HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | gls2ro's commentslogin

Unless AI will be ar the level of saying "I want a scheduling app that fits me" I still see value in buying some apps.

I like to customize my Neovim setup or terminal and a bunch of scripts that I keep making them nice and maybe my blog and so on.

I don't want to become the PM of every app I need. But I do agree changes will happen to the current apps and how we buy and use them. Not sure exactly where it will settle. But still unknown unknowns and domain knowledge and vocabulary is not yet allowing anyone to build their own apps unless for simple cases.

Or maybe it is just me: I want someone else to think about my accounting app. I dont want to spend time to learn and understand and keep myself up to date or setup a series of LLM sessions that navigate and watch laws and propose changes.


Why do you need a scheduling app when you have a secretary?

Why do you need an accounting app when you have an accountant?

Programs of the future will in no way resemble what they are today. I don't even want to call it a "program" because in my head it's more like an intelligent digital liquid that can rapidly flow into any state. This flash-in-the-pan 50 year archaic era of software will look like what the oil lamp looks like today. A crude intermediate tech during a time of much larger transition.


it's nice to see what's on my schedule at a glance, rather than needing to ask my secretary. also helps with situational awareness.

it's nice to see my financial situation at a glance, without asking my accountant.

speech/text is one modality. we humans are also visual and tactile. and we need consistency and recurring patterns of interaction to function well.


You ask your secretary to give you a visual representation of your schedule right now and presto - you got it.

Same thing for your accountant.

Imagine that both of them, while being good at their respective jobs, are also software engineers that can mint a custom throwaway app for you at a moment's notice.


You’re clearly missing the mark that many famous businessmen have verbalised in numerous interviews. Consumers do not know what they need. Ford said it. Jobs said it. Others said it. That’s the major flaw of chatbot-first UX.

>speech/text is one modality. we humans are also visual and tactile. and we need consistency and recurring patterns of interaction to function well.

I'm sure your secretary will make a note of your preference.


well, sure. I'm not against against text as, like, the command line. I'm just skeptical of text as the ideal user interface.

But is it?

Is it really 100x? Imagine that in 3 days you get the same amount of customers as you would in a almost a year so then in the next 3 days can you get the same and in the next 3 days again ... This is not even considering the idea that with AI you will get 100x of the previous 100x maybe which is really something pretty big.

If you have examples please share them.

I know good examples that are accelerating quite a lot with AI but not at the level of 100x.


My opinion is that this idea that seems to be in the same direction of all SaaS is dead because everyone will just build their own products is true only for a subset of people.

I do agree in case of terminals this subset of people might overlap a lot with the entire market -> developers.

I see the future a bit different as in many people/companies will offer to the market some kind of building blocks that will be extra configurable by agents and then we are combining them.

In this case libghostty is such a component that can be integrated in a lot of things and people building those things want to work at a higher level of abstraction than building the terminal emulator. To be honest is among the best example of such a component that I see in the future that I think about.


I am not sure this is true with regards to SaaS and IT.

For example I know at least one country (but I suspect many more are just I did not checked) where the IT creates a big enough chunk of GDP and hires a lot of people. Much more than it disrupted initially.

But more than this IT allowed so far for much more people to get a very good job and have a very decent life. Up until the promises of AI the IT industry was an industry that was hiring a lot of people and producing a lot of money in their economies. Not only by sales tax or sales but also by circulating money via paying their employees and thus along with IT a lot of other businesses where created.


My point is not necessarily to say that IT is bad in general, but rather that it used to displace people. I think workplace mobility for those who were displaced due to systems, is relatively low. The ageism in workplace I would say is highly related to abilities of using new tech. Older, less educated have high difficulty to use these systems. Therefore the benefits of rise of the IT is unevenly distributed. Same with AI just with the higher degree. On the other hand, AI is creating work for blue collar worker ( at least for now). So it goes in circles

I also think property based testing is great.

But they are very different IMO at what they focus on and so they occupy different places when talking about does a piece of software does what it should do and withing the state/parameters specified:

- Property based testing focuses on finding counter examples - Formal verification focuses to prove that a property always holds

More than this I think in all these discussions we are missing the most important piece: validation.

While verification means to prove or test or verify that the software does what is should do, validation means to prove or test or verify that the software is solving user needs.


It does not matter that they were stochastic events because the reason we have regulation and procedures and protocols for these systems is to reduce randomness and mistakes as close to zero.

While individually each event can maybe just be random mistake having two could be the beginning of some new information about the system(s) we have to consider.

So we should all say and act like this is not acceptable and we need more focus on making these stochastic events not happen now that they are not just a mere probability over an event space filled with randomness. They just happened.


I fail to understand this line of thinking.

Even letting aside any survival mechanism we have there are two rational posibilities:

1. We are alone in the universe => super huge loss of complexity and consciousness

2. We are not alone but at Universe scale intelligent life seems rather scarce => still huge loss in diversity


Welcome to nihilism, where nothing matters. On a grand enough scale, is there a difference between our universe existing and our universe not existing?


On a cosmic scale independent of human activity, sure. But things do matter to us every day. And things matter to other life forms we share the planet with.


Nope. Nothing will last. Everything is chance. Entropy will eat us all.

That's why it's important to find joy in the moment and ways to share that joy and happiness with those around you.


None of these two partners benefit from mass migration because both of them actually need more workers.

Also a trade partnership is not a zero sum game. Can also be that everybody will benefit by more trade, more cooperation and more exchanges for young people.


If this alliance will be signed and has the support of people from both sides then Buy Canadian and Buy European will mean Buy European or Canadian.

We might need a new name for this in 10 years if it works.

Like Buy EuroCan or But Caneu (maybe better names)


That is not a simple solution in practice, only on social media.

It will make prices go high, which will spiral in a lot of things and will increase the cost of living in the present even more for the vulnerable part of the population of a country.

of course it can be the proper solution for the future but saying it is simple is a huge huge understatement of the political and economical will needed to make it happen.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: