Does having 400M users and 1B emails per day factor into your forgiveness?
I’m no fan Outlook and what they’ve done for the world of email, but if they’re Rolls Royce and this outage is an engine failure then that’s an expected level of service?
Or they’re Boeing and this a 787 Max. I’m on the fence.
I heard someone threw half a billion dollars at an election and couldn't change people's minds. A company having a bunch of cash doesn't automatically get people to do the right thing. Especially when the priority at every turn is shareholders.
You're arguing that the governing structure democracy cannot accomplish things with money. That's true, but for completely different reasons. The analogy doesn't really work here because Microsoft is run by a CEO and is functionally a monarchy without any need to persuade anyone beyond their paycheck.
Someone else threw the same amount of money in the other direction. Your comparison would make sense if there were a second trillion-dollar company spending their entire budget on trying to make Outlook go down, which is not the case. But we do all know that your goal wasn't actually to make an apt analogy, and just to shove your political whining into an unrelated discussion.
>I heard someone threw half a billion dollars at an election and couldn't change people's minds.
hard to change the minds of a bunch of pissed off folks when your political campaign funding is pushing AI ads about transfolk and not grocery prices or datacenter rollouts.
Unlike other cloud systems, for email there doesn't seem to be any additional complexities, any dieconomies at scale, no? You could in theory run 100,000 domains as 100,000 separate email services. It's not like social media where everybody is looking at and interacting with everybody's posts. And the email algorithm is well established, it's definitely easier than, say, settling financial transactions.
I don't have very much forgiveness, perhaps only for those junior engineers tending the beast they grew, and which now has indigestion. No-doubt there are all the usual machinations of large corporations at work. Tech companies are no better (in some ways worse) than "normal" companies, because of the invisible complexity of software. Brooks, Ousterhout, and Stroustrup were not fools. But MS run a service, they get freedom to choose how it is engineered internally so long as it continues to present a service interface to the users/client apps/other internal and external services. This is an incredible level of freedom to choose what you engineer for. MS always had the ambition to serve the world with this service. It doesn't seem like they engineered accordingly. It's easy to knock them, but I think they must have made some significant wrong choices.
I'll spare readers the full anecdote, but I worked for the company running the largest mail service in the southern hemisphere, and at the same time a few of the large mail services in the northern hemisphere in the 1990s. We met with the Exchange team who wanted us to adopt their product. Where we could run a given service on 2-3 servers, Exchange sized by MS required 300 of them for just 1 of our countries. Fortunately our cash constraints prevented us going down that road. They offered the license for free and exerted pressure on the C-level, as you can imagine there were heated conversations and some choice language between mgmt and engineering on this topic.
> They offered the license for free and exerted pressure on the C-level, as you can imagine there were heated conversations and some choice language between mgmt and engineering on this topic.
Thanks to AI, heated conversations between management and engineering is mostly a thing of the past. Unless the engineer wields an outsized influence, they will be shown the door and replaced with a lower-priced AI-augmented engineer. Which might explain the increasing frequency of shitshows we are seeing lately.
No, and I've been discussing this with a friend today.
Internal software goes through rigorous change control, change windows, change freezes around key business dates, etc to minimize risk.
Then you sign up for some SaaS and they blow out email (which aside from security needs 0 updates lets be honest) midweek, mid business day without warning or reason.
When Microsoft has an outage it tends to be global. They don’t seem to learn institutionally how fault tolerance should work across a planet. All else- I wait for the postmortem to critiq
It's probably hacked together from bits of the on-prem version. We all know what these places are like on the inside. It's not the smooth running engine they like to present it as.
Is discussion of this report mentioned online anywhere (Reddit, this place)? If there is then it would lend more credibility to the claim that this a case of news cycle fashion / capriciousness.
I wish more things had bolts on them, it screams “take me apart and fix me!”
On the flip side the last thing I’d want to open up is an autonomous laser gun. I wonder what the safety-catch looks like on this thing? A big metal shutter?
There was a post on HN recently about a suspended string robot, and how it could manage different loads (picking up dirty laundry) depending on on where it was in the room.
Simon’s microphone configuration is very similar except instead of payload kg it would be affecting detection accuracy.
I wonder why the accuracy was an OOM outside the expected result (40cm vs 7mm)? Also using claps for calibration of unknown devices feels like a different approach to measuring distances between devices with a tape and solving the polygon. How many devices would be needed to self calibrate — 1x beep and Nx listening — instead of relying on smudgy claps? Or maybe every sound is smudged in a room filled with boxes?
An old tech friend and I were talking a few years ago about hobbies, and how our old CTO was one of the most impressive hobbyists we knew of. Not only was he an incredibly accomplished exec but he also produced amazing YouTube content about his model railway collection and model rocket building all in a custom home where everything had custom smart interfaces with a growing family who enjoyed home cooked meals together on furniture he built himself.
Built himself? Well, designed by him and built in his home workshop. Some of it done by him at least with his assistants. They had a home chef too of course who gave the kids a bowl of stuff to mix during prep. The model railway involved design work that was more like commissioning 3D prints and model assembly. Input on the design really, as a lot of it was handled by assistants. Assistants assisting assistants based on prompts and review and feedback. Everything was custom and bespoke and made in his vision. Almost the entirety of the labor and craftwork were outsourced.
This person was a great leader — or “orchestrator” in the language of agents — but a lot of his accomplishments boiled down to having the physical world equivalent of a massive token budget: money and staff.
The great scientists of the 19th century, the ones whom we named fundamental units after, had skilled craftsmen who cut precision screw threads and blew perfect glass for them. Major scientific leaps are written up on papers authored by department leads et al. Les chefs célebres of the world front a kitchen filled with skilled staff supporting the name over the door.
If your work can be done on a computer though, AI can provide you with a Python line cook or a C++ glassblower of your own, so you can’t just show us your perfectly julienned potatoes or evaporation flask and expect us to praise anything other than your wallet, and your ability to motivate robots to do your bidding.
For what it’s worth I had the same thought as the ancestor post. Town squares are as privatization friendly as water, electricity, and oxygen. We just took it for granted that they were self sustaining as a public amenity and are now suffering because rich people bought up everything and are renting it back to us at half the quality and twice the price.
I don’t doubt the technical details but on the economics: surely saving a small amount of money per store is still a small amount of money per thousand stores? If each store costs $500k per year in staff, maintenance, and power then the savings from having fancy refrigeration units mean I can run one more store on top of the 1,000 I already have. It doesn’t seem like much, but I am a business illiterate computer programmer not an exec!
If margins are already at the least possible bottom (according to market logic this should always happen with commodities and competition) then you need to start to look for ways to reduce your operating costs in order to increase them again
Why? If you are already at an optimum (which "least possible bottom" indicates), then any kind of you trying to move into a different state, is going to leave the optimum.
It’s nice they tried with a more fleshed out exemplar. Polymorphism (“generics”) and interfaces (“OOP”) would have been even better to see, especially across any kind of visibility boundary enforced by the language (packages, and the like.)
Programming to an abstract interface — and in large codebases, enforced visibility controls — represent the middle ground everyone wants, in my experience, between “OOP” and “sir, this is C”.
The example definitely shines. Doing something barely non-trivial is great since it gives a feeling for the language. I wish other language introduction pages would take note.
It does feel like you need some shared understanding with the author about what the interesting parts of a programming language are and what can be left implicit.
Perhaps the author and I have similar intuitions? I guess I also like that isn't pure LLM output style. It was refreshing to see some human work.
What's the difference between an exemplar and an example?
between “OOP” and “sir, this is C”.
That's more templates, ownership and operator overloading.
Polymorphism is not a modern way to program because it introduces dependencies and enormous speed hits from pointer chasing, both of which are corrosive to a good program.
An example is any random instance of something that illustrates a concept. You can load up a document with examples to demonstrate a range of possibilities. An exemplar is the chosen best way to model and explain a concept.
So in a programming text for a new language, one would use examples of things that are strings, or examples of structures one might declare. You might even see examples of multiple ways to solve a problem in code. An exemplar though shows the one best - or at least most recommended - way to do something in the language.
You'd choose something that's less than ideal if you're including multiple examples, because it's unlikely every example is the best one. You might give an example labelled specifically as a bad example. The word exemplar might be more familiar to many English speakers as the form "exemplary".
It can be difficult to know if your example is the exemplar. It can be reasonably assumed that if the creator of the language provides only one example, it at least should be the best one. It is at least the best one in the docs if it's the only one.
I don’t really like the keep-a-changelog idea. Most changelogs get rewritten on release anyway so the main branch’s changelog becomes its own meta-branch of half-baked language that only reaches production state when the release is finalized. Something about that doesn’t sit well with a codebase where everything else has to be production ready all of the time. Where else do you accumulate temporary code/code-like features that need editing and annealing before the code is production ready?
If you have a part of your codebase that’s constantly suffering from merge conflicts then for me that’s a sign that something more fundamental isn’t working. Throwing more code at the problem feels like a hack.
Would you block a change that looked good but had the wrong language for the release notes that was rejected by the person responsible for the release? If one person writes the code and another person releases it, shouldn’t these be two commits anyway?
Perhaps your changelog is for internal use to explain why the codebase changed and when? Why is that not documented in your commit history and instead kept in a mutable part of the codebase?
If you kept each log entry in a file (do people do changelog.d and treat release notes as a compilation step?) then new log entries never conflict and a commit that edits an existing log entry will correctly flag as a conflict with anyone else who made an edit. No tool needed.
I think though, in all honesty, these kinds of ideas are hard to land well. I’m wary of dogmatic advice that — by definition as being a do-this-thing.com — is broadcast-only with a lack of any local context.
(To the author, given that this appears to be a Show HN: although I don’t think this stands up as a general purpose tool, it’s a nice solution and a good example for what a automated merge tool can look like.)
Gaming used to be done in arcades for 25c a play*.
Over time NeoGeo realized they could sell you the hardware to play at home (“on-prem”) at arcade quality albeit at a price out of reach to most people. Alongside them, Nintendo and Atari gave you 80% of the fun at 20% of the cost. History will view games arcades as a flash in the pan compared to gaming at home.
Namco, Capcom, and Konami went into selling software instead of hardware but it feels hard to imagine buying a home copy of Fable** for $X,000 any time soon.
⸻
* That’s for video games. In fairground arcades you’d literally pay for tokens then use tokens for play. The analogy almost writes itself.
If you think the idea of buying Fable like model is hard, you should really try some of the latest open models like Qwen 3.8. They’re getting there very fast.
Qwen 3.8 and GLM 5.3 are my workhorses right now. Qwen for simpler stuff because it is wicked fast using 'ninfer', GLM 5.3 because it is very good a more complex stuff and less likely to get stuck so I can let it run for much longer without intervention.
I have Qwen 3.8 running under ninfer or Strata sized to fill my 5090.
From a fair bit of coding with the agent, my experience with Qwen 3.8 (Qwen3.8-Flash-Next-GSQ-RCO-IQ3_S-0 on Strata, Qwen 3.8 27B on ninfer). In my particular case, I was trying to clone a recent HN post which allowed you to visualize how out of tune your singing was relative to a song, but as a web app or portable native app.
My experience is that both those models will generate an enormous amount of noise (literally: it was running audible unit tests on my machine to test the note-detection algorithms) while coming to a solution, if they do find a solution- while Claude (whatever the latest model is) or ChatGPT (ditto) will do 1/10th the amount of work to get the right solution. I suspect if I had the resources to run GLM 5.3, it would probably be significantly faster to get to a working solution than Qwen-3.8 27B, but likely still somewhat inferior to Claude or ChatGPT solutions, and also would generate a much larger energy bill on my part.
Even 2 DGX sparks are limited to Q2 at best. As for GPUs, it of course depends, but anything under 50k just can't run it, not even Q2.
And at Q2, I think you're better of with Qwen3-coder-next on one DGX spark (or much better: on any apple silicon max, we are currently in the ridiculous situation that a second hand m1 max 64G will beat a DGX spark that's at least triple the price)
It reminds me that coin-op SF2 champion edition was like $6000 new, and you rented time with tokens. Eventually you could play a very good but more limited SNES version of SF2 at home for no tokens. And then PC hardware matured to the point where you can play the exact bits via emulator at better than original fidelity.
It will be very nice when AI gets to the emulator stage.
I'm already nostalgic for very early Dall-e LSD-like art. Ref: "Sleeping Horses - Nov 2021."
Those early GAN image generators were so weird that they produced art that felt genuinely creative. I don't know that whatever people are using to create modern Tung-Tung-Tung-Sahur instagram reel slop is even capable of producing similar things.
I'd say Nintendo gave you 10x the fun of neo geo. Yeah it looked cool, but mario and Zelda on the nes played like nothing else. And then we got street fighter 2 on snes which is better than any snk fighter I've played :)
(I'll run for cover now as I'm sure neogeo fans will disagree!)
I'll agree, since arcades could never give the experience a JRPG could. No shop would allow a player to occupy a machine all day unless they spent a lot of quarters.
> Rent-seeking is the act of growing one's existing wealth by manipulating public policy or economic conditions without creating new wealth.
Game industry has first manipulated the economic conditions by restricting access to game content (skins, modding capabilities, always online drm, etc.) that previously was included in the price (buy game, you own that game outright).
Manipulation of public policy was a more recent thing with the laws surrounding underage gambling via 'loot-boxes'.
So I think the onus is on you to show us why these behaviors, which increase the wealth the companies are able to extract per game, are not rent seeking behavior.
Changing how you sell your own products is not "manipulating economic conditions" whatsoever. If it was, that would mean that every business in the history of commerce has engaged in it.
As for the laws on underage gambling, countries all over the world are outlawing that, suing gaming companies, etc. The public is not in favor of underage gambling, and it's unclear to me how banning it increases the wealth of these companies? So I think the onus is on you to explain how this is an example of rent seeking.
Modern gaming companies can be considered rent seekers not because they charge money for their products, but because many increasingly rely on extracting additional revenue from consumers by exploiting market power, consumer lock-in, and artificial scarcity rather than creating proportionately greater value. In economics, rent seeking is the pursuit of economic gains through the exploitation of existing advantages rather than through productive activity. Developing a great game is productive; leveraging an established franchise or player community to extract additional money without providing equivalent value is rent seeking.
Consider the use of microtransactions, battle passes, paid progression, and downloadable content. These systems often exploit the time, money, and emotional investment players have already made in a game. By deliberately slowing progression, withholding content, or introducing artificial scarcity, companies can encourage consumers to spend more money not because they are receiving a better product, but because they want to avoid frustration or access something they already value. The company is monetizing the player's existing commitment rather than necessarily creating new value.
This does not mean every gaming company or microtransaction is inherently rent seeking. Selling meaningful new content is a legitimate business activity. The criticism is that parts of the modern gaming industry increasingly prioritize extracting revenue from an existing player base over developing better games. When companies use their control over popular franchises and digital ecosystems to extract additional money from consumers who have few alternatives, they exhibit the very characteristics of rent seeking that economists criticize in other industries.
You've stumbled on exactly why the big providers are lobbying for regulation and big claims that Ai is unsafe. They don't want you running these at home.
Arcades mostly failed to adapt to the advances of home consoles to provide experiences you couldn't get at home. That's on the dimwitted game suits of the 1990s who cared little about novel gameplay, networked gameplay, or better NPC AI and physics. Then mobile happened and there was a brief glorious Cambrian explosion of new ideas until the Zynga playbook and DLC. Evidence: lived through it as a small game studio developer trying to do original things. The fun experiment now and then is to break out your 1980s video game consoles and play through their libraries. Most of the games are objectively terrible but gems like Yar's Revenge are still gems today IMO.
It will take a while till prices drop to a level where affording 256GB card (even if it would be shared between few coworkers) will have any sense over buying tokens.
And the AI debt bubble price spike will probably stay there for a while.
That's going to be pretty pricey though. And I really want to see some independent benchmarks, that all looks very good on paper but there are some complications (notably: chip count, run length of the traces).
I’m no fan Outlook and what they’ve done for the world of email, but if they’re Rolls Royce and this outage is an engine failure then that’s an expected level of service?
Or they’re Boeing and this a 787 Max. I’m on the fence.
reply