the people at the top. But if you let the wealth (and power) gap get too large this will no longer be the case, and the poor might lose access to those things. If the wealth gap becomes such that the rich can afford automated production and protection but the poor can not, the current economic and political systems will no longer have a reason to give access to any of those things to the poor.
No they didn't. In castles meat wasn't very fresh at all, and food poisoning was both common and a common cause of death especially in medieval times. Which is why we have so many traditional dishes that are effectively just ways to keep food fresh and especially safe for longer. How many stew recipes did people invent worldwide, for example? Slow cooking will keep food edible for a week if you do it right. And if you really push it, for months (ie. add animal gelatin as a last step and keep cooking for 2 hours after that, at some point it will solidify and you get something that can be considered "instant soup" by extremely flexible interpretation). If you look back 100 years there are books with year-round menus, and bits of that survive. Why? To give you specific dishes when the ingredients are available according to the "agricultural calendar" as it's called in France. Christmas is great. October sucks.
The very oldest book in the bible contains the basic recipe for keeping meat fresh for ~week, and that's what Kosher, Halal, ... are really about.
And yeah, it depends. Roman emperors, for example, would have had fresh meat available whenever. Medieval kings, no way. Renaissance kings ... probably not constant fresh meat, and certainly not constant fresh fish, but a lot better than medieval kings.
> On the other hand kings had free-range organic grown meat prepared by personal cook anytime they wanted which is a true luxury even
There is no refrigeration, so "fresh" meat has to be slaughtered the same day. Kings tended to live in populated areas, so wild game would be scarce. Majority of meat would have been pork kept in pens (not free-range in the modern sense), or mutton/goat (free range, but typically older and tougher). At the same time, even a king likely wasn't slaughtering 365 pigs/year just to have fresh meat every day - lots of dried, smoked, or even salted meat in the diet...
I think it’s disingenuous to imply that there isn’t an inequality issue because the basic standard of living has advanced since the Middle Ages. Even if we compare the standard of living for say, Mississippi lower third and Uganda lower third, it’s obvious that you’re better off in Mississippi. However, the fact that the wealth and means to uplift the poor actually exists in the US but is not exercised is itself an issue - Uganda does not have that possibility.
> Even if we compare the standard of living for say, Mississippi lower third and Uganda lower third, it’s obvious that you’re better off in Mississippi.
I mean, it’s no wonder people move from uganda to mississipi (or other places in the us) and not rhe other way around.
I’m trying to understand what tokenized stocks actually mean. Where does the value come from? A stock is an actual percentage of a company’s ownership. A token of a stock is basically an NFT of a stock? The value is only from what other people are willing to pay for it?
Company A will accept funds to buy some stock like MSFT, then they will mint a token i.e. xMSFT that you'll own in a blockchain ledger. You can trade this for whatever you want but the company promises to buy any token xMSFT at MSFT price whenever you want[1]. So the tokenized asset remains pegged as long as there's trust in the institution.
Also, the company will grow a balance sheet out of the funds created by the owners of the tokens and they frequently will give you some sort of yield on your position.
[1] Open Market hours and usually accompanied by a fee.
I'm assuming that, like most crypto, the benefits are for the exchange. They don't have to purchase any Microsoft stock. They can just sell virtual stock, invest the crypto in whatever they want, and only have to pay back when people actually want to sell it. And like the fractional reserve system, they hope that only a small fraction want out at any given time.
Microsoft loses because all of that investment activity does nothing to help their valuation, but the middlemen in the crypto market take their share on each transaction.
Not a crypto person, but is it a situation where one may have crypto and wants to invest it without converting it to USD/CAD/JPY/etc.. and paying taxes on it?
Have you ever tried to actually buy and hold a stock yourself without a middlemen like a brokerage actually holding it for you? It's a very annoying and sometimes almost impossible process.
This is just a different kind of middlemen with different trade-offs.
To make a long story short, and because I'm not an expert: A similar thing kinda-sorta happens behind the scenes with retail investing anyway. When you buy and sell stocks online, often the real ownership of the stock, in the stock exchange, doesn't change hands. Instead, the stock is exchanged among customers of the same platform.
IE, if you buy and sell stocks on ETrade, most of the time the ownership with the dow doesn't change, instead the ownership within ETrade's database changes.
Shares should simply just be tokens. Why do we have that complex systems where shares can only be traded by regulated entities (brokers) and only be traded during certain times? If a share is a token, the holder of the token will be entitled to the same rights such as dividends collection and voting in the shareholder meeting. No need for brokerage accounts, I can trade my shares 24/7 and transfer it to whomever I want. Paying 2-5$ fees on trades seem backwards this day and age.
> Why do we have that complex systems where shares can only be traded by regulated entities (brokers)
Because it safeguards against fraud and tax evasion.
> Paying 2-5$ fees on trades seem backwards this day and age.
Many brokerages don’t charge for buying or selling stock. They make their money elsewhere, likely with contracts on calls/puts. But to your point, having to pay a variable rate fee for moving my Ethereum from one wallet I own to another wallet I own also seems silly. I’m certain though that in both cases the charges cover the maintenance costs to keep the platform going. Everything comes at a cost.
I didn't say anything about decentralized blockchain or anonymous tokens. We could have a kyc process and a single centralized blockchain run by the stock exchange, which only settles transactions to kyc customers - fraud prevention and tax evasion applies.
The real-time trading independent of brokerages, the free information flow of trading volume/direction etc. all benefits and a true, real free market. Right now we have mountain of unneeded intermediaries, that sit and cash in on the data and access.
Would you expect exchanges to permit everyone to trade directly? How would you police the consequences of, for example, no entry policing? How would you want to police requirements if everyone is on the exchange or some venue (e.g., around algorithms)?
But complexities of any new system aside, what is an example of a cashing in of an unneeded example in terms of an activity?
You public key is registered with a kyc progress. Transactions (transfer of shares) is only settled when all parties have a kyc-verified key. Again, centralized chain (proof of authority). Any and all transactions can be reversed and changed by the regulator if needed. The main difference over today is, you have a open, access-to-all (after kyc) and no intermediaries.
Examples for cashing in: payment for order flow (was recently banned in the EU). They litterally sold their trading data of retail clients for money.
Not sure how you think brokers make money, but they get kickbacks from market makers and fund providers, or simply higher spreads. No one works for free.
I have some fairly good understanding actually, hence my point about just data vs orders. Not sure what you want me to take from your link specifically?
Minor benefits around clearing and settlement, but these allow for 24/7 even if the clearing house is not so. On the other hand, I don’t see how they should be able to block it. It is a derivative product, can MSFT block e.g. puts on its stock? Stock ownership gives rights, not obligations.
The other thing would be using it in any other automated whatever that accepts tokens with the same interface. Loans, escrow, trades, whatever it is that someone has built.
There's a lot of technical and other issues with blockchains, but framed as "a single shared database that allows stored procedures and shared data types, with no central owner" I'd hope devs here could see something interesting to mess about with there. If it wasn't for the fact that "a currency" is absurdly easy to make and then there was a lot of quick money to be made or lost, I think it'd be liked more as an odd shared network.
If nothing else, there's some interesting programming challenges involved given the compute limits.
There’s many countries around the globe where buying US shares is either impossible or prohibitively expensive. Also composability in DeFi protocols.
For the issuer, same playbook on how stables issuers print money - you get cash that you can put into treasuries to earn “free” yield on. Works as long as rates aren’t zero.
I guess because it's easier to trade USDT for stock tokens in an Ethereum contract. Same reason USDT is on the blockchain and not just a database run by its owners, who are already centralized of course.
There are also a lot of examples of contracts with some centralization that would appear to remove the entire point of using a blockchain, but they're simple enough that the blockchain is actually easier than hosting their own API, dealing with auth, keeping ddos and hackers out, etc.
Database by itself is easy, but the rest of a public-facing exchange would be a lot of security to get right. I've seen contracts for blockchain exchanges, they're not that complicated, and the footguns have been figured out already. Once they set that up, they don't have to host anything publicly, or very little. The orders are typically matched off-chain, but their backend just talks to the chain, not end users.
The ultimate goal of tokenized stocks is that the token is a share - just represented on the public blockchain instead of in the databases of companies like Fidelity. So in this respect, it's just changing the record keeping system. We're not quite there yet, but that's the vision.
Why would you do this? Current stock trading often takes a day or so to actually settle - you execute a buy but it doesn't settle immediately. There is room for leverage and counter-party risk to live in that gap.
Tokenized stocks (or any asset) is building towards atomic on-chain settlement - you have stock in MSFT, I have stablecoins, we perform an atomic transfer where you send me MSF and I send you stablecoins. This speeds up the system and eliminates counterparty risk. We each must have the asset ready to trade at this point in time.
The benefit is faster settlement, not keeping capital locked up because of long settlement times and decreasing the space where leverage and counter-party risk can live.
Longer term - this potentially means it could be easier for non-US parties to buy US stocks. I can put my savings in the stock market, but a farmer in a developing country cannot. But with tokenized shares, they could invest in US equities - or even a fraction of a US equity if they cannot afford a full share. So this longer term vision could democratize global access to capital markets.
The mechanism is usually that you can exchange tokenized stocks for real stocks for some fee. That causes prices to be similar.
Another similar instrument is perpetuals, which are kept close to the price of the underlying by having people who hold long positions pay people who pay short positions, or vice versa, when the price deviates. (This is called funding.)
Value comes from the underlying. Of course you are carrying some intermediary risk but that's also inherent with stock brokers as well. Similar to a stablecoin backed by treasuries. Voting isn't the only value of holding stock, although some platforms have proposed passing through to token holders voting and dividend distributions as well.
One of the primary benefits for traders is 24/7 liquidity and the ability to plug the token into other products onchain, like lending markets.
Provided via email correspondence by SIPC investor services:
"SIPC protection generally extends to tokenized securities to the same extent that it extends to traditional securities, with protection limited to instruments that qualify as “securities” within the meaning of SIPA’s “security” definition. Thus, for example, if held by a SIPC member for a customer under the conditions established in SIPA, tokenized instruments that qualify as “stock” may be eligible for SIPC protection regardless whether those instruments are registered with the SEC under the Securities Act of 1933, whereas tokenized “investment contracts” are eligible for protection only if so registered."
Sounds like the “blockchain” part of this is marketing, since it’s on a private blockchain controlled by the exchange. The real selling point is 24/7 trading.
The cash for buybacks comes from company operations, which they give to investors in exchange for destroying the outstanding security. The cash for Ponzi schemes comes from other investors, which they receive in exchange for issuing more securities and use to fund investors who want to cash out. They are in many ways opposites.
> The cash for Ponzi schemes comes from other investors, which they receive in exchange for issuing more securities and use to fund investors who want to cash out.
If the value of something is only "someone else will pay for it, and then later they will sell it", that to me is effectively the same as a Ponzi scheme. There's no inherent value in the actual thing being bought and sold other than the buying and selling of it. Maybe calling them "Pokemon cards for companies" would be a better way of describing why I find it nonsensical to claim there's any real link between the company and the stock unit when buybacks are the only way to make money off them.
Ponzi scheme has a very specific definition, which is that the money to pay out earlier investors comes from new investors. That's specifically the test that the FTC and SEC use to prosecute such cases. With buybacks, the money used to buy out investors comes from the operating profits of the company. Economic activity is happening, money is being exchanged for goods and services, and then the money is being returned to shareholders in accordance with the company's fiduciary duties.
Curious if you understand where the cash from a buyback comes from? That it's out of the corporate treasury, where it was previously accounted for as part of the profits of the corporation?
I can't tell if you're being condescending intentionally or not, but I'm not sure how you could get the impression that I don't understand what "buyback" means. Obviously it comes from the company; otherwise it's just a regular stock sale that doesn't need any additional descriptor.
The issue to me is that the division between "money companies get from selling their shares" and "money companies get from selling their products" is artificial; whether it gets taxed differently is a procedural issue, not something that inherently defines what "value" is. When the value of something is only from selling it again in the future, it's inherently only valuable as long as there's someone else to pass it onto to sell it again later. Sticking the company in the middle of passing it along doesn't magically change whether it's sensible or not. That's what I mean by "effectively a Ponzi scheme", even if it's not strictly one in the definitional sense. The same arguments for why a Ponzi scheme is undesirable apply.
I'm condescending to everyone; my wife, when we first started dating, was like "He doesn't mean to be condescending, but, well, he is."
> Obviously it comes from the company; otherwise it's just a regular stock sale that doesn't need any additional descriptor.
This is incorrect. A buyback is when a company buys its stock. It is giving cash to shareholders, and taking the shares back. A stock sale is the opposite, when the company sells its stock and receives money from the new shareholders. The direction of cash flow is very important here, because a key difference between a Ponzi scheme and a buyback is that in a buyback, the company is distributing cash to investors, not taking cash in.
> The issue to me is that the division between "money companies get from selling their shares" and "money companies get from selling their products" is artificial
If you're collapsing these two, you're generalizing beyond the point of usefulness, and ignoring all of the reasons why people engage in economic activity in the first place.
There are many, many industries where the consumer does not even get to sell the object again in the future. When you go out to a restaurant, the meal disappears within an hour, leaving you with just memories and indigestion. When you go to an amusement park, you have fun while you're there and leave with nothing. When you pay rent, you have a roof over your head for the month and then nothing afterwards. When you go to a casino, you get your hopes and excitement up while you're there and leave with less than nothing. When you buy alcohol or tobacco, you're spending money on the privilege of poisoning yourself.
Almost everyone would consider these legitimate economic exchanges, though. They may be inadvisable on a time-preference basis because your money disappears and you end up with nothing durable in return, but few people would argue that a large part of our economy is made up of transactions like this.
You're right though that you can take the corporation out of the equation and they still make just as much sense. If you take the corporation, its accounting statements, and the corporate treasury out of the equation, then a buyback is taking money earned from providing goods and services, and distributing it to the shareholders. The difference from a dividend is which shareholders receive the distribution: in a dividend it is distributed equally across all shareholders (who continue to remain shareholders), while in a buyback it distributes the cash to the people who least want to own the business in the future, paying them out entirely and distributing future profits to a smaller set of shareholders.
> This is incorrect. A buyback is when a company buys its stock. It is giving cash to shareholders, and taking the shares back
When a company buys stock, the money comes from the company. You're literally saying the same thing as me and telling me I'm wrong. It's not worth it for me to read beyond that because it's not clear you're reading what I'm saying properly.
The value of stock buybacks come from lowering shares in circulation. Fewer shares means that shareholders have to share profits with fewer, leading to larger profits or dividends per share.
I see it as a Ponzi scheme when people argue that they're a replacement for dividends. You're describing them as if dividends are an assumption, in which case they're perfectly reasonable.
I don't think buybacks are really the thing here. The question is why a stock would have value if it doesn't pay dividends. If there's a good reason for that then buybacks are perfectly sensible. If there isn't then such companies are engaged in some sort of weird scheme regardless of buybacks.
I'd argue that if the only value of something is that you can sell it later, that is a weird. At best, it's like a collectible card or something, and at worst, it's just a Ponzi scheme.
Respectfully, I think that perspective may be too simplistic.
A collectible card doesn’t have paying customers; many publicly traded companies do. They are real businesses that make money. When they make more, the price goes up.
If you wanted to base the entirety of the world economy on baseball cards, I'd say that you're crazy. The fact that you put company names on them instead and don't make them physical cards doesn't make it less crazy.
Again, no baseball card produces anything of value in the world. Many publicly traded companies do. They employe people and pay their salaries.
You seem to ignore that.
The economy is not based on the stocks, but on the value the underlying companies produce. E.g. Tesla makes cars, Google runs a search engine. Such companies impact the real world - Baseball cards collect dust.
It is a bit weird. And yet a lot of people are willing to pay a lot of money for stocks that show no sign of ever paying out dividends. Seems like it's probably more than just collecting cards.
Even for companies that do not pay dividends, buybacks should increase the value of each share, because you share profits with fewer other shareholders.
Buybacks raise the EPS/earning-per-share by lowering the denominator (number of outstanding shares).
EDIT:
If P/E stays the same, but the E (earnings) grows, the P (price) has to grow too.
I think it’s quite uncontroversial to equate buybacks with dividends. Personally, I prefer dividends, even if they’re suboptimal tax-wise.
I can see what you mean if very speculative or whatever, but many (most?) publicly traded companies earn money and own tangible assets.
Buying shares means you own some of that; that is the value.
These companies likely pay their employees, and as a shareholder you get to partake and harvest value, without having to work for it.
If the company earns more than last year, the stock should be worth more. But of course, valuation clouds the picture, where dividends are usually simpler to model.
This just sounds like nonsense to me. Why would it be "more valuable" to have a piece of paper with the name of a company on it that makes more money on it than a company that made less money if it never translates to actually getting money from having it? You might as well be describing baseball cards, because someone else will want to pay more for a card that has a player who does really well even though they don't get anything from having it. That might be reasonable for collectors, but it's a pretty clearly insane basis for such a huge portion of our economic activity.
They're currently a replacement for dividends because dividends are less tax-efficient than stock buybacks.
I struggle with the same initial impression as you, and have reached an uneasy peace with the status quo by telling myself that the stock price is about the amount of dividends the company could issue in a dividend-friendlier tax environment, once its growth plateaus and it goes into cash-cow mode.
I guess this is where politics comes into it, because in general I don't really like the idea of a capital gains tax at a much lower rate than income in the first place.
However, if they're at parity then the incentive is to just squeeze your assets for as much income as possible until you run their value into the ground. Which seems like a pressure for business owners / shareholders to be even more short-sighted than they already are.
Which is also my objection to a wealth tax actually (incentive to tank paper value of all holdings).
IDK. Taxation is sort of a blunt instrument and seems woefully inefficient compared to nationalizing assets on a case-by-case basis.
reply