HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | gruez's commentslogin

>Most non-developers will not be able to produce good programs by AI and will have no idea about the security of their web apps or what every they produce.

Given all the AI discovered vulnerabilities that's been cropping up, were handcrafted programs really that much better?


"What about errors made without AI" is not a proper argument.

We don't need a fault-free method of producing software to realize that any levers used in the process can only amplify errors and their consequences. Sometimes the answer is to go slower and make it correct before pouring wattage on the system. Sometimes the answer is go go fast and break things.

The only certainty should be that there is no universally correct answer to how to seek answers. Sometimes an ad hoc app built quickly without looking at code is the best solution. It certainly shouldn't be a surprise that any gains therein are not without cost. Or that any such machinery can only ever make knowledgeable people doing slow work on fundamentals more necessary, not less.


> Given all the AI discovered vulnerabilities that's been cropping up, were handcrafted programs really that much better?

No hand crafted programs where not 'better' and I am not saying that we can ignore and not use AI, I am saying that knowing what you are actually producing and how it will run on a system and knowing what are the right things to want are better then someone who producing a program that does everything they want but what they wanted was bad, insecure (by design), poorly thought out and scales badly (in terms of adding new features).

AI can produce good code, good enough code and build excellent scripts and wrangle tools like socat, but leaving it on it's own and just asking make me a web app that does X. Further how many bright ideas will come to the users mind when they get excited for example "actually I don't like the way this database works each user should have a table, I think that would be better and easier to work with and look better as I can just inspect a user like a report!", time will tell but users of AI to vibe code apps who will be liberated from the details of how will not question their why's.


No, because so much of the vulnerable production code made in the last couple decades was offshored to human-ran slop mills that focused on speed and not quality. Not to mention the architectures used in many web stacks specifically haven’t had great track records on memory safety or security.

A microsoft support scam involves pretty straightforward deception through. The same can't be said of cheap "junk" on amazon.

Don't basically all podcast apps have this feature?

>How to steal scientists' ideas and buckmaster them under the guise of "teamwork".

That's OpenAI (allegedly), not google


Doesn't matter with BigTech company we are talking about.

Skype and Hangouts were forbidden for sensitive research at some German universities:

https://www.cms.hu-berlin.de/de/dl/multimedia/bereiche/tele/...

Now everyone leaks everything by using AI even for mundane things like file format conversions.


they are all the same

Isn't that straightforwardly explained by typical hoarding behavior, not " afraid to let their competitors to make inference"? During the pandemic people were hoarding TP that they couldn't possibly use within a reasonable amount of time, but it'd be crazy to accuse people of doing that because they were afraid of their neighbors having clean asses.

Simple. If everybody stinks, nobody is stinking.

If you cannot wipe efficiently, you better make sure nobody else can too so that no-one can call you out on that.


>If you cannot wipe efficiently, you better make sure nobody else can too so that no-one can call you out on that.

But so far as we can tell, American proprietary models are more compute efficient than open models? They're also practically cheaper, if you factor subscriptions into account. Does that mean we should be decrying all the GPUs used for GLM, when they can be put to better use for claude or chatgpt models?


> Does that mean we should be decrying all the GPUs used for GLM, when they can be put to better use for claude or chatgpt models?

That wasn't my personal opinion, just guessing the mindset behind those who want to prevent competition.

Funny enough that seems to be the exact stance of OpenAI/sama.

https://www.tomshardware.com/tech-industry/data-centers/open...


I have a feeling why. Somehow I got into an argument with Grok over Flock cameras and I realized AI is Government thought.

No one seriously denies the actual activity was happening, they just dispute its implications, and for good reason. Vendors frequently extend financing with the hope of making more sales, the most obvious example being auto loans and BNPL

Vendor financing is already a sign of an unhealthy market. When widespread, almost always. If the only easy way you can borrow enough to buy a thing is from the vendor, that’s bad. And if vendor financing is an increasing, not decreasing, proportion of the finance in a market, that’s worse.

Channel-stuffing, if it is happening, is usually plain illegal.

The implications are obvious: if people are using GPU scarcity and prices as a proxy for AI demand (and they absolutely have and still are, at every level), and use it as an indication that they must secure GPUs while they can, then it matters a lot if in fact that demand is being padded out and front-loaded in various ways.


>Vendor financing is already a sign of an unhealthy market. When widespread, almost always. If the only easy way you can borrow enough to buy a thing is from the vendor, that’s bad. And if vendor financing is an increasing, not decreasing, proportion of the finance in a market, that’s worse.

How much % of car loans are vendor financed?


I don’t know, because I am in the UK and I don’t know exactly what definition of vendor finance you’re working with.

For example, here in the UK, that is extremely regulated, and you’re usually not buying with the dealer’s money, or the dealer chain’s money. Sometimes you are buying with the manufacturer’s money (through a regulated subsidiary finance company or joint venture) but most of the time you’re simply buying with money from a regulated finance company, from which the dealer is getting an introducer’s fee (and for which they must agree to be regulated).

(I am not a driver and have no car loans but I am reasonably familiar with the business model from previous client business)

It is my understanding that Nvidia is pretty directly using their own money for this: there is a criticism that they are essentially “selling their balance sheet as a service”, and that their total exposure is about $200 billion.

Nvidia’s loans are not, in that sense, particularly comparable to even the loosest definition of auto loans. Not least because there’s no competition for the products.

This is all putting aside how much money Jensen Huang has persuaded others to loan. Perhaps that side of things won’t go away; I think we might see him carrying on that function in some future capacity. But it will almost inevitably be at a much smaller scale, because the market is significantly less enthusiastic about lending more money.


Almost none. Dealerships will arrange financing for you, but the actual financing comes from a third party financial institution. The dealership walks away from the deal with the full cash value of the sale; and maybe a kickback from the bank. The concerning thing with vendor financing is that the vendor is supposed to be in the widget business, not the financing business. If they are getting into the financing bussiness, that is generally a sign that the professional financers don't want to get involved; which is not a good sign.

captive lender originations account for between 20% and 30% of the us auto loan volume depending on whether you count the loans or the volume

You're being deliberately obtuse. Every auto manufacturer has a captive finance arm. That captive finance arm may be operated by a financial institution, but the financing is subvented by the auto manufacturer. Chase isn't offering 0% financing on a Subaru because they like the car, they're offering it because Subaru pays them to.

This is, nevertheless, a quite different story. Nvidia does not have a captive finance company.

The concern has to be that ordinary financial institutions might not make such loans to startups, and that therefore Nvidia is using vendor finance to create sales that otherwise would not happen.

Rather than the auto loan system, where essentially the front face of an entire finance industry has moved into the dealerships but you can still get a car loan outside it.


> Nvidia does not have a captive finance company

You don’t need to when you have a few dozen customers you’re doing this for. You meet with them and plot world dominance over cocktails.

Auto companies have the structure they do to support 1000s of dealerships and millions of customers.


Surely the credit risk level is completely different between individual customers personally on the hook vs speculative corporations?

Sure, but no matter the risk level the vendor always has the most ability to absorb defaults. It’s probably why they are the only reasonable lender in many markets

Bullshit. Most of our economy is financing. Airlines are literally credit card companies with some aircraft leases attached.

Right but aren’t you kind of underscoring the point? It’s not really the kind of vendor finance we are talking about then; it’s really just the finance industry moving into loaning other things, moving the storefront into another business. It’s pretty highly regulated.

Vendor finance of the kind Nvidia is doing is different: they are the single vendor for one thing, they are loaning to startups who otherwise might not get funding from banks, it’s coming from the same balance sheet as the product, and these loans are materially causing GPU scarcity.

In general, vendor finance of the kind Nvidia is doing is indicative of an uncertain market, and when it’s the only vendor and it causes the price of the thing to rise, that’s obviously bad.

The industry is very aware that it relies on this for its continuing growth and stability.


it's also an issue for cat companies. they get a double whammy during economic downturn because demand drops and supply rises (due to repossessed data flooding the market)

Yes, but also, vendors are best positioned and most incentivized to be the lenders for their customers. They often just provide unbeatable terms compared to all options, even better than cash for those who do have that option and ability.

A financing company usually is fully taking the credit risk. They have to charge a high interest and hope their underwriting process is sound. That is generally the only way they make money from the transaction.

A vendor can give 0% interest or even a discount to financing customers because they are protected by the profit margin of the transaction. They can also have a looser underwriting process and take more credit risks while doing so.


The enthusiasm for consumption seems real, though. Very large enterprises would purchase many more if they could.

Exactly.

"Banks allegedly engineered inflation by funding[1] consumer's spending"

[1] aka. credit cards


But that's exactly what happen in 2007-8 crisis.

No? Whatever banks were trying to do in 2007, it wasn't "engineered scarcity" or even inflation. The only overlap is that lending is involved and people hate it

The prices of building or buying rapidly escalated around mid 20s' We can say they didn't intend to crash but the inflation in real estate was rather obvious.

but thats how banks actually create inflation under the limits of the regulators, isn’t it?

Thats what "spin" is. Things that are technically true but massively misleading, or selectively applied.

While I generally dislike scaling consumer finance up to larger markets, to go with your analogy.

Isn't the "credit" that Nvidia extended secured by the value of the GPUs and Datacenters the creditors end up buying/building? If so then should the value of those things suddenly plummet Nvidia is left holding billions in junk debt?


Yes like iterate appeals to neutrality by people with inherent skin in the game

People who are inherently biased to select themselves, thus upending any rhetorical appeals they are capable of the mythical perfect neutrality they appeal to via generalized words


Characterizing ~10 weeks to "weeks" is also a bit misleading

Exactly. Put "2.5 months" in the headline and no one bats an eye.

>Barely enough time for the domain to resolve!

contrary to popular belief, DNS doesn't actually need 24 hours (or whatever) to "propagate". It only needs enough time for caches to expire, if they exist. For non-existent domains this shouldn't be an issue.


DNS controls the length of time an answer is valid (with time-to-live/TTL), some (poorly configured, but for a historical good reason) caching servers ignore the TTL and keep the record much longer (~24 hours).

A non-existent (not yet resolvable) domain, will get an NXDOMAIN response which also gets cached via a TTL setting (which again might be ignored by caching servers).

All that caching - while the current response is still "valid" because the TTL hasn't expired - is what people call "propagation".


Aside from regular caches (that use TTLs), there can also be a replication delay between primary master and secondary master servers.

You make your changes to the zone file on the primary server. The secondary replicates the zone file (a "zone transfer") and uses its copy to serve requests, enabling you to have multiple authoritative servers.

In the old days, the secondary server simply polled the primary server at a fixed interval to see if its zone data was out of date. It could potentially be hours if that's the schedule you chose. It wasn't uncommon to restart the secondary servers by hand if you needed something to propagate faster.

Later, more sophisticated stuff was added like incremental zone transfers and the ability for the primary to send a notification to the secondary instead of relying only on polling. Those made it more practical to replicate quickly.

There were scenarios back in the day when quick replication wasn't worth the cost. The primary and secondary servers might be on opposite sides of a 9600 baud modem connection where zone transfers would eat up a significant portion of available bandwidth.

TLDR: DNS "propagation" is real, not a myth. It's just that today it's pretty trivial to make the propagation delay so tiny that it's negligible.


>I understand this is true in a strictly legal and financial sense.

"Legal and financial sense" is how you run a business. Getting salty because a company decided to switch to a more profitable customer, while understandable, is also totally unreasonable. It's like getting mad at a band for selling $1000 concert tickets after they made it big. Doubly so when the product segment being affected is essentially a luxury product to begin with.


You're not really arguing anything here except that greed is expected, which is fair but not logical in the sense that, there is nothing about a business that says it has to operate this way, and no law that says being a fair and good entity in our community is necessarily going to bankrupt them. It's a choice leadership makes, for obvious and boring reasons, to fuck over the general community.

Big music artists could totally sell cheaper tickets and still make enormous piles of cash.

Nvidia could have continued supporting the consumer market alongside their AI ambitions.

The sad part is that we simply don't expect it anymore, because we no longer see businesses as part of our communities. Just as profit engines, with no other goal.

Companies don't exist in a vacuum, they are entities in our community, and we should expect them to behave in a way that is beneficial and fair, and sometimes that might be at the expense of unrealised profits. Not bankruptcy obviously, but there's a wide gamut of extreme prosperity between bankrupt and trillion dollar market cap.


>Big music artists could totally sell cheaper tickets and still make enormous piles of cash.

>Nvidia could have continued supporting the consumer market alongside their AI ambitions.

No, in both cases they'll just get scalped. If you're selling something for $1 that the market is willing to pay $10 for, the market will find a way to equalize this.

>Companies don't exist in a vacuum, they are entities in our community, and we should expect them to behave in a way that is beneficial and fair, and sometimes that might be at the expense of unrealised profits. Not bankruptcy obviously, but there's a wide gamut of extreme prosperity between bankrupt and trillion dollar market cap.

Give me a break. This might work if it's walmart replacing a dozen local shops with a giant big box store on the edge of town, but GPUs are already a niche luxury product. If there's one sector where it's justified for companies to make outsized profits on, it's this. Otherwise it's as out of touch as getting mad at Hermes for selling $10k hand bags.


Yes so thinking purely in corporate thoughts, the supply is the issue on concerts and GPUs. For supply constrained items like concert space, or theme parks, other countries where profit isn't the dominant motive will sell tickets via lotteries or first in, first serve, ID linked and no reselling.

For the GPU situation, consumer GPU supply is constrained because demand isn't being met. It's not being met (in my understanding) because NVidia has a monopoly on the software ecosystem around the workloads that are diverting consumer GPU supply to businesses, first crypto, recently AI. The solution would have been to create and supply two different verticals independently, and to open the ecosystem up for other manufacturers to help meet B2B supply. There is precedent for this going in different directions, but it was a choice nVidia made to squeeze the market for every penny. Extremely good business. Shareholders are stoked, a fantastic win for the stock market.

I can't worry about all things but since you bring hermes bags up, yes that is also a pretty clear sign of a perverse economy. Selling an at-cost $10 bag for $10,000 is pretty disappointing behaviour by the seller and the buyer. The seller does it because they can, and the buyer does it because they don't mind getting fleeced. The key difference there is you can still get full utility from a bag for $15, but you have to participate in this new GPU market to get a GPU.

This is the world we live in, I get that, but it's no less disappointing to see the majority of people get ditched for the sake of the shareholders time and time again. If you feel that this isn't what's happening then I would be interested in that, otherwise we might just disagree on some base principles which is fine but probably not worth debating.


>For supply constrained items like concert space, or theme parks, other countries where profit isn't the dominant motive will sell tickets via lotteries or first in, first serve, ID linked and no reselling.

How are you going to enforce this for GPUs? Even if you somehow add the remote tracking systems that AI safety proponents have been asking for, you can still make a handy profit renting out your GPU to people who want to play gta6 or whatever.

>because NVidia has a monopoly on the software ecosystem around the workloads that are diverting consumer GPU supply to businesses, first crypto, recently AI

Maybe if you need CUDA specifically for AI workloads. For gaming AMD or intel is perfectly serviceable. It's not as good as a RTX 5090, but again that's like complaining you can only afford a LV bag rather than a Hermes (the embarrassment!)

>The key difference there is you can still get full utility from a bag for $15, but you have to participate in this new GPU market to get a GPU.

Only if you're only interested in carrying stuff, but not if you're interested in status signaling. The same applies to some extent for concerts. How many people are going for the experience of nosebleed seats (or standing room), overpriced food, and other travel hassles, vs the social cachet of being to a limited concert?


> "Legal and financial sense" is how you run a business.

That is how immoral people run a business. But there are a great many businesses in this country run by people who (correctly) recognize that there are higher obligations than the law and making a profit. Treating your customers fairly, making good products, doing things in an ethical way... these are not optional to a well-adjusted person, even if not required by the law.

Continuing to serve your loyal customers even has benefits above and beyond the intangible. When the bubble pops (and it will pop), Nvidia's sales to AI customers will crater. When that day comes, they will come to regret chasing away all the customers who would still be giving them business if they had not been cast aside as "not profitable enough, sorry guys".


>That is how immoral people run a business. But there are a great many businesses in this country run by people who (correctly) recognize that there are higher obligations than the law and making a profit. Treating your customers fairly, making good products, doing things in an ethical way... these are not optional to a well-adjusted person, even if not required by the law.

Higher obligations like... letting sweaty PC gamers run GTA 6 at 4K? I'm only half joking with the characterization, but AI at least have a good story going for it, productivity gains, competition with china, etc. What does gaming have going for it? For a slightly less sympathitic example, imagine there's some water shortage and datacenters[1] bought up all the water rights, forcing golfers to play on brown golf courses. Are we really supposed to be mad at either the datacenters or the farmers that sold the water rights, because they weren't serving the "higher obligations" of golfers wanting green golf courses?

[1] yes, I know they don't actually use that much water.

>When the bubble pops (and it will pop), Nvidia's sales to AI customers will crater. When that day comes, they will come to regret chasing away all the customers who would still be giving them business if they had not been cast aside as "not profitable enough, sorry guys".

As much gamers would love this revenge fantasy to happen it's not going to happen. I wager there's approximately zero brand loyalty in the PC gaming market. If nvidia is going to lose customers, it's because they're behind technologically.


> but AI at least have a good story going for it,

It was not advancing good story. If you listened to CEO it was advancing pretty horrifying story of obsoleting people and centralizing all power into their own hands.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: