HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | gretch's commentslogin

My weakness is rain and getting wet.

I saw an ad for $30 water proof shoes at Costco.

I have no illusion that these are the most comfortable/durable shoe in the world, but I do believe that they are $30 and water proof.

I didn't know they existed because they are online only. But I'm very glad I saw this ad, especially with the el nino season coming up in california


I bought water proof shoes after measuring them in shop, 7th size/model variant I tried.

Doing it online, even with free returns, would be far more annoying.


We're not talking about the same thing.

I'm saying I didn't know those shoes existed, especially at that price point.

Are you claiming that you are fully aware of all the products in the world that would be a benefit to you?

Its a discovery problem, not a fulfillment problem.


> Are you claiming that you are fully aware of all the products in the world that would be a benefit to you?

No, but ads are not effective way of learning about them. Too much of lying and deliberately misleading info and manipulation.


> For nearly all tasks, I want the fastest and smartest AI model.

This is not nearly true for everyone else in the world.

For example, think about the world in ~2021 pre-LLM. Would anyone say the sentence "I only want the fastest and smartest humans working on my project"?

No of course not. Most people don't want to pay $10 million dollar salary to the best programmers in the world. They prefer to pay $200k salary to a median programmer and that's good enough for their ecommerce website.


I mean people said this all the time, but wouldn’t pay for it (as you said), couldn’t recruit for it, and definitely couldn’t retain them.

But so many teams said they wanted to Raise the Bar to infinity and hire a World Class Team.


Yes this is all true.

So then the problem is that Anthropic seems hypocritical when they knowingly insert themselves into this chain, and then complain about people down-chain from them.

To remedy the negative impressions (if they even care to do so) they should do 1 of 2 things: 1) stop complaining about it 2) stop distilling other people's work


It's hypocritical and we shouldn't listen to their bullshit but I wouldn't expect anything else from them.

This generation of frontier models is "good enough." At some point, the Chinese labs will get to where the Americans are right now, they'll race to the bottom, and we will actually see what proliferation of AI looks like.

If Anthropic wants to be a trillion dollar company, they need to make revenue like Google or Apple do. Both of them have near monopolies, Anthropic is only getting further and further away as time goes on.

Of course they're gonna complain until they either figure out a better plan or accept a new valuation which is high but not spectacular.


They insert themselves into this chain for profit and complain about it. I really think that adds a thick layer to the hypocrisy that people, or at least me, feel is especially distasteful.

No LLM products would exist without the avalanche of largely non-consensual use of IP to create them, full stop. Any of these companies doing this and then turning around and complaining when their IP is "breached" are going to met with a chorus of tiny violins.


I'm American and I enjoy hosting at my house. I do it often (imo).

I think some of the stats reviewed in this post are crazy because it is specifically "did it 12+ times in the last year", which means if you only did it 11 times, you simply register as a 'false' according to this modeling.

The graphs with once per year are much more reasonable.

I'm sure these stats still tell you something about life in america, but I feel like this bar is set so extremely high. I'm saying this as someone who LOVES hosting - I don't want to do it 12 times a year. (maybe it's because I set too high of a quality bar for myself?)


When people say “the problem is that our economic system…”, I’ve stared to simply ask, “which economic system is the one where you do not need a job?”


One that isn't built on debt bondage and a massive wealth transfer to the old and wealthy. Student debt, housing debt and medical debt are all designed to keep you a complaint worker who will increasingly never escape that debt. We have increasingly just replaced the dukes and kings of old with centibillionaires. Together we're bouldering towards what many of us call "neofeudalism".

This is one thing that Karl Marx and Adam Smith agreed on: landlords are parasitic that reduce economic output. It's another way we're returning to a virtual aristocracy as land gets concentrated in fewer and fewer hands.

This is all going to further fall apart once we don't need everyone to be employed. Arguably we're already there. What are the rest of the people meant to do? Starve and die? At some point you realize the only way forward is to collectively own the wealth you help create.


>This is one thing that Karl Marx and Adam Smith agreed on: landlords are parasitic that reduce economic output.

But going back to the original premise, everyone still has to work, even without landlords. The soviets even codified it as a crime: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Social_parasitism_(offense)


We will eventually reach the point where not everyone needs a job. Many basic functions of life like agriculture and food production will be automated. Construction will probably be automated.

AI is being used to reduce the labor pool to suppress wages. You not only save on wages for laid off people but the remaining workers need their jobs and won't be asking for raises. They'll probably be doing extra unpaid work to boot.

If 20% of the workforce is no longer necessary, society as it stands now will collapse. That's the point.


You made the assumption that it was fairly valued before and the loss was a "true" loss.

But possible it could have been over-valued before, unbeknownst to low-information external investors. After all, right now it as a PE of 450+. (Google PE is 17, Meta PE is 27, Tesla PE is 330)

The stock dropping on CEO departure had nothing to do with his personal performance, and everything to do with the information that he revealed on the way out. Why would the CEO leave a rising and successful company on the verge of innovation?

And thus tying it back to pay - people should be paid based on their output and their personal performance, not based on simply serving as a signal which any warm body can do. That said, I don't think truly amazing CEOs are overpaid, e.g. steve jobs of old.


> but I don't think you can reasonably expect that of paying taxes at all.

You should beware that you've rationalized everything you do as good enough, and everything that other people do is morally questionable.

Have you set the bar for what is 'reasonable' to be extremely convenient for your own circumstances?


Wrong. I specifically stated I hold myself to a higher bar than I held anyone else. I took actions to diminish my contribution, and eventually left. I do not begrudge other Americans who did less than I did.


> Wrong. I specifically stated I hold myself to a higher bar than I held anyone else. I took actions to diminish my contribution, and eventually left. I do not begrudge other Americans who did less than I did.

This is not what I was trying to say.

First let me state the assumption I made: You think that working at Anthropic/OpenAI is morally bad because that's the parent thread, and you made a comment about how somethings are good enough and other things are too bad to tolerate.

So yes, you hold yourself to the bar of I should not work at Anthropic/OpenAI - but the point is that this bar is convenient to hold yourself to.

Did you "took actions to diminish my contribution, and eventually left. I do not begrudge other Americans who did less than I did."

Or did you simply never work there, maybe never even had an offer to work there.


I wasn't particularly commentating on specific companies. The scope of my reply was strictly responding to a claim that voluntarily choosing to contribute to an evil organization is the same as being physically coerced to do it.

That said, I do hold myself to professional standards that are 'inconvenient' as well. User surveillance, manipulative dark patterns for maximizing engagement and monetization, and just about everything else big tech does is antithetical to the way I live my life. I strive to develop software that I myself am happy to use and that my users are delighted to use. My career certainly got off to a slower and less lucrative start than it otherwise would have if I had no scruples about how I made a living. I could've made much more money if I harvested my users' data and sold it. And yet, I chose not to. That is a choice you can just make. If you were in a position where you were facing homelessness, I could understand taking any job you can get, but the people chasing $300k+ TC jobs at $evilcorp aren't usually in that position.


This isn't the gotcha you think it is, and you're basically accusing the individual of "sour grapes". It isn't clever, it's plainly transparent, and about the easiest way to trivialize someone else's moral convictions. Shame on you. Be better.


> This isn't the gotcha you think it is

You really presume what I think about it huh?

> It isn't clever

Never said it was

> easiest way to trivialize someone else's moral convictions

Did not trivialize it at all. Regardless of what's "right" or "wrong" we are definitely in the territory of "advanced ethics" and not "trivial/beginner ethics"


It is because you know this and you continually choose to keep using it.

It’s be like if your 2001 BMW car was super fuel efficient, and then for whatever reason the 2028 model guzzled gas and you chose to buy it anyway

Just because the thing you did once upon a time was efficient, does not mean you have a lifetime pass to engage with it no matter the updated circumstances


So your suggestion is all responsibility is shifted to the consumer? Absolutely braindead take.


This really isn't a new problem.

That's why the mantra in running restaurants has been "location, location, location".

Location was a proxy for marketing and attention, based on foot traffic. So yes it does need to be updated to be the 2026 version for what gets peoples' attention on trying your new thing.

I think almost all good restaurateurs know that. The rest, who hyper focus on food quality, are tragically doomed.

source: my parents were in the restaurant business


And its still location. Marketing will get get people to come try your food, but location gets them to come back every week.


Location makes them try it once. Quality makes them come back every week. Which is useless if they never tried it once. On the other hand if you set up in a place where each person only comes by once or twice in a lifetime, like an airport, you don't have to make them come back and you just have to make sure the food is tolerable.


I agree

I only wish I could convince some humans in my life to slow down and do things with care.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: