HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | generalizations's commentslogin

^ guy who never heard of a telemetry-blocking firewall

Just put codex in a continuous goal loop to keep you off the blacklists...give it whatever email / creds it needs to make the appropriate requests and make the needed changes (ofc tell it the guardrails it should follow).

Selfhosted email is likely easier now than it ever was before.


> give it whatever email / creds it needs

Oh man, please tag me if you're ever the lead on any project so I know to stay far away from it.


Better late than never.

Some of us have been taking this approach for literally years now.


“Late”

ChatGPT isn’t 4yo yet. We’re just getting started


Better approach: "holy sh*t, I can solve way harder math problems now". I bet openai would have loved to have Terry on their team leading the 'solve math' department.

It's telling that isn't his response.


holy sht, I can solve way harder math problems now. I'll just start on this one over h..."

Aand it's gone.

"Oh wow, that opened the door to a whole new area of..."

Aand it's gone.


How can this possibly be considered a bad thing?


Math culture optimized for thinking skills of proof-based understanding. Funding and education partly determined too. 3blue1brown did an analysis recently.


How can putting effort in and then repeatedly having the rug pulled be considered a good thing?


That used to be his response, he just doesn't agree with the way OpenAI is doing it.

I'm not sure this article is a good way to figure out his stance on the issue, I'd recommend reading his blog posts or mastodon threads.


I'm aware it was his response, back when he thought that an LLM couldn't possibly actually match his own intelligence. The 180 as soon as the AI did the whole proof without him is telling.

"the way OpenAI is doing it" - unfortunately while mathematicians have had an internal culture of not stepping on each other's toes, their ingroup is still susceptible to the same disruption as every other field as AI shows up to eat their lunch.

You can either get with the program and discover this is the greatest opportunity in the history of mankind to accelerate knowledge, or, you can cry over your lost prestige. Terry has chosen the latter.


I really think that you should actually read the article.


If you use an LLM, you aren't solving a thing. Just as people who post about how "I built" some vibe coded thing are lying to themselves. You didn't do the thing, the LLM did the thing.


I can't lift a car, unless I use a jack. Mathematicians use theorem provers. Software developers use IDEs. Programmers would be pretty screwed if their keyboards had a 0 and a 1 on them and nothing else. Tools evolve.


Theorem provers don't generate proofs. IDEs don't generate software.


They are so desperate for claude to be good at maths, like chatgpt. But claude is optimized for quick, pragmatic results and chatgpt is trained to be careful. There is a reason the best anthropic could do was an organized search - not real mathematics.


I haven't seen much in the way of benchmarks of those smaller quants. How does it compare to e.g. various generations of Opus?


We already established precedent (Biden election results disputes) that we don't get to question how fair the elections are.


What do you mean you don't get to question how fair the elections are? The sitting president of the entire country has questioned and investigated them. No one has stopped questioning and investigating them. People literally stormed the capital over it and had effectively zero real long term consequences in the overwhelming majority of cases. Dozens and dozens of lawsuits, none of which amounted to anything, even when they were in front of Trump appointee judges.

The precedent, if anything, is that we will tolerate people upending the whole public discourse and portions of the government for years over nonsense that never had any evidence of anything occurring on a level that would impact the elections.

Meanwhile, Trump has spent the entire administration trying to restrict the ability for demographics that won't vote for him from being able to vote. Openly. Sometimes honestly, but mostly also blaming all of it on the election he lost and claiming it's to stop the voter fraud that never actually occurred.

The precedent that was set is that questioning the election can become dogma for a political party no matter if there is absolutely zero evidence of what they are saying happened.


Are you suggesting the other side didnt get to dispute that Biden won? There were literally a 100 lawsuits, all of them lost except like 1 on some random technical issue that had zero impact to the results.

Some states had quite a deep dive, forensic audits, the whole thing. https://apnews.com/article/joe-biden-wisconsin-presidential-...

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2021_Maricopa_County_president...

The 2020 election was probably the most scrutinized in history. How is that not being able to question a fair election?


Except this time, the regime in charge taking public action to tamper and interfere with elections, including threats of intimidation at polling stations. Red state governments are outright gloating that they're gerrymandering their districts based on party lines to retain power.

Even if Dems take the House and Senate, this can't be called a fair election.


Of course what's interesting is that when viewed from the perspective of 'I have a kid and I'm willing to orchestrate their education myself', AI means the kid can get an education unheard-of even ten years ago. Personal, genius-level tutor, expert in any subject in which the kid can muster a question.

The only people really having a crisis here are teachers who want to feel relevant.


Why is that interesting? How often does that happen? Has it happened even once? Seems like fantasy; this has been possible for a long time, and despite it being possible, it almost never actually happens. Before AI, kids willing to orchestrate their own education could use the internet to become experts in anything. Before the internet kids could use libraries and books to become experts in anything. But how many take the time and effort to match a 4 year degree? Statistically, approximately zero.

One major problem: how do you get a job for which a degree is required, if you teach yourself via books/internet/AI? How do you get into graduate schools for which a degree is required? How do you envision advanced degrees working without funding or labs or mentors?

All of education is undergoing dramatic seismic shifts because of AI right now. Attempting to insult teachers for talking about it doesn’t reflect on teachers, it reflects on you.


It's interesting because it clarifies that the problem here isn't the kid's education; the 'problem' is that teachers and colleges are upset that they are no longer offering something valuable.

The kids are fine; the rent seekers aren't.

And to your larger point: the entire university/graduate/lab/scientific system was created to formalize what was originally citizen scientists trying to understand the world from their basements. Scientific journals are just a formalization of nerds writing letters to each other about what they figured out. Consider from first principles how much of what exists now actually still serves that original purpose.

You want it to be a jobs program? Sounds good. Take their computers away and make them use pencils and you can create even more jobs.

You want to do science? Figure out how to do science. You want the kids to learn? Figure out how to teach them.

Just don't protect a jobs program under the guise of something nobler.


I disagree that’s the problem, and I don’t think your claim is true. Degrees are still extremely valuable, and income stats alone prove it conclusively. I don’t find your suggestion very interesting, not because colleges are gatekeeping, but for the reason already stated: because most people do not and cannot teach themselves and curate their own educations at a university level, and because even if they did, which they don’t, it still wouldn’t help them get jobs or advanced degrees in today’s workforce. It might be an interesting suggestion if that happened with any statistical significance, but it doesn’t, and isn’t a realistic path for education for society.

Figuring out how to teach kids is exactly what this article is doing. How do you propose to teach kids, when they refuse to put in the work, and reach for AI for everything? Your suggestion to make them use pencils seems naïve/ignorant/obtuse; this article is written by a computer science teacher. You can’t force people to use only pencils for homework (as the article points out), and it would be ridiculous to use pencils for writing computer programs in 2026. That suggestion is a non-starter. FWIW, the impression I’m getting is not that you have any helpful suggestions for education, but that you don’t have experience teaching and don’t understand what’s happening in schools right now.

Who is protecting jobs programs under the guise of something nobler? This seems like a straw man unrelated to your previous comment. I’m getting the feeling you’re anti-education for some reason, maybe have some bone to pick with the university system, is that accurate? Asking kids to teach themselves or forcing them to use pencils are not going to be successful ways to improve education.


You're making ad hominem comments about me; your argument about the degrees is making some heavy assumptions that such things won't be massively changed by AI.

And you're taking the pencil comment weirdly literally, like it apparently went completely over your head. We're clearly talking past each other. I don't see any purpose to talking about this further.


Things are being massively changed by AI. That’s what this article is about, the article you seem intent on poo-pooing. I only asked you a question about your stance, it was not an attack. My question was aimed at trying to uncover why you’ve cast insults toward teachers multiple times, and implicitly the one who authored this article. The only ad-hominems were yours, and they started with your first comment.

What heavy assumptions are you referring to? If you mean assuming that kids probably won’t skip university and instead will be self-motivated enough to use AI non-stop for several years in order to teach themselves enough to get a job as a biologist or a ballet dancer or a civil engineer, and if you mean assuming that companies and organizations probably won’t suddenly start accepting self-AI-taught candidates as being the same as having a degree… if these are the assumptions you’re referring to, then you’re right - I am assuming those things and I believe them. No matter how AI changes things, it’s a pretty heavy assumption you’ve made to think kids will self-motivate an education just because information is available, especially given that was always possible and still chosen so rarely that it effectively doesn’t exist. And it’s a pretty heavy assumption to think that universities and organizations will change together in a way that can vette the merit of prospective candidates any time in foreseeable future. AI will change a lot of things, but you’re underestimating our social structures and what things like the accreditation system do for the workforce and the economy. You can argue it’s got problems, but assuming like you did that AI can replace it anytime soon is a very heavy assumption.

If the pencil comment and suggestion to take away computers wasn’t literal, then you’re right, I have no idea what you meant. Feel free to explain. If you can’t, then I’d agree, there’s no further purpose.


That's only relevant insofar as it can be a long time before the commercial viability is realized or apparent.

If an AI can make 100 commercially unviable discoveries (for now) on its way to each immediately commercially viable discovery, that's great - bank them in the discovery library for later.

Still doesn't mean we need mathematicians doing everything with pencils instead.


Very cool. Did you also try using the karpathy autoresearch? How do you think this compares?


honestly I know it exists but I never used it so can't compare


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: