It's always an interesting conversation because like socialism, eugenics covers a lot that normal people consider obviously fine and obviously good but don't believe the word covers that use because all eugenics and all socialism must be evil.
i.e. most people are happy for taxes to go to roads/water/power infrastructure while being dead set against 'socialism'.
The classic eugenics gotcha is filtering for genetic disease. Most people are happy with that, but then to make the question harder what if you filter out embryos with sickle cell and then are also disproportionately filtering out multiple ethnic heritages as well.
I don't really blame people if they are exposed to these technologies and see the stats that say 'yes taller people are statistically more successful', or most people consider x or y more advantageous, then say I want my kid to have as many of those advantages as possible. The same will apply with the even more extreme case of genetic engineering where you aren't just selecting for possible traits but inserting ones that wouldn't occur naturally for a couple, though it crosses a convenient place to draw a line and would likely homogenize people more.
That doesn't necessarily mean it should be allowed, there's plenty of behaviors that are advantageous and not even problematic for individuals to do that are illegal because if too many people do it there's a problem and so the easiest or possibly even most elegant solution is to ban it or sub types of a behavior. Especially if a sub group of people are known to abuse it, there's a difference between picking green eyes and strawberry blonde hair because you believe it'll cause shallow people to be nicer to your kid, vs choosing blue eyes and blonde hair because you believe that is the ultimate pinnacle of man.
> I think the fundamental disagreement is you believe that cheaper models can just break the state of the art.
No their argument is that the existence of a worse quality cheaper product will eat too much of the market for the SOTA company, making the SOTA company less profitable (not necessarily unprofitable) because the number of people who need/want the quality difference supplied by the SOTA product aren't enough to pay to sustain the extra resources required to supply the next iteration of the better product or even if they are then they are not enough to get a respectable ROI on the current investment.
>SOTA can also stop developing and spending on SOTA and just use a cheaper model
Yes, and they will be forced to (if the market shapes out as above) but the point is that then the company won't be getting the returns that justify the valuation being talked about in the IPO and will likely never return the amount of money that has already been invested in it even if it is a profitable company. i.e. If I spend $20,000,000 making a lemonade stand that is a successful best in class stand and it nets me $50 profit a day then it doesn't matter how that as far as lemonade stands go that it's a pretty amazing example. I am effectively never going to see that 20 million again let alone a real profit.
They're not arguing that these SOTA companies aren't better, they're arguing that there won't be a decent return on investment let alone justifying further investment and means everyone will be taking a huge haircut on what is already invested (with the possible exception of early investors who take the bag with the IPO when it inevitably succeeds based on people disagreeing with this evaluation and thinking it a good investment or simply because of index funds being required to buy in)
If you want debate the economics of these companies then you have to bring receipts or examples.
The only examples we see, open source software, for example, shows that the major market players still make a boatload of money. Anyone off the street can download OpenOffice and it's the "worse quality cheaper product", but Microsoft makes hundreds of millions of dollars (estimate) on Office and that's what everyone uses.
What compelling evidence do you have that things will be different now?
You can implement policies that tax more than just income. So no not regardless of policy but yes where policies don't exist to reshape a system where capital (i.e. investment in automated production) inherently takes more of the wealth than labour it will inherently lead to an agglomeration of capital.
Today, if sanitation workers go on strike, they rapidly end up with a negotiated settlement. If we had self driving garbage trucks that didn't need them, what political leverage would they have? The same too goes for other industries.
If police have advanced surveillance technology and drones, even violent protest becomes very hard.
What pressure is there to cater to people who are powerless dead weight on the economy?
Driving isn't the hard part or expensive part of a garbage truck. Sanitation workers have to hoist haphazardly-placed and badly-packed garbage cans. Some municipalities have cans that can be lifted by arms on the truck, though many don't, and even where they exist not everybody uses them.
Voting is still a thing. You still have to convince people that just voting for what they want is less important than carefully considering the affect their votes will have on billionaires.
How long will it remain a thing when the voters have no leverage? King Louis didn't set up the French Republic out of the goodness of his heart. He set it up by reducing the amount of weight carried by his neck.
Voting happens because economic power implies political power. People must be kept satisfied for things to keep running.
If that deal gets upended, I don't think the economic dead weight will be treated well.
I wished, unfortunately the companies are going to complain that doing so will stop them to have enough money to innovate compared to other countries, or that they are too small to compete. (At least it's the current speech of the lobbies in EU for example).
But instead, ever since the brief federal surplus at the end of the 90s, we've done multiple multi-trillion dollar tax cuts for the highest earners. Bush tax cuts + 2x Trump tax cuts (most recently in the BBB). In each case after fudging the projections beforehand to claim it will reduce the deficit somehow, then the deficit grows by a massive amount.
We've been reshaping the system to redistribute trillions to capital owners via government IOUs that will eventually come due. Inevitably, this will be "solved" by cutting benefits to workers while insisting no other solution could possibly exist.
Like, you know, undoing these relatively recent handouts to the ultra rich and restructuring policy to the benefit of workers.
While a good rule of thumb for the US court system is that someone with more money can screw over a smaller party. That's only up until a point. The most expensive lawsuit in history by legal fees was (adjusted for inflation) $1.15 billion. That was the 1998 Tobacco masters settlement (involving years of litigation by law firms across 46 states). So any award in the billions makes a case arguably justifiable (even more so when the highest litigation cost cases are often that expensive because the litigation fee includes a percentage of winnings).
Companies like autodesk with a ttm revenue of $7.8 billion would probably have fiscally compelling cases (if not legally compelling) to pursue if reverse engineered tools cut into their revenue. That's without getting into class action cases.
> While a good rule of thumb for the US court system is that someone with more money can screw over a smaller party. That's only up until a point.
Exactly.
Adobe had a FY2025 operating income of 8.7b on 23.77bn revenue. They employ over 33k people..
So Adobe alone has the money for a law suite that defends themselves from an existential threat, but I would imagine a class action.. It is, IMHO, just a matter of time before these companies put it together and take their shot.
Without getting into the much debated philosophy of restoration/display of preserved things and how restoration can often cause degradation to the original piece, consider that just preserving the data in the manner you suggest also requires preserving the original software if you ever want to view it. Which requires not just preserving that original software but also all the external hardware and software that original software relies on. Quite often that's a dead end as it requires preserving an activation/license server that the preservers don't have access to.
That isn’t true, you preserve the data as is for the software as is. You can emulate under it if you need to run it. This is what internet archive has done and the proper preservation of the media is in tact. In NO WAY do you ever need to convert the data back to a workable source in its original authoring program.
You are wrong, you are basically saying "black cats exist therefore cats can't be tabby", there are plenty of preservation initiatives that preserve works in different forms when the original media can not be practically preserved or displayed. Yes best practice is to preserve as close to initial state as possible, that does not mean that when you cannot feasibly preserve the work in it's original state (with digital it's often due to drm) that you just say screw it nothing we can do but chuck it in the dustbin of history.
That's like saying bank robbers don't actually shoot guns, only people who use guns legally shoot them. It's still preservation. Or even more apt saying archeologists aren't archeologists they're tomb raiders. They may be tomb raiders but they are still archeologists.
It is worth considering that without being able to identify people then only unacceptable behaviour that rises to the level of needing and having an immediate response can actually be punished.
It's the qualitative change than comes with the change in quantity and ease of monitoring (and accessibility of that info) that means being identifiable is so much worse now days.
The reason so many people used the deleted items folder as a filing system is exchange didn't set a quota on that folder and by default would only get emptied by a manual emptying. So back in the days when a user could have a 100mb mailbox quota 'unlimited' space could start looking very attractive. Especially if that quota was 5 years old because the server hadn't grown with the times, since what business wants to spend money on a 'cost center' that won't improve profits.
Then these people didn't change their ways when they were given adequate space.
Install an app. For apple you need to try test flight to find out too many people use the app so you need to be able to install in developer mode.
I can understand the argument that you should have some technical competency to evaluate that these programs are safe to install, but neither accounts for a technically competent friend/family member suggesting/helping you install an app. Apple requires expertise to even keep an app that doesn't pay to be on the app store installed longer than a week.
People joke about a fire drills at work or their neighbour in the apartment building burning the toast and setting off the alarm. We don't equate that to people laughing about dozens of people burning to death (even if that's a possible reality of a fire) because to most of us it's not conceptualized like that.
This is a teacher in the US who would have had to sit through live shooting drills and never believed a live shooting would happen at her school (How much would you need to be paid to work somewhere where you seriously believed you had a 1 in 100 chance of being shot in the next 5 years, it wouldn't be a teachers salary for most of us).
No because, some companies know they'll need ram, but they may have some leeway on timing (i.e. doing more to prolong the life of systems they'd typically replace). That means to guarantee ram they need to enter an agreement to buy the ram now. By setting the expectation that these prices continue or get worse companies that may have put off agreeing to these terms locking in prices based on demand rather than something closer to the cost of production. The agreements that these companies are being forced to make are upfront payment and then a top up to meet current market prices before delivery, there is no downside for these ram companies whether the price rises or falls (at worst they end up with supply that was already payed for by a bust company at a healthy margin and a glut in the market that would arrive anyway)
Competitors are going to come online anyway because of the threat of chip embargoes against China that mean they are investing in production regardless of what the outside world is doing.
i.e. most people are happy for taxes to go to roads/water/power infrastructure while being dead set against 'socialism'.
The classic eugenics gotcha is filtering for genetic disease. Most people are happy with that, but then to make the question harder what if you filter out embryos with sickle cell and then are also disproportionately filtering out multiple ethnic heritages as well.
I don't really blame people if they are exposed to these technologies and see the stats that say 'yes taller people are statistically more successful', or most people consider x or y more advantageous, then say I want my kid to have as many of those advantages as possible. The same will apply with the even more extreme case of genetic engineering where you aren't just selecting for possible traits but inserting ones that wouldn't occur naturally for a couple, though it crosses a convenient place to draw a line and would likely homogenize people more.
That doesn't necessarily mean it should be allowed, there's plenty of behaviors that are advantageous and not even problematic for individuals to do that are illegal because if too many people do it there's a problem and so the easiest or possibly even most elegant solution is to ban it or sub types of a behavior. Especially if a sub group of people are known to abuse it, there's a difference between picking green eyes and strawberry blonde hair because you believe it'll cause shallow people to be nicer to your kid, vs choosing blue eyes and blonde hair because you believe that is the ultimate pinnacle of man.
reply